Florida isn’t all sunshine and beaches; it harbors some ghostly secrets too! Join me on a spine-chilling culinary journey through ten haunted island eateries.
Each spot serves a side of paranormal with its menu, perfect for those who enjoy a dash of mystery with their meal. Let’s see who’s brave enough to dine with the spirits.
1. First Flight Island Restaurant & Brewery
If you’ve ever wanted your dinner served with a side of ghostly intrigue, First Flight Island Restaurant & Brewery is your spot. Once the bustling Pan Am ticket office, this place now offers more than just craft beer. Cleo Musick, the unfortunate wife of a pilot lost to the skies, is said to linger here. Her loyal spirit awaits her beloved, creating a sense of timeless yearning.
But Cleo isn’t alone. A spectral man in a zoot suit is rumored to make unexpected appearances. He adds a dash of vintage flair to the hauntings. And let’s not forget the mysterious “supervisor” ghost, ensuring everything runs ghostly smooth.
Dining here is like stepping back into a bygone era, where the past never truly lets go. The whispers of history are almost tangible, making your meal an unforgettable experience. Just be sure to save room for dessert, as you might have a supernatural dining companion!
2. Captain Tony’s Saloon
Picture this: enjoying a drink in a saloon that used to be a city morgue. That’s Captain Tony’s Saloon for you, a place where the air is as thick with history as it is with hauntings. This joint, famous for its hanging tree of yore, might just send a shiver down your spine.
The “Lady in Blue,” a spectral figure from a notorious execution, is the star of the ghostly show. Her presence is as palpable as the cold spots reported by visitors. It’s not uncommon to feel a sudden chill when she’s around.
Pirates and phantoms both make appearances here, adding to the rich tapestry of tales. Whether you’re there for the spirits of the drinkable kind or the ghostly ones, Captain Tony’s is an adventure in itself. Just watch where you step; you might be treading on history!
3. Hard Rock Cafe
Nestled in a building with a storied past, Key West’s Hard Rock Cafe is more than just rock memorabilia. Robert Curry, the restless spirit who never quite left, might just wander by and say hello. Though he met his end in New York, his ghostly whispers are still heard here.
The ornate staircase is a particular hotspot for ghost sightings. Visitors often sense an otherworldly presence, as if eyes are watching them from beyond. The kitchen and office are also known for strange happenings, keeping staff on their toes.
Dining here is a rock ‘n’ roll experience with a twist of the supernatural. Who knows, you might just leave with more than a souvenir T-shirt. Keep your senses sharp, as the echoes of history might play a tune just for you.
4. Old Town Tavern
Old Town Tavern is where history takes a ghostly turn. Once a simple furniture store, it now serves up some of Key West’s finest ghost stories. Renowned playwright Tennessee Williams himself claimed to have seen a pirate storming out of the backroom.
The taps here have a mind of their own, often turning on after closing. This mischievous spirit seems to enjoy keeping the owners guessing. It’s as if the ghosts are still keen to join the revelry.
Here, the past mingles with the present in the most delightful way. Each visit offers a glimpse into a different era, where the spirits are just as lively as the patrons. Don’t be surprised if you find yourself sharing a toast with a friendly phantom!
5. Island Hotel & Restaurant
The Island Hotel & Restaurant in Cedar Key is a timeless treasure. Built in 1859, this place is steeped in history and ghostly gossip. Its dining room is not just a feast for the senses but a playground for the paranormal.
Local legend has it that several resident spirits call this place home. They add a touch of mystery to the already charming ambiance. Diners often report unusual phenomena, from cold spots to unexplained sounds.
A visit here is like stepping into another world. The blend of historical elegance and supernatural intrigue creates a dining experience that is truly one-of-a-kind. Who wouldn’t want a side of mystery with their meal?
6. The Blue Anchor British Pub
Transported from 19th-century London, The Blue Anchor British Pub in Delray Beach is a haunt in every sense. This pub has stories that could fill an entire library, most notably, the tale of Bertha.
Bertha, a spirit with a penchant for mischief, makes her presence known with flying mugs and sudden chills. Her tragic story adds a layer of melancholy to the pub’s lively atmosphere.
The charm of an old-world pub combined with spectral surprises makes for an unforgettable visit. Each corner seems to hold a secret, waiting to be uncovered. So grab a seat and perhaps a ghostly companion will join you!
7. The Veranda
In the heart of Fort Myers, The Veranda is a blend of Southern charm and supernatural allure. This century-old establishment is home to a spectral resident who seems to enjoy the ambiance as much as the patrons do.
Stories of ghostly encounters often center around the main dining room. The friendly ghost here seems more like a gracious host than a haunting presence. Diners often feel a gentle breeze or catch a glimpse of a figure out of the corner of their eye.
It’s a place where the past is very much alive, offering a dining experience like no other. The blend of elegance and mystery creates an atmosphere that draws you in and keeps you enchanted. A meal here is more than just food; it’s a journey into history.
8. Gator Club
Gator Club in Sarasota is where history and hauntings go hand in hand. With a past steeped in bootlegging and more, it’s no wonder this place has its fair share of ghost stories.
Long-time staff and patrons alike have recounted tales of spectral apparitions. From flappers to bootleggers, it seems the party never truly ended here. The echoes of laughter and music from days gone by still resonate.
It’s a slice of history with a twist of the paranormal, making every visit a thrill. Whether you’re there for the music or the ghosts, Gator Club promises an adventure like no other. Just be prepared for an encounter with the other side!
9. Tween Waters Inn & Marina
Perched on Captiva Island, Tween Waters Inn & Marina is more than just a picturesque getaway. It’s a place where ghost stories have become part of the lore, with the restaurant and marina sharing in the spooky tales.
Longtime visitors have reported ghostly figures wandering the property. These spirits seem to enjoy the laid-back island vibe just as much as the living guests do.
Staying here is like stepping into a storybook, with every corner holding a piece of history. The mix of natural beauty and supernatural intrigue makes for an unforgettable visit. It’s a place where the past and present dance together in perfect harmony.
10. Ashley’s of Rockledge
Ashley’s of Rockledge is as charming as it is chilling. This Tudor-style restaurant holds the tragic tale of Ethel Allen, whose spirit is said to linger on the premises.
Visitors often report flickering lights and unexplained alarms, particularly around the women’s restroom. Ethel’s presence is both eerie and enchanting, adding a touch of mystery to the dining experience.
Dining here is like stepping into a chapter of a ghost story. The blend of vintage charm and spectral whispers creates an ambiance that’s both inviting and intriguing. It’s a place where the past is as alive as the present.
Dear Reader: This page may contain affiliate links which may earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase. Our independent journalism is not influenced by any advertiser or commercial initiative unless it is clearly marked as sponsored content. As travel products change, please be sure to reconfirm all details and stay up to date with current events to ensure a safe and successful trip.
