This Minnesota Pie Factory Sells Its Own Bakery Favorites Directly to Shoppers

The bakery’s signature Tipsy Pies feature locally sourced spirits in their fillings.

That clever trick is only part of the story. The signature Tipsy Pies use the crust recipe passed down from founder Sara Hayden’s late mother, preserving an important family tradition.

The bakers also make savory hand pies, frozen pies to bake at home, donuts, bars, and lefse. You can shop it all straight from the source in Minnesota.

I like how a pie maker with a State Fair following still keeps things this personal.

A Pie Story That Started With Mom’s Crust

A Pie Story That Started With Mom's Crust
© Sara’s Bakery – featuring Tipsy Pies

Sara Hayden never set out to build a pie empire in a lab coat. She started baking in 2012, the year after her mother passed, to carry on a family passion.

The business first went by Rustic Pies of Stillwater LLC. Over time it grew into Sara’s Bakery – featuring Tipsy Pies, and the name stuck for good reason.

Every pie still uses her mother’s hand-rolled crust recipe. That means each slice carries a little family history along with the filling.

Sara is known around town as The Pie Lady. It’s a fitting title for someone who turned grief into something warm and shareable.

The bakery describes its approach as baking from the heart. Family recipes, classic techniques, and good ingredients guide nearly everything that comes out of the oven.

I believe that kind of origin story changes how a pie tastes. You aren’t just buying dessert from a factory line in Minnesota.

You’re buying a recipe that someone loved enough to keep alive. That’s a pretty sweet reason to stop by.

Next time you see a pie with that golden edge, think of the mom behind it. Then go ahead and take a second one home.

Yes, the Pies Are Tipsy, and Yes, Kids Can Eat Them

Yes, the Pies Are Tipsy, and Yes, Kids Can Eat Them
© Sara’s Bakery – featuring Tipsy Pies

Here’s a fun twist on a classic dessert. Each Tipsy Pie gets a local spirited twist mixed right into its filling.

So Grandma, the kids, and your picky cousin can all share the same pie. Nobody needs a separate dessert table.

Names on the menu lean playful. You might spot a Boozy Blueberry-Lemon Hand Pie or an Irish Pecan Tart on the shelf.

The Irish Pecan Tart also comes in a gluten-friendly version. Sara has also shared that Drunken Pumpkin tarts show up around the holidays.

Flavors rotate with the seasons, so the lineup doesn’t sit still for long. That’s great news for anyone who gets bored easily.

A smart move is to grab a familiar favorite plus one wild card. You’ll get comfort and adventure in the same bag.

The concept sounds like a contradiction at first. Then you realize it’s simply a clever way to add depth to fruit and nut fillings. Honestly, it’s the kind of idea you wish you’d thought of first.

Savory Hand Pies Make a Strong Case for Pie at Lunch

Savory Hand Pies Make a Strong Case for Pie at Lunch
© Sara’s Bakery – featuring Tipsy Pies

Chicken Pot Pie in a crust you can hold. Bacon Mac and Cheese tucked inside pastry. Lunch just got a lot more interesting.

Sweet pies get plenty of attention here, but savory options hold their own. The bakery makes hand pies plus full-size pot pies.

That variety helps when you’re feeding a crowd. One person wants dinner, another wants dessert, and both leave happy.

Meat pies come in both handheld and larger sizes. It’s an easy way to plan a quick weeknight meal without cooking from scratch.

The chicken pot pies are a frequent favorite on this menu. They’re the kind of food that feels made for a Minnesota winter evening.

Breakfast-style savory pies have also appeared in the lineup. A vegetarian version has been part of the mix in past seasons.

Gluten-free shoppers have some choices too. The shop has carried treats from NoWaySweets, a gluten- and dairy-free baker.

Picking a savory pie first and a sweet one second just makes sense. Call it a balanced meal, at least by pie logic.

Your future self, staring into an empty fridge, will be grateful you planned ahead.

Your Freezer Is About to Get a Lot More Exciting

Your Freezer Is About to Get a Lot More Exciting
© Sara’s Bakery – featuring Tipsy Pies

Fresh pie is great today. Frozen pie is great on a random Tuesday three weeks from now.

Many of the creations at Sara’s Bakery – featuring Tipsy Pies come either fresh-baked or frozen. That second option is a real game-changer for busy households.

You can take home unbaked pies and pop them in the oven later. Your kitchen will smell like a bakery, and you barely lifted a finger.

The frozen selection runs wide. Both savory and sweet pies show up, so stocking up for a few meals is easy.

Frozen pizza has also been on offer. It’s a handy backup when pie for dinner feels a little too bold.

This setup fits perfectly with the shop’s main idea. The bakery sells its own products directly to shoppers, straight from the people who made them.

That direct line means you aren’t hunting for a few flavors on a grocery shelf. You get the bigger lineup in one stop.

Bring a cooler if you’re driving far. A cabin weekend or holiday gathering suddenly gets a lot easier when dessert is already handled.

Galaxy Donuts and Lemon Bombs Steal Some Spotlight

Galaxy Donuts and Lemon Bombs Steal Some Spotlight
© Sara’s Bakery – featuring Tipsy Pies

Swirls of color on a donut called Galaxy? That name alone earns a closer look at the pastry case.

