You Can Find Authentic British Meat Pies And Groceries At This Charming New Jersey Bakery

Who knew a little slice of Britain was hiding in a New Jersey strip mall?

This charming bakery has been a local favorite for years, specializing in authentic savory pies that would make any Londoner feel right at home.

The menu boasts a rotating selection of traditional favorites like steak and mushroom, shepherd’s pie, and Cornish pasties, alongside a solid lineup of sweet treats including key lime and banoffee pies.

But it is not just the pies.

A small but mighty selection of imported British groceries fills the shelves, from proper chocolates to classic sauces.

It is a one-stop shop for a true taste of the UK, right in the heart of New Jersey.

Just make sure you check the hours before you go.

Savory Meat Pies That Taste Like British Kitchen

Walking past the display case at The Pie Store feels like stumbling into a proper British kitchen, minus the jet lag. The savory pie selection here is genuinely impressive, ranging from a rich Steak, Ale, and Mushroom Pie to a deeply satisfying Shepherd’s Pie.

Each one is made fresh daily using 100% fresh ingredients, which you can absolutely taste in every bite.

The Chicken and Mushroom Pie deserves its own moment of appreciation. The filling is tender and well-seasoned, tucked inside a golden, flaky crust that holds together beautifully.

Then there is the Turkey and Stuffing Pie, which shows up seasonally and immediately becomes the reason people plan entire road trips to Montclair.

These pies are sold cold, meant to be finished at home in the oven. That might sound like extra work, but it actually makes the whole experience feel more personal.

You pull it out golden and bubbling, and suddenly your kitchen smells like something from a cozy British countryside cottage.

Cornish Pasties With a Filling That Respects the Tradition

Cornish pasties have a long history in British food culture, and The Pie Store takes that history seriously. The classic version here is filled with ground beef, onion, carrots, potatoes, and thyme, all wrapped in a lighter puff pastry crust that bakes up wonderfully at home.

It is hearty without being heavy, which is a harder balance to strike than it sounds.

What makes these pasties stand out is how substantial they feel. This is not a snack masquerading as a meal.

One pasty, warmed properly in the oven, is genuinely filling and satisfying in a way that fast food simply never manages to be.

The texture of the puff pastry crust adds something special too. It is lighter than a traditional shortcrust but still sturdy enough to hold everything together.

For anyone who grew up eating proper pasties or has ever visited Cornwall, the first bite brings back a surprisingly strong wave of nostalgia. For everyone else, it is a delicious introduction worth repeating.

Pocket Pasties in Bold Flavors

The Pie Store does not stop at traditional. The pocket pasty lineup here reads like a flavor adventure, offering combinations that feel creative without being gimmicky.

Steak and Cheddar is a crowd-pleaser for obvious reasons. BBQ Pork and Cheddar brings a smokier, more American-influenced spin to a very British format.

Chana Masala as a pasty filling is a genuinely clever move. It brings warmth and spice into a format that is usually reserved for meat and root vegetables.

The Lamb and Feta option leans Mediterranean, pairing gamey richness with the salty tang of feta in a way that works surprisingly well inside a pastry shell.

These pocket pasties are great for people who want something quick and portable without sacrificing flavor. They heat up fast at home and travel well, making them an easy choice for a packed lunch or a lazy dinner.

The variety alone makes it hard to pick just one, which is honestly the best kind of problem to have at a bakery.

Sweet Pies, From Classic Apple to Weekend-Only Banoffee

The sweet side of The Pie Store is just as thoughtfully put together as the savory. A Double Crust Apple Pie sits comfortably at the top of the classics list, with a buttery crust and a filling that is sweet without being cloying.

Key Lime Pie shows up with a tart, creamy middle layer and a graham cracker crust that has real texture and flavor.

Chocolate Mousse Pie brings something a little more indulgent to the lineup. Seasonal options like Double Crust Cran-Apple Pie and Mince Pie give the menu a rotating quality that keeps things interesting throughout the year.

Mince Pie in particular carries a lot of British holiday tradition with it.

Banoffee Pie is the weekend special, and it is worth planning your visit around. The combination of banana, toffee, and cream inside a pastry shell is genuinely wonderful and not something you find easily in New Jersey outside of this shop.

Sweet pies here are sold cold, so they arrive home in perfect condition and ready for the oven or fridge.

