I never expected to find a place quite like All My Relations when I first drove down Rockville Road on Indianapolis’s west side. Honestly, I’d passed by that stretch dozens of times without noticing the unassuming storefront at 7218 Rockville Road.
But once I stepped inside, I realized I’d discovered something truly special. This isn’t your typical retail experience where everything is neatly organized and predictable.
All My Relations is part treasure hunt, part spiritual journey, and entirely unforgettable. The moment you walk through the door, you’re greeted by an overwhelming collection of crystals, metaphysical supplies, oddities, and collectibles that seem to multiply the longer you look.
I’ve brought friends here who thought they’d spend twenty minutes browsing, only to emerge three hours later with bags full of things they never knew they needed. With a 4.5-star rating from nearly 900 Google reviews, this metaphysical supply store has built a devoted following among locals who appreciate the unusual and unexpected.
Whether you’re a seasoned collector of the strange or just curious about what lies beyond the ordinary shopping experience, All My Relations offers seven compelling reasons to visit.
The Overwhelming Crystal Collection That Keeps Growing
Walking into All My Relations feels like entering a geologist’s dream mixed with a spiritual seeker’s paradise. The crystal collection here isn’t just impressive, it’s genuinely overwhelming in the best possible way.
You’ll find everything from tiny tumbled stones perfect for carrying in your pocket to massive geodes that require two people to lift.
What makes this collection stand out is the sheer variety and accessibility. Unlike some metaphysical shops that keep their best pieces locked away or priced beyond reach, All My Relations displays crystals at every price point.
I’ve watched kids excitedly pick out their first piece of rose quartz for a few dollars while serious collectors examine rare specimens worth hundreds.
The staff actually knows their stuff too, which is refreshing. They can tell you about the metaphysical properties if that’s your interest, or simply discuss the geological formation and origin of each piece.
I’ve learned more about crystal structures and mineral compositions here than I ever did in school.
New inventory arrives regularly, so even frequent visitors discover something they haven’t seen before. The bins of tumbled stones near the front are particularly addictive to browse through, and I’ve never left without at least one new addition to my collection.
The Bizarre Oddities Section That Defies Description
Calling it an “oddities section” doesn’t quite capture the experience. This corner of All My Relations houses items you didn’t know existed and probably never imagined you’d want to own.
Yet somehow, you’ll find yourself drawn to these strange treasures like a magnet.
I’ve seen everything from vintage medical equipment to preserved specimens, antique apothecary bottles to handcrafted ceremonial items. The collection changes constantly as new oddities arrive and others find their way to new homes.
One visit might reveal a collection of Victorian mourning jewelry, while the next showcases unusual taxidermy or carved bone pieces.
What I appreciate most is that nothing feels exploitative or disrespectful. The items are presented with genuine curiosity and appreciation for their historical or cultural significance.
The owners clearly curate this section with care, choosing pieces that tell stories or spark imagination rather than simply shocking for shock’s sake.
For collectors of the unusual, this section alone justifies the trip. I’ve brought visiting friends here specifically to show them this area, and they always leave with at least one conversation-starting piece.
The prices vary wildly depending on rarity and condition, but there are affordable oddities alongside investment-worthy specimens.
The Treasure Hunt Shopping Experience Unlike Any Other Store
Shopping at All My Relations isn’t like walking through a carefully merchandised retail space where everything has its designated spot. This is genuine treasure hunting, and that’s exactly what makes it magical.
Items are packed into every available space, creating layers of discovery that reward patient exploration.
You might spot something interesting on a high shelf, only to discover three more fascinating items behind it when you reach up to grab it. I’ve spent entire afternoons here just methodically working through one section, finding treasures I’d missed on previous visits despite walking past that exact spot dozens of times.
This density of inventory means you really need to take your time. Rush through, and you’ll miss incredible finds hiding in plain sight.
The regulars know this, which is why you’ll see people carefully examining shelves, moving items gently aside to see what’s behind them, and occasionally exclaiming in delight when they uncover something perfect.
The store is open Tuesday through Thursday from noon to 7 PM, Friday from noon to 7 PM, Saturday from 11 AM to 7 PM, Sunday from noon to 6 PM, and Monday from noon to 7 PM. Plan to spend at least an hour, though two or three is better if you really want to explore thoroughly.
The Knowledgeable Staff Who Actually Care About Your Experience
Finding staff who genuinely care about helping customers rather than just making sales has become rare. At All My Relations, the people working there are passionate about what they sell and eager to share their knowledge without being pushy or pretentious about it.
