Indiana’s donut scene is a hidden treasure trove of sweet, doughy delights that locals have cherished for generations. From small family-owned bakeries to regional chains with cult-like followings, these shops create magic with flour, sugar, and secret family recipes. Morning travelers know the drill: arrive early or risk finding empty display cases and a ‘Sold Out’ sign hanging on the door.
1. Long’s Bakery in Indianapolis: A Local Legend
The aroma of freshly fried yeast donuts wafts through the air around Long’s Bakery, pulling in customers before they even spot the modest storefront. Cash-only and no-frills, this Indianapolis institution has been serving heavenly donuts since the 1950s, becoming as much a part of the city’s identity as the Indianapolis Motor Speedway.
Their plain glazed donuts achieve the seemingly impossible balance of crisp exterior and cloud-like interior that melts on your tongue. Morning commuters create a line that often stretches around the block, especially on weekends. Regular customers know to arrive before 8 AM to secure their favorites.
While the menu remains delightfully simple, their apple fritters have achieved legendary status among pastry enthusiasts. Locals swear the secret to Long’s success lies in their unchanged recipes and cooking methods, proving that sometimes tradition truly is best.
2. Rise’n Roll Bakery in Middlebury: Famous for Sweet Treats
Born from humble Amish roots, Rise’n Roll has grown from a small farm stand to a beloved Indiana institution while maintaining its commitment to quality. Their signature cinnamon caramel donut (affectionately nicknamed ‘Amish crack’ by devoted fans) creates an almost cult-like following that drives people to make special trips to Middlebury just for a taste of these legendary treats.
The bakery opens its doors at 6 AM, but regulars start queuing up much earlier, especially on Saturdays. Unlike mass-produced alternatives, these donuts feature hand-mixed dough made fresh each morning without preservatives or artificial ingredients.
What makes Rise’n Roll truly special is their perfect marriage of traditional Amish baking techniques with just enough modern flair. Visitors to the original Middlebury location can sometimes catch glimpses of the baking process, adding to the authentic experience that keeps travelers returning whenever they pass through northern Indiana.
3. Titus Bakery in Lebanon: Family Tradition in Every Bite
Stepping into Titus Bakery feels like being transported to a simpler time when neighborhood bakeries were the heart of the community. For over 40 years, the Titus family has been crafting donuts that strike the perfect balance between innovation and tradition, with recipes passed down through generations.
Their maple bacon donut has garnered statewide fame, with the sweet maple glaze complementing the savory bacon crumbles in a harmonious flavor symphony. Travelers along I-65 often plan their journeys with a Titus stop in mind, knowing they need to arrive early to beat the rush of regular customers who’ve made these donuts part of their morning ritual.
Beyond the incredible pastries, it’s the warm family atmosphere that makes Titus special. Staff members greet regulars by name, remember their usual orders, and treat first-time visitors like old friends. This combination of exceptional donuts and genuine hospitality makes Titus worth any detour.
4. Tom’s Donuts in Angola: Lake Country Favorite
Nestled near the shores of Lake James, Tom’s Donuts has been serving vacation memories alongside their sweet treats since 1970. The retro building with its distinctive orange and yellow sign has become an iconic landmark for anyone traveling to the northeastern Indiana lakes region.
Summer mornings bring a unique energy as lake visitors, many still in pajamas or swimsuit cover-ups, form cheerful lines before the sun has fully risen. The apple fritters here achieve cult status among regular visitors, with their perfect combination of crispy exterior, tender interior, and generous apple chunks.
Tom’s expanded menu includes over 50 donut varieties, but purists argue their simple glazed remains unbeatable. What makes this shop particularly special is how it has become a multigenerational tradition, with grandparents bringing grandchildren to experience the same donuts they enjoyed in their youth, creating a sweet thread of continuity through family vacations across decades.
5. Parlor Doughnuts in Evansville: Flaky Layers and Flavor Variety
The newcomer making big waves in Indiana’s donut scene, Parlor Doughnuts has quickly established itself as a must-visit destination for pastry enthusiasts. Their signature layered donuts, reminiscent of croissants in texture, offer a distinctive alternative to traditional cake or yeast varieties that dominated the state for decades.
Morning visitors to their Evansville flagship location are greeted by the intoxicating scent of butter and sugar as bakers work in the open kitchen. The French Toast donut has become their calling card, featuring warm cinnamon notes and maple glaze that perfectly complement the flaky, buttery layers.
