I’ll be honest, I almost walked right past it. Standing near a small gazebo in Syracuse, Indiana, I had no idea that one of the most memorable meals of my life was waiting for me just a few steps underground.
Down Under Bar and Grill is exactly what its name promises, a restaurant literally buried beneath the street, and it is unlike anything else I have found in Indiana. If you love discovering places that feel like a real secret, this one is going to stop you in your tracks.
Syracuse is a small lake town in Kosciusko County, and most visitors come for the water. But locals know that the real hidden treasure has nothing to do with the lake.
Down Under pulls you in with its speakeasy atmosphere, comfort food that hits every time, and a staff that genuinely makes you feel at home. Once you find it, you will wonder how you ever missed it.
The Underground Location That Feels Like Discovering a Secret
Nobody finds Down Under by accident on the first try. The entrance sits beneath a modest gazebo at 801 N Huntington St STE 12, Syracuse, IN 46567, and more than a few visitors have circled the block two or three times before finally spotting it.
One reviewer even laughed about walking past it three times before a friendly local pointed them in the right direction.
That moment of discovery is part of what makes this place so special. You walk down the steps, and suddenly the whole vibe shifts.
The underground setting wraps around you like a warm secret you were not supposed to know about. It feels intentional, cozy, and genuinely exciting in a way that most restaurants simply cannot recreate.
The atmosphere has been described by regulars as speakeasy-esque, and that comparison is spot on. Low ceilings, warm lighting, and the hum of conversation from nearby tables create an energy that feels both intimate and lively at the same time.
For Indiana locals who think they have seen everything this state has to offer, Down Under is a reminder that the best surprises are often the ones hiding right beneath your feet. It is the kind of place you want to bring a friend just to watch their face when they finally walk down those steps for the first time.
Prime Rib That Regulars Cannot Stop Talking About
Ask any regular at Down Under what to order and the answer comes back fast. Prime rib.
Without hesitation. Multiple reviewers have called it some of the best they have ever tasted, with one diner saying it was a perfect early Father’s Day dinner and another raving that the queen cut was melt-in-your-mouth tender and seasoned perfectly.
The Wednesday powerhouse steak special draws a loyal crowd every week. One guest called ahead to let the staff know she was bringing her mother in for a 78th birthday, and the team came out to wish her happy birthday and delivered a complimentary chocolate lava cake.
That kind of thoughtfulness is rare, and it says a lot about the culture this restaurant has built.
Green beans with bacon make a standout side dish that pairs beautifully with the prime rib, according to repeat visitors. The portions are generous, the seasoning is confident, and the overall experience of eating a well-prepared cut of beef in an underground dining room with warm lighting is genuinely hard to beat.
Down Under opens Tuesday through Saturday at 3 PM, so planning a Thursday or Friday evening visit gives you the best chance of catching the full menu. If prime rib is your thing, this spot deserves a spot on your must-visit list in Indiana.
Burgers, Pizza, and Pretzel Bites Worth the Drive
Beyond the prime rib, the menu at Down Under covers a satisfying range of comfort food that keeps people coming back. The Western Burger features a half-pound patty, and while one reviewer noted their particular visit left something to be desired in the seasoning department, the fries earned serious praise.
Seasoned just right, crispy, and reportedly even better when dipped in cheese sauce.
The pretzel bites with cheese have become a fan favorite that shows up in review after review. Multiple guests have called them amazing, and they make a perfect starter while you settle into the underground atmosphere and decide what to order next.
The Big Burger, which stacks two half-pound patties, is not for the faint of appetite.
Wednesdays bring half-price pizzas, and guests who have stumbled onto that deal have left genuinely delighted. One group accidentally ended up at Down Under after a reservation mix-up at a nearby spot, ordered the Wednesday pizza special, and immediately started planning their return visit.
The chicken alfredo, the French dip sandwich, and the chicken strips have all earned positive mentions from regulars. For a place that markets itself around its underground novelty, the food more than holds its own.
The menu is approachable, the portions are solid, and the overall value at a mid-range price point makes it easy to justify the trip.
Service That Makes You Feel Like Family
Good food can bring people through the door once. Exceptional service is what keeps them coming back.
At Down Under, the staff has built a reputation for treating every guest like they belong there, and that reputation is earned visit after visit. Servers like Heather and Talia have been mentioned by name in multiple reviews, with guests going out of their way to highlight their energy, humor, and attentiveness.
