Unlimited pizza, deluxe breadsticks, and cinnamon bites for about the price of a single takeout pie? That deal shows up at lunch twice a week at a family-run pizza spot in central Indiana.
I like how simple the idea is. You grab a plate, pick a slice, and go back when that slice disappears.
A fountain drink comes along for the ride, and kids get an even smaller price.
The setting adds another twist. Reservoir views stretch out from the parking lot and patio, and the dining room hides a cozy pizza cave with a fireplace.
The same family has run the business since 1993, and it moved twice before landing here.
I can’t imagine a better excuse to stretch a Friday lunch break. So the real question is simple: how many slices count as a reasonable lunch?
Your Lunch Break Is About To Get A Lot Less Rushed
Friday and Sunday lunch hit differently at Pizza House in Cicero. From 11 AM to 2 PM on those days, the dining room turns into an all-you-can-eat pizza stop.
The buffet is dine-in only, so plan on staying a while. That’s honestly the best part, since nobody wants to balance unlimited pizza in a car cup holder.
The price sits right around what you would expect to pay for a fast-food combo. For that, you get pizza, deluxe breadsticks, cinnamon bites, and a fountain drink.
Not a bad trade for a weekday lunch.
Kids 10 and under get an even friendlier price. That makes Sunday lunch with the whole crew a lot easier on the wallet.
The three-hour window matters, so don’t stroll in at 1:55 expecting a full spread. Arriving closer to the start gives you more time to sample different pies without rushing.
Hours at small restaurants can shift, too. A quick check before you drive is a smart move, especially if you are coming from another Indiana town.
Think of it as a tasting tour with no pressure. Try a slice of something new, and if it wins you over, grab another.
Save Room For The Breadsticks, Seriously
Breadsticks might be the sneaky star here. They come up constantly when people talk about this place, and the deluxe version gets special attention.
That’s why it matters that deluxe breadsticks are part of the buffet lineup. You don’t have to choose between pizza and the side everyone talks about.
Pacing becomes the real challenge. Load up on breadsticks first, and suddenly that third slice of pizza feels like a big ask.
Then come the cinnamon bites. They give the buffet a sweet ending, so you can finish lunch on dessert without ordering anything extra.
A fountain drink rounds out the deal. It sounds small, but it keeps the whole lunch simple with no surprise add-ons.
On the regular menu, the bread lineup grows even bigger. Deluxe Breadsticks share space with Cheesy Pepperoni Bites, Boscos, and Fried Ravioli.
There are also Macaroni Jalapeno Bites, Mozzarella Sticks, and Chips and Queso. Fried Green Beans and Cream Cheese Jalapeno Poppers fill out the list.
A smart plan is a small first plate. Grab one breadstick, one slice, and one cinnamon bite, then decide where your loyalty lies.
Good luck keeping that plan for long. Breadsticks this popular tend to win every argument.
Pick A Crust, Then Pick A Personality
Taco Deluxe, Tropical Habanero, and something called the “MAC” Attack all live on the same menu. That tells you the kitchen likes to have a little fun.
The specialty list runs deep. Combination, Deluxe, House Specialty, and All Meat cover the hearty side of things.
Vegetarian, Hawaiian, and Margherita bring lighter or classic flavors. Roasted Chicken and The Kelso add a few more twists to the lineup.
Of course, a plain cheese pizza is always an option. Sometimes the classic is exactly what a hungry kid, or adult, needs.
Crust is where things get personal. You can pick hand-tossed or original thin, depending on how much chew you want.
Gluten-free diners have real choices here, too. Cauliflower and cheese crust and brown rice crust both come in a 10-inch size.
The kitchen also works with vegetarian and lactose-free preferences. That makes group orders far less stressful when everyone eats a little differently.
My advice is to treat the menu like a choose-your-own-adventure book. Pick one familiar favorite and one wild card.
Worst case, you found a new order to repeat next time. Best case, the “MAC” Attack becomes your new personality.
The Broasted Chicken Deserves Its Own Spotlight
Pasture-raised, hand-breaded broasted chicken is not what most people expect at a pizza place. Yet here it is, sitting proudly on the menu.
That detail says a lot about Pizza House. The kitchen clearly wants to be more than a one-trick pie shop.
Wings come three ways: dry rub, sauced, or boneless. So the wing debate at your table can stay friendly.
Pasta fans have options as well. Spaghetti, Baked Spaghetti, and Lasagna bring some comfort food to the lineup.
Oven-baked sandwiches are another route. Stromboli, Hot Italian, Chicken Cordon Bleu, Kelso, and Ham and Cheese all make the list.
Calzones are available for anyone who likes their pizza folded and stuffed. Salads round things out, from a simple side to a Deluxe Taco salad.
Then there’s dessert, and it gets a bit playful. Brownie Pizza and Cinnamon Sticks sit alongside Vanilla Soft Serve.
The real curveball is Dole Pineapple Soft Serve. Yes, the famous pineapple treat, right here in a small Indiana town.
