I have eaten a lot of lasagna in my life, and I mean a lot. There is something about a perfectly layered dish of pasta, sauce, and bubbling cheese that just gets me every single time.
Indiana might not be the first place you think of when Italian food comes up, but trust me, this state is hiding some seriously incredible spots. I started hunting down the best lasagna across Indiana, and what I found blew me away.
From cozy family-run kitchens to lively neighborhood restaurants, each place brought something different to the table. Whether you are a longtime Hoosier or just passing through, these ten spots deserve a spot on your food bucket list.
Get ready to plan your next great meal.
1. Iozzo’s Garden of Italy – 946 S Meridian St, Indianapolis, IN 46225
Iozzo’s Garden of Italy has been feeding Indianapolis families for generations, and the moment you walk in, you feel that history. The walls carry decades of stories, and the kitchen carries on a tradition of honest, soul-warming Italian cooking that never tries too hard to impress but always does.
The lasagna here is the kind that makes you close your eyes after the first bite. Layers of hand-rolled pasta, savory meat ragu, creamy ricotta, and just enough mozzarella to hold it all together come out of the oven golden and bubbling.
It is not flashy. It is just really, really good.
Iozzo’s sits right along South Meridian Street, putting it close to Lucas Oil Stadium and the Indianapolis Zoo at 1200 W Washington St. If you are making a day of it in that part of the city, this is the dinner you deserve at the end. The portions are generous, the service is warm, and the lasagna will have you planning your return trip before you even finish your plate.
Locals have been loyal to this place for a reason, and one visit will make that crystal clear.
2. Mama Carolla’s Old Italian Restaurant – 1031 E 54th St, Indianapolis, IN 46220
Mama Carolla’s feels like the kind of place your Italian grandmother would have taken you if you were lucky enough to have one. The house itself is a converted historic home on East 54th Street, and eating here feels genuinely personal, like someone actually cared about every detail of your meal.
The lasagna is a standout on a menu full of standouts. It is layered with care, using a slow-cooked meat sauce that clearly spent hours on the stove before it ever touched a noodle.
The ricotta is fresh, the pasta is tender, and the whole thing arrives at your table looking like it belongs in a food magazine.
What makes Mama Carolla’s special is the atmosphere paired with the food. You are not just eating lasagna.
You are sitting in a beautifully preserved old home, surrounded by soft lighting and the kind of quiet that lets you actually enjoy your meal. Broad Ripple Park at 1550 Broad Ripple Ave is just a short drive away if you want to walk off dinner.
Regulars here are fiercely devoted, and once you try the lasagna, you will completely understand why this place has held its reputation for so long.
3. Vito Provolone’s – 8031 S Meridian St, Indianapolis, IN 46217
Vito Provolone’s has a name that practically dares you to love it, and the food absolutely backs that energy up. On the south side of Indianapolis, this place has built a loyal following by keeping things simple, generous, and genuinely delicious every single time.
The lasagna is one of those dishes that feels like it was made with someone specific in mind, and that someone is whoever is lucky enough to be sitting across from it. The layers are thick and satisfying, the meat sauce has real depth, and the cheese situation is handled exactly right.
Nothing is skimpy here, and that matters.
Vito Provolone’s has a fun, unpretentious vibe that makes it easy to relax and just enjoy the meal. Families come in, couples come in, and everyone seems to leave happy.
The south Meridian Street location puts it near Southeastway Park at 5624 S Carroll Rd if you want to get some fresh air before or after your meal. The staff moves with the kind of confidence that comes from knowing the food is good.
And the lasagna here is absolutely worth a special trip across town, no matter which part of Indianapolis you are coming from.
4. Capri Italian Restaurant – 2602 Ruth Dr, Indianapolis, IN 46240
Capri Italian Restaurant on Ruth Drive is one of those neighborhood gems that does not need a big sign or a trendy social media presence to keep people coming back. Word of mouth has kept this place busy for years, and the lasagna is a huge reason why.
What you get here is a deeply traditional lasagna that respects the dish. The pasta layers are just right, neither too thick nor too thin, and the filling hits that perfect balance of meat, cheese, and sauce without any single element taking over.
It bakes up with a crust on top that gives way to something incredibly soft and rich underneath.
The restaurant has a warm, lived-in feel that is hard to manufacture and impossible to fake. You can tell the people running this place genuinely care about what they are putting on your plate.
The north Indianapolis location keeps it close to Keystone at the Crossing and the Castleton area, making it an easy stop after a day of shopping or exploring. If you have never been to Capri, you are missing one of the city’s most honest and satisfying Italian meals.
The lasagna alone is worth clearing your schedule for a weeknight dinner.
5. Maialina Italian Kitchen + Bar – 1103 Prospect St, Indianapolis, IN 46203
Maialina sits in the heart of Fountain Square, one of Indianapolis’s most creative and energetic neighborhoods, and the restaurant matches that energy perfectly. The kitchen here takes Italian classics seriously but is not afraid to bring some personality to the plate.
The lasagna at Maialina leans into quality ingredients in a way that you can actually taste. The pasta has a homemade quality that sets it apart, and the bolognese-style filling is rich without being heavy.
Each layer is intentional, and the finished product is something that feels elevated without being unapproachable or pretentious.
Fountain Square itself is worth exploring before or after your meal. The Fountain Square Theatre Building at 1105 Prospect St is practically next door, and the neighborhood is full of murals, small shops, and great energy.
Maialina fits right into that creative, community-driven spirit. The staff is knowledgeable and enthusiastic about the menu, which makes ordering feel like a conversation rather than a transaction.
If you want lasagna that reflects both tradition and a little modern creativity, this is the spot. It is the kind of meal you think about for days after, in the best possible way.
