An Ohio Immigrant Bought a Cheese Factory for $700 in 1928, and It Grew Into a 10-Million-Pound Business

In 1928, a Swiss immigrant purchased a tiny Ohio cheese factory and a neighboring house for just $700. At the time, the operation produced a single 200-pound wheel of Swiss cheese each day.

Nearly a century later, that modest beginning has grown into a family-owned cheese business that crossed 10 million pounds of annual production. Visitors can still stop at the factory store, sample cheeses, and watch part of the production process.

I love how the original craft remains visible even as the operation has expanded. Swiss is still a signature product, but the selection now includes Colby, Gouda, and other varieties that make choosing just one difficult.

The experience goes beyond shopping. Free factory tours give visitors a closer look at cheesemaking, while the store stocks locally made foods that turn a quick stop into a memorable outing.

Swiss Cheese Has Been Running the Show for Nearly a Century

Swiss Cheese Has Been Running the Show for Nearly a Century
© Pearl Valley Cheese Inc

Holes in cheese are not mistakes. At Pearl Valley Cheese, they are the whole point, and the family has been perfecting them since 1928.

Swiss cheese is the signature here, and it shows up in several styles. Shoppers can find mild Swiss, aged Swiss, smoked Swiss, lacey Swiss, and an Emmentaler old world Swiss.

Lacey Swiss is a fun one to know about. It’s a Swiss style with smaller holes, which makes it great for thin slices on sandwiches.

Aged Swiss brings a stronger, nuttier punch than the mild version. If you like cheese with real personality, that block deserves a spot in your basket.

Smoked Swiss adds another layer of flavor without any extra work on your part. Melt it on a burger or a grilled sandwich, and dinner suddenly feels upgraded.

What makes this Ohio stop special is the freshness. The cheese is made right there, so it travels from the vat to the counter without a long trip in between.

A smart move is buying two kinds of Swiss and comparing them at home. You’ll learn more about your own taste in one snack than in years of grocery shopping.

Nearly a hundred years of practice tends to pay off. One bite of the Swiss here explains why the family never changed the main act.

Swiss, Colby, Gouda, and Spicy Cheeses Fill the Cases

Swiss, Colby, Gouda, and Spicy Cheeses Fill the Cases
© Pearl Valley Cheese, Fresno, OH

Thirty-plus kinds of cheese under one roof can make a simple errand feel like a big decision. Good luck walking out with just one block.

Pearl Valley Cheese goes well beyond Swiss. The lineup includes colby, marble, sharp cheddar, gouda, smoked gouda, and onion cheese.

Spice fans have plenty to explore too. Look for jalapeño, pepper jack, smoked hot pepper, and a fiery one called super hot jumping jack.

Horseradish cheese is another favorite worth trying. It brings a zippy kick that wakes up crackers, sandwiches, and even scrambled eggs.

The shop also carries lactose free cheese options. That’s a helpful detail for anyone who usually has to skip the cheese board at parties.

Here’s a practical tip for a first visit. Pick one mild cheese, one smoked cheese, and one spicy cheese, then build a tasting plate at home.

Kids can make it a game by ranking each one from best to worst. Adults can do the same, though nobody has to admit they picked the spiciest one just to look brave.

Staff can slice cheese at the counter, and pre-wrapped blocks are ready to grab. Either way, your fridge is about to need some serious rearranging.

Taste First, Decide Later, and Nobody Will Judge You

Taste First, Decide Later, and Nobody Will Judge You
© Pearl Valley Cheese Inc

Buying cheese without tasting it first is like picking a movie by the poster alone. Pearl Valley Cheese solves that problem by offering samples at the counter.

That small perk makes a big difference. You can try the horseradish, compare the cheddars, and figure out if smoked gouda is really your thing.

Staff members know their cheese and how it’s made. Ask what pairs well with apples or which block melts best, and you’ll likely get a helpful answer.

Sampling is also a sneaky way to discover new favorites. Plenty of people plan to buy plain colby and leave with something spicy they never expected to love.

Here’s a friendly warning, though. Tasting tends to grow your shopping list, not shrink it.

A good plan is to set a loose budget before you start. Then sample freely, pick your winners, and skip the guilt.

Families can turn sampling into a fun little challenge. Let everyone choose one cheese to bring home, and suddenly snack time has a theme for the week.

I can’t imagine a better way to shop for food. Trying before buying feels generous, smart, and a lot more fun than reading labels in a grocery aisle.

See Where the Curds Come From on a Factory Tour

See Where the Curds Come From on a Factory Tour
© Pearl Valley Cheese Inc

Milk does not magically turn into Swiss cheese overnight. At Pearl Valley Cheese, visitors can learn the real process on a cheese-making tour.

Tours walk guests through how the cheese gets made on site. They also share the long history of the family-owned business, which goes back to 1928.

Seeing the process makes the cheese taste even better. You start to notice the care and patience behind every block in the case.

Free factory tours are offered every Wednesday at 9:30 a.m. from March through December. Visitors can also watch the Colby cheesemaking process through the retail store windows on weekdays from 8 a.m. to noon.

Anyone planning a special trip should check the current schedule before traveling.

