A 12-foot skeleton stands guard outside this bakery. The welcome sign greets everyone with a cheerful “hey creeps.” I love a business that tells you exactly who it is before you even reach the door.
Inside, the gothic decor makes every day feel like late October. The pastries carry names that sound like inside jokes.
Some savory treats even come shaped like little skulls.
I believe Ohio has plenty of sweet bakeries, but very few with this much attitude. The menu changes monthly, sometimes weekly, so returning visitors can find new flavors alongside familiar favorites.
Cookies, brownies, and stuffed bagel bites share the spotlight.
The shop is small, and the treats can sell out. That only makes the hunt more fun.
I like how this place makes a simple bakery run feel like a little Halloween adventure, even when October is nowhere in sight.
That Giant Skeleton Out Front Is Your Official Greeter
Most bakeries hang a cute chalkboard sign out front. Bite This By Annie went with a 12-foot skeleton instead.
That bony giant stands outside the shop in the Clintonville area of Columbus. It works like a lighthouse for anyone who loves spooky style and sweet treats.
Then comes the welcome sign. It greets everyone with a friendly “hey creeps,” which somehow feels warmer than a plain hello.
I like how the outside sets expectations right away. Nobody wanders up thinking this is a pastel cupcake shop with lace doilies.
The skeleton also makes a great landmark when you’re hunting for parking. Telling a friend to meet you by the giant skeleton is hard to misunderstand.
Bring your camera, because that tall greeter practically begs for a photo. It’s the kind of picture that gets reactions from friends online.
Kids who enjoy Halloween will probably think this is the best bakery ever invented. Adults who never outgrew Halloween will agree with them.
Year-round spooky decor means you never have to wait for fall to get your fix. The skeleton doesn’t care if it’s July or January.
Every Day Feels Like October Once You Get Inside
Black walls, witchy touches, and cheeky details fill this tiny shop. The whole space feels like a cozy haunted house that happens to sell cookies.
The gothic theme isn’t a seasonal costume. It runs through the decor, the signs, and even the way pastries get presented.
Look closely and you’ll find playful little jokes tucked around the room. Every corner gives your eyes something new to spot.
The shop is small, so there’s no indoor seating. Think of it as a grab-and-go stop with serious personality.
That size also means everything feels close and personal. The pastry case sits right there, tempting you from the moment you step through the door.
I can’t imagine a better spot for anyone who owns more black clothing than colorful clothing. Spooky fans will feel right at home here.
Even folks who aren’t into dark style can enjoy the creativity. It’s fun to see a business commit this fully to a theme.
Plan to take your treats somewhere else to eat. A nearby park bench or your car’s front seat works just fine.
Just don’t rush out too fast. The decor deserves a good look before you leave with your goodies.
Skull-Shaped Reapers Might Be the Cutest Lunch in Town
A savory stuffed bagel shaped like a skull? Yes, that’s a real menu item, and it’s called a Reaper.
These little skulls work like a bagel version of a handheld pocket. Fillings rotate, and past versions have included a hot chicken salad and a loaded nacho flavor.
They’re filling enough to count as a meal. That makes them a smart pick when you want lunch before diving into dessert.
The shape is pure fun. It’s hard to stay grumpy while eating a pastry that grins back at you.
Reapers also travel well, which matters at a shop without seating. You can warm them up at home later if you want them toasty again.
I like that a spooky bakery didn’t stop at spooky sweets. Turning a savory snack into a tiny skull shows real commitment to the bit.
Because the menu changes, the flavor you loved last month might not be back. That keeps things exciting, though it can also break a few hearts.
My advice is simple. If a Reaper flavor sounds good, grab it now and save the regrets for someone else.
Bonus points if you snap a photo before the first bite. That smiling skull won’t look the same afterward.
Biscuit Bombs and Bagel Bombs Bring the Savory Side
Sweet treats get plenty of attention here, yet the savory lineup holds its own. Biscuit Bombs and Bagel Bombs show up as two of the shop’s well-known stuffed favorites.
A Biscuit Bomb packs a filling inside a biscuit. One past version featured sausage gravy, which sounds like breakfast in its most comforting form.
Bagel Bombs follow the same playful idea with bagel dough. They make an easy pick for anyone who wants something hearty on the go.
Bite This By Annie has also offered breakfast buns. Past fillings have included chorizo and gravy, plus a breakfast chili version.
Spicy deviled eggs have appeared on the menu too. Clearly, the kitchen enjoys surprising people beyond the dessert case.
Here’s a smart strategy for a first trip. Grab one savory item and one sweet item so you get the full picture.
Since the menu rotates, the exact fillings will change over time. Checking the shop’s social media before you go helps you plan your order.
Savory items also make great sharing snacks for a group. Everyone gets a taste, and nobody has to pick just one.
Honestly, a bakery that serves gravy-filled biscuits beside brownies understands people. Hunger rarely chooses a single lane.
