When the New York Times puts a taqueria on its list of the fifty best restaurants in the country, people pay attention, and when that taqueria turns out to be a small, unassuming spot in Texas that most visitors have never heard of, the story gets even better.
The recognition did not come from fancy plating or a celebrity chef, but from the kind of careful, consistent cooking that turns a simple taco into something worth traveling for, with tortillas made fresh and fillings prepared with real attention to detail.
Locals had been eating here for years before the national spotlight arrived, and they will tell you the food has always been this good, which makes the honor feel less like a surprise and more like a long overdue acknowledgment of what they already knew.
A spot like this reminds you that the best meals are not always the ones with the biggest reputations, and sometimes the most ordinary looking building holds something extraordinary.
Why The New York Times Took Notice
National food lists usually shine a light on big cities, so seeing an El Paso taqueria on The New York Times 50 Best Restaurants list is a happy surprise. The paper praised ELEMI for excelling at every style of taco on offer.
That is high praise for a place in a city already packed with great taco spots.
One example that stood out was the al pastor. The pork is prepared, partly frozen, and then sliced thin before being stacked on a trompo, the tall spinning spit used for this style.
Freezing the meat first helps create even slices, and even slices cook evenly.
The result is meat with crisp, caramelized edges that still stays juicy inside. Pair that with a fresh tortilla off the comal and salsas made with the same care, and it is easy to see why critics paid attention.
Nothing on the plate feels like an afterthought.
For travelers, this kind of recognition is a helpful clue. It suggests a kitchen that pays attention to small steps most diners never see, like how thick a slice should be or how long masa should rest.
Still, the best part is that the honor has not made the place stuffy. It remains a relaxed spot where people come in for tacos, conversation, and a good time.
Think of the list as a nudge to visit, not a reason to feel nervous about dressing up.
Casual clothes are totally fine here.
Blue Corn Tortillas Made to Order
Great tacos start long before the filling goes in. At ELEMI, the story begins with corn that has been soaked and cooked in a process called nixtamalization, then ground into masa by hand.
It sounds like a lot of work, and it is.
The blue corn tortillas are pressed and cooked on the comal only after an order comes in. That means each one reaches the table warm, soft, and full of a nutty, earthy flavor that store-bought tortillas simply cannot match.
Many diners say these tortillas are the first thing they remember after a meal here.
The idea behind it is simple. Chef Emiliano Marentes likes to keep dishes uncomplicated while making every part from scratch, and the tortilla is where that belief shows most clearly.
When the base is this good, the fillings get a real chance to shine.
Fun fact time. Blue corn has been grown in the American Southwest and Mexico for centuries, and it often has a slightly sweeter taste and a sturdier bite than yellow corn.
It also gives tacos that striking purple-gray color that looks great in photos.
A tip for first-timers is to pay attention to the tortilla before adding salsa. Take one plain bite and notice the texture and the toasty smell.
It sounds a little silly, but it helps explain why so much of the menu is built around this humble round of masa.
Small detail. Huge payoff.
That sums it up nicely.
The Heart of New Tejano Cooking
Tex-Mex is famous, and Mexico City tacos have their own fans, but ELEMI follows a different path. The kitchen is often called the pulse of New Tejano cuisine, a style growing in El Paso that looks back to older, deeply local roots.
It is less about melted cheese and more about the land itself.
The cooking here explores regional Mexican food through the lens of the Chihuahuan Desert and Sonoran traditions. That means corn with a long history, ingredients grown along the Rio Grande, and flavors that have crossed the border for generations.
El Paso sits right next to Ciudad Juarez, and the two cities have shared recipes, families, and markets for a very long time. Food in this area does not fit neatly into one country or the other.
ELEMI leans into that blend instead of picking a side.
What does this mean for a diner? Expect dishes that feel familiar at first glance, like tacos or esquites, but taste a bit different.
There might be a smoky chile, a surprising herb, or a meat that is not usually found at a quick taco stand.
A good way to enjoy it is to order something unfamiliar alongside a safe favorite. That way, the meal becomes a small lesson in borderland history without feeling like homework.
Curiosity is rewarded at this table.
Honestly, it is one of the tastiest geography lessons around. Few classrooms serve rabbit tacos.
A Menu Full of Delicious Surprises
Duck in a taco? Rabbit too?
At ELEMI, both show up regularly, and diners often count them among their favorites. The Pato al Pastor gives duck the classic al pastor treatment, while the rabbit dishes, including the Conejito Pibil, have earned special mention from the James Beard Foundation.
Plenty of other dishes deserve attention. The Taco Campechano mixes flank steak with chopped pork chicharron for a rich, crunchy bite.
The suadero and brisket tacos are also popular, and the brisket is cooked so tender that it almost feels like barbacoa.
