9 Hidden New York BBQ Spots Locals Swear By

New York City is a barbecue lover’s paradise if you know where to look. As a self-proclaimed BBQ connoisseur, I’ve scoured the city to uncover those secret spots only locals know.

Grab some napkins, and let’s embark on a smoky, saucy journey through NYC’s most clandestine BBQ havens.

1. Hometown Bar-B-Que (Red Hook, Brooklyn)

Ever stumbled upon a place where the air is so thick with the scent of smoked meats, it almost feels like a warm embrace? Welcome to Hometown Bar-B-Que in Red Hook, Brooklyn. This spot serves up a tantalizing array of meats smoked to perfection. The beef rib is a must-try, with a flavor that dances on your taste buds like a well-rehearsed tango.

The atmosphere is as authentic as the barbecue itself, with a rustic charm that makes you feel right at home. Wooden tables, dim lighting, and a sea of patrons all savoring every bite. You might even forget you’re in bustling NYC for a moment, swept away by the Southern hospitality.

Make sure to arrive early, as the line can snake around the block. But trust me, the wait is part of the experience. As the anticipation builds, so does the craving for that first bite. It’s not just a meal; it’s a rite of passage in Brooklyn’s BBQ scene.

2. Hudson Smokehouse (Mott Haven, The Bronx)

In the heart of Mott Haven, The Bronx, lies Hudson Smokehouse, a culinary gem that promises a barbecue experience like no other. Walking in, you’re greeted by an industrial-chic vibe that’s as inviting as the aroma wafting through the air. The ribs here are something of a legend, with a smoky, savory glaze that’s utterly irresistible.

Locals flock to Hudson Smokehouse for its vibrant atmosphere and mouth-watering menu. The brisket is melt-in-your-mouth tender, a perfect companion to their house-made sauces. Don’t let the modern setting fool you; the passion for tradition here runs deep.

Each visit is like a celebration of flavor, a testament to The Bronx’s burgeoning food scene. Whether you’re a first-timer or a seasoned regular, every bite invites you to join the ever-growing community of BBQ enthusiasts. Get ready to savor each mouthful and make new friends along the way.

3. Bark Barbecue (DUMBO, Brooklyn)

Tucked away in the trendy neighborhood of DUMBO, Bark Barbecue is where flavor and style collide. Imagine the perfect balance of juicy meats and a lively, artistic atmosphere. It’s like a symphony of tastes and sights that grab your senses from the moment you step inside.

Bark Barbecue is known for its innovative twist on classic BBQ dishes. Their pulled pork is a fan favorite, seasoned with a secret blend that could make even the most stoic New Yorker crack a smile. It’s served with a side of charm and a dash of the unexpected.

The backdrop of the Manhattan skyline adds an extra layer of magic to your dining experience. Whether you’re a local or a curious traveler, this spot promises a unique taste of Brooklyn’s culinary creativity. It’s a BBQ adventure that invites you to savor every quirky, delightful moment.

4. Au Jus (East Harlem, Manhattan)

In East Harlem, Au Jus serves up nostalgia with a side of unbeatable barbecue. Walking in feels like stepping into a retro diner, complete with neon signs and chequered floors. It’s a place where old-school charm meets modern BBQ brilliance.

Au Jus has mastered the art of brisket, with slices so tender they practically melt at the touch of a fork. The flavor profile is rich and robust, a comforting embrace of smoky goodness that warms the soul. It’s the kind of BBQ that stirs up memories and creates new ones.

Locals often swap stories over plates of ribs and laughter echoes through the space. It’s more than just a meal; it’s a testament to East Harlem’s vibrant community spirit. Here, every visit is a celebration of food, friendship, and the joy of shared experiences.

5. Taste of Heaven (East Williamsburg, Brooklyn)

In the bustling heart of East Williamsburg, Taste of Heaven is exactly what its name suggests. Picture a cozy corner filled with eclectic decor and the inviting glow of warm lighting. The vibe is intimate yet buzzing with energy, much like the neighborhood itself.

Their smoked chicken is heavenly: succulent, tender, and bursting with harmonious flavors. Each bite transports you to a blissful place where BBQ dreams come true. Paired with their homemade sides, it’s a feast that leaves you blissfully satisfied.

The charm of Taste of Heaven lies in its unpretentious approach to serving great food. It’s the kind of place where locals linger, and newcomers feel instantly welcomed. Whether it’s the first time or the fiftieth, every visit feels like a little slice of BBQ paradise.

6. John Fazio Farms BBQ (Modena, Hudson Valley)

Nestled in the scenic Hudson Valley, John Fazio Farms BBQ combines rustic charm with culinary expertise. Imagine savoring slow-cooked meats in an idyllic farm setting, surrounded by nature’s tranquility. It’s a BBQ experience that feels both wholesome and invigorating.

The star of the show here is the farm-raised pork, smoked to perfection with a delicate balance of flavors. It’s as if each bite carries the essence of the land and the expertise of seasoned pitmasters. The freshness and quality are unparalleled, making it a must-visit for barbecue purists.

John Fazio Farms BBQ is more than just a dining spot; it’s a place where community spirit thrives. The welcoming staff and picturesque views make it perfect for family gatherings or a peaceful solo retreat. Here, every meal is a celebration of the Hudson Valley’s bounty and charm.

7. Handsome Devil BBQ (Peekskill, Hudson Valley)

In Peekskill, Hudson Valley, Handsome Devil BBQ is a devilishly delightful dining destination. The vintage decor sets the scene for a cozy yet lively atmosphere that pulls you in from the get-go. It’s where history and flavor come together beautifully.

Their signature brisket is a revelation, smoked to a juicy perfection that has barbecue lovers returning time and again. The secret? A special rub that enchants the senses with its aromatic brilliance. Even the most discerning palates can’t help but fall for its charms.

Besides the food, it’s the spirit of Handsome Devil BBQ that enchants visitors. The friendly banter among staff and patrons alike creates a sense of belonging. It’s a place where everyone is welcome, and every meal feels like a warm embrace from a long-lost friend.

8. Smokin’ Petes Barbecue (Geneva, Finger Lakes Region)

Perched by the serene waters of the Finger Lakes, Smokin’ Petes Barbecue offers a lakeside dining experience like no other. Picture an unassuming shack with a wooden deck and the sun setting in brilliant hues over the gentle waves. It’s BBQ bliss.

The menu is a testament to smoky splendor, with ribs that sing with flavor and have a tender bite that feels almost magical. Each dish is crafted with a love for tradition and a flair for the extraordinary. It’s comfort food with a lakeside twist.

Locals cherish Smokin’ Petes for its ability to blend culinary excellence with a laid-back vibe. It’s where the simple joys of life are celebrated, one delicious bite at a time. Here, every sunset is a backdrop to shared stories and unforgettable meals.

9. J&J Smokehouse BBQ (Catskill, Greene County)

In the heart of Catskill, Greene County, J&J Smokehouse BBQ serves up flavor with a side of charm. Imagine a quaint joint with rustic wooden elements and a welcoming staff that makes you feel like family. It’s a BBQ escape that captures the essence of small-town warmth.

Their pulled pork is a local legend, succulent and seasoned to perfection. Each plate is a testament to the art of slow cooking, with flavors that are as rich as the area’s history. Whether you’re a BBQ aficionado or a curious traveler, the experience is nothing short of delightful.

J&J Smokehouse BBQ is more than just a restaurant; it’s a community hub where laughter flows as freely as the sauce. It’s a place to relax, unwind, and savor the simple pleasures of life. Every visit is a reminder of the beauty in sharing good food and great company.