Ah, the Florida Keys: a paradise where the sunsets are painted with every shade of pink and orange you can imagine. But what’s a trip to this tropical wonderland without sinking your teeth into a glorious grouper sandwich? Let me take you on a taste adventure through the ten best cafes in the Keys that’ve mastered this culinary masterpiece.
1. Square Grouper – Islamorada
Strolling into Square Grouper in Islamorada feels like entering a laid-back island paradise. The staff greets you with a smile that suggests they know the secret to a perfect grouper sandwich. And they do. Imagine the freshest, flakiest grouper nestled in a toasted bun with just the right amount of crispiness.
Their secret? A tangy remoulade that ties the whole creation together. It’s a sandwich so good, you might just consider moving nearby to have it every day. The ambiance here is equally compelling, with tropical decor that could make even a turtle want to shake a tail feather.
Fun fact: This spot is named after the Square Grouper fish, which got its quirky name from bales of marijuana that would wash ashore in the 1980s. A nod to history with a side of humor!
2. Key Largo Fisheries Backyard Café
Tucked away in Key Largo, the Fisheries Backyard Café is a hidden gem. It’s the kind of place where locals and savvy travelers gather to discuss the island’s secrets over grouper sandwiches. The fish is freshly caught, grilled to perfection, and served with a casual flair that makes it all the more satisfying.
The cafe offers an authentic Keys experience, with a rustic setting that lets the fresh ocean breeze do the talking. Sometimes, simplicity is key, and their grouper sandwich is proof that less is more.
The history here is as rich as the flavors. Starting as a wholesale fish market, it evolved into a beloved eatery. Don’t miss the chance to chat with the fishermen who might just have caught your lunch!
3. B.O.’s Fish Wagon
Welcome to B.O.’s Fish Wagon, where the charm of Key West is as palpable as the grouper sandwich is delightful. Imagine a place that embraces its quirkiness: rustic decor, mismatched chairs, and a vibe that says, “Come as you are.” That’s B.O.’s.
Their grouper sandwich is as unique as the venue itself. Served on fresh Cuban bread, it’s a crispy, juicy marvel that reflects the creativity of Key West. The secret sauce adds a zing that’ll make you want to dance.
Legend has it, this spot started as a mobile wagon and became a stationary delight due to its overwhelming popularity. Who knew a sandwich could have such a journey?
4. Lazy Days Restaurant
At Lazy Days in Islamorada, the motto is simple: relax and enjoy. Overlooking the azure waters, this place offers a slice of paradise with every bite of their grouper sandwich. It’s a beach lover’s dream come true.
The expertly grilled grouper, topped with a medley of fresh vegetables, is a testament to their dedication to quality. Pair this with their beachfront seating and you’ve got a recipe for bliss.
This spot has been a staple for both locals and tourists alike, drawing visitors with its promise of relaxation and delectable dishes. They say you can taste love in food, and here, it’s abundantly clear.
5. Hobo’s Café
Hobo’s Café in Key Largo isn’t just a restaurant; it’s an institution. Known for its welcoming atmosphere, this place serves grouper sandwiches that have a cult following. The moment you walk in, you’re treated like family.
Their sandwich is an ode to the ocean’s bounty. The fish is marinated in a secret blend of spices, giving it a flavor that lingers long after the last bite. The atmosphere is as warm as the Florida sun, making it a perfect pit stop on your Keys adventure.
Did you know? Hobo’s started as a small barbecue joint before becoming the seafood haven it is today. It’s a testament to how greatness can grow from humble beginnings.
6. The Square Grouper – Key West
Nestled in Key West, The Square Grouper offers a gourmet twist on the classic sandwich. This isn’t just a meal; it’s a culinary experience that elevates the humble grouper to an art form. The presentation is as refined as the flavors are robust.
The sandwich itself features perfectly seared grouper, complemented by a house-made aioli that adds a touch of elegance. It’s a dish that whispers sophistication with every bite.
In a city known for its artistic flair, The Square Grouper stands out, offering a dining experience as memorable as a sunset over the ocean. Discovering this gem feels like finding a pearl in an oyster.
7. Captain Craig’s Restaurant
In the heart of Islamorada, Captain Craig’s Restaurant serves grouper sandwiches with a side of nautical charm. The decor is a delightful nod to the sea, with maritime memorabilia adorning the walls.
Their sandwich is a classic, with the grouper fried to a golden perfection and served with a zesty slaw. It’s comfort food at its finest, capturing the spirit of the sea with every bite.
Captain Craig’s is more than just a restaurant; it’s a testament to the love of all things maritime. For those seeking a taste of the ocean’s bounty in a setting that celebrates the seafaring life, this is the place.
8. Fisherman’s Café
In the bustling streets of Key West, Fisherman’s Café offers an escape to flavor town. Their grouper sandwich is a star attraction, crafted with fish caught that very morning. Freshness is more than a promise here; it’s a guarantee.
The sandwich is lovingly prepared, with the grouper coated in a light batter and fried to perfection. Served with a side of island charm, it’s a dish that encapsulates the spirit of the Keys.
Did you know? This cafe is located near the historic seaport, adding a layer of history to your culinary experience. It’s where taste meets tradition.
9. Keys Fisheries Restaurant & Market
Keys Fisheries in Key Largo is both a restaurant and a seafood market, ensuring the freshest catch for your grouper sandwich. The lively atmosphere is infectious, making it a favorite among locals and visitors alike.
Their sandwich is a marvel; a testament to the quality and freshness of their seafood. The grouper is grilled to perfection, served on a fluffy bun with a secret sauce that adds a zing.
The market aspect of Keys Fisheries allows diners to witness the journey from sea to plate. It’s an experience that’s as educational as it is delicious.
10. Stingray’s Seafood
Stingray’s Seafood, just a stone’s throw from Key West, is where laid-back vibes meet culinary excellence. Their grouper sandwich is a celebrated dish, known for its fresh ingredients and vibrant flavors.
The fish is expertly blackened, creating a beautiful contrast of textures and flavors. Served with a lively side salad, it’s a well-rounded meal that leaves nothing to be desired.
This spot celebrates the joy of dining by the sea, where the air is salty, and the experience is unforgettable. It’s a place where every meal feels like a celebration of the ocean’s bounty.
Dear Reader: This page may contain affiliate links which may earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase. Our independent journalism is not influenced by any advertiser or commercial initiative unless it is clearly marked as sponsored content. As travel products change, please be sure to reconfirm all details and stay up to date with current events to ensure a safe and successful trip.
