New York in December feels like a movie set, and the bakeries play a starring role with windows that glow and cookies that sparkle.
You can wander a few blocks and find peppermint scents drifting into the cold air, then step inside for warmth and the soft crunch of sugar.
Each stop has its own style, from Italian classics to inventive sablés that look ready for a ribbon.
This guide hits the most beloved counters for Christmas cookies that are worth planning a trip around.
Pack some patience, bring a tote, and let the cookie crawl begin.
1. Levain Bakery, 167 W 74th St, New York, NY 10023
Levain Bakery on the Upper West Side draws steady lines for a reason, and those lines get longer when holiday flavors arrive.
You feel the rush the moment you push the door, hearing trays slide and timers ping as the staff keeps a calm rhythm.
The room stays tight and to the point, which makes every minute inside feel focused on the cookie mission.
The seasonal star here is the Dark Chocolate Peppermint cookie that lands with a balanced snap of mint against deep cocoa.
It is rich but not cloying, and the peppermint pops without reading like candy store sweetness.
You will want to share a bite, yet you will likely change your mind after the first warm crumble.
Regulars swear by the classic chocolate chip walnut, and grabbing one alongside a peppermint is a good move.
The contrast lets you taste how Levain builds texture, with an exterior crunch and a molten center that stays chewy as it cools.
If you plan to gift, ask for a box early, since packaging can run low on peak weekends.
Arrive on weekday mornings if you want the shortest wait, since afternoons pull neighborhood families and after-school crowds.
The shop sits near Central Park, so you can stroll a few blocks and find a bench for a quick cookie break.
New York in winter makes that bench feel like a small holiday stage set.
Service moves briskly and stays friendly, even when the door keeps swinging in the cold.
Card payments are quick, and the line flows in clear order, so the pace never spirals.
You leave with a warm bag, a cloud of cocoa on your gloves, and a plan to return before the season ends.
2. Ferrara Bakery & Cafe, 195 Grand St, New York, NY 10013
Ferrara Bakery & Cafe anchors Little Italy with polished wood, glass cases, and a steady hum that feels timeless.
The staff moves with practiced grace, handing over ribbon-tied boxes that look ready for a mantel.
You step inside from Grand Street and the room smells like almonds, butter, and a hint of espresso.
Holiday trays here lean classic, with Italian Rainbow cookies layered in color and cloaked in chocolate.
The texture lands tender and neat, and the almond paste brings a steady richness that never shouts.
It is the kind of cookie that travels well, which makes a strong case for gifting.
Beyond rainbows, look for pignoli, butter cookies with red and green sprinkles, and jam thumbprints arranged like ornaments.
The cases turn quickly, and staff will suggest a mix if you ask for variety by the pound.
The resulting box looks like a striped scarf when opened at a party.
Seating offers a pause from the street, and it is easy to linger with a cappuccino as you warm up.
New York holiday crowds stream past the windows like a parade, and you feel snug as the door swings closed.
The room keeps conversations soft and cheerful, even during prime hours.
If you want the largest cookie trays, order ahead for weekend pickups, since demand spikes near Christmas.
Boxes hold shape on the subway if packed upright, so bring a tote with a flat base.
The staff tapes corners neatly, which helps the cookies arrive ready for a bow.
3. Dominique Ansel Bakery, 189 Spring St, New York, NY 10012
Dominique Ansel Bakery sits on Spring Street with a sleek facade and a line that often curves past the window.
Inside, the pace is lively as trays move out and the team chats through custom orders.
The space feels bright and clever, much like the treats that made it famous.
The Cronut gets crowds year-round, but December brings playful options like Christmas Morning Cereal and decorated sablés.
ou can watch boxes get packed with crisp cookies that carry just enough butter to melt on cue.
The seasonal shapes change weekly, so each visit brings a fresh set of designs.
If you plan a morning stop, arrive early for a smooth line and the best selection.
The back garden can open for seating when weather cooperates, which gives you a quiet nook in SoHo.
It is a nice break from the bustle while you map the next cookie stop.
Staff is happy to guide choices, especially if you want a mix of whimsy and classics for gifting.
The sablés hold well overnight, so travel plans by subway or train stay simple.
You will appreciate the sturdy packaging when the city streets get crowded.
New York holiday lights reflect in the front glass, setting a cozy glow over the counter.
The layout keeps movement flowing, which helps when the afternoon rush hits.
