One Amish store on my list closes its doors from noon to 1 PM on weekdays, like the whole place is taking a lunch break. Honestly, I find that charming.
Another spot sits on a gravel county road and skips Wednesdays entirely. A third sells organic wheat berries so you can mill your own bread flour at home.
That’s my kind of shopping list.
Missouri has Amish and Mennonite markets scattered from the northern farm country down into the Ozarks. I love that they still sell spices by the scoop, jams in jars, and cheese by the slab.
I ranked eight of them on variety, specialty goods, and road trip appeal. The list runs from roomy discount grocers to tiny shops down quiet country roads.
Which one deserves your Saturday morning, and how much cinnamon do you really need?
1. Nolt’s Country Market (Bulk Foods, Bakery, Deli, Made-to-Order Sandwiches), Eldon, MO
A roadside produce stand from the late 1990s grew into the top pick on this list. That’s quite a glow-up for a few crates of vegetables.
The market moved to its current spot in 2003 to give itself more room. In 2020, new owners took over and built a fresh store right behind the original.
The old building came down to make space for parking. So yes, the past literally turned into the parking lot.
Inside, you’ll find the full Mennonite market lineup. Bulk foods share space with a deli, a bakery, and seasonal produce.
The bakery case is where willpower goes to fail. Look for homemade pies, breads, cinnamon rolls, and cookies.
The deli makes sandwiches to order, which solves lunch before you even finish shopping. Grab one and keep browsing.
Bakers should head straight for the staples. Flour, wheat, and several kinds of sugar fill the shelves.
The candy selection is big enough to make grown adults act like kids again. You’ll also spot jams and jellies in plenty of flavors, plus BBQ sauces.
Spice fans get a real treat here. The range is wide, and ground options cover most of what a home cook might want.
Eldon sits in Miller County, not far from Lake of the Ozarks. That makes this an easy stop on a lake weekend.
Hours run 8 AM to 5:30 PM on weekdays and 8 AM to 4:30 PM on Saturday. Friday and Saturday afternoons get busy, so plan around them.
Address: 1907 US-54 BUS, Eldon, MO 65026
2. Dutch Country Store, Barnett, MO
Bargain hunters, meet your new favorite road trip. Dutch Country Store has been running as a Mennonite general store since 1992.
It works as a discount grocer with one of the largest bulk food selections in Missouri. That’s a bold title, and the shelves back it up.
Close-dated and overstocked groceries are a big part of the appeal. You can save money on items that would cost more elsewhere.
Regular grocery departments round things out nicely. Look for frozen foods, milk and dairy, and cleaning supplies.
The full-service deli deserves a slow lap. It carries a wide variety of meats and cheeses, with Amish cheeses as a highlight.
Hungry already? The deli also makes sandwiches and wraps to order.
Organic products and fresh produce are on hand too. Flowers show up as well, which makes this a handy stop before a dinner invite.
One quick heads up: there’s no bakery here. Save your pie cravings for another stop on this list.
The store sits in rural Morgan County, an area known for its Mennonite community. It’s a quiet countryside drive from the Lake of the Ozarks area.
Weekday hours run 8 AM to 5 PM, with Friday stretching to 6 PM. Saturday is open 8 AM to 5 PM, and Sunday is closed.
Saturdays bring the biggest crowds. Weekday mornings and afternoons tend to be calmer, so a Tuesday trip might be your sweet spot.
Address: 18268 Kelsay Road, Barnett, MO 65011
3. Jamesport Country Store Bulk Foods, Discount Groceries, & Variety, Jamesport, MO
Jamesport is the hub of one of Missouri’s best-known Old Order Amish settlements. So it makes sense that this town lands more than one spot on the list.
Jamesport Country Store is the place to start. It mixes bulk foods, discount groceries, and a variety section under one roof.
Bulk staples come in big deals, but you can also buy smaller amounts. That’s great news if your pantry isn’t the size of a barn.
Jam lovers, clear some shelf space. The store carries a strong lineup of Amish jams and preserves.
Amish-made sweet treats are on hand too. There’s also a bakery offering, which makes the snack situation even better.
Close-dated groceries help stretch your grocery budget. Household items and dry goods fill out the practical side of the store.
Here’s a fun surprise. The shelves even include candles, plus food and treats for dogs and cats.
So your pets don’t have to sit out the shopping trip. Somebody in the house deserves a souvenir, right?
Bring cash, and confirm the store’s current payment options before visiting. Hours run 8:30 AM to 5 PM, Monday through Saturday.
The store is closed Sundays, Good Friday, and Ascension Day. Check the calendar before you head out in spring.
Saturdays draw the biggest crowds. Weekday mornings are your best bet for easy aisle browsing.
Address: 31115 State Hwy NN, Jamesport, MO 64648
4. Home Gardens Community Market (Mennonite), Farmington, MO
Fresh-picked strawberries in April? That’s the kind of seasonal win this little Mennonite market can deliver in southeast Missouri.
Home Gardens Community Market is run by Mennonite farmers. It focuses on fresh local fruits and vegetables, which is exactly what you want from a farm market.
Produce is the star here. Expect the selection to shift with the seasons, so each visit can look a little different.
Gardeners get a bonus. The market sells vegetable plants, so you can bring home dinner and next summer’s garden in one trip.
Homemade baked goods share the spotlight with the produce. Jams sit on the shelves too, ready to meet a slice of fresh bread.
The setting is part of the charm. The market sits along Old Fredericktown Road in the countryside just outside Farmington.
It’s a smaller, simpler stop than the big bulk grocers on this list. Think farm stand with a little extra, not a giant warehouse.
A quick visit works perfectly here. Grab your berries, pick up a pie or loaf, and enjoy the drive home.
