
A family sausage recipe from 1935 is still being made today, and it’s the reason a small brick storefront in Missouri smells like an Italian grandmother’s kitchen.
The recipe came from a father and his two sons who opened a market together. Four generations later, their family still runs the show.
I love that the same flavors once sold in an old Italian neighborhood are still here.
The shop sits inside a charming Tudor-style building that looks a little out of time. Inside, deli cases hold dozens of meats and cheeses.
Shelves are packed with imported olive oils, canned tomatoes, and Italian treats.
I can’t imagine a better place to grab a sandwich and a jar of sauce in one stop.
A Tudor Storefront That Looks Like It Wandered In From Another Century

Brick walls, a peaked Tudor shape, and old-school charm make Scimeca’s Retail Market & Deli easy to love before you even open the door. The little building stands out in North Kansas City like a storybook cottage that decided to sell sausage.
That out-of-time look fits the place perfectly. A shop built on recipes from the 1930s deserves a home with some personality.
Plenty of delis set up in plain strip malls with bright signs. This one feels more like a neighborhood corner store from your grandparents’ day.
The brick exterior hints that something with real roots waits inside.
Inside, the space is tidy and lined with Italian staples and treats. Shelves and cases fill the room, so your eyes keep wandering while you decide what to order.
It’s a little like shopping and sightseeing at the same time.
The building also sets the mood for the whole visit. You aren’t just grabbing lunch at a counter.
You’re stepping into a small slice of old-world style in the middle of Missouri.
Bring your phone for a quick photo of the storefront. Friends back home may not believe this cozy Italian corner exists so close to downtown Kansas City.
The Family Story Started On Independence Avenue In 1935

Back in 1935, Frank “Chico” Scimeca opened a market with his father, Fillipo, and his brother, Louis. Their shop sat on Independence Avenue in Kansas City’s Historic Northeast neighborhood.
It quickly became known for fresh and specialty groceries.
Families from around the area came for Italian ingredients they couldn’t easily find elsewhere. Some longtime fans remember shopping there as kids to gather supplies for big pots of Sunday sauce.
That’s the kind of place that sticks in a city’s memory.
The neighborhood changed over the years, and the original market eventually closed. For nearly 25 years, that “Little Italy” style shopping experience was missing.
Kansas City still had the family’s products in grocery stores, but not the full market feel.
Then the family brought it back in North Kansas City. Today, the fourth generation carries on the tradition, with Toni Bonadonna leading the way.
Four generations is a serious streak for any business.
Knowing this history makes each visit feel richer. You’re not just buying a meatball sub.
You’re supporting a Missouri family story that has kept going for nearly a century, one sausage link at a time.
Thirty-Five Meats And Eighteen Cheeses Walk Into A Sandwich

Decision-making gets tough fast here. The family’s former Independence Avenue store was reported to carry 35 different meats, many of them imported, plus 18 kinds of cheese.
The star sandwich wears the family’s founding year proudly. The 1935 Italian Classic stacks salami, sandwich pepperoni, and hot ham with provolone.
Lettuce, tomato, onion, banana peppers, and Italian dressing finish the job on a hoagie roll.
Other favorites cover plenty of cravings. Phil’s Meatball Sub brings saucy comfort, while the Chicken Parmesan Sandwich leans warm and hearty.
The Reuben comes served on a marble rye hoagie, which is a fun twist.
A Caprese option works well if you want something lighter. Turkey and cheese fans aren’t left out either.
There really is a sandwich here for every type of eater at the table.
Gluten-free diners get good news, too. The shop offers house-made gluten-free bread, which is a thoughtful touch for a sandwich spot.
Sandwiches come with chips, and the hot and cold choices make it easy to split two and trade halves. Can’t pick between the Classic and the Reuben?
Order both and call it research.
You Will Want To Plan Your Week Around These Lunch Specials

Tuesday might become your new favorite day. That’s when the “Not Your Average Cheeseburger” shows up, built with golden-fried meatballs on a toasted bun.
Scimeca’s Retail Market & Deli rotates specialty entrees through the week, and some appear only once. Wednesdays bring Chicken Spiedini, a classic Kansas City Italian favorite.
Fridays often feature the Cheese Lasagna, made from a family recipe that goes back to 1935.
The lasagna comes with your choice of a meat side. Sausage and meatballs are both popular picks, so choose wisely or bring a friend who shares.
Feeling extra hungry? The Ultimate Scimeca Sampler piles on a little of everything.
Think lasagna, sausage with peppers and onions, and chicken parmesan in one bowl. Your dinner plans may need to be canceled afterward.
Since specials change by day, it helps to check before you go. That way, you won’t show up craving spiedini on a lasagna day.
One more tip worth remembering. A side of pasta salad or olive salad rounds out any meal nicely.
The olive salad especially brings bright, briny Italian flavor that pairs well with rich, saucy entrees.
Shelves Packed With Enough Tomatoes To Make Any Nonna Proud

