9 All-You-Can-Eat Seafood Buffets In New Jersey Where Catfish Could Be The Catch Of Your Life

New Jersey might be famous for its boardwalks and pizza, but the Garden State has quietly become a seafood lover’s paradise, especially if you know where to look.

All-you-can-eat buffets have exploded across the state, serving everything from snow crab legs to fresh oysters, and yes, even perfectly fried catfish that could make you rethink your favorite fish.

These spots aren’t just about quantity; they’re about variety, freshness, and giving you the chance to sample flavors from coast to coast without breaking the bank.

Whether you’re planning a family feast or just want to pile your plate high with shrimp, scallops, and that crispy catfish you’ve been craving, New Jersey’s got you covered.

From the bustling streets of Newark to the sandy shores of Atlantic City, these buffets are turning heads and filling bellies across the state.

Imagine walking into a restaurant where the smell of garlic butter and Old Bay seasoning hits you the moment you step through the door.

Picture rows of steaming trays loaded with mussels, clams, lobster tails, and yes, golden catfish fillets that crunch with every bite.

Ready to eat your weight in seafood without worrying about the bill?

1. Umi Hotpot & Seafood Buffet in Freehold

Stepping into this Freehold favorite feels like entering a seafood wonderland where East meets West in the most delicious way possible. Located at 4345 US-9, Freehold, NJ 07728, this spot has mastered the art of combining traditional Asian hotpot with classic American buffet favorites, creating a dining experience that keeps locals coming back week after week.

The moment you walk in, you’ll notice the massive selection of fresh seafood laid out before you, from plump shrimp and tender mussels to those golden catfish strips that somehow manage to stay crispy even under the heat lamps.

What sets this place apart is the interactive hotpot station where you can cook your own seafood exactly how you like it, choosing from a variety of broths that range from mild and comforting to spicy and bold. Families love this spot because there’s truly something for everyone, whether you’re a sushi fan, a fried food enthusiast, or someone who just wants to sample a little bit of everything.

The catfish here deserves special mention because it’s seasoned perfectly with a light cornmeal coating that adds just the right amount of crunch without overwhelming the delicate fish flavor underneath.

Kids get a kick out of building their own hotpot bowls while parents appreciate the reasonable prices and the fact that nobody leaves hungry. The staff keeps the buffet stations well-stocked throughout lunch and dinner service, so you never have to worry about your favorite items running out.

Between the sushi bar, the grill station, and the dessert section loaded with fresh fruit and sweet treats, you could easily spend two hours here and still not try everything. Pro tip: come hungry, wear stretchy pants, and don’t skip the catfish because it might just surprise you as the star of your meal.

2. Umi Hotpot Sushi & Seafood Buffet in Deptford

Down in Deptford at 1692 Clements Bridge Rd, Deptford, NJ 08096, this sister location brings the same winning formula to South Jersey with its own unique local flair. Regulars rave about the sushi selection here, which rivals some dedicated sushi restaurants in freshness and variety, but don’t let that distract you from the hot buffet where the catfish waits to steal your heart.

The restaurant spans a huge space with high ceilings and plenty of natural light, making it feel open and inviting rather than cramped like some buffet joints can get during peak hours.

One thing people absolutely love about this location is how they’ve organized the buffet stations by cuisine type, making it super easy to navigate even when the place is packed on weekend evenings. You’ve got your Asian section with lo mein, fried rice, and dumplings; your American comfort food area with mac and cheese and roasted vegetables; and then the star of the show, the seafood section where everything from crab legs to that perfectly seasoned catfish beckons you to grab another plate.

The hotpot area here is especially popular because they offer more broth options than most places, including a rich tomato base that pairs beautifully with fresh fish and shellfish.

Families celebrating birthdays or special occasions often choose this spot because the atmosphere feels festive without being loud or chaotic. The dessert bar features soft-serve ice cream machines that kids adore, plus traditional Asian sweets like mochi and sesame balls that offer something different from the usual buffet fare.

Service remains attentive even during rush times, with servers quickly clearing plates and refilling drinks so you can focus on the important work of sampling everything. If you’re driving through South Jersey and need a filling meal that won’t disappoint, this place delivers every single time.

