This Hidden Small-Town Indiana Candy Shop Is A Time Machine Packed With Sweets You Haven’t Seen Since You Were A Kid

Ronald Reagan once ordered jelly beans from a small-town candy shop, and they were roughly four times the size of normal ones. That alone makes me want to grab my car keys.

The store sells more than 75 tons of these giant beans every year. It all started with a black licorice bean made for a maple syrup festival back in 1969.

Inside, a wall of over 1,000 wooden drawers climbs from floor to ceiling. Glass jars line the shelves, packed with Wax Lips, Candy Buttons, Necco Wafers, and Sky Bars.

I have a feeling even the most casual visit would turn into a trip down memory lane.

This little Indiana shop has been part of its downtown since the early 1900s. So which forgotten candy from your childhood is still waiting there for you?

A Peddler’s Dream Turned Into Your New Favorite Candy Stop

A Peddler's Dream Turned Into Your New Favorite Candy Stop
© Wakarusa Dime Store

Long before anyone sold jumbo jelly beans here, a German immigrant named Mose Wolfberg traveled Elkhart County as a peddler. In 1907, he finally put down roots and opened Wolfberg’s Department Store.

Back then, the business served as a true town cornerstone. People could shop for everyday goods, and some even dropped off laundry there.

Over time, a variety store was added to the department store. That variety store slowly grew into what we now know as the Wakarusa Dime Store.

The Wolfberg family ran things until 1983, which is an impressive stretch for any family business.

In 1995, Mac and Deb McNally bought the store. Their goal was simple and smart: keep the quality and traditions that made the place special.

As the years rolled on, the focus shifted toward snacks, sweets, and candy. Honestly, that feels like the right call.

Laundry service is useful, but nobody ever drove across Indiana for clean socks.

Knowing this history makes a visit feel richer. You’re not just buying a candy bar.

You’re shopping in a business that has served its community for well over a century, and that’s a pretty sweet legacy to hold in your hand.

Over 1,000 Wooden Drawers Will Make Your Jaw Drop

Over 1,000 Wooden Drawers Will Make Your Jaw Drop
© Wakarusa Dime Store, Wakarusa, 103 E Waterford St, Wakarusa, IN 46573

One wall inside this shop could keep a curious kid busy for an hour. It holds more than 1,000 wooden drawers, stacked from the floor all the way to the ceiling.

That’s not a typo. A thousand drawers.

Most of us can barely keep track of one junk drawer at home.

The rest of the room adds to the old-time charm. Original hardwood floors stretch underfoot, and pressed tin ceilings shine overhead.

Both details come from a building that dates back to the turn of the 20th century.

Glass jars filled with colorful candy line the shelves. They make the whole space feel like a scene from an old photograph, only brighter and much tastier.

Here’s a tip for your visit. Look up, look down, and look around before you grab a basket.

The building itself is part of the fun, and it’s easy to miss the details when sugar is calling your name.

Aisles can feel snug, so take your time and move slowly. Small spaces like this reward patience.

Every shelf seems to hide another surprise, and the wooden drawer wall makes a great backdrop for a quick family photo.

Jelly Beans So Big A President Kept Ordering Them

Jelly Beans So Big A President Kept Ordering Them
© Wakarusa Dime Store

Ronald Reagan loved jelly beans, and he ordered these giant ones from Wakarusa more than once. That kind of fan helped turn a small-town treat into the store’s “World Famous Jumbo Jelly Beans.”

The story starts in 1969. Lou Wolfberg, son of founder Mose Wolfberg, created them as a special treat for the Wakarusa Maple Syrup Festival.

The very first flavor was black licorice. That’s a bold opening move, since licorice fans and licorice skeptics rarely agree on anything.

Each jumbo bean is about four times the size of a regular jelly bean. You don’t nibble one of these.

You commit to it.

The numbers are wild too. The Wakarusa Dime Store sells more than 75 tons of jumbo jelly beans every year.

They go to visitors from around the region and to online shoppers all over the world.

Not sure which flavor to try? Samples are often available in the store, so you can test a few before picking your favorites.

That’s a smart way to build a mix you’ll actually love, rather than guessing and hoping for the best.

Your Childhood Candy Bag Is Still Here

Your Childhood Candy Bag Is Still Here
© Wakarusa Dime Store, Wakarusa, 103 E Waterford St, Wakarusa, IN 46573

Remember Wax Lips? They’re still around, and you can find them right here.

So are Wax Moustaches, which might be the silliest snack ever invented.

The shop carries a huge mix of nostalgic and hard-to-find candy. Some sources count more than 450 different kinds on hand.

Old favorites fill the shelves. You’ll spot Candy Buttons, Candy Necklaces, Apple Heads, Necco Wafers, and Turkish Taffy.

Classic bars like Clark, Zero, Score, and Sky Bar show up too.

Big League Chew is part of the lineup as well. That shredded gum pouch made a lot of kids feel like baseball stars.

This is where the store works its real magic. Parents and grandparents often bring kids here to share the candy they loved growing up.

It’s a fun way to swap stories, and maybe settle which decade had the best sweets.

A good plan is to make a short list before you go. Think about the treats you haven’t seen in years.

Then hunt for them on the shelves, and let the kids pick something new while you relive something old.

Sixty Taffy Flavors Means Decisions Get Tricky

Sixty Taffy Flavors Means Decisions Get Tricky
© Wakarusa Dime Store

Saltwater taffy fans, brace yourselves. The store stocks more than 60 flavors, which makes choosing just a few a real challenge.

