Beneath towering pines and mirrored waters, Wisconsin’s North Woods invites slow evenings and savory traditions. Hidden in this lakeside tapestry, the Maiden Lake Supper Club feels like a secret you’re thrilled to share – run by the Dinkelman family for over 30 years. Rustic charm, crackling fireplaces, and the glow of sunset on Maiden Lake set the stage for endless prime rib and classic supper club comforts. Come hungry, stay longer; this is the kind of place that makes you plan your next visit before dessert arrives.
A Lakeside Legend in the North Woods
Nestled on the shores of Maiden Lake, the Maiden Lake Supper Club captures everything travelers love about Wisconsin’s North Woods: shimmering water, whispering pines, and an easy, unhurried rhythm. Family-run by the Dinkelmans for over three decades, it exudes a lived-in warmth that makes first-timers feel like regulars.
Step onto the deck and you’ll catch loons calling and boats gliding by, all while the dining room glows with knotty pine and picture-window views. This is a place to settle in, not rush through. The pace invites conversation, the kind that lingers with clinking ice and candlelight. With every plate, you taste tradition that’s been refined, not reinvented.
It’s a genuine lakeside legend – equal parts supper club, retreat, and local gathering place – where prime rib isn’t just a dish, it’s a ritual worth the trip.
Arrival, Bar Time, and the Two-Tiered Deck
Arriving at Maiden Lake Supper Club feels like stepping into a cherished tradition. There’s a friendly first-come, first-served flow – no rush, just the pleasant hum of a night out. While you wait, order an Old Fashioned at the rustic bar or carry your drink onto the two-tiered deck to watch the light fade across the lake.
It’s common to grab an appetizer while you wait, turning the queue into a social hour with a view. Conversation threads through the pine-scented air, locals swapping stories with travelers. The staff keeps things easygoing, calling tables when ready.
It’s an invitation to slow down, sip something classic, and let the woods do the rest. The wait becomes part of the evening’s charm – an appetizer of laughter, loons, and lake breezes before the main event arrives steaming and savory.
Relish Trays and Starters: Classic Wisconsin Welcome
Before the main course, the Maiden Lake tradition unfolds with a beloved Wisconsin ritual: the relish tray. Crisp pickles, snappy radishes, carrots, olives, and celery arrive like a colorful invitation to graze. Warm bread and creamy butter follow, comforting and familiar, while diners choose soup or salad to set the stage.
It’s all about pacing and pleasure – small bites, sips of an Old Fashioned, laughter across candlelit tables. This is where appetites awaken, where memories of family gatherings and Friday nights resurface. The team honors the supper club canon with care, from the chilled plates to the thoughtful portions.
You realize the relish tray isn’t filler; it’s the overture. It sets an unhurried tempo and signals the kitchen’s commitment to tradition, preparing you for that star turn of the evening: a prime rib feast worth writing home about.
Endless Prime Rib: The House Legend
The talk around Maiden Lake always turns to prime rib – and for good reason. House-roasted low and slow, the beef arrives blushing, tender, and perfumed with savory jus. Ask locals and they’ll point to the endless prime rib tradition: generous slices that keep coming until you happily surrender. It’s an experience, not a gimmick – anchored in consistent roasting, careful carving, and attention to temperature.
Horseradish cream sharpens each bite; a baked potato or seasoned fries completes the comfort. The servers glide from table to table, checking temps, refreshing au jus, and reading the room with practiced ease. It’s North Woods hospitality on a platter – abundant, welcoming, and reassuringly old-school.
Come hungry, stay curious, and let the carvers do their magic. You’ll leave full, but more importantly, satisfied by a supper club ritual done exactly right.
Beyond Beef: Walleye, Steaks, and Supper Club Favorites
While prime rib headlines, the supporting cast is outstanding. Hand-breaded walleye fries to delicate, flaky perfection – lightly crisp outside, pure lake-sourced comfort inside. Steak lovers gravitate to a gorgonzola-crowned tenderloin, where tangy crumble melts into a buttery sear. Chicken Ultimate leans indulgent, a creamy, craveable classic.
There’s a respectful nod to German-inspired plates, seafood selections, and hearty cuts that pair with relish trays and warm bread. Portions satisfy without showboating; flavors resonate with familiarity and care. The kitchen cooks like it trusts its guests – no fuss, just well-seasoned execution. It means everyone at the table finds a favorite, whether they’re chasing nostalgia or exploring something new.
