Let me let you in on a little secret that most tourists never discover. The best pizza in this state isn’t found in flashy chain restaurants or trendy downtown hotspots. It’s hidden in unassuming strip malls, tucked behind faded neon signs and served from tiny storefronts.
I’ve spent years chasing that perfect slice, and I can tell you the real magic happens in these humble little spots. The crust is perfectly charred, the cheese pulls just right, and the toppings are piled on with reckless generosity.
Locals guard these addresses like precious family heirlooms, and now I’m sharing them with you.
Trust me when I say your first bite will make you forget every chain pizza you’ve ever eaten. The atmosphere is unpolished, the service is honest, and the flavours are absolutely unforgettable. Oregon’s best pizza gold is waiting, and it’s time you discovered it for yourself.
1. Zola’s on the Water, Brookings
The bright blue building at Brookings Harbor hums with coastal energy. You cannot describe it until you are actually there, surrounded by salty breeze and the gentle sounds of the Pacific. Seafood toppings travel just a few feet from the fishing boats to the kitchen.
That brings a freshness to every bite you simply cannot get elsewhere. That kind of proximity to the source makes a real difference.
Inside, the decor is a wonderfully quirky mix of glossy woods, eclectic wall art, and wallpaper made from photos of old customer drawings and pizza box art. It’s a charming, community-built aesthetic that feels genuinely personal rather than designed by committee.
I love finding places that wear their history so openly.
On cooler days, their heated patio overlooking the Chetco River offers a front-row seat to harbor activity, a peaceful and scenic backdrop for a satisfying meal. The combination of hyper-fresh ingredients and unforgettable views makes this spot a true coastal treasure.
Address: 16374 Lower Harbor Rd, Brookings, OR 97415
2. Martolli’s Authentic Hand-Tossed Pizza, Sisters
There’s something deeply satisfying about a place that has been perfecting the same craft since 2002. Martolli’s in Sisters does exactly that with an unhurried, confident approach to hand-tossed pizza. The rustic red facade fits right into this charming Western-themed town.
Their crust achieves that elusive balance of crisp on the outside and pleasantly chewy within, the kind of texture that makes you slow down and actually appreciate each bite. Comparisons to beloved East Coast pizza styles come up often among regulars, and after one pie, it’s easy to understand why.
The outdoor seating area, shaded by cheerful red umbrellas, is a prime spot for soaking in the relaxed energy of downtown Sisters while watching the steady stream of visitors and locals pass by.
Whether you’re grabbing a quick slice between hikes or settling in for a full meal, Martolli’s delivers with consistency and genuine care for every pie that leaves the kitchen.
Address: 220 W Cascade Ave, Sisters, OR 97759
3. Apizza Scholls, Portland
Apizza Scholls is the kind of place Portlanders speak about with reverence. It is a modest SE Hawthorne storefront that has earned national recognition without shouting about it. The draw is their New Haven-style pies.
They have a distinctively thin, deeply charred crust that takes real skill to perfect. It is pizza as a serious craft.
Their philosophy puts quality above quantity. The most talked-about example is a strict three-topping limit designed to guarantee a perfect bake every time. People willingly line up for this experience. That says everything about the trust they have built with Portland’s food community.
Inside, the decor is intentionally understated, with bare walls, exposed wood beams, and simple wooden tables keeping the focus exactly where it belongs: on the pizza. Large windows connect the dining room to the lively street outside, giving the space an open, neighborhood-friendly feel.
The wood-fired brick oven produces a crust that is firm, blistered, and deeply flavorful in every single bite.
Address: 4741 SE Hawthorne Blvd, Portland, OR 97215
4. Ye Olde Pizza Shoppe, Hermiston
Some restaurants exist purely to feed people, and others exist to hold a community together. Ye Olde Pizza Shoppe in Hermiston is firmly in the second category. The history here is felt the moment you arrive.
Thick, hearty crusts piled high with generous toppings are this place’s signature. It is a straightforward and deeply satisfying style of pizza that never tries to be anything else. Milestones have been celebrated here. Friendships have formed over shared pies.
The recipes have stayed comfortingly familiar across the years. That kind of consistency is genuinely rare.
This is the sort of spot that becomes part of a town’s shared memory, a place where the food is as much about connection as it is about flavor. For anyone passing through Eastern Oregon, stopping here feels less like a detour and more like an essential part of understanding this region.
Address: 845 N 1st St, Hermiston, OR 97838
5. Mississippi Pizza and Atlantis Lounge, Portland
The distinctive green building on Mississippi Avenue signals this is not your average pizza stop. That impression holds up completely once you are inside. Mississippi Pizza and Atlantis Lounge is part pizzeria and part live entertainment venue.
That combination makes for one of the more genuinely fun dining experiences in Portland. Creative pies and indie bands under one roof. Hard to argue with that.
The Atlantis Lounge is an intimate performance space. It has long been a cornerstone of Portland’s local arts scene, hosting an eclectic mix of music, comedy, and community events, many of which are all-ages. The front area keeps things casual and welcoming.
It is the kind of easy spot you can drop into without a reservation or a plan. Even the weekly spelling bees have become a beloved tradition here.
Outside, the surrounding stretch of Mississippi Avenue buzzes with independent shops and creative energy. The aroma of baking dough often drifts invitingly onto the street. This place anchors a neighborhood that takes its community seriously.
Every visit feels like participation in something genuinely local and alive.
