The crust is doing too much. It looks that good.
This Indiana bakery has spent 33 years making pies that turn “just a quick stop” into an extended period of standing in front of the display case. The selection is broad enough to cover creamy favorites, fruit-filled classics, and plenty of other baked goods that keep competing for attention.
Cookies. Brownies.
Rolls. Bread.
At some point, choosing one thing becomes less realistic than accepting defeat. The good news is that nobody seems particularly bothered by defeat here.
The box goes on the counter. The appetite takes over.
And the bakery trip becomes the sweetest part of the day.
A Pie Case That Makes Decisions Hard
Fresh pies sit in neat rows, and every one seems to call out for attention. Cherry, apple, peach, blackberry, strawberry rhubarb, and chocolate meringue all show up at different times of the year.
Pecan and pumpkin make regular appearances too.
The lineup changes with the seasons, so a return visit can bring a brand new surprise. Some flavors lean classic, while others, like watermelon key lime and Derby chocolate, feel a little more adventurous.
Even the names are fun to read out loud.
Choosing takes a little strategy. One smart move is to look over the whole case before picking, since the best-looking pie might be hiding at the end.
Another is to bring a friend and split two flavors, which turns the visit into a tasting party.
Pies are the heart of the shop at 2034 17th St, Columbus, IN 47201, and the variety is the reason many people keep coming back. A mixed berry slice with a spoonful of vanilla ice cream at home is a simple pleasure that never gets old.
Tuck a box into the car, and the ride home will smell wonderful.
Crust With Real Character
Great pie starts at the bottom, and the crust here gets plenty of praise. Fans describe it as soft, airy, crunchy, and buttery all at once.
That is a tall order for a bit of flour and fat, yet it works.
Crust is a craft built on patience and a gentle hand. Cold ingredients, careful rolling, and a good bake time all play a part.
Traditional methods help the layers puff up into flaky pieces that crackle under a fork.
Some customers have noticed the recipe has shifted slightly since new owners took over, which is common whenever a beloved bakery changes hands. The bakers have said they want pies to come out extra flaky, and many recent visitors rave about cherry pie with a crust that shatters just right.
A good tip is to ask about reheating. A few minutes in a warm oven can wake up the layers and bring back that fresh-baked snap.
Skip the microwave, since it tends to make crust soft in all the wrong ways.
Treat the crust as the star, and every slice becomes more satisfying.
Sugar Cream Pie, the Hoosier Classic
Ask almost anyone from Indiana about their favorite old-school dessert, and sugar cream pie is bound to come up. It is simple, smooth, and sweet, with a custard-like filling that melts on the tongue.
Many people call it a true state tradition.
Fun fact, the pie is often tied to early settlers who made treats from pantry staples like cream, sugar, and flour. Fancy fruit was not always around, so cooks got creative.
The result became a beloved comfort food that is still baked in kitchens across the state.
At this bakery, the sugar cream pie has a loyal following. Some visitors say it is the single reason they drive over, and one out-of-state customer even phoned in an order as a birthday gift for a parent.
Plan ahead if possible, because popular flavors can sell out near closing time. Stop by earlier in the day for the best pick of the case.
One slice is rich, so share it with the table or save half for tomorrow. It tastes just as good chilled the next morning.
Cookies, Rolls, and Other Sweet Surprises
Pie gets the spotlight, yet the cookie shelf deserves a standing ovation. Snickerdoodles, chocolate chip, frosted sugar cookies, strawberry crinkle, and snowball cookies all show up in happy piles.
Oatmeal raisin cookies have been known to disappear before the car even leaves the parking lot.
Then come the brownies and bars. German chocolate brownies are gooey and topped with plenty of nuts, which makes them a fan favorite.
Cookie bars and no-bake cookies add even more variety.
Pecan rolls are another crowd pleaser. Sticky, warm, and swirled with sweet glaze, they are the kind of breakfast that makes a morning feel special.
Fluffy donuts, flaky danishes, and fresh breads round out the shop.
Mixing a few smaller treats into the pie order is a smart plan. A pie feeds the family dinner table, while cookies can ride along in the cup holder for the drive.
