If you’re looking for a stay that feels more like a storybook than a hotel, The Roxbury in the Catskills might just be your dream destination. From emerald wizard rooms to superhero hideouts, guests say it’s one of New York’s most imaginative places to stay – though not without a few quirks. This contemporary lodging experience has travelers raving about its creativity and charm, making it a must-visit for anyone seeking something beyond the ordinary.
Why The Roxbury Still Tops Traveler Wishlists
Despite minor drawbacks, The Roxbury remains wildly popular for good reason. Its creativity and charm simply can’t be replicated anywhere else. Travelers seeking something beyond cookie-cutter hotels find exactly what they’re looking for here – an experience that sparks joy and creates unforgettable memories.
The combination of themed rooms, private spa experiences, and beautiful Catskills scenery outweighs breakfast limitations. Most guests agree that staying somewhere this unique is worth planning meals elsewhere. What matters most is the sheer delight of sleeping in a fantasy world.
Reviews consistently end with “worth the trip” sentiments. People leave already planning return visits, often wanting to try different themed rooms. For anyone craving magic, nostalgia, and pure imagination in their travels, The Roxbury delivers an experience that justifies every bit of its wild reputation.
A Hotel That Feels Straight Out of a Fairytale
Imagine stepping into a world where pop culture meets fantasy, and every corner tells a story. The Roxbury transforms the typical hotel experience into something truly magical. Located in the peaceful Catskills, this lodging blends art, imagination, and nostalgia into one unforgettable escape.
Travelers describe it as a place where childhood dreams come alive. Each element has been carefully crafted to transport guests into different worlds. Whether you’re a fan of classic movies or fairy tales, there’s something here that will spark your imagination.
What makes The Roxbury special is its commitment to immersive experiences. Unlike chain hotels with identical rooms, every space here offers a unique adventure. Guests often say they’ve never stayed anywhere quite like it, and that’s exactly the point.
The Themed Rooms Everyone’s Talking About
Rooms like “Wizard’s Emeralds” and “Superhero Incognito” cottage have become legendary among travelers. One guest wrote, “It’s like staying inside a movie set!” The attention to detail is remarkable, from custom furniture to themed décor that covers every inch.
Many visitors say the photos don’t do justice to how impressive these spaces really are. The Wizard’s Emeralds suite features shimmering green accents and magical touches that make you feel like you’ve entered Oz. Meanwhile, the Superhero cottage offers a playful hideout vibe with comic book elements throughout.
Families and couples alike appreciate how each room tells its own story. Kids especially love exploring all the hidden details and surprises. These aren’t just places to sleep – they’re experiences that create lasting memories and countless photo opportunities.
From Spa Retreat to Fantasy Escape
The Shimmer Spa and Crooked Cabana Spa offer private bookings that guests absolutely adore. Couples especially rave about having hot tubs, saunas, and steam rooms all to themselves. It’s the perfect blend of relaxation and fantasy that makes romantic getaways extra special.
Privacy is key here – you won’t be sharing space with strangers. Many reviews mention how this intimate setting helped them truly unwind and reconnect. The spa facilities are maintained beautifully, with the same creative touches found throughout the property.
Booking a spa session adds another layer to your Roxbury experience. After exploring the Catskills trails or nearby attractions, returning to your private spa feels incredibly luxurious. Travelers consistently mention this as a highlight worth every penny of their stay.
The Magic of the Catskills Setting
Nestled in the peaceful Catskills mountains, The Roxbury benefits from truly breathtaking surroundings. Fresh mountain air, towering trees, and nearby Stratton Falls create the perfect backdrop for a fantasy escape. Nature lovers find this location ideal for combining outdoor adventures with unique accommodations.
The waterfall and hiking trails offer excellent day-trip opportunities. Guests appreciate being able to disconnect from city life while still enjoying modern comforts. Morning coffee on your themed balcony overlooking the mountains becomes a cherished daily ritual.
This setting enhances the magical atmosphere inside the hotel. When you’re surrounded by natural beauty, the fantasy elements feel even more enchanting. Many travelers say the location itself is worth the trip, with the creative rooms being an incredible bonus that makes their stay truly unforgettable.
Clean, Cozy, and Carefully Designed
Cleanliness receives consistent praise from Roxbury guests. Travelers note that rooms look exactly like the photos – or even better in person. The housekeeping team maintains high standards, ensuring every fantasy element stays pristine and inviting throughout your visit.
Comfort hasn’t been sacrificed for creativity. Beds are plush, linens are quality, and amenities work perfectly. Guests appreciate that while the décor is playful, the practical aspects of hospitality are taken seriously.
Attention to detail extends beyond just theme elements. Corners are dust-free, bathrooms sparkle, and everything feels well-maintained. Many reviews specifically mention being impressed by how immaculate their rooms were. For travelers worried that quirky means messy, The Roxbury proves you can have both imagination and impeccable standards working together beautifully.
Service That Feels Personal and Genuine
Staff members at The Roxbury frequently appear in glowing reviews, often mentioned by name. Guests describe them as genuinely warm and helpful, not just going through corporate motions. This personal touch makes visitors feel like welcomed friends rather than room numbers.
Local recommendations are a specialty here. Staff members know the best nearby restaurants, hidden hiking spots, and seasonal attractions. Their insider knowledge helps travelers make the most of their Catskills adventure beyond the hotel itself.
Responsiveness stands out as another strength. When guests have questions or need assistance, help arrives quickly and cheerfully. This combination of friendliness and efficiency creates an atmosphere where people feel truly cared for. Many travelers mention the exceptional service as a reason they’d return to The Roxbury again.
But Let’s Talk About That Breakfast…
Honesty time: breakfast is The Roxbury’s most common complaint. The continental offering consists mainly of prepackaged pastries and coffee, which doesn’t match the creativity found elsewhere. Many guests express disappointment after experiencing such imaginative rooms only to find basic morning fare.
Travelers frequently choose to eat breakfast elsewhere instead. Local diners and cafes become popular alternatives for those seeking heartier morning meals. While convenient, the limited selection feels like a missed opportunity for a property otherwise known for going above and beyond.
This isn’t a dealbreaker for most visitors, but it’s worth knowing beforehand. Setting proper expectations helps avoid morning disappointment. Several reviews suggest management could elevate the entire experience by improving this one aspect of their otherwise magical hospitality.
Charming and Eccentric Rooms
Stepping into one of the hotel’s rooms feels like entering a whimsical world of its own. Each room is a patchwork of colors, with eclectic furniture and creatively mismatched decor. Guests are often surprised by delightful oddities like a clawfoot bathtub in the center or a vintage record player by the window.
Though some might find the design choices bold, others appreciate the artistic flair. Minor issues like a creaky floorboard or a flickering light are quickly addressed by attentive staff. The uniqueness of each room ensures memories that guests cherish long after their stay.
Dear Reader: This page may contain affiliate links which may earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase. Our independent journalism is not influenced by any advertiser or commercial initiative unless it is clearly marked as sponsored content. As travel products change, please be sure to reconfirm all details and stay up to date with current events to ensure a safe and successful trip.
