8 Enormous Thrift Stores in Indiana Where Bargains Never End

I’ve spent countless weekends hunting for treasures in thrift stores across Indiana, and honestly, there’s nothing quite like the rush of spotting a hidden gem at an unbeatable price.

Some days it’s a vintage lamp that perfectly matches your living room vibe, other days it’s a designer jacket you’d never expect to find tucked between a rack of everyday jackets.

The Hoosier State is full of massive secondhand shops where you could easily lose hours; aisles packed with everything from quirky home decor and retro kitchenware to antique furniture and rare collectibles.

Whether you’re furnishing your first apartment on a tight budget, looking for a one-of-a-kind accent piece, or just love the thrill of the hunt, these enormous stores are full of unexpected surprises.

Every corner holds the possibility of a discovery that makes you pause, smile, and wonder how it ended up there. It’s part treasure hunt, part nostalgia trip, and all the fun of finding something unique that you didn’t even know you needed.

1. Goodwill (North Keystone Avenue) – 7150 N Keystone Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46240

Walking into this Goodwill location feels less like entering a typical thrift store and more like stepping into a well-organized department store that happens to have incredible prices. The sheer size of this place is impressive, with dedicated sections that make finding exactly what you need surprisingly easy.

Clothing racks stretch for what seems like miles, organized by size and color in a way that makes browsing actually enjoyable instead of overwhelming. You’ll find everything from everyday basics to designer labels tucked between the hangers, and the home decor section rivals many retail stores in terms of selection.

What really sets this location apart is how they’ve mastered the art of presentation. Items are clean, displayed attractively, and priced fairly, which means you can shop without feeling like you’re digging through chaos.

The furniture area deserves special mention because it’s constantly rotating with quality pieces that range from modern to vintage. If you’re near the Fashion Mall at Keystone at 8702 Keystone Crossing, Indianapolis, IN 46240, this Goodwill makes for a perfect budget-friendly addition to your shopping day.

Regular shoppers know that timing matters here. New items hit the floor throughout the week, so frequent visits often yield the best finds before other treasure hunters snag them.

2. Mission 27 Resale – 132 Leota St, Indianapolis, IN 46202

Mission 27 Resale operates with a purpose that goes beyond just selling secondhand goods. Every purchase you make here directly supports St. Vincent de Paul’s mission to help families in need throughout central Indiana, which adds a feel-good factor to your bargain hunting.

The sprawling layout of this store means you need to set aside plenty of time for your visit. The furniture section alone could keep you busy for an hour, with everything from complete bedroom sets to individual accent pieces that could transform any room.

Housewares fill multiple aisles with dishes, cookware, small appliances, and decorative items that range from everyday practical to genuinely unique vintage finds. The pricing stays consistently reasonable, making it possible to furnish an entire apartment without breaking your budget.

Clothing takes up a significant portion of the store, with separate areas for men’s, women’s, and children’s items that are sorted by type and size. You’ll discover both current styles and vintage pieces that fashion-forward shoppers love to incorporate into their wardrobes.

The store’s proximity to downtown Indianapolis makes it easily accessible, and you can combine your thrifting trip with a visit to the Indiana State Museum at 650 W Washington St, Indianapolis, IN 46204. The staff here genuinely cares about helping customers find what they need while supporting their charitable mission.

3. Village Discount Outlet – 2706 E 165th St, Hammond, IN 46323

Northwest Indiana residents consider Village Discount Outlet their go-to destination for serious bargain hunting. This massive store has built a reputation for carrying surprising amounts of brand-name merchandise at prices that make you do a double-take.

The clothing selection here is truly impressive, with new items constantly arriving to keep the inventory fresh and exciting. You’ll spot recognizable labels mixed in with everyday brands, and the sheer volume means there’s always something in your size waiting to be discovered.

Home accessories and decor fill multiple sections of the store, from kitchen gadgets to decorative pieces that can update your living space without the retail price tag. The treasure hunt aspect keeps things interesting because you never know what you might find on any given visit.

What makes this location particularly appealing is how they’ve managed to maintain organization despite the enormous amount of merchandise. Color-coded sections and clear signage help you navigate efficiently, though many shoppers still prefer to wander and stumble upon unexpected finds.

The Hammond location serves communities throughout the Region, and it’s become a weekend destination for families looking to stretch their budgets. After shopping, you can grab a bite at one of the many restaurants along Indianapolis Boulevard or explore the nearby Wolf Lake at 2324 Calumet Ave, Hammond, IN 46320, for some outdoor time.

4. Thrifty Threads – 1501 W 86th St, Indianapolis, IN 46260

Thrifty Threads stands out from typical thrift stores because of the consistently high quality of items you’ll find here. Operated by The Julian Center, which provides services to survivors of domestic violence and sexual assault, your purchases directly support life-changing programs in the community.

The donation base for this store includes some of Indianapolis’s more affluent neighborhoods, which translates to an inventory that often features designer labels, genuine antiques, and fine jewelry. Shoppers who appreciate quality over quantity tend to make this their first stop when thrifting in the area.

The jewelry section deserves its own visit, with cases displaying everything from vintage costume pieces to genuine gold and silver items at prices far below retail. Estate sales and generous donors keep this section well-stocked with unique finds that make perfect gifts or personal treasures.

Antique furniture and home decor rotate regularly, and serious collectors know to check back frequently because quality pieces don’t last long on the floor. The store maintains a boutique-like atmosphere that makes shopping feel more curated than chaotic.

