9 Highest-Rated Italian Restaurants in All of Oklahoma

You would think Oklahoma’s food story starts and ends with barbecue and chicken fried steak. Then you sit down to a plate of handmade pasta that stops conversation mid-sentence, and suddenly the narrative shifts.

I have spent enough meals chasing red sauce, wood-fired crust, and perfectly balanced flavors across the state to know this is not a side note. It is a full chapter.

From Oklahoma City to Tulsa and well beyond, chefs are honoring old-world technique while adding just enough personality to make it feel current. Bubbling mozzarella, slow-simmered sauces, pasta with that ideal bite, these kitchens are not playing around.

The kind of places you leave already planning your return. If you think you know what Oklahoma does best, this list might change your order entirely.

1. Patrono, Oklahoma City

Patrono stands as a beacon of refined Italian dining in Oklahoma City’s growing Chisholm Creek district, where modern architecture meets culinary tradition.

The restaurant draws food lovers from across the metro area who appreciate the careful attention paid to every detail, from the house-made pasta rolled fresh each day to the carefully sourced ingredients that make each dish shine.

Walking into Patrono feels like stepping into a contemporary Italian kitchen where the wood-fired oven serves as the heart of the operation. The flames lick at pizzas and roasted vegetables, adding that irreplaceable smoky depth that only live fire can provide.

Pasta dishes arrive at tables with steam still rising, the noodles perfectly al dente and dressed in sauces that balance richness with brightness.

The dining room strikes a balance between sophisticated and welcoming, making it equally suitable for date nights and family celebrations. Large windows flood the space with natural light during lunch service, while evening brings a warmer, more intimate atmosphere.

Service staff demonstrate genuine knowledge about the menu, offering thoughtful recommendations without being pushy.

Chisholm Creek itself has become a destination for shopping and dining, and Patrono anchors the culinary scene with its commitment to quality over trends.

Address: 305 N Walker Ave, Oklahoma City, Oklahoma

2. Gabriella’s Italian Grill & Pizzeria, Edmond

Gabriella’s has built its reputation one generous plate at a time, serving the kind of Italian-American comfort food that keeps families returning for decades. This isn’t the place for tiny portions arranged like modern art on oversized plates.

Instead, expect hearty servings of classics done right, the kind of meals that might require a takeout container but never disappoint.

The menu reads like a greatest hits collection of Italian-American favorites, from spaghetti and meatballs to chicken parmesan with melted cheese stretching from fork to plate.

Red sauce flows freely here, rich with tomatoes and herbs, coating pasta in the satisfying way that reminds diners why these dishes became beloved in the first place.

Pizza emerges from the oven with crispy crusts and toppings that don’t skimp on quantity or quality.

Gabriella’s occupies the sweet spot between neighborhood joint and special occasion restaurant. The atmosphere feels relaxed enough for kids in soccer uniforms yet polished enough that nobody feels underdressed.

Servers often greet regulars by name, creating the welcoming vibe that turns first-time visitors into loyal customers.

The restaurant’s longevity speaks volumes in a city where dining trends come and go with the seasons.

Address: 3601 S Broadway Ste 600, Edmond, Oklahoma

3. Stella Modern Italian Cuisine, Oklahoma City

Midtown Oklahoma City pulses with creative energy, and Stella fits perfectly into this revitalized neighborhood where historic buildings house contemporary businesses.

The restaurant takes Italian traditions and presents them through a modern lens, creating dishes that honor the past while embracing current culinary sensibilities.

Wood-fired cooking provides the foundation, with flames adding character to pizzas and other preparations.

Fresh pasta appears throughout the menu, each shape chosen specifically to complement its accompanying sauce. The kitchen understands that texture matters as much as flavor, so noodles arrive with the right amount of bite, never mushy or overcooked.

Pizzas showcase high-quality toppings on crusts that achieve the ideal balance between crispy edges and chewy centers, with char marks from the wood fire adding visual appeal and smoky notes.

