This Quirky West Virginia Pizza Spot Serves Monster-Themed Pies And Cryptid Sodas

You walk in and immediately spot a giant footprint on the wall. That is your first clue this is not a normal pizza joint.

The menu reads like a creature catalog.

Sasquatch pie. Mothman special. A soda list full of cryptid names you cannot pronounce but absolutely want to try.

Every inch of this place leans into the weird and wonderful side of West Virginia lore.

Families crowd the booths pointing at artwork and laughing over slice number three.

The pizza itself holds up too. Crispy edges. Generous toppings.

No skimping just because the theme is playful.

Do you believe in monsters?

After eating here, you might still say no, but you will definitely leave with a smile and a full stomach.

The Cryptid-Themed Atmosphere

Walking into Mythical Pizza feels like stepping into a roadside folklore exhibit that also happens to make incredible food.

Newspaper clippings about Mothman line the walls, “Vote for Mothman” signs hang near the counter, and hand-painted cryptid art fills every corner of the room.

The whole setup somehow avoids feeling cluttered and instead lands in a sweet spot of charming, weird, and genuinely inviting.

The ambiance is the kind that makes you slow down and actually look around. Kids point at Bigfoot illustrations while parents read the cryptid lore posted near the ordering stations.

Even the restrooms carry the theme, which earns serious bonus points for commitment.

There is a small gift shop section near the entrance stocked with branded merch, cryptid-themed soaps, and collectibles that are worth browsing before your order arrives. The arcade games tucked into the corner keep things lively while you wait.

Altogether, the atmosphere turns a pizza stop into a full-on experience you actually want to talk about later.

Monster-Named Signature Pies

Every pie on the menu here comes with a name that makes you grin before you even take a bite.

“Mothman Strikes Back,” “Daddy Bigfoot,” “A Nightmare on Braxie Street,” and the deep-dish “Grafton Monster” are just a few options that prove the creativity runs deeper than just branding.

The names are fun, but the flavors are what keep people coming back.

The Yeti’s Pepperoni Pie is a crowd favorite, loaded with classic comfort and a crust that holds up beautifully.

The Alfredo-based pies have earned their own loyal fanbase, with rich, creamy sauce that balances the toppings without overwhelming them.

Flash-firing the pizzas in high-tech impingement ovens means each one is done in roughly four minutes, hot and perfectly cooked.

Ordering feels exciting rather than stressful, and that is a rare thing. The menu reads more like a field guide to mythical creatures than a typical restaurant list.

That energy carries straight through to the first bite.

Build-Your-Own Pizza With Over Forty Topping Options

For anyone who has ever stared at a pizza menu wishing they could just design their own perfect pie, this place is basically a dream come true.

With more than forty sauces, cheeses, meats, vegetables, and finishing touches to choose from, the combinations are almost endless.

Balsamic drizzle, garlic oil base, chili flakes, artichoke hearts, pickles, banana peppers, and fresh mozzarella are all fair game.

Ordering happens through large touch-screen tablets, which makes the whole process feel surprisingly smooth even when the restaurant is packed. The interface walks you through each layer of the pizza one step at a time.

It is genuinely fun to build, almost like a game before the meal.

Regulars have a tip worth following: the extra bake option is great for anyone who prefers a crispier bottom crust.

Finishing touches like a balsamic drizzle or a garlic Parmesan crust edge can completely transform a simple pie into something memorable.

The level of control here is something most pizza spots simply do not offer.

Unique Crust Options

The crust situation at Mythical Pizza deserves its own spotlight because it goes well beyond the usual thin-or-thick choice.

The Sasquatch Stuffed crust is packed with gooey cheese that stretches with every pull, turning the outer edge from an afterthought into a highlight.

Mothman’s Pepperoni and Cheese Stuffed crust takes it even further, layering in savory pepperoni alongside the melted cheese.

Then there is the Taki-dusted crust, which brings a bold, tangy crunch to the exterior that genuinely surprised me on first bite. It sounds like a novelty but eats like a deliberate flavor decision.

The contrast between the crispy, spiced outer crust and the soft, cheesy interior is genuinely satisfying.

Gluten-friendly cauliflower crust rounds out the lineup for guests who need or prefer a lighter base. It holds toppings well and does not fall apart, which is more than can be said for many cauliflower crusts elsewhere.

Choosing a crust here feels like picking a character before starting a game, each one changes the whole experience.

Cryptid Club Sodas In Glass Bottles With Wild Flavors

The Cryptid Club Soda line is one of those small details that quietly elevates the entire visit. Each flavor comes in a glass bottle with a creature-themed label that is genuinely cool enough to want to keep.

Made with pure cane sugar and completely caffeine-free, these sodas taste clean and bright without the artificial aftertaste that often comes with specialty drinks.

The SQUONK flavor is a raspberry-lime rickey that hits a perfect balance of tart and sweet. Mothman’s West Virginia Scream Soda leans into bold berry territory, while the Flatwoods Fantasie Orange soda tastes like a premium version of the childhood classic.