You leave with a box that feels like a small art project and a grin that lasts until dinner.
4. Veniero’s Pasticceria & Caffé, 342 E 11th St, New York, NY 10003
Veniero’s Pasticceria & Caffé glows with old New York charm, from stained glass details to patterned tile floors.
The space invites a pause as you scan long cases filled with cookies and pastries that span decades of tradition.
It feels like a sweet museum where everything is meant to be taken home.
Holiday butter cookies come dusted with red and green sprinkles that catch the light just right.
The bite lands crisp at first then softens with a buttery finish that keeps you reaching for another.
Order by the pound and let the staff guide the mix for a balanced tray.
Beyond sprinkles, look for rainbow cookies, jam-filled thumbprints, and sesame-studded reginelle that add texture.
Each style brings a different note, so variety keeps the platter lively for guests.
Boxes stack neatly for subway rides across Manhattan.
Service moves with practiced ease, and you will hear regulars order in quick shorthand.
The team handles holiday surges with steady patience and clear direction.
It keeps the line moving without losing the friendly touch that locals love.
The East Village location sits close to several train lines, which simplifies multi-stop holiday errands.
New York winter days grow dark early, and the neon sign becomes a beacon from down the block.
You step back outside with a warm box and a plan to share, then immediately recheck your share plan.
5. William Greenberg Desserts, 1100 Madison Ave, New York, NY 10028
William Greenberg Desserts holds court on Madison Avenue with a crisp storefront and steady Upper East Side foot traffic.
The counter shines with neat rows that show a love for symmetry and classic style.
You walk in for one box and quickly realize a second box might be wiser.
The holiday showstopper is the Red and Green Black & White Cookie, which flips a New York icon into seasonal colors.
The icing sets glossy with clean lines, and the cake base holds a tender crumb that feels balanced.
It tastes familiar yet festive, which is exactly what December calls for.
Linzer tarts appear in smart shapes with bright jam that pops through powdered sugar.
They pack beautifully, and the tart note plays well after a rich meal.
Ask for a mixed box if you want a ready-made gift that looks like a ribbon should be tied on top.
Staff keeps conversation quick and friendly while handling repeat orders from neighborhood regulars.
The line flows at a calm pace and never loses its cheer.
It feels like a small holiday play where every cue hits on time.
New York visitors will appreciate how close the shop sits to Central Park for a scenic stroll.
The location makes a convenient stop between museums and lights on Fifth Avenue.
You leave the shop already planning who gets the first cookie and who will never know a second one existed.
6. Maman, 237 Centre St, New York, NY 10013
Maman on Centre Street mixes rustic French charm with New York energy in a space that feels both cozy and photogenic.
Blue and white patterns run through the decor and make even a quick stop feel special.
You walk in and notice calm music, warm lighting, and friendly greetings from the counter.
The bakery is famous for nutty chocolate chip cookies, and the holiday season adds beautiful Gift Boxes that travel well.
You can ask for a curated selection that highlights seasonal flavors alongside the signature staple.
The packaging looks ready for photos and holds up on a crowded subway ride.
During December, greenery and subtle ornaments frame the seating area with gentle color.
The cafe makes a relaxing pause between downtown errands, and the staff keeps the line moving.
You will likely spot office groups collecting boxes for team celebrations.
If you are planning a cookie crawl, Maman works nicely as the midday stop for a coffee and regroup.
The space breathes, with enough seating to take a beat and map the next move.
New York crowds ebb and flow, and this room helps you reset before diving back in.
Ask about shipping timelines if you want gifts sent around New York State or beyond.
The team can share cutoffs and box sizes so your holiday plans stay on track.
You leave feeling like you checked several things off the list with one calm visit.
7. Breads Bakery, 18 E 16th St, New York, NY 10003
Breads Bakery by Union Square offers a bright counter and a steady rhythm that keeps lines moving smoothly.
The team bakes throughout the day, so shelves look refreshed rather than picked over.
You step inside and feel the warm blast of an oven working overtime in winter.
The shop is famous for babka, yet holiday fans come for the Cookie Tins that showcase Linzer and Matcha shortbread.
The tin opens like a small gift with neat rows and a beautiful scent that hints at spice and butter.
It is a dependable option for hosts who like clean presentation and flavor balance.
Weekday mornings deliver the calmest experience, while late afternoons draw shoppers from the market.