3. Umi Seafood and Sushi Buffet in East Brunswick

Central Jersey folks know that 275 NJ-18, East Brunswick, NJ 08816 is where you go when you want quality and quantity in equal measure. This location sits right on a busy stretch of Route 18, making it super convenient for anyone traveling through Middlesex County or looking for a satisfying meal after a long day.

Walking through the doors, you’re immediately greeted by the sight of an enormous buffet spread that seems to stretch on forever, with everything from delicate sashimi to hearty comfort food and yes, that irresistible Southern-style catfish that keeps customers talking.

The East Brunswick location has earned a reputation for keeping its food exceptionally fresh, rotating trays frequently so you’re always getting hot, just-cooked items rather than stuff that’s been sitting out for hours. Their catfish gets a special preparation here with a hint of Cajun seasoning that gives it a subtle kick without overwhelming those who prefer milder flavors.

Watching the chefs work behind the grill station is half the fun, as they constantly cook fresh batches of seafood, vegetables, and proteins to keep the buffet at peak deliciousness throughout service hours.

College students from nearby Rutgers University flock here for affordable all-you-can-eat meals, while families appreciate the kid-friendly options and the fact that even picky eaters can find something they enjoy. The hibachi grill station lets you customize your stir-fry with your choice of proteins and vegetables, and the chefs put on a little show as they cook, adding entertainment value to your meal.

Weekends can get busy, so arriving slightly before peak lunch or dinner hours means shorter wait times and easier access to the most popular stations. Whether you come for the sushi, stay for the crab legs, or discover that the catfish is your new obsession, this East Brunswick gem rarely disappoints hungry diners looking for variety and value.

4. Umi Sushi & Seafood Buffet in Egg Harbor Township

Just minutes from Atlantic City at 6725 Black Horse Pike, Egg Harbor Township, NJ 08234, this coastal location brings serious seafood credentials to the buffet game. Being so close to the shore means this restaurant has access to incredibly fresh catches, and you can taste the difference in every bite of their perfectly prepared fish and shellfish.

The catfish here gets special attention, arriving crispy on the outside while remaining tender and flaky inside, seasoned with a proprietary blend that locals swear makes it the best version in the entire Umi chain.

Tourists visiting the Atlantic City area often stumble upon this place and end up making it a must-visit stop on every subsequent trip to the Shore. The buffet layout here feels more spacious than some other locations, giving you plenty of room to browse without bumping into other diners even during busy summer weekends when the Shore crowds descend.

Beyond the expected sushi rolls and seafood standards, you’ll find regional specialties and rotating seasonal items that keep the menu feeling fresh and exciting rather than predictable.

The restaurant’s proximity to the casino district means it stays open later than many buffets, making it a perfect spot for a late dinner after a day at the beach or an evening of entertainment. Servers here seem genuinely friendly and helpful, offering recommendations and making sure water glasses stay filled without being intrusive.

The dessert section features saltwater taffy and other Shore-inspired treats alongside the usual cakes and cookies, adding a local touch that visitors appreciate. Parking is plentiful and easy, which anyone who’s driven around Atlantic City during summer knows is practically a miracle.

Whether you’re a local looking for your weekly seafood fix or a visitor wanting to experience New Jersey’s buffet culture, this Egg Harbor Township location delivers on all fronts with style and substance in equal measure.

5. Flaming Grill & Modern Buffet in East Hanover

Tucked away at 240 Route 10 West, East Hanover, NJ 07936, this spot takes the buffet concept and gives it a contemporary twist that appeals to both traditional buffet lovers and those seeking something a bit more upscale. The name Flaming Grill isn’t just for show; they feature multiple live cooking stations where chefs prepare fresh items right before your eyes, including a dedicated seafood grill that turns out perfectly cooked catfish with a slightly charred exterior that adds incredible depth of flavor.

Morris County residents consider this their go-to spot for special occasions when they want the variety of a buffet with a touch more sophistication than the typical all-you-can-eat joint.