One reviewer described Heather as having an awesome attitude with excellent service, adding that she wished more people in the food industry could follow her example. Another guest said that Talia made her birthday dinner exactly what she had hoped for, bringing genuine personality to the table rather than going through the motions of a standard dining experience.
The staff also goes beyond the expected in quieter ways. Remembering that a guest is celebrating a birthday, bringing out a complimentary dessert, or simply making sure drinks arrive quickly on a busy Friday night are the kinds of details that separate a decent restaurant from a genuinely great one.
Down Under scores consistently high in this department, sitting at 4.5 stars across more than 700 reviews. For a small-town Indiana spot that opens at 3 PM and closes at 10, that rating reflects a team that takes hospitality seriously every single shift.
A One-of-a-Kind Atmosphere You Will Not Find Anywhere Else in Indiana
There is something genuinely thrilling about eating a meal underground. The moment you descend those three flights of steps at Down Under, the ordinary world above fades out completely.
The space has a character that no amount of interior design budget could manufacture from scratch. It is raw, warm, and surprisingly comfortable once you settle in.
Reviewers consistently use the word unique when describing this place, and that word does not get thrown around lightly when you live in Indiana and have visited your share of lakeside restaurants and small-town diners. The speakeasy comparison keeps coming up because the vibe genuinely earns it.
Low ceilings, close tables, and the energy of a room where everyone seems to be having a good time create an atmosphere that feels celebratory without trying too hard.
One thing worth knowing before your visit is the stairs. Getting to Down Under requires navigating three flights of steps, which is part of the adventure but also something to plan around if mobility is a concern for anyone in your group.
For most visitors, the climb down is just part of the story they tell afterward. Syracuse sits on the shores of Lake Wawasee, Indiana’s largest natural lake, and the town has no shortage of scenic spots to explore.
But when the sun goes down and you want somewhere with real personality, nothing in the area competes with what is waiting beneath that gazebo.
The Perfect Spot for Birthdays and Special Occasions
Something about celebrating a birthday underground just works. Down Under has quietly become a go-to destination for special occasions in the Syracuse area, and the staff clearly understands how to make those moments feel memorable.
From surprise birthday greetings to complimentary desserts, the team here puts in effort that guests genuinely notice and appreciate.
The chocolate lava cake has made more than one appearance in reviews as an unexpected highlight of a birthday visit. Rich, warm, and clearly made to impress, it is the kind of dessert that ends a meal on exactly the right note.
One reviewer shared that the staff came out to wish her mother a happy 78th birthday after she had simply called ahead to mention the occasion. That level of care is not something you can train into a team overnight.
Whether you are marking a first date, a milestone birthday, or just a Tuesday that deserves to feel special, Down Under delivers the kind of setting that photographs well and feels even better in person. The underground atmosphere adds a natural sense of occasion to whatever you are celebrating.
The restaurant is open Tuesday through Saturday from 3 to 10 PM, so reservations or at least arriving early on weekends is a smart move. Groups have reported minimal wait times even on busy Friday nights, which is another reason the regulars keep returning without hesitation.
Exploring Syracuse, Indiana Before or After Your Visit
Syracuse is worth more than just a quick dinner stop. The town sits on the edge of Lake Wawasee, Indiana’s largest natural lake, and the surrounding area offers a full day of exploration before you head underground for the evening.
Yogi Bear’s Jellystone Park at 990 S Lakeview Dr, Syracuse, IN 46567 is a popular family destination nearby, especially during warmer months when the lake activity picks up.
Oakwood Resort at 702 E Park Dr, Syracuse, IN 46567 offers lakeside dining and recreation for those who want to make a full weekend out of the trip. The Syracuse-Wawasee Historical Museum at 705 N Long Dr, Syracuse, IN 46567 is a quiet, charming stop for anyone curious about the history of this lake community and how it grew into the destination it is today.
After a few hours on the water or wandering the town, arriving at Down Under right when it opens at 3 PM is a smart strategy. You beat the dinner crowd, get your choice of seating, and ease into the underground atmosphere at a relaxed pace.
The combination of a scenic Indiana lake town and a genuinely one-of-a-kind underground restaurant makes Syracuse a surprisingly strong destination for a weekend getaway. Once you find Down Under, you will start looking for any excuse to come back.
Dear Reader: This page may contain affiliate links which may earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase. Our independent journalism is not influenced by any advertiser or commercial initiative unless it is clearly marked as sponsored content. As travel products change, please be sure to reconfirm all details and stay up to date with current events to ensure a safe and successful trip.