Staff will guide you to tins that travel best and explain storage for peak texture.
The advice pays off when you open the tin after a long day and the snap still sings.
Seating is limited but helpful for a quick coffee and a plan.
New York winter light falls early on East 16th Street, and the window glow makes a comfortable pause.
It is easy to get swept into a second purchase before you step back out.
For gifting across New York State, ask about shipping or same-day courier within the city.
The packaging is sturdy and helps keep cookies in neat formation on the move.
You leave with a tin that feels like a sure bet for any celebration on the calendar.
8. Martha’s Country Bakery, 175 Bedford Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11211
Martha’s Country Bakery brings a welcoming glow to Bedford Avenue with long hours and a neighborhood buzz.
The space invites lingering with comfortable seating and a friendly staff that keeps things upbeat.
You step up to the display and find a colorful spread that fits the season.
Holiday-themed sugar cookies and ginger snaps anchor the December lineup with nostalgic charm.
The cookies hit that sweet spot where decoration meets a clean, balanced bite.
It is the kind of tray that disappears quickly at gatherings without much conversation left over.
Lines form in the evening as friends meet for dessert after dinner nearby.
If you want a quicker visit, late morning often feels calmer and just as joyful.
The staff stays patient and organized, which helps first-timers feel at ease.
Williamsburg gives you plenty to pair with the stop, from shops to waterfront views within a short walk.
New York winter nights bring twinkling lights to the avenue, and the bakery fits right into that mood.
The room buzzes in a way that makes a second round of cookies easy to justify.
For gift giving, ask for box dividers to keep designs intact during travel around the city.
Boxes fit well in a backpack if placed upright, which is useful on the L train.
You leave with the sense that holiday plans are coming together piece by piece.
9. Librae Bakery, 35 Cooper Sq, New York, NY 10003
Librae Bakery brings a fresh voice to Cooper Square with a bright corner space and a relaxed soundtrack.
The design leans minimal and warm, encouraging calm in the middle of downtown movement.
You feel welcomed by staff who offer smart guidance without a hard sell.
Cookie lovers should look for Strawberry Sumac Linzers and Chai shortbread when the holidays arrive.
The flavors deliver gentle spice and citrus notes that stay balanced rather than bold.
Each bite reveals a thoughtful approach that rewards slow tasting.
This is a bakery where ingredients matter and textures get careful attention.
The linzers hold shape with a tender crumb and a clean cut that keeps boxes tidy.
Shortbread rounds land sandy and aromatic, which makes them perfect with a quiet cup of tea.
Seating runs limited, but the windows provide a pleasant perch for a quick break.
New York streets flow past like a moving postcard while you catch your breath. It is a light-filled pause that resets the day before the next errand.
Ask about availability since small batch runs can sell through late in the day.
The staff can suggest alternatives that keep the same spirit if a flavor rotates out.
You leave with a bag that feels curated and a plan to return for another thoughtful box.
10. Petee’s Pie Company, 61 Delancey St, New York, NY 10002
Petee’s Pie Company is a pie shop first, yet the cookie counter earns attention during the holidays.
The Lower East Side shop glows softly at night and feels like a neighborhood secret that everyone knows.
You walk in and notice the gentle hum of conversation that fits the cozy room.
Shortbread and ginger cookies step forward in December with shapes that look ready for a gift box.
The shortbread brings a clean butter profile and a crisp edge that softens as it warms in hand.
Ginger rounds carry spice in a steady arc rather than a heavy hit.
If you need a small but thoughtful present, ask for a tidy box with a simple ribbon.
The staff packs neatly and offers quick suggestions for a balanced mix.
The cookies hold up well on the train, which makes last-minute gifting stress-free.
Seating is limited, so plan for a quick stop or a stroll to nearby parks if weather holds.
New York nights feel cinematic on Delancey Street when the lights reflect off the pavement.
It is a nice moment to enjoy a cookie before heading to the next stop.
The team posts holiday hours ahead of time, and it helps to check before a late visit.
Popular items can sell out near closing, so earlier trips are wiser for the best pick.
You leave with a simple box and the sense that little details can make the season shine.
Dear Reader: This page may contain affiliate links which may earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase. Our independent journalism is not influenced by any advertiser or commercial initiative unless it is clearly marked as sponsored content. As travel products change, please be sure to reconfirm all details and stay up to date with current events to ensure a safe and successful trip.