Pies may be the headliner, but the full bakery lineup goes deep. Raised and cake donuts sit alongside those eye-catching Galaxy versions.

Bars bring their own charm. Swedish Almond and Lemon bars feel right at home in a state with strong Scandinavian roots.

Then come the Bombs. Flavors like Lemon Cream and Chocolate Ganache sound like dessert with a dramatic entrance.

French pastries round out the case, along with muffins and quick breads. The Lemon Blueberry loaf and blueberry muffins are two to keep in mind.

Date cookies wrapped in a family shortbread-style sugar cookie dough have also appeared. That kind of detail shows how far the family recipes reach.

Sara also makes lefse using her family’s recipe. During the holidays, she’s even made lefse dough for families keeping their own traditions alive.

So pie lovers, consider yourselves warned. You may come in for a tart and leave with a donut, a bar, and a loaf.

Nobody will judge you for it.

The Bakery Now Shares a Roof With a Classic Market

The Bakery Now Shares a Roof With a Classic Market
© Sara’s Bakery – featuring Tipsy Pies

Two local favorites, one address. In mid-July 2026, the bakery moved its retail storefront inside Brine’s Market and Deli.

Brine’s is a Stillwater name with nearly 70 years of history. It’s known for its deli, fresh meats, and prepared foods.

Now Sara’s full lineup sits right there too. You can find it all at 1790 Washington Ave, Stillwater, MN 55082.

The combined space includes an expanded bakery section. A full-service pastry case and fresh coffee are part of the new setup.

That makes errands far more fun. Grab deli meat for sandwiches, then wander over for pie, donuts, or a frozen pot pie.

The move pairs two award-winning businesses under one roof. Each keeps its own traditions while giving shoppers a bigger reason to visit.

Hours generally run from 9 a.m. on every day of the week. Weekdays close a bit later than Saturday and Sunday, so plan accordingly.

I like how this new chapter keeps things local. Minnesota shoppers get a one-stop food destination without losing the personal touch.

It’s grocery shopping with a serious dessert upgrade, and that sounds like a fair trade.

Grab a Cup of Coffee With Roots in Costa Rica

Grab a Cup of Coffee With Roots in Costa Rica
© Sara’s Bakery – featuring Tipsy Pies

Most bakeries just brew a pot and call it done. This one pours coffee with a personal connection.

Fresh Willows Coffee is on offer. There’s also a Costa Rican blend sourced from a friend’s family farm.

That’s about as close to the source as a cup can get. It pairs nicely with something buttery from the pastry case.

The coffee lineup has included cold press options too. A Costa Rican creamer has also been part of the experience.

Fresh coffee is now part of the expanded bakery space inside Brine’s. So your pie stop can double as a proper coffee break.

Pairing ideas come easy here. A pecan tart with a dark roast feels cozy, while a lemon bar might call for something cold.

Small choices like this make a visit feel thoughtful. It’s clear the bakery cares about more than just what’s in the oven.

So slow down for a minute. Sip, nibble, and enjoy the fact that dessert and caffeine both came from people with a story.

Then decide whether you need a second pastry for the road. You probably do.

Every Pie Purchase Can Help Someone Nearby

Every Pie Purchase Can Help Someone Nearby
© Sara’s Bakery – featuring Tipsy Pies

Pie with a purpose sounds like a slogan. Here, it’s an actual campaign that has run since 2014.

Called Pies with a Purpose, it donates part of the proceeds to local groups. Recipients have included Valley Friendship Club Stillwater and the Down Syndrome Association of Minnesota.

Jack’s Baskets is another organization on that list. It supports families welcoming babies with Down syndrome.

The cause runs close to home for Sara Hayden. Her daughter, Madi, has Down syndrome and inspired the effort.

That changes how a dessert run feels. Your sweet tooth gets a little side mission of doing good.

The bakery’s community ties show up elsewhere too. Sara’s lefse once helped bring smiles to memory care residents at a local senior community.

Small businesses often say they love their towns. Sara’s Bakery – featuring Tipsy Pies backs that up with steady, long-running action.

So when someone asks why you bought three pies, you have a great answer. You were supporting your community, obviously.

Nobody can argue with generosity, especially when it comes with a flaky, hand-rolled crust on top.

State Fair Crowds and Wedding Guests Know These Pies

State Fair Crowds and Wedding Guests Know These Pies
© Sara’s Bakery – featuring Tipsy Pies

Eleven years at the Minnesota State Fair is no small feat. Tipsy Pies have become a regular part of that huge summer tradition.

Fair specials have included creative tarts, like a Strawberry Ube Sundae Tart. It’s a fun reminder that this bakery likes to experiment.

The pies also travel to weddings, grad parties, reunions, and corporate events. Catering is a big part of the business.

Wedding couples get a sweet bonus. The bakery offers a free one-year anniversary pie, which beats a paper card any day.

Individual pies work especially well at big gatherings. Guests can grab their own instead of waiting for someone to slice a giant cake.

If you’re planning an event, reach out early. Busy seasons fill up, and good dessert deserves a little planning.

Of course, you don’t need a big occasion. A random weeknight counts as a perfectly valid pie celebration in my book.

From a fairground booth to a reception hall to a Stillwater market, these pies sure get around. Catch them wherever you can.

Just maybe save room for one at home, too.