Freshly Baked Scones

Scones at The Pie Store are baked fresh every single day, and the flavor variety goes well beyond the standard plain or raisin options you might expect. Cranberry-orange brings a bright, slightly tart note that pairs beautifully with the buttery base.

Chocolate chip feels a little indulgent for a morning treat, but that is exactly the point.

Raisin scones are there for purists who want something closer to the traditional British version. Strawberry scones add a fruity softness that works especially well when eaten warm.

Each scone has a proper crumb structure, meaning they hold together without being dry or crumbly in the wrong way.

Warming a scone at home takes only a few minutes, and the result is something that feels genuinely homemade. The Pie Store also bakes Portuguese Egg Custard Tarts and miniature fruit tarts daily, which means the sweet baked goods section covers a lot of ground.

Stopping in for just one scone and leaving with four is a completely understandable outcome that happens to a lot of first-time visitors.

Imported British Groceries

Beyond the baked goods, The Pie Store stocks a solid selection of imported British groceries that feel like a small treasure hunt for anyone who knows what to look for.

HP Sauce, Heinz Beans in their distinctly British formulation, and curry powder blends line the shelves alongside British biscuits and crisps that are simply not available in regular American supermarkets.

Skips, the prawn cocktail-flavored corn puff snack, shows up here too. Finding them outside of the UK is genuinely rare, and stumbling across them on a shelf in Montclair, New Jersey feels slightly surreal in the best possible way.

Jams, savory sauces, and curry mixes round out the grocery section nicely.

The UK Cadbury chocolates are worth calling out specifically because they are made with a different recipe than the American version. The texture is creamier and the flavor is noticeably richer.

For British expats living in the area, this grocery section alone is reason enough to make The Pie Store a regular stop. For everyone else, it is a genuinely fun way to explore British food culture.

UK Cadbury Chocolates

This one deserves its own section because the difference is real and noticeable. UK Cadbury chocolate is made with a higher milk fat content and a different sugar ratio than what gets sold in the United States under the same name.

The result is a creamier, smoother melt that feels distinctly different from the first bite.

For anyone who grew up in the UK, Ireland, or Australia, eating American Cadbury can feel quietly disappointing. The Pie Store solves that problem by stocking the genuine article, imported and ready to take home.

Dairy Milk bars are the most recognizable, but the shop carries a variety of formats depending on what is in stock.

Picking up a bar alongside a savory pie creates a nice balance for a weekend afternoon treat. The chocolates also make excellent gifts for British friends or family members who have been quietly suffering through American alternatives.

Even for people with no British connection at all, trying the real thing is a simple and delicious way to understand what all the fuss is about.

The Atmosphere Inside the Shop

The Pie Store is small, which is part of what makes it feel special. Walking in for the first time, the space immediately communicates that everything here was chosen with care.

The display case holds the freshly baked pies and pastries up front. Shelves along the walls carry the imported grocery items, organized neatly without feeling clinical.

The warm smell that greets you at the door is not manufactured or artificial. It comes from actual pastry being baked and goods being prepared fresh.

That detail matters more than it might seem, because it sets the tone for the entire experience before you even look at what is available.

The shop has the energy of a neighborhood spot that has earned its place on the street. It is the kind of place where people come back regularly, not just because the food is good but because the whole visit feels like a small, pleasant ritual.

The Pie Store operates Tuesday through Saturday from 11 AM to 5 PM and Sunday from 11 AM to 3 PM, so planning ahead is worthwhile.

The Tea Store Next Door

A couple of doors down from The Pie Store at 106 Watchung Ave sits its sister shop, The Tea Store. The two businesses complement each other in a way that makes the whole block feel like a small British enclave in the middle of New Jersey.

The Tea Store carries an extensive collection of British and global teas, along with coffee, matcha, and sandwiches.

Treats sourced directly from The Pie Store show up at The Tea Store too, which means you can sit down with a proper cup of tea and enjoy a scone or a pastry without having to choose between the two shops.

The pairing is genuinely satisfying and makes for a relaxed, unhurried afternoon.

Planning a visit that covers both spots is easy since they share the same street and the same general hours.

Starting with a savory pie from The Pie Store and finishing with a pot of tea and a sweet treat next door is a perfectly reasonable way to spend a Tuesday afternoon in Montclair.

Address: 100 Watchung Ave, Montclair, NJ