For a gift box, pick a few different textures, like something chewy, something crumbly, and something frosted. Every bite offers a new flavor, and the sampler feels like a mini celebration.
Custom Cakes for the Big Days
Birthdays, anniversaries, and family get-togethers all taste better with cake. The bakers here design custom cakes made to fit special occasions, and a few good ideas can turn a plain dessert into the centerpiece of the party.
Special orders also reach beyond cake. Tiramisu has earned rave reviews, carrot cake has saved a birthday or two, and the team can often accommodate sugar-free or gluten-free requests when given advance notice.
Planning ahead is the key.
A good approach is to call or send a message a week or more before the event. Share the date, the number of guests, and any dietary needs.
That gives the bakers time to do careful work.
Last-minute situations sometimes work out too. One customer reached out about a carrot cake, and the bakery offered to make one before closing time.
Still, rushing is a gamble, so plan early whenever possible.
Pick up the cake in person and check the box before leaving. Then drive carefully, because frosting and sharp turns do not mix.
A cake that arrives in one piece makes the whole celebration feel smoother.
A Family-Owned Spirit With Small-Town Warmth
Local bakeries tell stories, and this one has a long one. For 33 years, family recipes and steady community support have kept the ovens running.
Ownership changed hands in recent years, and the current bakers, Samantha and Sarabeth, have kept the shop rooted in homemade treats.
Regular visitors often mention how kind and welcoming the team can be. Some customers stop by almost every week and say the shop feels like part of the neighborhood.
A small business like this thrives on that sense of connection.
Of course, a busy bakery has busy moments, especially near closing time. Arriving earlier in the day gives time to chat, ask questions, and browse without feeling rushed.
A little patience and a friendly hello go a long way.
Supporting a place like this means more than buying dessert. It helps keep traditions alive and gives the town a gathering spot that has lasted for decades.
Bring the kids, since a bakery trip is an easy way to teach them where good treats come from. Even a small cookie can turn into a happy memory.
Seasonal Fruit Pies Straight From the Farm
Ask any regular, and they will tell you the best time to visit depends on what is ripe. Strawberries and rhubarb show up in late spring, bringing bright, tangy flavors that work beautifully in pies and baked treats.
Once summer arrives, peaches and blackberries take over, adding plenty of juicy sweetness to the bakery case. When fall rolls in, apples become the star, bringing those familiar warm, spiced flavors that make a fresh pie especially tempting.
Because the bakery sits on a working farm, the fruit does not have to travel far before it lands in a pie shell. That short trip helps preserve the fresh flavor and natural juiciness of the fruit, so each filling tastes closely tied to the season it came from.
It also means the selection can change as quickly as the harvest does. Try calling ahead to see what is fresh that week before making the drive.
A favorite flavor might be available one day and gone the next, especially when the bakery gets busy. Popular pies can sell out by noon, so an early visit can make sense if there is a particular flavor you have your heart set on.
Otherwise, let the season choose for you.
Planning the Perfect Visit
A good bakery trip starts with a little planning. Ahlemeyer Bakery sits close to many of the sights that make the city a fun stop.
It is an easy detour between a walk through town and the drive home.
Hours vary by day, so checking ahead is wise. The shop is open most weekdays, has shorter hours on Saturday, and stays closed on Sunday and Monday.
Tuesday opens later in the afternoon. The website at ahlemeyer-bakery.square.site is a handy place to look.
Arriving earlier gives the best selection, since popular pies can disappear. Refrigerated pies may not be out on the counter, so asking politely about special items is a good move.
Phone orders can help lock down a favorite.
Bring a cooler on warm days if the drive is long, especially for cream pies. A flat spot in the trunk or on the floor of the back seat keeps boxes steady.
With a bit of timing and a hungry crew, the visit can turn into the sweetest stop on a Columbus getaway.
Dear Reader: This page may contain affiliate links which may earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase. Our independent journalism is not influenced by any advertiser or commercial initiative unless it is clearly marked as sponsored content. As travel products change, please be sure to reconfirm all details and stay up to date with current events to ensure a safe and successful trip.