6. Iaria’s Italian Restaurant – 317 S College Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46202
Iaria’s is one of the oldest Italian restaurants in Indianapolis, and that history shows up in every dish that comes out of the kitchen. Since the 1930s, this family has been feeding the city, and the lasagna has carried that legacy forward with remarkable consistency.
There is something deeply comforting about eating at a place that has been doing the same thing well for nearly a century. The lasagna at Iaria’s is straightforward, classic, and executed with the kind of confidence that only comes from decades of practice.
Layers of pasta, meat, cheese, and sauce come together in a way that feels timeless.
The South College Avenue location puts it right near the vibrant Mass Ave Arts District and the Indianapolis Museum of Art at 4000 Michigan Rd. It is a great anchor for a full day in the city. The dining room has an old-school charm that feels genuinely authentic rather than staged.
Framed photos, warm lighting, and the smell of garlic and tomato sauce greet you at the door. Iaria’s is not trying to be trendy.
It is simply one of the best, most reliable Italian restaurants in Indiana, and the lasagna proves that every single time it lands on a table.
7. Stacco House by Mammamia – 834 W Main St, Carmel, IN 46032
Carmel has become one of the most talked-about dining destinations in the Indianapolis metro area, and Stacco House by Mammamia is a big reason why. This spot brings an elevated Italian sensibility to a city that has developed a real appetite for quality food experiences.
The lasagna here is not your grandmother’s version, and that is meant as a compliment. The kitchen plays with technique and ingredients in ways that feel exciting without losing the soul of the dish.
The layers are precise, the flavors are bold and clean, and the presentation makes it clear that someone in that kitchen takes real pride in what they are sending out.
Carmel’s Arts and Design District surrounds Stacco House, and the whole area has a walkable, upscale energy that makes a dinner here feel like a full event. The Carmel Center for the Performing Arts at One Center Green is just nearby if you want to build an evening around your meal.
Service at Stacco House is polished and attentive without being stuffy. The lasagna draws people in from all over the Indianapolis metro, and regulars tend to order it every single visit because it is simply that hard to pass up.
8. Rosemary & Olive – 870 Massachusetts Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46204
Massachusetts Avenue is one of the most exciting stretches of restaurants and culture in all of Indianapolis, and Rosemary and Olive holds its own beautifully among some serious competition. The name tells you something about the philosophy here: fresh, herby, and rooted in Mediterranean warmth.
The lasagna at Rosemary and Olive has a brightness to it that sets it apart from heavier, more traditional versions. Fresh herbs actually show up in the flavor, not just as a garnish, and the sauce has a freshness that balances the richness of the cheese and pasta.
It feels like a lasagna that respects the season and the ingredients.
Being on Mass Ave means you are surrounded by incredible things to do. The Indianapolis Museum of Contemporary Art and dozens of galleries and boutiques are all within walking distance.
Before or after your meal, the neighborhood rewards exploration. Rosemary and Olive draws a lively, creative crowd that matches the energy of the street.
The staff is friendly and clearly enjoys talking about the menu. If you want a lasagna that feels a little lighter and more herb-forward while still delivering on comfort and satisfaction, this is your spot on the avenue.
9. Salvatori’s Authentic Italian Eatery – 12244 McKenzie Dr, New Haven, IN 46774
New Haven might be a small city just outside Fort Wayne, but Salvatori’s Authentic Italian Eatery proves that great lasagna does not require a big city address. This place has earned a reputation that stretches well beyond its zip code, drawing food lovers from across northeast Indiana for a reason.
The lasagna at Salvatori’s is the real deal. The kind of dish that takes time and patience to build properly, and you can taste every minute of that effort.
The meat layers are generous, the ricotta is creamy and well-seasoned, and the whole thing bakes up with a beautiful golden top that promises good things before you even take a bite.
There is a genuinely family-friendly atmosphere here that makes it a great spot for a group dinner or a casual weeknight meal. The Fort Wayne area offers plenty to do nearby, including Franke Park at 3411 Sherman Blvd in Fort Wayne if you are visiting with kids.
Salvatori’s is the kind of place where the owner probably knows half the regulars by name. That personal touch shows up in the food.
If you are ever in the Fort Wayne corridor and craving lasagna that actually earns the word authentic, this is the stop you need to make.
10. Amore! Italian Kitchen – 9757 Fall Creek Rd, Indianapolis, IN 46256
The name says it all. Amore means love in Italian, and the kitchen at this northeast Indianapolis spot puts that feeling into every dish that comes out.
Fall Creek Road is not exactly a famous food destination, but Amore! has quietly become one of the best-kept secrets in the city.
The lasagna here is homestyle in the best possible sense. It is the kind of dish that makes you feel like someone cooked it specifically for you, with attention and care baked into every layer.
The sauce is tangy and rich, the pasta is soft without falling apart, and the cheese coverage is generous and satisfying all the way through.
Amore! has a neighborhood restaurant feel that is genuinely welcoming. Families, couples, and solo diners all seem equally at home here.
The northeast Indianapolis location puts it near Geist Reservoir Park at 11701 Olio Rd, which is a lovely spot for a pre-dinner walk if the weather cooperates. The staff at Amore! moves with the kind of ease that tells you they love what they do.
The lasagna is the dish that keeps people coming back week after week, and after one visit, you will be adding it to your own regular rotation without a second thought.
Dear Reader: This page may contain affiliate links which may earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase. Our independent journalism is not influenced by any advertiser or commercial initiative unless it is clearly marked as sponsored content. As travel products change, please be sure to reconfirm all details and stay up to date with current events to ensure a safe and successful trip.
