Looking for a place where crisp leaves, glowing hearths, and timeless hospitality set the stage for a heartwarming Thanksgiving?
These Pennsylvania inns deliver the kind of comfort that feels like coming home. Each offers historic character, serene surroundings, and thoughtful touches that make the holiday memorable. Settle in and discover where tradition meets cozy seasonal magic.
1. The Inn at Leola Village: Amish Country Warmth and Heritage
In the heart of Lancaster County, The Inn at Leola Village blends restored farmstead charm with refined comfort. Former tobacco barns and artisan workshops now host inviting rooms filled with handcrafted details and soft lighting.
Autumn settles over quiet lanes and tidy fields, creating a peaceful backdrop for a nostalgic holiday escape. Guests can wander the village grounds, admire stone walls, and relax by crackling fireplaces in cozy common spaces.
Thoughtful service and classic decor make gatherings feel intimate and unhurried. The surrounding countryside adds carriage paths, covered bridges, and gentle scenery that encourages reflection and rest.
Every corner hints at heritage while keeping modern comforts close at hand. It is a serene setting for gratitude, conversation, and timeless Thanksgiving memories.
2. The Inn at Herr Ridge: History and Holiday Charm in Gettysburg
Overlooking pastoral fields, The Inn at Herr Ridge combines Civil War history with thoughtful hospitality. Period accents and restored woodwork set a reflective tone.
Firesides and quiet parlors invite guests to slow down and savor the season. Autumn light settles across rolling farmland, creating a calm, contemplative mood.
Rooms carry a sense of place with antique touches and soft textiles. Public spaces highlight heritage while keeping the atmosphere warm and welcoming.
Nearby landmarks add depth to a holiday centered on gratitude and remembrance. It is an ideal retreat for travelers who appreciate stories, serenity, and classic comfort.
3. The Golden Plough Inn: Small-Town Comfort in Peddler’s Village
Nestled within Peddler’s Village in Lahaska, The Golden Plough Inn places guests amid quaint lanes and twinkling seasonal decor. Colonial-inspired buildings and tidy gardens create a picture-book setting.
Cozy rooms overlook brick walkways and festive displays that celebrate the season. Gentle lighting and warm color palettes set an inviting tone.
Common areas feel intimate and relaxed, perfect for savoring quiet moments between strolls. Shops and courtyards add charm without disrupting the calm of the village evenings.
Surrounding countryside roads lead to scenic overlooks and peaceful woods. It is a charming base for a nostalgic Thanksgiving retreat with small-town soul.
4. The Hotel Hershey: Elegance and Tradition in the Heart of Pennsylvania
Perched on a hilltop, The Hotel Hershey pairs grand Mediterranean Revival architecture with garden-lined pathways. Its classic lobby and fireplaces set an elegant holiday mood.
Manicured grounds blend with nearby woodlands that glow with autumn color. Interiors feature refined finishes, cozy seating, and a tranquil rhythm.
Quiet corners invite reading and reflection between leisurely walks. The atmosphere balances grandeur and warmth, making gatherings feel special.
Nearby attractions add gentle diversions without overshadowing rest. It is a stately choice for travelers seeking timeless tradition and seasonal beauty.
5. The Settlers Inn: A Cozy Hideaway in the Pocono Mountains
Set along the Lackawaxen River in Hawley, The Settlers Inn welcomes guests with Arts and Crafts character and a hearth-warmed lobby. Handcrafted woodwork and mission-style furnishings create an inviting refuge.
Outdoor paths lead to gardens and riverside nooks framed by colorful leaves. Inside, glowing fireplaces and tasteful seasonal decor encourage unhurried conversations.
The inn’s architecture balances rustic charm with thoughtful polish. Public rooms feel intimate, perfect for reading, planning a scenic drive, or simply enjoying the hush of late autumn.
Nearby trails and waterways add gentle adventure without crowding the holiday. It is a soothing base for travelers seeking comfort, tradition, and mountain calm.
6. The Inn at Westwynd Farm: Country Serenity Near Hershey
Set on a peaceful horse farm, The Inn at Westwynd Farm offers pastoral views and gentle quiet. Wraparound porches and farmhouse accents create a comforting retreat.
Autumn fields and fence lines frame golden sunsets that linger over the hills. Inside, fireplaces and cozy living rooms encourage unrushed conversation.
Rooms feature rustic touches, quilts, and soft textures that feel like home. Trails and barns add a sense of place without hurry.
Evenings are calm, with starlit skies and the hush of countryside nights. It is an ideal haven for gratitude, rest, and simple holiday pleasure.
7. The Inn at Bowman’s Hill: Peaceful Retreat Surrounded by Woods
Tucked near New Hope, The Inn at Bowman’s Hill offers a secluded woodland setting that feels restorative. Stone walls, mature trees, and garden paths create a private escape.
Autumn leaves paint the canopy, and quiet patios invite lingering. Indoors, fireplaces warm elegant rooms with soft lighting and classic furnishings.
The property’s intimate scale encourages a slower pace. Guest spaces are thoughtfully arranged for privacy and comfort.
Nearby river towns add quaint scenery and historic architecture. It is a serene choice for travelers seeking quiet beauty and a sense of tradition.
8. The Sayre Mansion: Old-World Beauty in Bethlehem’s Christmas City
Overlooking South Bethlehem, The Sayre Mansion blends Gilded Age architecture with a warm residential feel. High ceilings, carved wood, and period details set a gracious tone.
With autumn giving way to festive lights, the mansion feels especially enchanting. Parlors and nooks invite reading, planning, and unhurried conversation.
Rooms carry elegant touches that complement historic charm. The setting is calm, with views of town landmarks and leafy streets.
Nearby walks reveal stone churches and heritage sites that add seasonal wonder. It is a refined home base for a nostalgic Thanksgiving in Christmas City.
9. The Mercersburg Inn: A Grand Setting for Thanksgiving Memories
Housed in a stately Georgian Revival mansion, The Mercersburg Inn offers gracious spaces and towering trees. Broad porches and a sweeping lawn create a cinematic arrival.
Inside, fireplaces and rich woodwork pair with inviting seating. The atmosphere is unhurried, encouraging guests to savor quiet holiday moments.
Rooms include vintage-inspired details that enhance the inn’s heritage. Gardens and nearby hills showcase mellow fall color and peaceful views.
Evenings feel warm and dignified, perfect for reflection and family time. It is an inspiring place to celebrate tradition and gratitude.
10. The Eagles Mere Inn: Timeless Hospitality in a Mountain Village
Set in the storied village of Eagles Mere, this inn captures the spirit of mountain quiet. Weathered wood, porches, and a small-town green create a nostalgic scene.
Autumn brings crisp air and rustling leaves around serene lakeside paths. Inside, nooks by the fireplace invite slow afternoons with a book.
Rooms feel homey and simple, emphasizing comfort over fuss. The village setting adds charm that endures from season to season.
Trailheads and scenic overlooks are close, yet the inn remains peaceful. It is a timeless refuge for a heartfelt Thanksgiving getaway.
Dear Reader: This page may contain affiliate links which may earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase. Our independent journalism is not influenced by any advertiser or commercial initiative unless it is clearly marked as sponsored content. As travel products change, please be sure to reconfirm all details and stay up to date with current events to ensure a safe and successful trip.