I’ve asked countless questions over my visits, from the practical (“Will this crystal fade in direct sunlight?”) to the philosophical (“What’s the difference between all these sage varieties?”). Every time, I’ve received thoughtful, informed answers that helped me make better decisions.
They’ll steer you toward what actually fits your needs rather than what costs the most.
What impresses me most is their patience with newcomers. I’ve watched staff members spend twenty minutes explaining basics to someone completely new to crystals or metaphysical practices, never once making that person feel foolish for asking beginner questions.
They treat seasoned collectors and curious first-timers with equal respect and attention.
The staff also knows the inventory remarkably well despite the overwhelming amount of merchandise. Ask about a specific item you saw on a previous visit, and they can usually point you right to it or tell you if it sold.
You can reach them at 317-227-3925 if you want to check on specific items before visiting.
The Affordable Prices That Make Collecting Accessible
Metaphysical shops often develop reputations for pricing items beyond what average collectors can afford. All My Relations breaks that mold by offering something for literally every budget.
You can walk in with five dollars and leave with something meaningful, or you can invest in museum-quality pieces if that’s what you’re seeking.
The tumbled stone bins near the entrance are perfect examples of this accessibility. For just a few dollars, you can select beautiful pieces that would cost significantly more at other shops.
I’ve built an impressive collection of pocket stones without breaking the bank, and I love that I can bring nieces and nephews here to pick out their own crystals without worrying about the cost.
Even the larger, more impressive pieces are priced fairly. I’ve compared prices with other metaphysical shops in the Indianapolis area and online retailers, and All My Relations consistently offers better value.
The owners clearly prioritize getting interesting items into customers’ hands over maximizing profit margins on every sale.
This pricing philosophy extends to the oddities and collectibles too. While rare pieces command appropriate prices, you’ll find plenty of affordable curiosities that let you start or expand a collection without major financial commitment.
It’s refreshing to shop somewhere that doesn’t assume everyone has unlimited funds.
The Constantly Changing Inventory That Rewards Repeat Visits
Some stores feel static, offering the same products week after week until you stop checking back. All My Relations operates on the opposite principle.
New items arrive constantly, making each visit feel like exploring a completely different store even though you’re in the same familiar space.
I’ve developed a habit of stopping by at least twice a month, and I’m always rewarded with discoveries. One week might bring in an incredible collection of vintage tarot decks, while the next features newly arrived mineral specimens from a supplier the owners just connected with.
This constant turnover keeps the shopping experience fresh and exciting.
The regulars understand this rhythm and often time their visits around when new shipments typically arrive. I’ve struck up conversations with other frequent visitors, and we’ll sometimes text each other about particularly interesting new items we’ve spotted.
It creates an informal community of treasure hunters all keeping eyes out for special finds.
This ever-changing inventory also means that if you see something you love, you should probably grab it. I’ve made the mistake of leaving items behind, thinking I’d come back for them later, only to find them gone on my next visit.
When something speaks to you here, trust that instinct and take it home.
The Convenient West Indianapolis Location With Easy Access
Location matters when you’re talking about a shop you’ll want to visit repeatedly. All My Relations sits at 7218 Rockville Road on Indianapolis’s west side, making it easily accessible from multiple neighborhoods and suburbs.
The location puts it within easy reach whether you’re coming from downtown, the northwest suburbs, or communities further west.
Parking is straightforward, which anyone who’s tried to visit shops in more congested areas will appreciate. You can pull right up without circling blocks looking for a spot or feeding meters.
This convenience makes it easy to pop in even when you only have a short window of time available.
The surrounding area offers other stops worth combining with your All My Relations visit. Eagle Creek Park sits just a few miles north at 7840 West 56th Street, perfect for a nature walk before or after your shopping.
If you’re hungry, Los Arroyos Mexican Restaurant at 6903 Rockville Road serves excellent food and sits less than a mile away.
The west side location also means you’re experiencing a part of Indianapolis that visitors often overlook. This isn’t the trendy, heavily touristed areas.
It’s real Indianapolis, where locals shop and interesting businesses thrive without the pretension that sometimes comes with more fashionable neighborhoods.
Check their website at allmyrelationsindy.com for current hours and any special events.
Dear Reader: This page may contain affiliate links which may earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase. Our independent journalism is not influenced by any advertiser or commercial initiative unless it is clearly marked as sponsored content. As travel products change, please be sure to reconfirm all details and stay up to date with current events to ensure a safe and successful trip.