That’s the kind of menu surprise that turns a quick dinner into a longer one. Save a little room, because skipping pineapple soft serve feels like a mistake.
Three Decades, Two Towns, One Family
Back in 1993, this story started in Alexandria, not Cicero. The family behind Pizza House opened there first.
Later, the restaurant made the move to Cicero. Its first home in town was on Peru Street.
Then came another move to the current spot near Morse Lake. Few restaurants relocate that many times and keep the same family at the wheel.
As of 2026, that adds up to 33 years in business. That is a long run for any independent pizza shop.
Family ownership shows in small ways. The place has a reputation for friendly, welcoming service.
I believe that kind of staying power comes from people wanting to come back. Restaurants don’t last three decades on luck alone.
The moves also tell a quieter story. Each one seems to bring the restaurant closer to the heart of the community it now calls home.
Today, Pizza House feels rooted on Main Street. It’s the sort of local spot where the history isn’t on a plaque, but it’s there.
Next time you grab a slice, consider the road it traveled. From Alexandria to Peru Street to the lake, that pizza has put in some miles.
Yes, There Is A Pizza Cave, And Yes, It Has A Fireplace
Few sentences sound better than this one: the restaurant has a pizza cave with a fireplace. It’s a cozy lounge space, and it works nicely for groups.
Picture-perfect for a chilly Indiana evening? Absolutely.
A fireplace and a hot pizza feel like a natural pair.
The rest of the interior blends modern touches with a relaxed vibe. It’s often called super cute, and the mood stays casual and family-friendly.
One small detail keeps showing up, too. Decks of cards sit on the tables, ready to fill the wait for your food.
That’s a charming move. Instead of staring at phones, your table can sneak in a quick round of Go Fish or rummy.
The dining room is on the smaller side, which adds to the friendly feel. It reads more neighborhood hangout than giant chain restaurant.
The building is wheelchair accessible as well. That makes it easier for everyone in the group to join in.
If your crowd is large, ask about the cave when you plan ahead. A fireplace, cards, and pizza make for a gathering that nobody rushes to leave.
Lake Views Come Free With Every Slice
Morse Reservoir is part of the scenery here. You can catch views of it from the parking lot and patio areas.
To be clear, the restaurant isn’t sitting right on the water. Still, a lake glimpse with your lunch is a pretty sweet bonus.
The patio makes good use of that setting on nice days. Outdoor seating is a popular feature, especially when Indiana weather cooperates.
You’ll find Pizza House at 11 N Main St, Cicero, IN 46034. It sits right in the heart of town.
Cicero is a small Hamilton County community built around the reservoir. That gives the area a relaxed lake-town feel, even on a regular weekday.
The location makes the restaurant an easy stop after time on the water. Boaters and lake visitors don’t have to go far for a hot meal.
It also works as a reason to explore the town. Grab lunch, then take a slow drive to see more of the reservoir.
Honestly, it’s a better view than most office break rooms offer. Trading a sad desk lunch for pizza near a lake sounds like a solid upgrade.
Bring The Whole Team, Or Let The Pizza Come To You
Planning a birthday, a team meeting, or a post-game party gets easier with pizza involved. Pizza House handles more than walk-in tables.
Catering is available with its own specialized menu. That means you can feed a crowd without juggling a dozen separate orders.
Group reservations are welcome for private dining. The restaurant offers indoor and outdoor spaces for events, meetings, and gatherings.
That flexibility is handy in a small town. Not every local spot can host a group and still keep the regular dinner rush moving.
For everyday nights, carry-out is a big part of the business. Online ordering makes it simple to grab dinner on the way home.
Planning ahead helps a lot with bigger orders. Give the team a heads-up, and your party gets the attention it deserves.
Sports teams and families should keep this in mind. Few things end a long Saturday better than a table piled with pizza and breadsticks.
The menu variety helps too. Between pizza, wings, broasted chicken, and gluten-free crusts, even picky guests can find something.
So the next time someone asks who is handling food, you’ll have an answer ready.
Timing Is Everything, So Plan Your Visit Smart
A little planning goes a long way with this one. Lunch runs from 11 AM to 2 PM, and the buffet sticks to Fridays and Sundays.
Dinner opens at 4 PM every day. It wraps up at 9 PM Sunday through Thursday and at 10 PM on Friday and Saturday.
That gap between lunch and dinner is important. Show up mid-afternoon, and you may find the doors locked until 4.
Schedules at small restaurants can change, so check the latest hours before you head out. It’s worth it if you’re driving from elsewhere in Indiana.
Online ordering is a great backup plan. Order ahead, swing by, and enjoy your pizza at home or by the lake.
Dinner is a fun choice for date nights or family outings. The pizza cave, the cards on the table, and the cozy feel all shine after dark.
The buffet, though, is the headline act. Unlimited pizza with breadsticks and cinnamon bites makes a Friday feel like a mini holiday.
Pizza House has been feeding people for over three decades. Show up hungry at the right hour, and you’ll see why it keeps going strong.