Fat Bois, Skinni Bois, and Some Seriously Famous Brownies
Cookie names at this bakery sound like characters in a cartoon. You’ll spot Fat Bois, Skinni Bois, and NFBB brownies on the lineup.
The Sea Salt Chocolate Chip Fat Boi has built a strong following. It comes loaded with chocolate and finished with flaky salt on top.
Skinni Bois offer a thinner style. Past flavors have included Fluffernutter and a matcha lemonade version that sounds wonderfully bright.
Brownies might be the true stars of the case. Flavors like cherry and cookie dough have shown up, along with themed specials.
One past brownie even arrived with an edible flame on top. That’s dessert with a flair for drama.
Peanut butter pie, cinnamon rolls, and banana muffins have also earned attention. Clearly, the bakers know their way around classic comfort desserts.
Many flavors combine in ways you won’t find at a grocery store. Grape white chocolate chip and cherry cordial cookie sandwiches prove that point nicely.
If you can’t decide, start with a chocolate chip cookie as your baseline. Then add one wild flavor to test your bravery.
Your sweet tooth will thank you either way. Your willpower, sadly, might not survive the trip.
A Rotating Menu Keeps You Coming Back for More
Nothing stays the same for long at this Ohio bakery. Bite This By Annie rotates its menu regularly, with some items changing weekly or monthly.
A few favorites stick around as steady options. Others pop in for a short run and then vanish like ghosts.
Themed menus make things even more fun. One past September menu celebrated literacy month with a Lord of the Rings week.
That lineup included a Nazgul Fudge Round and a birthday cake honoring Frodo and Bilbo. Book fans clearly had a good time.
Music has inspired treats too. A Sleep Token cookie once appeared, and the shop also marked a Noah Kahan album release.
I love how this turns a bakery run into a little adventure. You never quite know which surprises will fill the case.
The best way to stay updated is to follow the shop online. New menus and specials get shared there before you show up.
Fans have also mentioned that the team welcomes flavor ideas. That makes the menu feel like a group project with the community.
Just remember that a treat you adore may not return soon. Enjoy every bite like it’s a limited edition, because it probably is.
Show Up Early, Because the Line Is Part of the Ritual
Timing matters at Bite This By Annie. The bakery currently lists Wednesday through Friday hours from 7 a.m. to 1 p.m., and Saturday and Sunday hours from 9 a.m. to 3 p.m.
It stays closed Monday and Tuesday. Check the bakery’s latest schedule before visiting, especially around holidays.
The space is small, so lines can form, sometimes outside. Dress for the weather if you’re going on a busy weekend.
Popular items can sell out later in the day. Arriving closer to opening gives you the best shot at your top choices.
Think of the wait as part of the experience. You get extra time to study the giant skeleton and plan your order.
Bringing a friend helps too. One person can hold a spot while the other scouts the menu online.
Having a backup pick in mind is smart. If your first choice disappears, you won’t panic at the counter.
The team keeps things moving, which helps with crowds. Still, a little patience goes a long way at any popular bakery.
Once you’ve got your bag of treats in hand, the wait suddenly feels worth it. Funny how a cookie can rewrite your memory like that.
From Market Stands to a Spooky Shop of Her Own
Long before the skeleton went up, Annie’s treats showed up at local markets. Early fans followed her baking from those market days to the shop.
That journey gives Bite This a homegrown feel. It started small and grew because people kept coming back for more.
Annie fully embraces her gothic, alternative style. The bakery reflects that personality in every sign, shelf, and pastry name.
I believe that kind of honesty makes a business stand out. It invites people who share that vibe to feel welcome and seen.
The shop also offers merch like hats and shirts. Fans can carry a bit of that spooky spirit home with them.
Custom cakes are another option worth knowing about. They’re handy for birthdays or any celebration that needs extra creativity.
Vegetarian options have been part of the lineup too. That makes the case friendlier for more kinds of eaters.
Watching a market vendor grow into a destination is pretty inspiring. It’s a reminder that bold ideas can find their crowd.
Every visit supports a local Ohio business with a clear point of view. And that point of view happens to taste great.
Make a Clintonville Morning Out of Your Bakery Run
Finding the skeleton is easy once you know where to look. Bite This By Annie sits at 3009 N High St, Columbus, OH 43202.
That spot places it along North High Street in the Clintonville area. It’s a lively stretch with plenty of local character.
Since there’s no indoor seating, plan where you’ll enjoy your haul. A nearby park or a quick drive home both work well.
Out-of-town visitors often add this stop to Columbus trips. It pairs nicely with a concert, a family visit, or a weekend getaway in Ohio.
Consider buying extra for later. Savory items like Reapers can be reheated at home for a second round of fun.
A box of treats also makes a fun gift. Few hosts expect a dessert with this much personality on their counter.
Keep an eye on the shop’s social pages before heading out. Special menus, pop-ups, and themed weeks get announced there.
Leaving with only one cookie is technically possible. Nobody has proven it can be done without regret, though.
So wave goodbye to the giant skeleton and head out happy. He’ll be standing right there whenever your sweet tooth calls again.