Vegetable lovers are well covered. The El Campesino taco brings together confit portobello mushrooms, grilled eggplant, avocado, cheese, and black beans.
Cauliflower tacos and crispy Brussels sprouts with balsamic and goat cheese also get lots of love.
A handy feature is the mix and match option, which lets diners combine two different tacos on one plate. Sharing plates with friends is another smart move, since it means tasting more without overeating.
The esquites can be quite filling, so splitting them is a good idea.
The Oaxamole is worth a look for adventurous eaters. It adds chile pasilla mixe, pepitas, and chapulines, which are toasted grasshoppers, to the usual guacamole idea.
The menu changes with the seasons and fresh ingredients, so a dish seen online might not always be there. Ask the server for current favorites.
It keeps each visit a little different.
Meet the Couple Behind the Name
Every restaurant name has a story, and this one is sweet. ELEMI comes from a term of endearment that Kristal Marentes uses for her husband, Emiliano.
The couple owns the restaurant together, with Emiliano leading the kitchen as chef.
That personal touch fits the whole place. The restaurant is not a big chain or a copy of another brand.
It grew from one family and a clear idea about how Mexican food from this region should taste.
Chef Marentes has earned plenty of respect for that idea. He was named a James Beard Foundation semifinalist for Outstanding Chef in 2022 and 2023, and he has been a finalist for Best Chef Southwest twice.
Those are some of the biggest honors in American cooking.
Television noticed too. In June 2020, ELEMI appeared on the Hulu series Taste The Nation with Padma Lakshmi.
During the episode, she learned how nixtamal is ground into masa for blue corn tortillas and helped make the El Campesino tacos.
For visitors, knowing this background adds meaning to the meal. Each plate reflects years of practice, family pride, and a love for El Paso.
It is easy to taste the difference when food comes from people who care this much.
The restaurant first opened downtown before moving to its current home on the east side, and longtime fans happily followed. Loyal customers are a good sign.
They rarely drive across town for average tacos.
Finding the Eastlake Location
Getting there is part of the fun, especially for anyone exploring beyond downtown El Paso. ELEMI now sits at 13500 Eastlake Blvd, El Paso, TX 79928, United States, on the far east side near Horizon City.
The drive gives a nice look at wide desert skies and the growing neighborhoods of the region.
Timing matters here. The restaurant opens at 5 pm Tuesday through Friday and at 3 pm on Saturday, closing at 10 pm each of those nights.
It is closed on Sunday and Monday, so plan weekend trips carefully.
Popularity can mean waits, especially on busy evenings. A reservation is a smart idea, and larger groups should definitely book ahead.
Arriving early in the evening is another easy way to avoid the dinner rush.
Saturday offers a longer window thanks to the earlier opening time. That makes it a great option for travelers who want an early dinner before heading off to see a sunset over the Franklin Mountains.
The light around town at that hour is lovely.
Parking at the plaza is usually simple, which is a nice bonus compared with crowded downtown streets. The restaurant website is the best place to check current hours and any menu updates before leaving.
A small tip for non-Spanish speakers is that many dish names are listed in Spanish. Servers are friendly and happy to explain anything.
Asking questions often leads to the best recommendations, so do not be shy.
Save Room for Something Sweet
Dessert here is not just a quick afterthought. The arroz con leche is a clever spin on a classic, made with chia seeds in coconut milk and topped with coconut flakes, berries, and toasted pecans.
It is creamy, a little crunchy, and surprisingly light.
Traditional arroz con leche is a rice pudding loved all across Mexico and Latin America. Swapping rice for chia gives it a playful texture while keeping the cozy, comforting spirit.
Fans who lean toward healthier eating often call it a favorite.
Chocolate lovers have a treat too. A chocolate tamale sometimes appears on the menu, and it has left more than one diner completely delighted.
Warm masa and rich chocolate make a very happy pair.
Here is a practical tip. Tacos and starters can fill people up fast, so consider sharing a dessert.
Two spoons and one bowl is a friendly way to end a meal without feeling stuffed.
Desserts, like the rest of the menu, may change with the seasons. Asking the server what is sweet tonight can lead to a pleasant surprise.
Sometimes the special turns out to be the highlight of the night.
Ending on something thoughtful fits the whole ELEMI style, from the first blue corn tortilla to the final bite. The meal feels complete.
And that is exactly the kind of ending that makes people start planning a return visit before they even reach the car.
Dear Reader: This page may contain affiliate links which may earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase. Our independent journalism is not influenced by any advertiser or commercial initiative unless it is clearly marked as sponsored content. As travel products change, please be sure to reconfirm all details and stay up to date with current events to ensure a safe and successful trip.