Hours run 9 AM to 5 PM, Monday through Friday. Saturday hours are 9 AM to 4 PM, and Sunday is closed.
Saturday mornings bring the most shoppers. Wednesday mornings are the quietest, which is handy for anyone who hates crowds.
Spring and summer are prime time for planning a trip. That’s when fresh produce and garden plants really shine.
Address: 819 Old Fredericktown Rd, Farmington, MO 63640
5. H & M Country Store, Jamesport, MO
Some family businesses hang on for a few years. H & M Country Store has been family-owned and operated since 1989.
The store first opened in 1983. Six years later, a new family bought it, and they’ve kept it running ever since.
Spice shoppers can go wild here. The bulk spice selection is wide, and health foods sit nearby.
Cheese gets serious attention too. You’ll find a large variety of Ohio cheeses, plus fresh country butter.
Local jams, jellies, and pickled vegetables line the shelves. That’s half a picnic basket right there.
Homemade pastas and old-fashioned candies are on hand. So is freshly ground peanut butter and almond butter, which sounds dangerously snackable.
Baking ingredients cover the needs of home bakers. Gluten-free and sugar-free products are available too, which is a big help for special diets.
Not everything here is edible. The store also carries kitchenware, including stainless steel items.
Fresh produce and a bakery offering add even more reasons to stop. It’s an easy add-on to a Jamesport shopping day.
The store sits along Missouri Route 190 in the farmland around Jamesport. Expect a peaceful drive through rolling country.
Hours vary by day, so pay attention. Thursday runs 10 AM to 4 PM, Monday opens at 9 AM, and other weekdays open at 8:30 AM.
Sunday is closed, and Saturday gets busiest. Most days close at 5 PM.
Address: 21910 MO-190, Jamesport, MO 64648
6. J & A Country Store (Amish Store), Seymour, MO
Lunch break rules apply here. J & A Country Store closes from noon to 1 PM on weekdays, so time your visit carefully.
The store sits along State Highway C outside Seymour. That’s Webster County, an Ozarks area known for its Old Order Amish settlement.
This one is small and simple. Don’t expect a sprawling warehouse with endless aisles.
Instead, the appeal comes from homemade products and traditional Amish wares. Dry goods round out the shelves.
The shop has a reputation for friendly service. That makes a quick stop feel personal.
It’s the kind of place that fits a slow Ozarks drive. Plan it as one stop in a relaxed day, not a rushed errand.
Hours take a little planning. Confirm the store’s current weekday hours and any midday closure before visiting.
Confirm whether the store opens on Saturdays before planning a weekend visit.
Early birds have the advantage here. A 7:30 AM opening means you can shop before most folks finish breakfast.
Bring a little flexibility along with your shopping bag. Smaller shops can have limited stock, so grab what catches your eye.
If you live in southwest Missouri, this makes an easy weekend outing. Springfield folks can turn it into a scenic morning drive.
Saturday shoppers should arrive early, since the doors close at noon. Nobody wants to pull up at 12:05 PM.
Address: 4910-4928 State Hwy C, Seymour, MO 65746
7. Amish Store (Vernie’s), Clark, MO
Gravel roads lead to good pie. That’s the takeaway from this little Amish store near the farming village of Clark.
The shop sits on a rural county gravel road in Audrain County. Slow down, enjoy the drive, and keep an eye on the dust behind you.
Pies are a big draw here. If you have a sweet tooth, this stop deserves a spot on your map.
Candy is another highlight. Old-school sweets make a fun treat for the ride home, assuming they last that long.
The store has a reputation for helpful, friendly service. That makes it easy to ask questions about what’s on the shelves.
Furniture is part of the picture too. The listing for this store includes a furniture offering, which adds an unexpected twist.
Hours are a little unusual, so take notes. The store opens at 9 AM on Monday, Tuesday, Thursday, and Saturday, closing at 6 PM.
Friday stays open later, until 7 PM. That’s handy if you want to swing by after work.
Wednesday is closed, which catches some people off guard. Sunday is closed too.
Clark sits in central Missouri, north of Columbia. It makes a fine detour if you’re already traveling the area.
Plan this as a quick stop rather than a full shopping day. Grab a pie, pick out some candy, and head back down the gravel.
Address: 670-674 Audrain Rd 116, Clark, MO 65243
8. Lilac Lane Bulk Foods, Windsor, MO
Ever wanted to mill your own flour? Lilac Lane Bulk Foods sells organic wheat berries for exactly that kind of kitchen adventure.
The store sits in rural Henry County outside Windsor. It’s about 30 minutes from Sedalia, which makes it an easy country drive.
Herbs are a strong suit here. Oregano, basil, and dill weed come at friendly prices.
Canned goods might steal the show, though. Many are made by Amish families and others in the local community.
Bulk foods and spices fill out the core of the store. Sweets show up too, because a trip like this needs snacks.
The shelves get more interesting from there. You’ll find vitamin supplements and stainless cookware and kitchen items.
Fresh produce rounds out the mix. It’s a solid stop for both pantry stocking and dinner ideas.
Think of it as a country-style grocery store with personality. It fits home bakers, budget shoppers, and anyone who likes trying new jars.
Hours run 8 AM to 5 PM, Monday through Saturday. Sunday is closed.
Saturdays are the busiest time to visit. Monday, Wednesday, and Thursday tend to be quieter.
West-central Missouri shoppers have a real gem nearby. It’s a great way to end this list, especially if your pantry needs a serious refill.
Bring a sturdy bag, because jars add up fast. Your future sandwiches will thank you.
Address: 1206 NE 1400 Rd, Windsor, MO 65360