What really makes this location stand out is the attention to presentation and the modern decor that feels more like a nice restaurant than a buffet hall. The lighting is warm and inviting rather than harsh and fluorescent, and the seating areas are divided into semi-private sections that give your group a sense of space and comfort.

The seafood selection rotates seasonally, but the catfish remains a year-round staple because customers have made it clear they’d riot if it ever disappeared from the menu.

Families celebrating graduations, anniversaries, and other milestones often choose this spot because it feels special without requiring reservations or formal dress codes. The salad bar here is surprisingly impressive with fresh greens, interesting toppings, and house-made dressings that go beyond the usual ranch and Italian options.

Kids enjoy the dedicated children’s area with familiar favorites like chicken nuggets and fries, while adventurous eaters can explore international cuisines from the various stations scattered throughout the restaurant. The dessert selection includes a chocolate fountain that’s always a hit, plus fresh-baked cookies and cakes that taste homemade rather than mass-produced.

Service strikes the perfect balance between attentive and unobtrusive, checking in without hovering, which diners definitely appreciate when they’re in the middle of their fourth plate.

6. Flaming Grill & Supreme Buffet in Manville

Small-town charm meets big-time flavor at 126 N Main St, Manville, NJ 08835, where this local favorite has become the unofficial community gathering spot for anyone craving serious variety without the big-city prices. Manville residents are fiercely loyal to this place, and for good reason: the portions are generous, the food stays fresh throughout service, and the catfish is consistently ranked among the best you’ll find at any buffet in Somerset County.

Unlike some chain locations that feel impersonal and rushed, this spot maintains a neighborhood vibe where servers remember regular customers and genuinely seem happy to see familiar faces walk through the door.

The buffet selection here punches way above its weight class for a restaurant in a town this size, offering everything from classic American comfort food to Asian specialties, Italian pasta dishes, and of course, an impressive seafood spread. Their catfish preparation leans traditional with a simple cornmeal breading that lets the fish flavor shine through, accompanied by tartar sauce and lemon wedges for those who want to customize their experience.

Local high school sports teams often celebrate victories here, and it’s not uncommon to see three generations of the same family sharing a meal on any given weekend.

Parking is easy and plentiful, which anyone who’s struggled to find a spot at busier locations will immediately appreciate. The restaurant isn’t fancy or trendy, but it’s clean, comfortable, and focused on what really matters: good food at fair prices served by people who actually care about your experience.

Lunch specials during weekdays offer incredible value for retirees and work-from-home folks looking for an affordable midday meal. The fruit bar stays well-stocked with fresh melons, pineapple, and berries that provide a refreshing contrast to heavier buffet items.

If you’re exploring Central Jersey and want an authentic local experience rather than a tourist trap, this Manville gem delivers exactly what you’re looking for without any pretense or fuss.

7. Flaming Grill & Supreme Buffet in Newark

Right in the heart of the Ironbound district at 293 Ferry St, Newark, NJ 07105, this location sits among some of the state’s best Portuguese and Spanish restaurants, yet it holds its own by offering something completely different: massive variety under one roof. Newark’s diverse population means this buffet caters to incredibly varied tastes, and the kitchen rises to the challenge with stations representing cuisines from around the world.

The catfish here gets an interesting treatment with subtle Portuguese-inspired seasonings that reflect the neighborhood’s culinary influence, creating a unique flavor profile you won’t find at other locations.

Ferry Street is known for amazing food, so any restaurant that survives here has to bring serious game, and this place absolutely delivers. The lunch crowd includes everyone from construction workers and hospital staff to office employees from downtown Newark, all looking for filling meals that won’t drain their wallets.

Watching the mix of people pile their plates high with everything from sushi to soul food to Spanish rice creates a fascinating snapshot of New Jersey’s beautiful diversity.

The seafood selection extends beyond the usual suspects to include items like grilled sardines and bacalhau preparations that nod to the neighborhood’s Portuguese heritage while still maintaining classic buffet staples. Their catfish remains a top seller because it’s consistently well-prepared and available throughout service hours without running out.