Groups can be a great fit for a tour. Church groups, scout troops, and family reunions could all turn this into a memorable outing.

Kids especially might enjoy learning where their cheese sticks come from. It’s a science lesson, a history lesson, and a snack stop all at once.

Bring your questions along. How do the holes form, and why does aging change the flavor so much?

After the tour, the shop is right there waiting. That timing is either very convenient or very dangerous, depending on how much cheese you planned to buy.

Trail Bologna and Chocolates Turn a Cheese Run Into a Picnic

Trail Bologna and Chocolates Turn a Cheese Run Into a Picnic
© Pearl Valley Cheese Inc

Cheese gets lonely on its own. Luckily, Pearl Valley Cheese stocks plenty of tasty sidekicks to keep it company.

Trail bologna is a big one here. Pair it with Swiss or colby, and you’ve got a classic Ohio snack combo.

The shelves also hold sausages, smokies, beef sticks, crackers, cured meats, and spreads. Jams and jellies sit nearby for anyone who loves a sweet and savory mix.

Then there are the chocolates and candies. They make a cheese run feel a little more like a treat trip.

Building a picnic basket here is easy. Grab two cheeses, one meat, a box of crackers, and a few chocolates for dessert.

These goodies also make great gifts. A small bundle of local cheese and treats feels thoughtful without needing any fancy wrapping.

Thinking about a party? A cheese and trail bologna tray tends to disappear fast, so plan on a little extra.

I like how the shop makes one stop feel complete. You can plan an entire snack spread without hopping between three different stores.

Award Ribbons Prove This Cheese Is Not Just Hometown Hype

Award Ribbons Prove This Cheese Is Not Just Hometown Hype
© Pearl Valley Cheese Inc

Small-town pride is great, but judges with clipboards are tougher to impress. Pearl Valley Cheese has earned awards for its cheese at contests beyond Ohio.

Pearl Valley Cheese has earned recognition at state, national, and international competitions. In 2025, its Swiss cheese won first place in the Swiss Style category at the U.S.

Championship Cheese Contest and was named Grand Champion at the Ohio State Fair.

The company’s Smoked Swiss and Jumpin’ Jack cheeses also earned first-place honors in their respective Ohio State Fair categories that year.

Awards matter because they come from blind judging. Experts taste and score cheese without caring about cute signs or friendly smiles.

Still, the friendly smiles don’t hurt. The combination of skilled cheesemaking and warm service is a big reason folks keep coming back.

Award-winning cheese usually costs a fortune in specialty shops. Here, the prices stay friendly, which feels almost unfair to the fancy stores.

Want to taste a winner? Ask the staff which cheeses have picked up recent honors, then compare them side by side.

That little experiment can sharpen your taste buds. You may start noticing creaminess, nuttiness, and sharpness in ways you never did before.

Family-owned since 1928 and still winning prizes says a lot. Generations of practice clearly turned into something judges far from Ohio take seriously.

Country Roads Lead Right to the Cheese Counter

Country Roads Lead Right to the Cheese Counter
© Pearl Valley Cheese, Fresno, OH

GPS might make you wonder if you took a wrong turn. Keep going, because the cheese is out here in the rolling countryside.

Pearl Valley Cheese sits at 54760 Township Rd 90, Fresno, OH 43824. It’s in Coshocton County, not far from the edge of Ohio’s Amish Country.

Plan around the hours before you leave home. The shop opens 8 a.m. to 5 p.m.

Monday through Friday, 9 a.m. to 4 p.m. Saturday, and stays closed Sunday.

Road work can affect the route from time to time. Checking for detours before a trip can save you some surprise gravel miles.

The drive pairs nicely with a day of exploring. Historic Roscoe Village in Coshocton makes a fun companion stop for shopping and strolling.

Morning visits make a lot of sense for travelers. You get first pick of the cheese case and plenty of daylight for other adventures.

Parking is easy, and there’s space to sit and enjoy a snack. That comes in handy when the smoked gouda simply refuses to wait.

Remember that cooler. Cheese and a warm car are not best friends on the drive home.

Live Far Away? Your Doorstep Can Still Get Cheesy

Live Far Away? Your Doorstep Can Still Get Cheesy
© Pearl Valley Cheese, Fresno, OH

Pearl Valley Cheese offers online ordering and ships its products throughout the contiguous United States. Shipping is not available to Alaska, Hawaii, Canada, or post office boxes.

Customers can browse the online selection of cheeses and gift boxes, with shipping costs and delivery options calculated during checkout.

Ordering a sampler of several cheeses is a fun move. You can host a tasting night and let friends guess which one is the spiciest.

Some people are surprised that great cheese comes from Ohio at all. Many folks assume Wisconsin owns the title, so this makes for a fun conversation starter.

Refrigerate your cheese as soon as the box arrives. Keeping it cold protects the flavor and keeps everything fresh longer.

Shipped cheese also makes a thoughtful holiday gift. Grandparents, teachers, and neighbors rarely complain about receiving a box of award-winning cheese.

Visiting in person still has its perks, of course. Samples, the bargain bin, and tours are hard to replace with a website.

Either way, a family that has made cheese since 1928 is ready to share it. Whether it travels by car or by mail, that first bite tastes like a well-earned reward.