Located along the busy 86th Street corridor, Thrifty Threads fits perfectly into a day of shopping or dining in the area. The nearby Nora neighborhood offers additional shopping and you can visit the beautiful Holliday Park at 6363 Spring Mill Rd, Indianapolis, IN 46260, to enjoy nature trails and the famous Ruins.

5. Amanda’s Exchange – 715 E Carmel Dr, Carmel, IN 46032

Amanda’s Exchange redefines what a thrift store can be by focusing exclusively on high-end consignment pieces. If you’re searching for designer fashion or upscale home furnishings without the luxury price tags, this spacious boutique delivers an experience that feels more like shopping at Nordstrom than a typical secondhand store.

The women’s fashion section showcases an impressive collection of designer labels, current styles, and classic pieces that never go out of fashion. Consignors in the affluent Carmel area contribute quality items that often still have tags attached or show minimal wear.

Home furnishings occupy a significant portion of the store, featuring everything from elegant dining sets to decorative accessories that could elevate any room’s aesthetic. The curation here is thoughtful, with only items meeting strict quality standards making it to the sales floor.

Pricing reflects the upscale nature of the merchandise but still offers substantial savings compared to buying the same items new. Regular sales and promotions make luxury brands even more accessible to budget-conscious shoppers who refuse to compromise on quality.

The Carmel location puts you in the heart of one of Indiana’s most desirable communities, surrounded by excellent restaurants and shopping. After browsing Amanda’s Exchange, you might explore the Carmel Arts and Design District or visit the Center for the Performing Arts at 1 Carter Green, Carmel, IN 46032, for world-class entertainment in a stunning venue.

6. Audrey’s Place Thrift Store – 3228 E 10th St, Indianapolis, IN 46201

Furniture hunters across Indianapolis know that Audrey’s Place is where you go when you need to furnish a home on a budget. This multi-room warehouse has earned its reputation as the go-to destination for finding quality furniture pieces, whether you’re looking for vintage treasures or more contemporary styles.

The sheer amount of furniture packed into this space is staggering, with room after room showcasing sofas, dining sets, bedroom furniture, and every type of seating imaginable. Both antique pieces with character and newer items in excellent condition fill the showroom floor, giving shoppers an incredible range of options.

What makes this store particularly valuable is the mix of eras and styles available at any given time. You might find a mid-century modern credenza next to a traditional oak dining table, allowing you to create an eclectic look or find exactly the period piece you’ve been searching for.

Pricing remains reasonable even for higher-quality antique items, and the staff can often share the history or provenance of special pieces. The warehouse setting means you should bring measurements and be prepared to arrange your own transportation for larger items.

Located on the near eastside of Indianapolis, Audrey’s Place sits in a neighborhood experiencing revitalization. You can combine your furniture shopping with a visit to nearby Irvington, a historic district with charming shops and cafes along East Washington Street that’s worth exploring.

7. Bargain Wright Thrift Store – 3700 Cassopolis St, Elkhart, IN 46514

Bargain Wright Thrift Store operates on a unique model that combines traditional thrift store finds with new liquidation merchandise, creating a shopping experience where you truly never know what you might discover. The massive size of this Elkhart location means you could easily spend an entire afternoon exploring every section.

New liquidation items arrive regularly, offering brand-new products at deeply discounted prices because they’re overstock, closeouts, or seasonal items that didn’t sell through traditional retail channels. This means you might find current-year merchandise with tags still attached at a fraction of the original price.

The secondhand section maintains the traditional thrift store appeal with clothing, housewares, and miscellaneous items donated by the community. The mix of new and used creates an interesting dynamic where bargain hunters can score deals on both ends of the spectrum.

Deep discounts are the norm here, with pricing that reflects the store’s commitment to moving inventory quickly. Sales and special promotions happen frequently, making already low prices even more attractive to savvy shoppers who time their visits strategically.

Elkhart’s location in northern Indiana makes Bargain Wright a destination for shoppers from surrounding communities and even Michigan residents who cross the border for deals. The city itself is known as the RV capital of the world, and you can explore that heritage at the RV/MH Hall of Fame at 21565 Executive Pkwy, Elkhart, IN 46514, after your thrifting adventure.

8. Midland Arts & Antiques Market – 907 E Michigan St, Indianapolis, IN 46202

Midland Arts & Antiques Market transcends the typical thrift store experience by functioning as a massive two-story warehouse filled with individual vendor booths. Each booth represents a different dealer’s collection, creating a maze of vintage finds and antique treasures that spans thousands of square feet.

The diversity of merchandise here is extraordinary because each vendor specializes in different areas, from mid-century furniture to vintage clothing, from antique tools to retro advertising signs. You’ll find yourself moving from one carefully curated collection to another, each with its own personality and focus.

Furniture hunters particularly love this market because the selection includes pieces from every era and style imaginable. Whether you’re furnishing a home with authentic period pieces or looking for that perfect statement item, the chances of finding it here are excellent.

Pricing varies by vendor, with some offering negotiable prices and others marking items firmly. The fun lies in the hunt, wandering through the maze of booths and discovering treasures you didn’t even know you were looking for until you spotted them.

The historic building itself adds character to the shopping experience, located in the near eastside of Indianapolis in an area rich with history. You’re close to the Mass Ave Cultural District, and the Indianapolis City Market at 222 E Market St, Indianapolis, IN 46204, offers great food and local vendors just a short drive away, making it easy to spend an entire day exploring this part of the city.