I stumbled onto Lakeside Wood Fire Pizza on one of those aimless Sunday drives where you’re just looking for something different, and let me tell you, it completely changed how I think about pizza in Indiana.
This little cabin restaurant sits outside North Vernon, and from the outside, you might drive right past it thinking it’s just another roadside spot.
But step inside and you’ll find a wood-fired oven cranking out some of the most flavorful, authentic pizza you’ve ever tasted, plus sandwiches, homemade ice cream, and cheesecakes that people drive hours to try.
The smoky aroma hits you the second you walk through the door, and the walls are decorated with railroad and race car memorabilia that give the place a cozy, nostalgic feel.
Whether you’re a local looking for your new favorite pizza joint or just passing through Jennings County, this hidden gem deserves a spot on your must-visit list.
Wood-Fired Pizza That Rivals Any Big City Pizzeria
Lakeside Wood Fire Pizza earned its reputation by doing one thing exceptionally well: cooking pizza the old-fashioned way in a blazing hot wood-fired oven. That oven is the heart of everything here, and you can watch the staff slide pizzas in and out with practiced precision while flames dance around the edges.
The heat from burning wood creates a crust that’s crispy on the outside but still soft and chewy inside, with those signature charred spots that add a smoky depth you just can’t get from a regular oven. Some folks worry about the blackened dough at first, but once you taste how it enhances the flavor without being bitter, you’ll understand why people drive from Columbus, Seymour, and even Indianapolis to get their fix.
You can order classics like pepperoni or supreme, or get adventurous with specialty pies like the Hawaiian or the Smoke Stack BBQ pizza that reviewers rave about. The cheese melts perfectly, the toppings are generous, and every bite delivers that wood-fired taste that makes this place stand out.
Located at 4105 IN-3, North Vernon, IN 47265, the restaurant opens at 11 AM most days, though their hours can be a bit unconventional, so calling ahead at 812-352-7854 is smart. Even on busy days, the kitchen moves fast and you won’t wait long for your order.
The Legendary Rail Bread That Customers Can’t Stop Talking About
Before you even get to the pizza, you need to know about the Rail Bread. This appetizer has achieved almost mythical status among regulars, and after one bite you’ll understand why people mention it in nearly every review.
Picture this: fresh pizza dough stretched out, brushed with garlic butter, and baked in that same wood-fired oven until it’s golden and pillowy. The result tastes like the best garlic bread you’ve ever had, but with that distinctive smoky flavor from the wood fire.
One reviewer compared it to their grandmother’s homemade bread, which is about the highest compliment you can give comfort food. Another said they nearly proposed to it, and honestly, that’s not an exaggeration when you’re holding a warm piece in your hand.
The Rail Bread comes out piping hot, perfect for sharing, though you might want to order extra because it disappears fast. It’s fluffy enough to pull apart easily but has just enough chew to feel substantial, and that garlic butter soaks into every bite without making it greasy.
If you’re bringing kids, they’ll devour this while waiting for the main course. If you’re dining with friends, it makes a perfect starter that gets everyone excited about what’s coming next.
Some people even order it as a side with their sandwiches or as a light lunch on its own.
Homemade Cheesecakes That Are Worth The Trip Alone
Saving room for dessert isn’t optional at Lakeside Wood Fire Pizza because their homemade cheesecakes have earned a dedicated following. These aren’t your standard factory-made desserts shipped in from some warehouse.
Every cheesecake is made in-house, and you can taste the difference immediately.
The peanut butter swirl cheesecake gets mentioned constantly in reviews, with its rich, creamy texture and the perfect balance of sweet and nutty flavors. But they also rotate seasonal and specialty flavors, including a jalapeño cheesecake that sounds wild but apparently works beautifully for anyone who likes a little kick with their sweetness.
People literally say these cheesecakes are “to die for” and that they “wish they had another stomach” after finishing a slice. That kind of enthusiasm doesn’t come from polite exaggeration.
It comes from dessert that actually delivers.
The texture is dense and velvety without being heavy, and the crust provides just enough crunch to contrast with the smooth filling. Whether you go with a classic flavor or try something adventurous, you’re getting a dessert that rivals anything you’d find at a dedicated bakery.
After a filling pizza or sandwich, a slice of cheesecake makes the perfect ending to your meal. Share it if you must, but don’t be surprised if everyone at your table wants their own piece once they taste it.
Handmade Ice Cream That Tastes Like Childhood Summers
Right alongside those famous cheesecakes, Lakeside serves handmade ice cream that transports you straight back to summer afternoons at your grandparents’ house. This isn’t the mass-produced stuff from a carton.