Weekend dinners transform the restaurant into a lively gathering spot where extended families celebrate together, filling multiple tables and creating an energetic, festive atmosphere. Parking can be challenging on busy streets, but there’s a lot nearby that makes visiting much easier than you’d expect in this urban location.

The restaurant stays open later than many suburban buffets, catering to Newark’s night-owl culture and providing a solid option for those seeking a substantial meal after evening activities. If you want to experience authentic Newark energy while enjoying an incredible all-you-can-eat spread, this Ferry Street location captures both perfectly in one delicious package.

8. Hibachi Grill & Supreme Buffet in South Plainfield

Positioned perfectly at 690 Oak Tree Ave, South Plainfield, NJ 07080, this restaurant has mastered the art of the hibachi-style buffet experience that keeps customers entertained while they eat. The name tells you exactly what to expect: a massive buffet with a special focus on hibachi-grilled items that you can watch being prepared fresh throughout your meal.

Their catfish gets the hibachi treatment with a light teriyaki glaze that adds a sweet and savory dimension to the traditional fried version available just a few stations away, giving you options depending on your mood.

What makes this spot special is the theatrical element of watching skilled chefs work the hibachi grills, flipping spatulas and creating small flames as they cook your custom selections. Kids are absolutely mesmerized by the show, making this an excellent choice for families with young children who might get restless at a typical sit-down restaurant.

The buffet selection rivals much larger locations with dedicated stations for Chinese, Japanese, American, and Italian cuisines, plus a seafood area that would make coastal restaurants jealous.

Middlesex County locals know this place gets packed on weekend evenings, so smart diners arrive during the early dinner window or opt for weekday visits when the atmosphere is more relaxed. The sushi here is surprisingly good for a buffet, with fresh fish and creative rolls that go beyond the basic California and spicy tuna options.

Their dessert bar includes soft-serve ice cream with an impressive array of toppings, plus traditional Asian sweets and American favorites like brownies and cookies. Service stays efficient even during rush periods, with bussers quickly clearing finished plates and servers keeping drink refills flowing.

The restaurant underwent renovations recently that modernized the space while maintaining the comfortable, family-friendly vibe that made it popular in the first place. Whether you’re a hibachi enthusiast or just someone who appreciates watching food being cooked fresh, this South Plainfield location offers entertainment and excellent eating in one convenient package that satisfies groups with varying tastes and preferences.

9. Flaming Grill & Supreme Buffet in East Rutherford

Sports fans and buffet enthusiasts unite at 53 NJ-17, East Rutherford, NJ 07073, where this location sits just minutes from MetLife Stadium and the American Dream mega-mall complex. Its proximity to major entertainment venues means this restaurant sees an interesting mix of customers, from football fans fueling up before Giants or Jets games to shoppers needing a break from the mall madness.

The catfish here is prepared with a slightly spicier kick than other locations, perhaps reflecting the energetic, game-day atmosphere that permeates this part of Bergen County on event days.

The restaurant’s size is impressive, easily accommodating large groups and pre-game parties without feeling overcrowded or chaotic. Stadium parking might cost a fortune, but parking here is free and plentiful, making it a smart choice for anyone planning a day in the Meadowlands area.

The buffet stations are strategically placed to handle high-volume traffic flow, so even when the place is packed, you’re not standing in endless lines waiting to access your favorite foods.

Beyond the standard buffet offerings, this location often features game-day specials and themed items that tie into whatever sporting event is happening nearby, adding a fun, festive element to your dining experience. The seafood selection remains strong year-round with the catfish holding its own against fancier options like crab legs and shrimp scampi.

Families appreciate the reasonable prices, especially compared to stadium food costs, and many make it a tradition to eat here before heading to events. The staff handles the pre-game rush with impressive efficiency, understanding that many diners are on a timeline and need to eat and get to their destination without unnecessary delays.

Desserts include a DIY sundae bar that kids absolutely love, plus fresh fruit for those seeking lighter options after a heavy meal. If you’re planning a visit to MetLife Stadium or American Dream, building in time for a meal here transforms your outing from expensive to economical while ensuring nobody in your group goes hungry or grumpy during your adventure.