Options range from classic to creative. Butter and black licorice swirl sit near playful picks like “dirty soda,” a cola flavor with coconut and lime.

Pickle lovers get attention here too. The shop has offered pickle taffy, pickle candy, and pickle gummies, so sour fans won’t feel left out.

Chocolate gets its own spotlight. Fine chocolates are available, and you can customize a chocolate box.

That makes this an easy place to put together a thoughtful gift.

Fudge, popcorn, sour candy, and spicy candy round things out. There are also sugar-free choices, which helps when someone in your group needs to watch their sugar.

Gummy fans should take a close look at the shelves. The selection goes way beyond bears and worms, with all kinds of unusual shapes.

My advice? Grab an assorted taffy mix if you can’t decide.

It lets you sample many flavors at once. Then you’ll know exactly what to load up on next time, and there will definitely be a next time.

Glass-Bottle Sodas And Snacks That Bug Some People

Glass-Bottle Sodas And Snacks That Bug Some People
© Wakarusa Dime Store

Thirsty after all that candy? Rows of unique glass-bottle sodas wait for you, and many are hard to find anywhere else.

Glass bottles just feel different in your hand. They add to the old-school mood and make a fun souvenir for soda fans.

The Wakarusa location also has a coffee bar. That’s handy for grown-ups who need a little boost while the kids debate gummy shapes.

Now for the brave part. The store has carried around 20 varieties of crickets and other edible insects.

The shop even joked that this really bugs some people.

Not everyone will try a cricket, and that’s totally fine. But if someone in your family loves a dare, this could become the story they tell for weeks.

Maple products are on the shelves too. They tie right into the town’s famous festival and make a tasty, local take-home treat.

Here’s a smart move for road trips. Pick up a few odd soda flavors and do a taste test in the car or at home.

Rate each one. It turns a simple snack stop into a game, and the loser picks the next soda.

Free Rides, Plush Toys, And Little Ones Grinning

Free Rides, Plush Toys, And Little Ones Grinning
© Wakarusa Dime Store, Wakarusa, 103 E Waterford St, Wakarusa, IN 46573

Kids get a bonus treat that doesn’t involve sugar. The shop has one of the oldest coin-operated horses in Indiana, and the ride is free.

The store joked that this makes it 100 percent cheaper than the one at Meijer. Hard to argue with that math.

A huge gumball machine also stands inside, adding a pop of color. Little ones tend to spot it fast, so plan your answer to “Can I have one?” ahead of time.

Beyond candy, there are PEZ dispensers, plush toys, and novelty items. These make great small gifts or rewards for kids who behaved nicely on the drive.

The shop has also hosted seasonal fun, like a Halloween scavenger hunt around the store. Activities like that turn browsing into a game for younger visitors.

A quick heads-up for families is helpful here. The store does not have a public restroom, so plan a stop before you arrive.

That small step can save a lot of wiggling and worried faces.

Give kids a set budget or a small bag to fill. It teaches choices, keeps things fair, and makes picking candy feel like a big, important mission.

Plan Around The Maple Syrup Festival For Extra Fun

Plan Around The Maple Syrup Festival For Extra Fun
© Wakarusa Dime Store

April is a big month in this small town. That’s when the annual Wakarusa Maple Syrup Festival takes over, and the candy shop plays a starring role.

Remember, the jumbo jelly beans were created for this very festival in 1969. Stopping by the Wakarusa Dime Store is considered a key part of the festival experience.

The town is known for maple syrup tapped by Amish producers. That local flavor gives the event a true Northern Indiana feel.

If you visit during the festival, expect a livelier downtown. Planning ahead makes sense, and arriving earlier in the day is usually a smart way to enjoy things at a calmer pace.

Can’t make it in April? No problem.

The store is open year-round, so the jelly beans and taffy are always waiting.

Wakarusa is also part of Elkhart County’s Heritage Trail Quilt Garden Tour. The tour features quilt-inspired gardens and murals, which add color to a road trip.

Pairing your candy stop with the quilt gardens or festival creates a full day out. Bring a bag for maple goodies too.

You’ll want something to remember the trip by besides a sugar rush.

Find The Big Windows On Waterford Street

Find The Big Windows On Waterford Street
© Wakarusa Dime Store, Wakarusa, 103 E Waterford St, Wakarusa, IN 46573

Spotting this shop is easy once you’re downtown. The storefront stretches with about 100 feet of window display, which is a lot of glass for a small town.

You’ll find it at 103 E Waterford Street, Wakarusa, IN 46573. The historic brick building sits right in the heart of the community.

Wakarusa is a small town in North-Central Indiana, inside Elkhart County. It’s the kind of downtown where a candy store can be a true landmark.

Hours are generally Monday through Friday from 10 a.m. to 5:30 p.m., and Saturday from 9 a.m. to 5:30 p.m. Sunday hours run from 11 a.m. to 4 p.m.

Since the store closes in the early evening, plan a daytime visit. It’s smart to double-check hours before a long drive, especially around holidays.

There’s a second location in Granger, but the Wakarusa store is the original. That’s where the drawers, tin ceilings, and creaky charm live.

Leave yourself plenty of time to wander. Rushing through a place packed with over a century of history and hundreds of candies just feels wrong.

Slow down, snack a little, and soak up the Wakarusa Dime Store.