New Hampshire summers bring warm sunshine, beautiful lakes, and something even sweeter; incredible ice cream stands tucked away in unexpected corners.
These aren’t your typical chain stores or fancy parlors. Instead, they’re the beloved local spots where families have gathered for generations, where portions are generous, and where every scoop is made with genuine care.
From roadside shacks to working farms, these hidden gems serve up frozen treats that keep locals coming back year after year.
1. Moo’s Place Homemade Ice Cream (Derry & Salem)
Consistently earning the title of “Best Ice Cream in NH” isn’t easy, but Moo’s Place makes it look effortless. Everything here is crafted on-site at their Derry location, ensuring absolute freshness in every single bite.
Walking up to this friendly neighborhood spot feels like visiting an old friend. The staff knows regulars by name, and newcomers are welcomed with genuine warmth. Portions are generous without being wasteful, and the quality speaks for itself.
What truly sets Moo’s apart is their dedication to homemade perfection. Each flavor is carefully developed and tested to create that ideal creamy texture locals crave season after season.
2. Hayward’s Family Ice Cream (Nashua & Merrimack)
Since 1940, Hayward’s has been serving up happiness one enormous scoop at a time. This Southern New Hampshire institution has watched generations grow up, bringing their own children and grandchildren through the same doors.
The flavor selection here borders on overwhelming; in the best possible way. With dozens of options rotating seasonally, you could visit weekly all summer and never try everything. Yet somehow, the staff remains patient as customers debate their choices.
Massive portions mean you definitely get your money’s worth here. Bring your appetite and maybe some napkins, because these servings don’t mess around when it comes to size.
3. Lago’s Ice Cream (Rye)
After a long day building sandcastles and riding waves, nothing hits quite like a trip to Lago’s. This Seacoast treasure has been delighting beachgoers for five decades with servings so gigantic they practically require two hands.
Cash-only operations might seem old-fashioned, but it’s part of Lago’s authentic charm. Their unique flavors like “Monkey Mess” have achieved legendary status among regulars who plan beach trips specifically around stopping here.
The line often stretches down the sidewalk on summer evenings, but locals know it moves quickly. Besides, watching the sunset while waiting for ice cream isn’t exactly a hardship in beautiful Rye.
4. Sanctuary Dairy Farm Ice Cream (Sunapee)
Imagine enjoying creamy homemade ice cream while cows graze peacefully in the background. That’s the magic of Sanctuary Dairy Farm, where the pastoral setting rivals the delicious frozen treats.
The farm atmosphere transforms a simple ice cream run into a genuine country experience. Children delight in spotting chickens, goats, and other farm residents while parents savor flavors made right on the property.
Every bite tastes richer here, perhaps because the ingredients travel mere feet from barn to batch. This isn’t just an ice cream stop; it’s a peaceful escape from everyday hustle, wrapped in sweetness and sunshine.
5. King Kone (Merrimack)
Sometimes simplicity wins, and King Kone proves this truth with every perfectly swirled cone. This back-to-basics roadside stand strips away fancy frills to focus entirely on what matters most: exceptional soft serve.
No elaborate flavors or trendy toppings distract here. Instead, you get classic vanilla and chocolate soft serve executed to absolute perfection. The texture is impossibly smooth, the flavor clean and satisfying.
Locals drive out of their way specifically for King Kone’s soft serve, which many consider the gold standard in the region. When you do one thing extraordinarily well, people notice and keep returning faithfully.
6. Ilsley’s Ice Cream (Weare)
Finding Ilsley’s feels like discovering buried treasure; and the ice cream rewards your navigation efforts handsomely. Tucked away from main roads, this genuine hidden gem creates unique homemade flavors that surprise and delight adventurous taste buds.
Their Brown Sugar Oatmeal flavor has achieved cult status among those in the know. It’s the kind of creative concoction that makes you wonder why every ice cream shop doesn’t think this inventively.
The “off the beaten path” location actually enhances the experience. Locals guard this secret somewhat protectively, though they’ll share directions with anyone willing to seek out truly exceptional homemade ice cream.
7. Memories Ice Cream (Kingston)
Memories Ice Cream earns its name by creating perfect summer moments families treasure for years. The quintessential rural farm-stand atmosphere, complete with picnic tables and a small petting area, makes every visit feel special.
Flavor variety here accommodates everyone, including those with dietary restrictions. Dairy-free and vegan options receive the same attention to quality as traditional flavors, ensuring nobody misses out on the fun.
Children beg to return not just for ice cream but for the whole experience; feeding goats, choosing flavors, eating outside under the trees. It’s wholesome entertainment that feels increasingly rare in our digital age.
8. Mac’s Maple (Plainfield)
Real maple syrup transforms ordinary soft serve into something extraordinary at Mac’s Maple. Located right on a working maple sugar farm, this spot specializes in Maple Creamee; a revelation for anyone who’s only tasted artificial maple flavoring.
The maple candy topping isn’t purchased from suppliers; it’s made right here on the farm. That authenticity shines through in every lick, offering genuine New Hampshire flavor you simply cannot replicate elsewhere.
Visiting during sugaring season adds extra magic, but locals know Mac’s delivers year-round. The combination of farm-fresh ingredients and generations of maple-making expertise creates something truly worth seeking out.
9. Arnie’s Place (Concord)
Why choose between dinner and dessert when Arnie’s delivers both spectacularly? This dual-purpose stop serves finger-licking barbecue alongside equally decadent homemade ice cream, making it perfect for complete road trip satisfaction.
Savory and sweet under one roof means families with different cravings can all leave happy. The burgers and barbecue build anticipation for the homemade ice cream finale waiting at meal’s end.
Locals appreciate the efficiency of one-stop satisfaction. Whether you arrive hungry for lunch or just craving something sweet, Arnie’s handles both missions with equal skill and generous portions that never disappoint.
10. Walpole Creamery (Walpole)
True “cow-to-cone” dedication isn’t just marketing at Walpole Creamery, it’s their entire philosophy. Fresh milk travels from a local Jersey cow farm just down the road to create small-batch, super-premium ice cream that tastes noticeably different from mass-produced alternatives.
While their ice cream appears in stores across the region, visiting the primary facility offers something special. You’re witnessing artisan ice cream making at its finest, where quality trumps quantity every single time.
Jersey cow milk contains higher butterfat, creating exceptionally rich and creamy texture. Combined with careful small-batch production, the result is ice cream that justifies every single calorie.
Dear Reader: This page may contain affiliate links which may earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase. Our independent journalism is not influenced by any advertiser or commercial initiative unless it is clearly marked as sponsored content. As travel products change, please be sure to reconfirm all details and stay up to date with current events to ensure a safe and successful trip.
