
More than 25,000 used vinyl records fill one store, and that’s before you count the new ones. Add another 10,000 new titles, and suddenly an afternoon disappears.
Prices on the shelves run from a single dollar to a jaw-dropping amount for true rarities. I think that’s part of the fun, since a curious kid and a serious collector can shop the same aisles and walk away with completely different finds.
This Indiana record shop has also caught the eye of The New York Times. It has collected local Best Record Shop honors year after year, too.
The best record stores make browsing feel like spending time with people who genuinely love music. The staff keeps albums playing while you dig, and I’d probably need a pretty good reason to leave before checking out a few more crates.
Thirty-Five Thousand Records Means You Should Clear Your Afternoon

Luna Music carries more than 10,000 new vinyl titles and over 25,000 used LPs. That adds up to a stack big enough to swallow a whole Saturday.
Numbers like that can sound like bragging. Here, they translate into bins you can flip through for hours without hitting the same album twice.
The selection is known for being eclectic and a little offbeat. Fans of indie and alternative music will feel right at home, but plenty of other genres get their space too.
Used records get their own sections, including a recently acquired area. That spot is worth checking first, since fresh arrivals rotate in from collections the shop buys.
Rare albums sit along the back wall, and some hang up above the bins. Good luck keeping your eyes on your budget once those catch your attention.
Prices range from about a buck to the high end of collector territory. That spread makes the hunt fun for every kind of shopper.
My advice is simple. Start with a loose wish list, then let the bins surprise you, because the best finds usually show up when you stop looking for something specific.
A December Opening Started A Thirty-Year Story

Back on December 21, 1994, Todd Robinson opened the first Luna Music. That original store sat near 86th Street and Ditch Road on the north side of Indianapolis.
Robinson drew inspiration from a record store in Dayton, Ohio. That shop mixed in a cafe and a hangout space, and the idea stuck with him.
As a result, Luna was never meant to be just a place to grab an album and leave. It was built to be a spot where music fans could linger and connect.
Growth came quickly. A second store opened on Massachusetts Avenue in 2001, and the current shop arrived in 2006.
The 86th Street location closed around 2008. Then the Mass Ave store shut its doors in March 2011, leaving one shop to carry the whole name.
Plenty of record stores vanished during those years. Luna adjusted, focused its energy, and kept going.
The shop reached its 30th anniversary year in 2024. For an independent business in a changing music world, that run says a lot about smart choices and loyal fans.
It also makes every visit feel connected to a longer Indiana music story.
The College Avenue Shop Is Easy To Find And Hard To Leave

Only one Luna Music remains today, and it sits at 5202 N College Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46220. Locals know this stretch as part of the Meridian-Kessler area.
The neighborhood setting gives the shop a friendly, walkable feel. It’s the kind of address where a quick errand can easily turn into a long browse.
Parking is available nearby, which helps when you’re hauling a heavy stack of records back to the car. Trust me, vinyl gets heavier than you expect.
The entrance is wheelchair accessible. That matters for a store built around wandering and browsing at your own pace.
Hours are generous on most days. The shop typically opens at 10 AM Monday through Saturday and 11 AM on Sunday.
Schedules can shift, so a quick check before heading over is smart. Some listings show a weekday closure, and nobody wants to arrive at a locked door with cash ready.
For visitors exploring Indianapolis, this address makes a great stop on a day around the north side. Pair it with a neighborhood stroll, and you’ve got a solid afternoon planned around music in Indiana’s capital city.
Turntables, Cassettes, And Candles Share The Spotlight

Vinyl gets top billing, but the supporting cast deserves a round of applause. CDs and cassettes have their own place on the shelves.
Need something to actually play those records on? The shop sells new and used turntables, plus hi-fi audio gear for people who care about sound.
That makes the store a handy first stop for beginners. You can leave with a player and your first few albums in one trip.
The gift side of the shop is surprisingly fun. You’ll find t-shirts, hats, baby onesies, slipmats, and tote bags.
There are also vinyl cleaning supplies, which every record owner eventually needs. Dusty records crackle, and nobody signed up for that.
Then things get cozy. Incense, sage, candles, coffee mugs, greeting cards, books, and magazines round out the mix.
I love that combination because it solves gift shopping fast. A music fan in your life will probably appreciate a record, but a mug or candle from a beloved shop works too.
Give yourself time to explore beyond the bins. Some of the best surprises here aren’t round and black.
Friendly Faces Make The Digging Even Better

