Explore eight unique pizzerias across Florida that bring the authentic taste of Naples to the Sunshine State.
From Miami to Jacksonville, these pizzerias are celebrated for their dedication to traditional Neapolitan techniques, quality ingredients, and creative flair. Each offers a distinct atmosphere and a slice that transports you straight to Italy.
1. Mister O1 Extraordinary Pizza (Miami & beyond)
Mister O1 Extraordinary Pizza began as a hidden gem in Miami and has blossomed into a beloved chain across South Florida. Known for its innovative “star-shaped” pizzas, this pizzeria fuses Neapolitan tradition with Miami’s vibrant culinary scene. The ultra-thin artisan pies are topped with creative combinations, making each bite a delightful surprise.
With multiple locations now open, Mister O1 maintains a reputation for quality and inventiveness that keeps pizza enthusiasts coming back. Whether you’re a local or a visitor, the unique presentation and flavor of these pizzas offer a memorable dining experience.
A visit to Mister O1 is not just a meal, but a culinary adventure that captures the essence of Naples with a Miami twist.
2. Pizza Bruno (Orlando)
Pizza Bruno in Orlando offers a distinctive take on Neapolitan pizza, celebrated for its wood-fired, blistered crusts and inventive toppings. The flagship location on Curry Ford Road remains a cornerstone in the Orlando pizza scene, drawing fans for its craft pies and welcoming vibe.
Each pizza here is a canvas for creativity, with options that surprise and satisfy discerning palates. From classic Margheritas to more adventurous flavors, Pizza Bruno ensures a delightful taste journey.
This pizzeria’s commitment to quality and community creates an inviting spot where friends gather to enjoy a slice of Naples with a unique Orlando flair.
3. Nomad Pizza (Jacksonville)
Nomad Pizza in Jacksonville is a cherished local favorite, offering handcrafted pizzas with a focus on quality ingredients and balanced flavors. This neighborhood gem provides a cozy atmosphere where families and pizza lovers come to enjoy a meal that feels both familiar and special.
The pizzas are crafted with care, showcasing a dedication to tradition and a love for good food. Whether opting for a classic option or a more inventive choice, each pizza promises a delicious experience.
Nomad Pizza stands out for its charming ambience and commitment to delivering a taste of Naples to Jacksonville, one slice at a time.
4. Andiamo! Brick Oven Pizza (Miami)
Located inside a converted 1950s gas station, Andiamo! Brick Oven Pizza is a Miami institution known for its lively atmosphere and delicious pies. The thin-crust pizzas, with a slight char, are piled high with fresh toppings and best enjoyed on the bustling outdoor patio.
The unique setting adds an element of nostalgia and charm, making each visit a memorable experience. Whether you’re drawn by the vibrant scene or the irresistible aroma of baking dough, Andiamo! captures Miami’s spirit with every slice.
This pizzeria not only delivers on flavor but also offers a taste of local history with its one-of-a-kind location.
5. Paulie Gee’s (Miami)
Paulie Gee’s brings a touch of Brooklyn to Miami, specializing in wood-fired pizzas that boast inventive toppings and classic flavors. Known for its honey-drizzled hot soppressata and traditional Margheritas, this pizzeria delights with every slice.
The modern setting offers a chic backdrop for enjoying these culinary creations, where the art of pizza making is celebrated in each bite. Paulie Gee’s Miami outpost maintains the wood-fired tradition and adds its own twist to the classic Neapolitan style.
Experience a harmonious blend of creativity and tradition that makes Paulie Gee’s a standout in Miami’s vibrant dining scene.
6. Anthony’s Coal Fired Pizza (multiple Florida locations)
Anthony’s Coal Fired Pizza has become synonymous with quality coal-fired pies across Florida, known for their crisp, smoky crusts and hearty toppings. With various locations, this pizzeria offers a consistent dining experience that appeals to those seeking a satisfying, casual meal.
The coal-fired method imparts a distinctive flavor, setting Anthony’s apart from other pizza options. Whether dining in or taking it to-go, these pizzas promise a taste of Naples with a unique twist.
Anthony’s commitment to quality and flavor makes it a go-to destination for pizza lovers seeking a hearty and flavorful slice, no matter where they are in Florida.
7. Pizzeria Del Dio (Orlando)
Pizzeria Del Dio is a hidden gem in Orlando, offering hand-tossed pizzas that bring a touch of New York to the Sunshine State. Known for its generous portions and rich flavors, this pizzeria has become a local favorite for those craving a traditional slice.
The cozy environment invites guests to relax and enjoy a meal reminiscent of classic pizzerias. Each pizza is crafted with care, ensuring a delicious experience with every bite.
Pizzeria Del Dio stands out for its commitment to quality and its ability to transport diners with its authentic taste and welcoming atmosphere.
8. V Pizza (Jacksonville & St. Augustine)
V Pizza has carved a niche in North Florida with its authentic Neapolitan pizzas, baked in wood-fired ovens imported directly from Italy. With locations in Jacksonville and St. Augustine, it offers a slice of Italy with every bite.
The pizzas are known for their quality ingredients and consistent flavors, earning a loyal following among locals and visitors alike. The welcoming settings provide an inviting space to enjoy these Italian delights.
V Pizza’s commitment to authenticity and quality makes it a standout choice for those seeking a genuine taste of Naples in Florida.
Dear Reader: This page may contain affiliate links which may earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase. Our independent journalism is not influenced by any advertiser or commercial initiative unless it is clearly marked as sponsored content. As travel products change, please be sure to reconfirm all details and stay up to date with current events to ensure a safe and successful trip.
