Indiana hides some amazing all-you-can-eat treasures that only true Hoosiers seem to know about. Beyond the chain restaurants and tourist spots, local buffets serve up home-style cooking, authentic international flavors, and Midwest hospitality that can’t be beat. These hidden gems offer generous portions, fair prices, and dishes made with recipes passed down through generations.
1. Stoll’s Lakeview Restaurant – Loogootee, IN
Located at 15519 US-231, Stoll’s Lakeview Restaurant is a beloved spot in Loogootee, offering hearty Amish and American buffet fare with a focus on home-cooked goodness. Overlooking a peaceful lake, the restaurant provides a scenic and relaxed setting ideal for a family meal or quiet dinner.
Diners can expect classics like crispy fried chicken, creamy mashed potatoes, homemade noodles, fresh vegetables, and a generous selection of pies and desserts. The buffet is consistently praised for its freshness and variety, with many items made from scratch using traditional recipes.
What truly enhances the experience is the welcoming and efficient service – staff are friendly, helpful, and attentive without being intrusive. While the restaurant is closed on Sundays, it operates throughout the week with varying hours. If you’re looking to enjoy a comforting, down-home meal in a warm and inviting atmosphere, Stoll’s Lakeview Restaurant is a destination worth the drive.
2. Paradise Buffet – Auburn, IN
Paradise Buffet, located at 1411 Shook Drive in Auburn, is a well-loved destination for buffet-style dining in Northern Indiana. Known for its wide variety of Chinese dishes, the restaurant also offers a sushi bar and a grill station where food is cooked fresh to order.
The layout is clean and spacious, making it comfortable for families, large groups, or solo diners. Guests often comment on the freshness of the food, the steady replenishment of buffet items, and the friendly, attentive service.
The staff is quick to clear plates and answer questions, helping create a relaxed and enjoyable dining experience. While the restaurant is closed on Mondays, it maintains steady traffic throughout the rest of the week, a testament to its popularity with locals and travelers alike. Whether you’re in the mood for classic lo mein, freshly made sushi, or grilled meats and vegetables, Paradise Buffet delivers reliable flavor and good service.
3. India Sizzling – Fishers, IN
India Sizzling Fishers, located at 11301 Village Square Lane in Fishers, offers an exceptional buffet experience focused on authentic Indian cuisine.
Featuring a rotating variety of flavorful dishes such as chicken tikka masala, palak paneer, samosas, naan, and basmati rice, the buffet caters to both vegetarians and meat lovers. Guests frequently mention the freshness of the food, balanced spices, and the satisfying range of traditional Indian flavors.
The interior is clean and welcoming, with a relaxed atmosphere that suits both casual and special outings. The staff is known for being polite, helpful, and attentive, ensuring that diners have a pleasant experience. Closed on Mondays, India Sizzling Fishers is a local favorite for those seeking rich, aromatic dishes and consistently good service in a comfortable setting.
4. Daily Buffet & Grill – Indianapolis, IN
Located at 9701 East Washington Street in Indianapolis, Daily Buffet & Grill is a spacious and modern buffet restaurant offering a wide variety of Chinese dishes, fresh sushi, and Japanese hibachi options. The buffet is open daily, making it a convenient stop for locals and travelers looking for a satisfying and affordable meal.
One of the restaurant’s highlights is its hibachi grill, where guests can select fresh ingredients and watch as they are cooked to order. The buffet line is well-stocked and includes everything from egg rolls and dumplings to seafood, stir-fries, and desserts.
Cleanliness and food quality are consistent, with many guests noting how frequently items are refreshed. The staff provides efficient and courteous service, maintaining a clean dining area and responding promptly to guest needs. With its large seating capacity and wide range of offerings, Daily Buffet & Grill delivers a reliable buffet experience that suits a variety of tastes.
5. MCL Restaurant & Bakery – Indianapolis, IN
MCL Restaurant & Bakery is a long-standing Indiana institution, offering cafeteria-style dining with the comfort of a traditional buffet. Founded in 1950, this family-owned chain remains a favorite in Indianapolis and surrounding cities.
The menu features home-cooked classics like roasted turkey with dressing, fried chicken, mashed potatoes, macaroni and cheese, and seasonal vegetables. Each meal concludes perfectly with MCL’s famous homemade pies, cobblers, and cakes baked fresh daily. Guests enjoy the flexibility to build their own plates while still experiencing the generosity of a buffet meal.
MCL is praised for its cleanliness, friendly service, and steady quality through the decades. Its nostalgic atmosphere makes it especially popular among families and longtime Hoosiers who appreciate genuine Midwestern comfort food. While not an all-you-can-eat buffet, MCL captures the same spirit of abundance and home-style cooking that defines Indiana’s best dining traditions.
6. Tokyo Grill & Sushi Buffet – Bloomington, IN
Tokyo Grill & Sushi Buffet in Bloomington remains one of southern Indiana’s best all-you-can-eat Japanese buffets. Located on College Mall Road, it offers an impressive variety of fresh sushi, hibachi dishes, and hot entrées inspired by Chinese and Japanese cuisine.
The sushi bar features neatly prepared rolls made throughout the day, while the grill station allows guests to customize their meal with fresh meats, seafood, and vegetables. The restaurant’s cleanliness, attentive staff, and well-maintained buffet area consistently earn positive reviews. Families appreciate the reasonable pricing and relaxed atmosphere, making it suitable for both casual lunches and group dinners.
The menu changes slightly with the seasons to incorporate fresh ingredients, keeping repeat visits interesting. With its wide variety and reliable quality, Tokyo Grill & Sushi Buffet continues to be a favorite dining destination for locals and visiting students from Indiana University.
Dear Reader: This page may contain affiliate links which may earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase. Our independent journalism is not influenced by any advertiser or commercial initiative unless it is clearly marked as sponsored content. As travel products change, please be sure to reconfirm all details and stay up to date with current events to ensure a safe and successful trip.