Good music plays overhead while you shop, and that soundtrack sets the mood. The staff often spins records that pair perfectly with flipping through bins.
Owner Todd Robinson has talked about the human side of the vinyl revival. He points to different generations of music fans meeting and talking in the aisles.
That idea fits the store’s personality. Older collectors and newer listeners can swap tips while hunting for the same kind of treasure.
The team can help with practical stuff too. If an album is out of stock, staff can order it in for you.
New to vinyl and feeling a bit lost? Ask questions, because learning the difference between pressings and editions is part of the fun.
The store is often described as clean, well stocked, and built for browsing. Everything is organized so you can dig without getting overwhelmed.
I can’t imagine a better place to start a record collection. A helpful staff turns an intimidating hobby into something friendly, and that’s worth more than any rare pressing.
Bring your curiosity along with your wish list, and you’ll probably leave with both a record and a new idea.
Live Music Sometimes Happens Right Between The Bins

Shopping for albums is great. Hearing a band perform a few feet from the record racks?
That’s a whole different level.
Luna Music hosts in-store performances by local acts and touring musicians. These shows bring the music off the shelves and into the room.
The shop also holds album release listening events. Fans gather to hear new records together, which beats hitting play alone in your bedroom.
Local artists get real support here. The store offers consignment for musicians who want to sell their own records.
That support runs deep in the shop’s history. Luna once ran a record label called Recordhead from its back office.
The label released nearly 100 records and invested in Indianapolis artists. Not many record stores can claim they helped build part of their city’s music scene.
Want to catch an event? Keep an eye on the shop’s social media and event calendar.
Events can be small and personal, so they make a memorable outing. You might discover your next favorite band while standing beside the bin where its album sits.
In Indiana’s music scene, this store keeps the stage door open.
Record Store Day Turns The Block Into A Party

One Saturday each spring, record stores around the world celebrate together. It’s called Record Store Day, and Luna Music treats it like a holiday.
The day honors independent record shops. Stores like this one stock special limited-edition releases you can’t easily find elsewhere.
Some of those titles get pressed in small numbers. Once they’re gone, they’re often gone for good, so planning ahead helps.
Luna takes the celebration outdoors with live music. Food trucks often join the fun, giving the whole thing a block party feel.
That mix makes it a great first visit for newcomers. You get shopping, music, and snacks in one stop.
Make a short list of the releases you want most. Then set a budget before you arrive, because limited editions have a sneaky way of draining wallets.
Comfortable shoes are a smart call, too. Between browsing, listening, and grabbing a bite, you’ll spend plenty of time on your feet.
Even if you skip the rare titles, the atmosphere is worth it. Few things beat a sunny day full of music lovers sharing one big hobby.
Old Records In The Basement Could Find A New Home

Got a closet full of dusty LPs from a relative? Luna Music might want to take a look at them.
The shop buys clean, used records. It also accepts collections on consignment, which can be a nice option for special pieces.
Used turntables and older audio equipment are welcome too. That old stereo receiver might deserve a second life with a new listener.
Big collections get extra attention. For hauls of around 400 pieces or more, the store often makes house calls.
That’s a relief for anyone staring at crates in a basement. Lugging hundreds of records across town is a serious workout.
Before bringing anything in, give your records a quick check. Clean vinyl in decent sleeves usually makes the process smoother.
Here’s the fun part of selling to a shop like this. Your old albums enter those used bins, ready for someone else to discover.
The constant flow of incoming collections helps explain why the used section stays so fresh. Every trip can turn up something new because Indiana music fans keep passing their treasures along.
Big Names Keep Praising This Shop, And Shipping Spreads The Love

Eight straight years of Best Record Shop honors from NUVO Newsweekly is no small feat. Indianapolis Monthly has given the store that title as well.
National attention followed. The New York Times called Luna Music an Essential Spot, and Time Out included it among the best things to do in Indianapolis.
Then The New Yorker mentioned the shop’s Sound Subscription Service. That shoutout landed in a 2025 holiday gift guide.
The subscription is a clever idea. Music arrives picked by people who know records, which feels like getting a mixtape from a friend.
Live far from Indiana? Worldwide shipping lets you shop anyway.
Records are hand-picked and carefully packed. That care matters, since a cracked record is one of life’s saddest packages.
Local shoppers can use pickup options too. Order ahead, then swing by College Avenue to collect your haul.
All that praise adds up to a simple message. Luna Music has spent three decades proving that a neighborhood record store can earn national respect and still feel personal.
I’d call that a pretty good reason to plan a visit, or at least a shopping cart full of records.