Beyond their innovative textures, Parlor stands out for their rotating seasonal flavors that incorporate local ingredients whenever possible. The shop’s modern, Instagram-worthy aesthetic appeals to younger donut enthusiasts while their commitment to quality wins over traditionalists. Despite their recent arrival on the scene, Parlor has earned its place among Indiana’s elite donut destinations.
6. Concannon’s Bakery in Muncie: A Classic Stop for Travelers
Family-owned since 1959, Concannon’s represents everything wonderful about small-town bakeries that refuse to compromise on quality. The unassuming exterior of their Muncie shop belies the extraordinary pastry magic happening inside, where third-generation bakers arrive well before midnight to begin the day’s production.
College students from Ball State University mingle with longtime residents in the early morning queue, all united by their appreciation for donuts made the old-fashioned way. Their tiger tail twists, featuring strips of chocolate and vanilla dough braided together, have become their signature offering that regularly sells out before 9 AM.
What makes Concannon’s particularly special is their steadfast commitment to using real ingredients when many competitors have switched to mixes and shortcuts. Butter, not margarine. Real vanilla, not artificial flavoring. Fresh eggs from local farms. These seemingly small decisions create a noticeable difference in flavor that keeps travelers making special trips to this Muncie landmark.
7. Square Donuts in Terre Haute: Unique Shape, Same Delicious Taste
The name says it all at this quirky Indiana institution where donuts break free from circular conformity. Founded in 1967, Square Donuts turned geometry into a successful marketing strategy that has since expanded to multiple locations across the state.
Early risers in Terre Haute know to arrive before 7 AM to secure their box of these uniquely shaped treats. The corners of their signature square glazed donuts create extra crispy edges while maintaining a pillowy interior that has kept fans coming back for generations. College students from Indiana State University often credit these distinctive donuts with helping them survive exam weeks.
The shop maintains a charming retro vibe with counters and signage that have barely changed since opening day. Beyond the novelty of their shape, Square Donuts earns loyalty through consistent quality and friendly service. Regular customers share stories of stopping here before road trips, after sporting events, and during life’s major milestones, making these square treats a woven thread in the community fabric.
8. Munster Donut in Munster: Consistent Crowd Favorite
Tucked into a modest strip mall in Northwest Indiana, Munster Donut defies its humble surroundings by producing some of the most sought-after pastries in the region. This family-run operation has been using the same recipes since opening in the 1970s, creating a sense of delicious nostalgia for longtime customers.
The shop’s apple fritters have achieved legendary status among donut connoisseurs across state lines, with their perfect ratio of cinnamon-spiced apples to crispy, fried dough. Chicago residents frequently make the journey across the state border just for these renowned treats, joining locals in the line that forms before dawn.
What makes Munster Donut particularly special is the connection between the owners and their customers. The same family has worked behind the counter for decades, watching children grow up and bring their own families in for Saturday morning treats. This continuity creates an atmosphere of community that’s increasingly rare in our fast-paced world.
9. Dan’s Variety Donuts in Kokomo: Small Shop With Big Flavor
Sometimes the most unassuming places hide the greatest treasures, and Dan’s Variety Donuts proves this point perfectly. Operating from a tiny building that barely fits a dozen customers, this Kokomo gem has built its reputation purely through word-of-mouth and the extraordinary quality of their hand-crafted donuts.
Locals set their alarms for pre-dawn hours to secure their favorite varieties, knowing that once Dan’s sells out, they close for the day. Their blueberry cake donuts have garnered particular fame, with wild blueberries folded into a batter that achieves the ideal balance between density and tenderness.
The shop’s limited hours and cash-only policy might seem inconvenient in our digital age, but regulars insist these old-school approaches help maintain the quality that makes Dan’s special. Owner Dan himself still works the fryer most mornings, greeting customers by name and occasionally slipping an extra donut into bags for regular patrons. This personal touch transforms a simple pastry purchase into a community experience worth waking up early for.
Dear Reader: This page may contain affiliate links which may earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase. Our independent journalism is not influenced by any advertiser or commercial initiative unless it is clearly marked as sponsored content. As travel products change, please be sure to reconfirm all details and stay up to date with current events to ensure a safe and successful trip.