The dining space reflects Midtown’s artistic character, with clean lines and thoughtful design elements that create visual interest without overwhelming diners. Large windows connect the interior to the streetscape, making the restaurant feel integrated into its urban surroundings.

The open kitchen allows guests to watch the culinary team in action, adding an element of theater to the dining experience.

Stella has become a gathering place for the neighborhood, equally suited for quick weeknight dinners and leisurely weekend meals.

Address: 1201 N Walker Ave, Oklahoma City, Oklahoma

4. Vito’s Ristorante, Oklahoma City

Vito’s represents the pinnacle of fine dining in Oklahoma City’s Italian restaurant scene, where Northern Italian traditions meet impeccable service standards.

The restaurant has cultivated a reputation for special occasions, the kind of place where engagements happen and anniversaries are celebrated over meals that become lasting memories.

Everything about the experience signals quality, from the moment guests step through the door until the last bite of dessert disappears.

Northern Italian cuisine forms the foundation of the menu, featuring preparations that tend toward elegance rather than heavy red sauces. Dishes showcase technique and restraint, allowing quality ingredients to shine without unnecessary embellishment.

The beverage program deserves special mention, featuring carefully selected options that complement the menu, with staff who provide thoughtful guidance on pairings to enhance the dining experience.

The dining room exudes sophistication without stuffiness, striking that difficult balance between formal and comfortable. White tablecloths and proper stemware set expectations, while attentive service ensures those expectations are consistently exceeded.

Servers demonstrate genuine hospitality, reading tables well to provide the right level of interaction without intrusion.

Vito’s has become an institution for those seeking refined Italian dining in Oklahoma’s second-largest city.

Address: 7628 N May Ave, Oklahoma City, Oklahoma

5. Ti Amo Italian Ristorante, Tulsa

Descending into Ti Amo feels like discovering a hidden gem, with the basement location creating an intimate atmosphere that immediately sets this restaurant apart from typical dining experiences.

The below-grade setting transforms what might be a limitation into an asset, creating a cozy, almost European feel that enhances the romantic appeal.

Soft lighting and close quarters encourage quiet conversation and connection, making this a favorite for couples seeking something special.

Mediterranean influences weave through the Italian menu, bringing bright flavors and diverse ingredients that expand beyond traditional red sauce territory. The kitchen demonstrates skill in balancing these regional influences, creating dishes that feel cohesive rather than confused.

Seafood preparations often highlight this Mediterranean connection, with olive oil, lemon, and herbs playing supporting roles that enhance rather than mask the main ingredients.

The beverage selection complements the menu, highlighting flavors from Italian regions and Mediterranean influences. Staff members show genuine enthusiasm when discussing menu items and pairing suggestions, their recommendations coming from experience rather than scripts.

The intimate size of the dining room means service feels personalized, with servers able to give proper attention to each table.

Ti Amo has carved out its niche as Tulsa’s go-to spot for romantic Italian dining experiences.

Address: 6024 S Sheridan Rd Suite A, Tulsa, Oklahoma

6. Villa Ravenna, Tulsa

Villa Ravenna earns its stellar reputation through unwavering commitment to traditional Italian techniques, particularly when it comes to pasta preparation.

The kitchen takes the time-intensive approach of making pasta from scratch, rolling and cutting noodles that carry the texture and flavor only fresh pasta can provide.

This dedication to craft separates good Italian restaurants from truly exceptional ones, and Villa Ravenna firmly occupies the latter category.

Authentic preparation methods guide the entire menu, with recipes that respect Italian culinary heritage while allowing quality ingredients to take center stage. Sauces build flavor through proper technique rather than shortcuts, developing the depth that comes from patience and skill.

The kitchen clearly understands that Italian cooking at its best relies on simplicity executed perfectly, where a few excellent ingredients combined skillfully create magic on the plate.

The dining environment reflects this same commitment to authenticity, with decor that nods to Italian tradition without veering into theme restaurant territory. Guests sense they’re experiencing something genuine, a quality that has built Villa Ravenna’s loyal following over the years.

Service maintains the standard set by the kitchen, with staff who understand the menu thoroughly and take pride in the restaurant’s reputation.