Each batch is made fresh, and the difference is immediately obvious.
The vanilla is pure and rich without being overly sweet, while the strawberry features real fruit flavor that tastes like actual berries instead of artificial flavoring. One reviewer said it was “beyond delicious,” and another mentioned being “beyond impressed” after their first taste.
The owner has been known to walk around offering samples to curious diners, which is the kind of personal touch that makes small restaurants special. When someone is that proud of their product, you know they’re putting real care into it.
The texture is smooth and creamy, the kind that melts on your tongue and leaves you wanting another spoonful immediately. It’s substantial enough to feel like a real treat but not so heavy that you feel uncomfortable after finishing it.
Kids absolutely love it, but adults appreciate the quality just as much. Some people order it as a standalone dessert, while others get a scoop alongside their cheesecake for the ultimate sweet ending.
Either way, you’re getting ice cream made with the same attention to quality that goes into everything else here.
Hearty Sandwiches And Subs That Hold Their Own
While pizza gets most of the attention, the sandwiches at Lakeside Wood Fire Pizza deserve serious recognition. Multiple reviewers specifically mentioned their sandwiches being “perfect,” and the Philly cheesesteak is apparently a customer favorite that keeps people coming back.
The secret weapon here is the bread. Remember that amazing Rail Bread everyone loves?
That same dough gets used for the sandwich rolls, giving you a foundation that’s fresh, flavorful, and substantial enough to hold generous portions of fillings without falling apart.
One reviewer described the pizza sub bread as tasting exactly like their grandmother’s homemade buns, except loaded with melted cheese and quality meats. That combination of nostalgic comfort and upgraded ingredients makes these sandwiches something special.
The fried bologna sandwich shows up in reviews too, which might sound simple but becomes something memorable when you’re using quality ingredients and fresh bread. They also serve ham and beans as a side or light meal option, adding variety for anyone who isn’t in a pizza mood.
The portions are generous without being ridiculous, and the sandwiches come out hot with the cheese properly melted and the bread still warm. Whether you’re grabbing lunch on a work break or stopping by for dinner, the sandwich menu gives you plenty of satisfying options beyond pizza.
A Cozy Atmosphere Decorated With Railroad And Race Car Memorabilia
Walking into Lakeside Wood Fire Pizza feels like stepping into someone’s well-loved cabin, except this cabin happens to serve incredible food. The walls are covered with railroad and race car memorabilia that give the place character and spark conversations while you wait for your order.
The decorations aren’t random or thrown up haphazardly. They’re thoughtfully arranged and create a nostalgic atmosphere that appeals to everyone from young families to older couples who remember when these items were part of everyday life in small-town Indiana.
Parents appreciate that the environment is peaceful and family-friendly, with enough visual interest to keep kids entertained while they wait. The seating is comfortable, the lighting is warm without being dim, and there’s enough space between tables that you don’t feel crowded even when the place is busy.
And it does get busy, especially during peak lunch and dinner hours, which tells you everything you need to know about the food quality.
Despite being just outside North Vernon along Highway 3, the interior feels removed from the road, creating a cozy retreat where you can relax and enjoy your meal. The parking lot has plenty of angled spaces, so you won’t have trouble finding a spot even on crowded days.
Outstanding Service From A Staff That Actually Cares
Great food only gets you so far if the service falls flat, but Lakeside Wood Fire Pizza consistently delivers on both fronts. Reviewers mention the staff by name, talk about how friendly everyone is, and note that the servers genuinely seem to enjoy their work.
Rose gets a specific shoutout in one review as “the best,” while another reviewer praises the efficiency of the woman working the wood-fired oven, describing her as a “pizza wizard” who handles the high-pressure job with skill and passion. When customers notice and remember individual staff members, that’s a sign of exceptional service.
Even on busy days when the dining room is packed, the food comes out surprisingly fast and orders arrive accurate and hot. The staff keeps the buffet stocked when it’s available, making multiple trips to ensure fresh pizza is always available.
The owner takes time to walk around and chat with customers, asking how everything tastes and sometimes offering samples of new items or desserts. That personal connection makes you feel like a valued guest rather than just another order number.
If you call ahead to check hours or place a takeout order, the staff is helpful and friendly over the phone too. They understand their hours are unconventional and encourage people to check their Facebook page or call before driving out, which shows they care about your experience from start to finish.
Dear Reader: This page may contain affiliate links which may earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase. Our independent journalism is not influenced by any advertiser or commercial initiative unless it is clearly marked as sponsored content. As travel products change, please be sure to reconfirm all details and stay up to date with current events to ensure a safe and successful trip.
