A national publication named a burger from this Ohio spot the best in the state. Smashed patties, house made pickles, shaved onion, and a special sauce.
Sounds almost too simple. But somehow it completely delivers. This place started as a market stall, spent years earning fans, and then opened its own location to a crowd that was already waiting.
The first bite stops being an exaggeration and starts making perfect sense. This is one of those rare spots where the food lives up to every word written about it.
From Market Stall to Cult Status: The Preston’s Origin Story
Before Preston’s had a permanent address, it had a reputation. For two full years, the team operated out of the North Market in Columbus, building a loyal following one smashed patty at a time.
That kind of slow, earned growth is rare, and it says a lot about what they were putting out.
When the brick-and-mortar location finally opened in 2023 on North High Street, it was not a soft launch. People already knew the name.
They already had favorites. The move from market booth to restaurant felt less like a debut and more like a homecoming for a crowd that had been waiting patiently.
The space itself is smaller than you might expect, but it fits the vibe perfectly. It feels urban and clean without trying too hard.
There is something grounding about a place that built its name through word of mouth and honest food rather than flashy marketing. Preston’s did not need a grand opening to make noise.
The burgers already did that job years before the doors ever opened on High Street.
The Classic Burger: Why Ohio’s Best Cheeseburger Sounds Simpler Than It Tastes
Lovefood, a national food publication, named it the best cheeseburger in Ohio. That is a bold claim for a sandwich that sounds almost plain on paper.
A smashed patty, American cheese, shaved onion, iceberg lettuce, house-made pickles, and a special sauce. Nothing on that list sounds revolutionary.
And yet, the result is something people describe as transcendental. The magic is in the execution.
The patty gets pressed hard against a hot surface, creating crispy, lacy edges that contrast beautifully with the soft, yielding center. Every ingredient earns its place, and nothing feels like filler.
What really sets it apart is the sourcing. Preston’s uses local Ohio beef and makes most items from scratch, including those pickles.
That attention to detail shows up in every bite. The special sauce ties everything together with a richness that lingers just long enough to make you reach for the second half faster than you planned.
Some people order it as a double without hesitation. Both versions hold up.
This is the kind of cheeseburger that makes you question every other cheeseburger you have eaten before it.
The Spicy Boi Burger: A Flavor Combination That Has No Right Being This Good
Pimento cheese and sambal jam on a smashburger sounds like something a food dare would produce. Instead, it turned out to be one of the most talked-about items on the Preston’s menu.
The Spicy Boi Burger brings together creamy, tangy pimento cheese with a sweet and spicy sambal jam that hits in layers rather than all at once.
The heat builds gradually, which keeps it interesting rather than overwhelming. Paired with the crispy-edged smash patties and those house-made pickles, each bite has something happening from start to finish.
It is the kind of burger that makes you slow down and pay attention.
Regulars who come in for the Classic often end up ordering the Spicy Boi on their second visit, and then they have a hard time choosing between the two. That is a good problem to have.
The sambal jam in particular has earned its own fans, with people specifically mentioning the chili paste flavor as a standout element. Preston’s clearly put thought into this one, and it shows.
Sometimes the unexpected combination is the one that sticks with you longest.
Gluten-Free Done Right: A Rare Thing in the Burger World
Gluten-free dining at a burger joint usually comes with a side of disappointment. The buns tend to be dry, crumbly, or so dense they overpower the food.
Preston’s seems to have taken that problem personally. Multiple guests who eat gluten-free have called it the best GF burger bun they have found in Columbus, and that is not a small claim in a city full of food options.
The bun stays soft. It does not disintegrate before you finish the first half, which is apparently rarer than it should be.
Beyond the bun, Preston’s offers a dedicated prep space, a separate fryer, and a separate grill for gluten-free orders. That level of care matters enormously to people who deal with dietary restrictions daily.
One guest put it simply: they finally got to experience a real burger again. That kind of feedback is not about food trends or menu marketing.
It is about someone feeling included at the table in a way that does not happen often enough. Preston’s earns real loyalty from this community, and the gluten-free fried chicken sandwich has become a fan favorite in its own right, praised for its crispy exterior and juicy interior.
The Atmosphere on North High Street: Small Space, Big Energy
The first thing you register when you arrive is that the space is compact. That is not a complaint, just a fact that actually adds to the character of the place.
Preston’s on North High Street has an urban, clean energy that feels intentional rather than accidental. It is the kind of spot where you feel comfortable whether you are grabbing a quick lunch solo or sitting down with family.
Ordering happens through a QR code at the table, which keeps things moving smoothly even when the house is full. There are also a couple of outdoor tables for those days when Columbus weather cooperates.
The vibe is casual without being careless, and the staff consistently earns praise for being friendly and genuinely helpful.
One guest described it as reminding their father-in-law of how burger places felt in the 1950s. That kind of nostalgia is hard to manufacture.
It comes from a place that actually cares about the food and the people eating it. The atmosphere at Preston’s does not try to compete with trendy restaurant design.
It just feels right, and that comfort makes the food taste even better than it might somewhere louder and more self-conscious.
Sides and Extras Worth Ordering Alongside Your Burger
The burgers get most of the attention at Preston’s, but the sides hold their own in a way that feels deliberate. The fries are served vertically in paper bags, which is a small detail that somehow makes them feel more considered.
They come out hot, lightly salted, and consistently crisp without being greasy. That consistency is worth something.
The mac and cheese has developed its own fan base. It comes out hot with a good texture, and the noodles stay firm rather than turning into a soft, forgettable mush.
The coney dog is thick, well-seasoned, and far more substantial than the standard version you might expect. At least one guest called it the best they had ever eaten.
The secret sauce, which some guests have identified as a garlic aioli, is versatile enough that people request it on the side specifically to use as a dipping sauce for their fries. That kind of crossover appeal is a sign of something genuinely well-made.
Preston’s does not treat the sides as an afterthought, and that philosophy shows up clearly in the finished product. Every item on the tray feels like it belongs there.
Why Preston’s Has Earned Its Place as a Columbus Food Destination
Columbus has no shortage of good places to eat. The food scene here is competitive, and people have strong opinions about their favorites.
For Preston’s to consistently rise to the top of burger conversations in this city means it is doing something genuinely right. The Lovefood recognition as Ohio’s best cheeseburger brought national eyes to a place that locals had already claimed as their own.
What keeps people coming back is not just the food, though the food is clearly the anchor. It is the combination of quality ingredients, honest preparation, and a staff that seems to actually enjoy being there.
Those elements together create the kind of experience that turns a first visit into a habit.
The price point sits at a moderate level, not cheap, but guests repeatedly say it is worth every dollar. That agreement across a wide range of diners is meaningful.
Families, solo eaters, gluten-free guests, and longtime Columbus residents all find something at Preston’s that feels made for them. That broad appeal without sacrificing quality is genuinely hard to pull off.
Preston’s manages it, and that is exactly why this little burger joint on North High Street has built a following that keeps growing.
Address: 2973 N High St, Columbus, OH 43202
Dear Reader: This page may contain affiliate links which may earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase. Our independent journalism is not influenced by any advertiser or commercial initiative unless it is clearly marked as sponsored content. As travel products change, please be sure to reconfirm all details and stay up to date with current events to ensure a safe and successful trip.
