10 Hole-in-the-Wall Crab Shacks in Florida Locals Don’t Want Tourists to Find

Florida’s coastline is a treasure trove of hidden seafood gems that locals cherish and often keep to themselves. These hole-in-the-wall crab shacks offer authentic experiences with fresh flavors and a laid-back vibe, away from the tourist-packed restaurants. Here are ten of Florida’s best-kept secrets where you can savor the coast like a true local.

1. Star Fish Company

Nestled right by the water, Star Fish Company offers a true “old Florida” vibe that transports you back in time. The shack’s simple wooden benches and tables invite you to sit back and enjoy the salty breeze. With a cash-only policy, this place is all about simplicity and freshness.

Locals rave about the blue crabs, caught fresh and prepared with minimal fuss. The atmosphere is relaxed yet vibrant, as families and fishermen mingle over heaping plates of seafood. Whether it’s a fresh crab platter or the crispy hush puppies, every bite whispers of coastal authenticity.

If you’re searching for an unpretentious meal with a stunning view, this is the spot. Its reputation as a local favorite means you’ll often find it bustling, but the wait is worth it. Experience Florida’s seafood as it should be: straightforward and delicious.

2. JB’s Fish Camp

Imagine a place where the seafood is as fresh as the ocean breeze. JB’s Fish Camp is exactly that. This rustic spot sits right on the water, offering a front-row seat to Florida’s natural beauty.

Known for its live crab “runs,” where you can watch fresh catches come in, JB’s offers an experience that is both tasty and authentic. Locals flock here for the crab legs and the casual, friendly atmosphere. The camp’s laid-back charm is matched only by the quality of its seafood.

With picnic tables scattered outside, you can savor your meal under the open sky. It’s the kind of place where time slows down, allowing you to enjoy each moment. A visit here is more than just a meal; it’s a connection to Florida’s coastal culture.

3. The Original Crabby Bill’s

Steeped in family tradition, The Original Crabby Bill’s is a testament to multi-generational charm. This beloved spot has been serving up fresh seafood for years, earning a reputation as one of Florida’s hidden gems.

Famous for its blue crabs and simple, yet mouth-watering dishes, Crabby Bill’s offers a taste of the sea that is both nostalgic and delicious. The family atmosphere is palpable, with generations coming together to enjoy the bounty of the ocean.

From the moment you step in, you’re enveloped in the warmth of its welcoming vibe. Here, seafood isn’t just a meal; it’s an experience. With its loyal following of local patrons, it’s clear why this spot remains a cherished secret.

4. Hogfish Bar & Grill

Tucked away on a pier next to a trailer park, Hogfish Bar & Grill is a quintessential escape from the mainstream. Known for its delectable hogfish and pink shrimp dishes, this spot is a culinary delight.

The atmosphere is as laid-back as it gets – far removed from the bustling tourist streets. Locals revel in the simplicity and freshness of the food, served with no pretense and a lot of flavor. The grill’s location gives it an endearing, almost secretive quality.

Dining here feels like discovering a hidden treasure. It’s where locals go to unwind and indulge in quality seafood, making it an essential stop for those seeking authenticity. Embrace the relaxed vibe and savor the true taste of Florida.

5. 12A Buoy

If you’re searching for a lively spot with a dive-bar aesthetic, look no further than 12A Buoy. Hidden away, this shack serves up some of the freshest seafood you’ll find in the area.

The crab-stuffed shrimp and raw bar items are crowd favorites, drawing in locals and seafood aficionados alike. The atmosphere is always buzzing, a testament to its popularity among those in the know.

The charm lies in its simplicity and the quality of its offerings. You won’t find frills here, just genuine, mouth-watering seafood. It’s the kind of place where you can sit back, enjoy a cold drink, and savor the flavors of the sea in the company of locals.

6. Fish Shack

In South Florida, Fish Shack is a revered institution. This hole-in-the-wall seafood spot has garnered a loyal following, thanks to its no-nonsense approach to dining.

The atmosphere is classic and casual, with a menu that focuses on delivering fresh seafood without overcomplicating things. Locals love the laid-back feel and the consistently delicious offerings.

It’s the kind of place where you’ll find fishermen and families enjoying a meal together. A visit to Fish Shack is an immersion into the community, offering a taste of Florida that’s as real as it gets.

7. The Docks Restaurant + Raw Bar

Located near the water, The Docks Restaurant + Raw Bar is an unassuming spot that packs a flavorful punch. Known for its fresh fish and simple preparation, it’s a local favorite.

The ambiance is low-key and welcoming, making it the perfect place to unwind. Locals praise the fresh seafood, expertly prepared to highlight its natural flavors. It’s a spot where you can enjoy quality food without any fuss.

Dining here feels like a well-kept secret, a place where you can escape the noise and enjoy a meal in peace. It’s a taste of Florida’s seafood scene that remains genuine and unpretentious.

8. The Hidden Crab

True to its name, The Hidden Crab is a gem tucked away from the main roads. Known for its seafood boils and succulent crab legs, this shack offers a laid-back dining experience.

The atmosphere is relaxed, with reasonable prices that keep locals coming back for more. It’s the kind of place where you can kick back and enjoy a seafood feast without the crowds.

Here, it’s all about the food and the experience. The simplicity and freshness are what make it special. For those seeking a little adventure off the beaten path, The Hidden Crab is a must-visit.

9. Old Dixie Seafood

Situated within a local seafood market, Old Dixie Seafood offers an authentic take-out experience. The focus here is on fresh catch and simple preparation, ensuring each dish bursts with flavor.

Despite its small size, the eatery is a favorite among those who know where to find quality seafood. The no-frills approach allows the natural taste of the food to shine.

If you’re on the hunt for genuine flavor and convenience, Old Dixie Seafood delivers. It’s a testament to the idea that sometimes, the best meals come in the simplest packages.

10. Key Largo Fisheries

In the heart of Key Largo, a bustling fish market doubles as a casual eatery. Key Largo Fisheries is beloved by locals for its authenticity and unbeatable freshness.

With stunning waterfront views, it’s the perfect spot to enjoy stone crabs and fish tacos. The market vibe adds to the charm, making it feel lively and inviting.

For those seeking a true taste of Florida, this is a go-to destination. The combination of a working fish market and eatery provides a unique glimpse into the world of fresh seafood.