Canned tomatoes rarely get the spotlight. The family’s former Independence Avenue store was described as having one of the largest canned tomato selections in the Midwest.
The grocery side is a home cook’s playground. You’ll find imported olive oils, vinegars, and hard-to-find Italian ingredients lining the shelves.
Cheeses like Caciocavallo and Mascarpone wait for anyone planning a fancy dinner or a homemade tiramisu.
The family’s signature spaghetti sauce is a must-grab. It comes from a recipe perfected over decades, and the marinara has fans of its own.
Pair it with their sausage and you’ve got dinner basically handled.
Prepared items help, too. Homemade olive salad, pasta salads, fresh mozzarella, and cannoli shells make it easy to pull together an Italian spread at home.
No passport required.
This section also makes the place great for gift shopping. A bag of Italian goodies from a historic Missouri family business beats another candle any day.
Give yourself extra time to browse after lunch. The shelves reward slow wandering, and you’ll probably spot something you didn’t know you needed.
That’s half the fun of a real Italian market.
Save Room, Because The Cannoli Are Watching You

Dessert at an Italian market isn’t optional. It’s practically tradition, and this place takes that seriously.
Traditional cannoli lead the lineup, with a creamy filling that earns real fans. Rich tiramisu offers layers of coffee-kissed sweetness.
A slice of Italian cream cake rounds things out for anyone who loves classic cake.
These treats work as the finale to a sandwich lunch. They also make a smart pick-me-up for the afternoon, or a sweet surprise for whoever is waiting at home.
Kids certainly won’t complain if you show up with a cannoli.
Love baking yourself? The market sells cannoli shells, so you can fill your own at home.
It’s a fun project for a family night, and nobody will judge if the filling disappears before the shells do.
Desserts are also an easy addition to a gift bag. Combine a jar of sauce, some pasta, and a sweet treat for a thoughtful present.
My advice is simple. Order dessert when you order lunch, so you don’t talk yourself out of it later.
Future you will be very grateful for that decision.
Feeding A Crowd Gets Much Easier Here

Party hosting can feel stressful, but trays of Italian food fix a lot of problems. Scimeca’s catering covers everything from casual office lunches to big family gatherings.
Options include charcuterie trays, family-style salads, and sandwich platters. Hot entrees bring serious comfort, like baked pasta, Italian sausage with peppers, and chicken spiedini.
That’s a menu that disappears quickly at any get-together.
Charcuterie makes especially good sense here. With dozens of meats and cheeses in the deli, the shop has plenty to work with.
Your guests get real variety instead of the same three grocery store slices.
Not local? Scimeca’s also sells products online and ships many of them nationwide.
Meats and sauces can travel to family members who moved away but still miss that Kansas City Italian flavor.
That shipping option is a sweet way to share a Missouri tradition. It’s especially nice for folks who grew up shopping at the old Independence Avenue store.
Plan catering orders ahead whenever you can. Big events go smoother when the food is locked in early, and you’ll have one less thing to worry about on party day.
Timing Your Visit Is The Smartest Move You Can Make

Lunch lovers, take note of the clock. Scimeca’s keeps daytime hours, opening at 10 a.m.
Monday through Friday and closing at 4 p.m.
Saturday hours run shorter, from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. The shop stays closed on Sundays, so plan your sausage cravings accordingly.
You’ll find it at 1611 Swift Street in North Kansas City, Missouri. The spot sits near 16th Street in the Northtown area, an easy hop across the river from downtown Kansas City.
It’s simple to reach without a long drive.
The setup works like a carryout counter with indoor seating. High-top tables let you eat on site, and the seating area was expanded in recent years.
Staff can also help point you toward popular picks if the menu feels overwhelming.
The family motto says customers become friends and friends become family. That warm spirit fits the cozy space well.
Here’s a final idea for your trip. Grab a sandwich to eat there, then leave with sauce, sausage, and dessert for later.
Scimeca’s Retail Market & Deli deserves more than one quick bite, and your kitchen deserves a little Italy too.