Tulsa diners seeking the real deal in Italian cuisine consistently point toward Villa Ravenna as their top choice.

Address: 6526 E 51st St, Tulsa, Oklahoma

7. Luigi’s Pizza, Del City

Luigi’s embodies the neighborhood Italian restaurant concept perfectly, serving as a reliable gathering place where Midwest City residents know they’ll receive generous portions of satisfying food without pretension.

The restaurant understands its role in the community, providing the kind of consistent comfort food experience that turns casual diners into regular customers who celebrate birthdays and graduations within these familiar walls.

Classic Italian-American dishes dominate the menu, prepared with the confidence that comes from years of repetition and refinement. Portion sizes lean decidedly generous, reflecting the value-conscious approach that neighborhood restaurants must maintain to thrive.

Plates arrive loaded with pasta, proteins, and accompaniments, often providing enough food for lunch the next day. The kitchen doesn’t chase trends or attempt to reinvent Italian cuisine, instead focusing on executing familiar favorites reliably well.

The atmosphere skews casual and welcoming, the kind of place where families with young children feel comfortable and solo diners at the bar receive friendly conversation. Servers often recognize repeat customers, creating the personal connections that build community around a restaurant.

Prices remain reasonable, another crucial factor in Luigi’s sustained success as a neighborhood staple.

In Del City, Luigi’s fills an important niche as the go-to spot for Italian comfort food that satisfies without breaking the bank.

Address: 3901 SE 15th St, Del City, Oklahoma

8. Napoli’s Italian Restaurant, Enid

Enid’s energy influences its dining scene, and Napoli’s serves as a reliable Italian option that appeals to university families, students celebrating special occasions, and locals seeking dependable meals.

The restaurant strikes a balance between quality and accessibility, offering dishes that satisfy without intimidating diners who might not consider themselves Italian food experts.

This approachable quality has helped Napoli’s build steady business in a market where student turnover creates constant flux.

Traditional pasta preparations form the menu’s backbone, supplemented by seafood options that expand choices beyond the expected red sauce standards.

The kitchen handles these seafood dishes competently, preparing fish and shellfish with the care required to avoid the rubbery textures or bland flavors that plague lesser establishments.

Pasta arrives properly cooked, sauces show proper seasoning, and portions provide good value for the price point.

The relaxed setting welcomes various dining scenarios, from family gatherings to date nights to casual meals with friends. Service maintains a friendly, unpretentious approach that matches the overall vibe, with servers who handle their tables efficiently without making guests feel rushed.

The restaurant’s location in Enid positions it well to serve both the university community and residential neighborhoods.

Napoli’s has earned its place as Enid favorite through consistent execution and welcoming hospitality.

Address: 225 S Grand Ave, Enid, Oklahoma

9. Papa Dio’s Restaurant, Oklahoma City

Papa Dio’s carries the weight of history as one of Oklahoma City’s longtime Italian dining institutions, a restaurant that has weathered changing trends by staying true to its core identity.

The beverage program adds distinction, signaling a commitment to thoughtful drink options that enhance the overall dining experience.

This curated approach elevates the dining experience, providing thoughtful pairings that enhance both food and drink.

Classic Italian preparations dominate the menu, dishes that have proven their staying power through decades of service. The kitchen clearly understands these recipes intimately, executing them with the confidence that comes from repetition and refinement.

While some might consider the approach traditional rather than innovative, there’s real value in consistency and reliability, particularly for a restaurant that has served multiple generations of Oklahoma City families.

The atmosphere reflects Papa Dio’s established status, with decor and ambiance that feel timeless rather than trendy. This creates comfort for longtime patrons while potentially intriguing newcomers curious about a restaurant with such enduring appeal.

Service standards remain high, with staff who understand that hospitality means making every guest feel valued regardless of whether it’s their first visit or their hundredth.

Papa Dio’s continues earning strong ratings by delivering the experience Oklahoma City diners have come to expect and appreciate over the years.

Address: 10712 N May Ave, Oklahoma City, Oklahoma