And like any great supper club, sides matter: potatoes, veggies, and soups round out plates with balance and comfort, ensuring each bite lands like a welcome home.
Friday Fish Fry: A Wisconsin Rite of Passage
On Fridays, the dining room hums with a tradition cherished across the Badger State: the fish fry. Golden, beer-battered cod arrives crackling and aromatic, joined by rye bread, creamy slaw, lemon wedges, and a choice of potato – pancakes with applesauce or crisp fries. It’s communal, celebratory, and wonderfully consistent, the kind of meal that anchors the week.
Couples share platters, families pass sides, and the bar stays lively with Old Fashioneds. The lakeside windows enhance it all, framing twilight as plates arrive. It’s more than dinner – it’s ritual, with roots in community halls and church basements. Here, the kitchen keeps it faithful and fresh, serving plates that feel both everyday and special.
For travelers, it’s a delicious introduction to Wisconsin tradition; for locals, it’s the taste of home, perfectly timed for the weekend’s start.
Warm Hearth, Pine Walls, and Picture-Window Views
Inside, the room glows with knotty pine, gentle lamplight, and the steady warmth of a stone fireplace. It’s a setting that encourages leaning in – hands around warm plates, voices softening as twilight dims the lake beyond picture windows. Décor hints at a lifetime of memories: vintage touches, family photos, and framed nods to seasons spent by the water.
Tables are arranged to showcase views without sacrificing intimacy. Service flows comfortably, attentive without hovering, letting conversations stretch as courses arrive. The hush of evergreens and the flicker of fire create a cocoon of calm. It’s rustic without feeling rough-hewn, nostalgic without feeling dated.
The room itself becomes part of the meal – seasoned by stories, tempered by time, and always ready to welcome another chapter in the club’s long-running lakeside narrative.
Sweet Finishes: Cheesecakes, Cakes, and Coffee
Dessert at Maiden Lake is a gentle encore, the final warm note of a cozy performance. Fresh-baked cheesecakes arrive dense and velvety, often crowned with a bright berry compote. Chocolate lovers gravitate to tall layer cakes, rich yet balanced, ideal alongside a hot coffee or after-dinner cordial.
It’s the moment to revisit the view, watch the last light dissolve over the water, and trade forkfuls across the table. Portions are generous but not overwhelming, designed for sharing and lingering. Servers know just when to suggest a slice or pour, keeping the pacing unhurried.
It feels celebratory without ceremony – the kind of sweet ending that nudges you to promise, “next time, we’ll try another.” Between the hush of pines and the gentle clink of cups, the evening closes on a contented, memorable sigh.
Why It’s a Must-Visit for Travelers
For food travelers and nostalgia-seekers, Maiden Lake Supper Club is the North Woods distilled: lakeside scenery, soulful comfort food, and unpretentious hospitality. The endless prime rib is a marquee draw, but the experience – deck-side waiting, relish trays, Old Fashioneds, and a fireplace glow – turns dinner into a getaway.
It’s ideal for couples chasing a quiet weekend, families introducing kids to a Wisconsin rite, or friends linking a scenic drive with a satisfying feast. You’ll find value in portions, pride in the cooking, and warmth in every interaction. Arrive early, linger late, and let the evening unfold at its own pace.
In a world that often rushes, this lodge reminds you to savor. That’s the real secret: you don’t just eat here – you belong here, if only for a night.
Plan Your Visit: Timing, Tips, and Seasons
To make the most of Maiden Lake, time your arrival for golden hour and be ready for a pleasant wait – bar snacks and the two-tiered deck make it effortless. Fridays fill up for the fish fry; weekends buzz with travelers, so plan accordingly.
Summer sparkles with boat traffic and long twilights; autumn brings blazing maples and quieter nights. Winter is pure coziness – snowy pines, crackling fireplace, and hearty plates that chase the chill. Call ahead for current hours and specials, and bring an appetite worthy of the prime rib ritual.
Designate a driver if you’re exploring the cocktail menu. Most of all, lean into the pace: greet the lake, sip something classic, and settle into a timeless Wisconsin evening where good food and good company take center stage.
Dear Reader: This page may contain affiliate links which may earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase. Our independent journalism is not influenced by any advertiser or commercial initiative unless it is clearly marked as sponsored content. As travel products change, please be sure to reconfirm all details and stay up to date with current events to ensure a safe and successful trip.