Address: 3552 N Mississippi Ave, Portland, OR 97227
6. American Dream Pizza, Corvallis
Rooftop dining in a college town hits differently. American Dream Pizza in downtown Corvallis has turned its elevated deck into one of the most coveted casual spots in the area. Oregon State students and long-time locals compete for those outdoor seats.
That is especially true on warm afternoons when the energy in the surrounding streets is at its most lively. It’s a scene worth being part of.
The sourdough crust is the real foundation of everything here. It brings a characteristic tang and satisfying chew that elevates even the simplest toppings. Creative pairings appear regularly on the menu.
They reflect a kitchen that enjoys experimenting while still respecting the fundamentals of good pizza. The results tend to be memorable.
This place has earned its status as a true community staple not through hype but through years of consistently delivering food that people actually want to return to. There’s a relaxed confidence to the whole operation that makes it easy to settle in.
Address: 214 SW 2nd St, Corvallis, OR 97333
7. Abby’s Legendary Pizza, Eugene
Since 1964, Abby’s Legendary Pizza has been a fixture in Eugene, a green-roofed building that has fed University of Oregon students, local families, and everyone in between. That kind of longevity doesn’t happen without a genuinely good product.
What I find most compelling about Abby’s is the unwavering consistency. Each pizza arrives piled with melty cheese and fresh ingredients, exactly as expected, exactly as remembered. For a place that has been around this long, maintaining that standard is a real achievement worth respecting.
The interior is comfortable and unpretentious, filled with booths and tables suited to groups of any size, making it equally welcoming for a solo lunch or a large family gathering.
Abby’s has grown from a simple vision into a beloved Pacific Northwest institution, and dining here genuinely feels like experiencing a living piece of Oregon’s culinary history. Some recipes stay delicious for a reason.
Address: 1970 River Rd, Eugene, OR 97404
8. Pegasus Pizza, Eugene
Pegasus Pizza has one of the most cheerful exteriors in Eugene, its bright red and green facade practically inviting you in before you’ve even made a decision. Inside, the coziness is immediate and genuine, the kind of warm, unhurried atmosphere. That comfort is part of the appeal.
The sourdough crust supporting their Greek-influenced pizzas is a genuine point of difference, offering a distinctive tang and texture. Since 1989, this family-owned spot has built a loyal following among university students and Eugene residents.
Pesto and teriyaki both make appearances, which keeps things interesting.
One small but thoughtful detail that regulars appreciate: the pizzas are cut into many smaller slices rather than the standard eight, making sharing natural and easy. It’s a minor thing, but it reflects a kitchen that pays attention to how people actually eat.
That kind of consideration adds up to a dining experience that feels genuinely cared for.
Address: 790 E 14th Ave, Eugene, OR 97401
9. Flying Pie Pizzeria, Portland
Flying Pie Pizzeria carries the kind of easy confidence that only comes with forty-plus years of doing something really well. Since 1984, this Portland institution has been serving creative specialty pizzas with a perfectly hand-tossed crust. The vintage sign and stone facade tell that story without a single word.
It’s the sort of place that Portland locals think of fondly and return to reliably, a warm and inviting space where the pizza artistry has been quietly perfected over decades of practice.
The specialty combinations here go beyond the expected, offering flavors that feel genuinely inventive without abandoning the fundamentals that make a great pie. That balance is harder to achieve than it sounds.
The neighborhood feel is strong here, the kind of spot that anchors its surrounding community and becomes part of the local rhythm rather than just another dining option. For anyone visiting Portland Flying Pie is an essential stop. Some institutions earn that word, and this one has.
Address: 7804 SE Stark St, Portland, OR 97215
10. Ken’s Artisan Pizza, Portland
Ken’s Artisan Pizza operates with the focused intensity of a place that has made a clear decision: pizza is a craft, and it deserves to be treated like one. The wood-fired oven at the heart of this operation reaches temperatures that bake each pizza in roughly two minutes.
The results justify the line that often forms outside.
The slow-fermented dough is what sets the foundation for everything else here. Italian-inspired toppings with a distinct American sensibility round out each pie in a way that feels thoughtful rather than arbitrary. Nothing here lands on the pizza by accident.
Inside, the design stays simple and unfussy, with bare walls, exposed wood beams, and wooden tables keeping the atmosphere grounded and focused. Large windows open the dining room to the street, connecting the experience to Portland’s lively energy.
This is a destination worth planning your evening around.
Address: 304 SE 28th Ave, Portland, OR 97214
11. Baby Doll Pizza, Portland
Baby Doll Pizza’s bright yellow facade on SE Stark Street is the kind of visual that sticks in your memory long after you’ve left the neighborhood. Since opening in 2011, this spot has carved out a significant and loyal place in Portland’s pizza scene.
The slices are famously XXL, cut from impressive 18-inch pies, and they mean business.
The thin crust achieves that particular balance that New York-style fans endlessly debate and rarely agree on. Dough, sauces, and cheeses are all made in-house, and premium locally-sourced toppings round out each slice with a freshness that elevates the whole experience.
Inside, pinball machines and checkerboard flooring give the space a bold, offbeat personality that feels completely authentic rather than themed. It’s casual, fun, and a little irreverent, which suits the neighborhood perfectly.
Baby Doll Pizza is the kind of place you tell friends about with genuine enthusiasm, not because it’s trendy, but because it’s simply that good.
Address: 2835 SE Stark St, Portland, OR 97214
Dear Reader: This page may contain affiliate links which may earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase. Our independent journalism is not influenced by any advertiser or commercial initiative unless it is clearly marked as sponsored content. As travel products change, please be sure to reconfirm all details and stay up to date with current events to ensure a safe and successful trip.
