Nestled amidst the rolling hills of eastern Kentucky, Pikeville was once an unassuming coal town. But in 1989, a crime so shocking occurred that it transformed the town into a magnet for true crime aficionados.
Books and films have since drawn national attention, turning Pikeville into a must-visit spot for those intrigued by the darker tales of small-town America.
1. The Setting – Life in Pikeville Before the Scandal
Pikeville, with its charming Appalachian backdrop, once offered a quiet haven where folks knew their neighbors and weekends meant local gatherings. Yet, beneath this serene facade, the town faced economic struggles, a common tale in coal country. The hills that provided not only natural beauty but also isolation served as both protectors and barriers.
In the late 1980s, the unexpected arrival of FBI agents stirred curiosity and whispers among the townsfolk. What was once a sleepy, tight-knit community suddenly found itself at the heart of a national intrigue. The contrast was stark; where there had been just the gentle hum of daily life, there was now the buzz of federal investigation.
Imagine the bewilderment as ordinary life met the extraordinary. For Pikeville, it wasn’t merely a change of pace; it was the dawn of a new chapter, one that would leave an indelible mark on its history. The townspeople, caught between past and present, became part of a story that would travel far beyond the mountains.
2. The Real Story – The FBI Agent and the Informant
Who could have imagined that an FBI agent and an informant would ignite a tale of passion and peril? Mark Putnam, the ambitious FBI officer, found more than he bargained for when he met Susan Smith. Their relationship, which began as a professional arrangement, escalated into an affair.
The drama took a dark turn when love spiraled into murder. Putnam, in a shocking betrayal of duty, strangled Smith in a fit of rage. This crime was not just a local scandal; it became national news as Putnam became the first active FBI agent convicted of homicide.
Their story, a cocktail of ambition, betrayal, and tragedy, captivated the public imagination. It was not just a crime of passion but a breach of trust, with a ripple effect that changed perceptions forever. Their ill-fated romance and the ensuing trial kept many enthralled, revealing the cracks in the facade of law and order.
3. From Crime Scene to Cultural Phenomenon
In the wake of the crime, author Joe McGinniss saw an opportunity to delve deeper into the tangled web of emotions and deceit. His book, ‘Above Suspicion,’ immortalized the scandal, turning it into a cultural phenomenon. The blend of crime, love, and betrayal caught the media’s attention like a wildfire.
Hollywood soon followed, with a film adaptation starring well-known actors that brought the story to an even wider audience. This wasn’t just a crime story but an exploration of human nature’s darkest corners. The combination of true events with dramatic retelling added layers to an already complex narrative.
The fascination wasn’t just about the crime itself but about how such a story could unfold in a quiet town. It tapped into the universal curiosity about how ordinary lives can be upended by extraordinary events. The allure of ‘Above Suspicion’ continues to draw those intrigued by the intersection of fact and fiction.
4. The Film’s Impact – Hollywood Comes to Pikeville
When Hollywood descended upon Pikeville, the town buzzed with excitement and curiosity. Filming locations across the region became temporary stages, capturing the essence of the story. Residents watched as their everyday streets were transformed into scenes of drama and intrigue, with Emilia Clarke and Jack Huston leading the charge.
The star-studded affair put Pikeville on the map in a way few could have imagined. Locals played extras, and familiar spots became backdrops for pivotal scenes. Suddenly, Pikeville wasn’t just a name on a map but a part of cinematic history.
For the townspeople, seeing their home on the silver screen was both surreal and thrilling. It was a chance to see the familiar through a new lens. The film’s production brought a sense of pride and a touch of glamour, forever linking Pikeville to the world of true crime cinema.
5. Pikeville Today – Shadows and Scenery
Pikeville today is a town of contrasts, balancing its notorious past with its natural beauty. The stunning Appalachian landscape offers hiking trails and outdoor adventures, while cultural sites tell stories of history and heritage. Visitors can explore the famous Hatfield-McCoy sites, adding another layer of intrigue to their journey.
Despite its dark history, Pikeville embraces its identity, offering travelers a chance to explore unique attractions like the Appalachian Wireless Arena. The town’s evolution from coal mining community to true crime curiosity is a tale of resilience and reinvention.
As you wander through Pikeville, you’ll find a community that values its roots while welcoming the curious. The shadows of its past linger, but the vibrant present shines brightly, inviting visitors to discover more. It’s a place where history and mystery intertwine, offering a memorable experience for all who venture in.
6. The Infamous Murder Trial
In 1990, Pikeville’s federal courthouse became the setting for a case that stunned the nation. The trial of FBI agent Mark Putnam drew reporters, spectators, and curiosity seekers from across the country.
Inside the courtroom, the story of betrayal and violence unfolded in gripping detail, revealing the human cost behind the headlines. Putnam ultimately pled guilty to manslaughter and received a ten-year sentence, making history as the first active FBI agent convicted of homicide.
The courthouse still stands today, a quiet landmark that reminds visitors how a single moment of tragedy once placed this Appalachian town in the national spotlight.
7. Remembering the Story
Pikeville has no official memorial to Susan Smith, but the memory of the case lingers in quiet ways. Locals still recall the upheaval it caused and how it reshaped the town’s identity.
Visitors sometimes seek the general area where the events unfolded, finding instead a reflective sense of place rather than marked sites. Conversations in cafés and museums touch on the story as part of Pikeville’s complex history.
The absence of a formal monument serves as its own statement; remembrance here lives through the people who still carry the story, not through stone or plaque.
8. The Local Legends Tour
Pikeville offers immersive walking tours that guide visitors through its storied past. Led by animated guides, these tours recount tales of mystery and legend.
Stops include infamous locales and hidden gems, each with a story that weaves into the larger narrative of the town. Participants gain a deeper understanding of Pikeville’s transformation.
The tour is not just an exploration of crime history but a celebration of community resilience. It’s a journey through time, revealing how a town faced its darkest chapters and emerged with a story to tell.
Dear Reader: This page may contain affiliate links which may earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase. Our independent journalism is not influenced by any advertiser or commercial initiative unless it is clearly marked as sponsored content. As travel products change, please be sure to reconfirm all details and stay up to date with current events to ensure a safe and successful trip.