Jersey Devil Ginger Ale has just enough heat to feel interesting without being overwhelming.

These sodas are sold exclusively at Mythical Pizza or through their online shop, which makes them feel like a proper souvenir as much as a drink. Grabbing a few extra bottles to take home is basically a requirement at this point.

The Loveland Frogman Lemonade has also earned devoted fans among regulars.

Vegan And Dietary-Friendly Options

Mythical Pizza put real effort into making sure guests with dietary needs feel just as welcome as everyone else. Vegan cheese alternative is available and works well with the garlic oil and BBQ sauce bases that are also vegan-friendly.

The cauliflower crust provides a gluten-friendly option that holds up better than expected under a full load of toppings.

The build-your-own format is especially valuable here because it gives guests total control over every ingredient. Someone eating plant-based can still explore the same wild flavor combinations as everyone else at the table.

That kind of inclusivity without making a big deal of it is exactly what a good restaurant does.

Regulars who follow vegan diets have noted that the red sauce base is also plant-friendly, which opens up a wide range of customization paths.

The fact that these options exist alongside Sasquatch Stuffed and Taki-dusted crusts shows that the menu was built with genuine variety in mind.

Everyone at the table gets to eat something they are actually excited about.

The Flight Of The Squonks For Trying Multiple Pies At Once

Deciding between the signature pies can feel genuinely difficult when every single name sounds more interesting than the last.

The Flight of the Squonks solves that problem beautifully by letting you pick three five-inch pizzas from the signature menu.

You get real, full-flavored bites of multiple styles without committing to a whole pie of each.

Sprout-Man, featuring garlic-roasted Brussels sprouts and balsamic glaze, has become a standout that surprises nearly everyone who tries it.

The Alabama White Thang and Attack of the 50-Foot Meatball have both earned enthusiastic repeat orders from guests who originally ordered them on a whim.

Sharing a flight with someone else at the table doubles the number of flavors you get to experience in one sitting.

It is the kind of ordering format that shows real thoughtfulness about the guest experience. Most pizza places force you to commit to one style for the whole meal.

Here, curiosity is not just welcomed, it is built into the menu structure itself, which makes the whole visit feel a little more like an adventure.

Batsquatch Wings, Paranormal Pretzels, And Other Creative Starters

Appetizers at Mythical Pizza carry the same creative energy as the rest of the menu, which means even the starters feel like part of the story.

Batsquatch Wings come out juicy on the inside with a satisfying crisp on the outside, and the sauce options range from classic to genuinely bold.

The Sriracha Honey finish adds a mild sweetness that works especially well with the natural flavor of the chicken.

Paranormal Pretzels and Cheesy Garlic Bread round out the starter options for anyone who wants something to snack on while the pizza fires up. Both are crowd-pleasers that hit that warm, salty, satisfying note you want before a main course.

Cryptid Rolls, including Mothman’s Pepperoni Roll, nod to a beloved West Virginia tradition while adding a thin, crispy, cheesy twist that feels fresh.

The pepperoni roll in particular has become a talking point for visitors who grew up with the classic WV version. Thin, loaded, and perfectly baked, it honors the original while doing something distinctly its own.

Starting with one before the pizza arrives is a very good idea.

Desserts Worth Saving Room For

Saving room for dessert at Mythical Pizza is a decision you will not regret. The Mothman Tiramisu takes a classic Italian dessert and gives it just enough personality to fit the theme without messing with what makes tiramisu great.

Layers of espresso-soaked cake and creamy mascarpone hit all the right notes, and the presentation is fun enough to photograph before eating.

Guests who have stayed for the dessert menu consistently report leaving with extra to take home because the options look too good to skip. That is genuinely high praise for a pizza-focused restaurant.

It means the kitchen is paying attention to every course, not just the main event.

The dessert section rounds out what is already a surprisingly complete dining experience. From the first bite of a pretzel starter to the last spoonful of tiramisu, the meal has a satisfying arc that feels considered rather than accidental.

Finishing strong matters, and the dessert menu here earns its place at the end of a very good meal.

Why Mythical Pizza Is A Must-Stop In Berkeley Springs, WV

Berkeley Springs is already a destination worth planning around, with its warm mineral springs, state park, and small-town charm that draws visitors from across the Mid-Atlantic region.

Mythical Pizza fits into that landscape perfectly as the kind of place that becomes a travel story rather than just a meal stop.

Ranked number 42 on Pizza Marketplace’s Top 100 Movers and Shakers list for 2026, the restaurant has earned recognition well beyond its mountain-town zip code.

The combination of immersive decor, creative food, craft sodas, arcade games, and genuinely warm service creates something that is hard to replicate.

People drive 45 minutes or more specifically to eat here, and they come back with family members who need to see it for themselves.

That kind of word-of-mouth loyalty says more than any ranking.

Open Monday through Thursday from 11:30 AM to 9 PM and Friday and Saturday from 11:30 AM to 10 PM, the schedule is easy to work around a road trip or weekend getaway.

Address: 1855 Valley Rd Ste 200, Berkeley Springs, WV.