Indiana might not be the first place that comes to mind when you think of authentic Italian food, but the Hoosier State has some seriously impressive pasta spots. From family-run trattorias serving recipes passed down through generations to upscale ristorantes with handmade noodles, these restaurants know how to do Italian right.
You will find everything from classic spaghetti carbonara to regional specialties that transport you straight to Rome or Naples. Whether you are craving a cozy date night or a hearty family dinner, these seven Italian eateries take pasta as seriously as any kitchen in Italy.
Fresh ingredients, traditional techniques, and a whole lot of love go into every dish. Get ready to twirl your fork into some of the best pasta Indiana has to offer.
1. Iozzo’s Garden of Italy
Walking into Iozzo’s Garden of Italy feels like stepping into a time capsule of old-world Italian charm. Located at 946 S Meridian St in Indianapolis, this family-owned spot has been serving up authentic Italian cuisine since 1933, making it one of the oldest Italian restaurants in the entire city.
The recipes here have been handed down through four generations, and you can taste that heritage in every single bite.
Their pasta is made fresh daily, and the kitchen takes pride in using traditional methods that honor the craft. The fettuccine alfredo is rich and creamy without being heavy, and the lasagna is layered with homemade meat sauce that simmers for hours.
Regulars swear by the spaghetti with meatballs, which are tender, flavorful, and generously sized.
The atmosphere is warm and inviting, with checkered tablecloths and vintage photographs lining the walls. It is the kind of place where the staff remembers your name and your favorite dish.
Families gather here for Sunday dinners, and couples come for intimate evenings over candlelight.
If you are exploring the area, the Indiana State Museum at 650 W Washington St is just a short drive away, offering exhibits on everything from natural history to sports legends. You can also stroll through White River State Park, which connects several attractions and provides a peaceful green space in the heart of downtown.
Iozzo’s does not just serve food; it serves memories. Every plate tells a story of tradition, passion, and a deep respect for Italian culinary roots.
When you want pasta that is made with care and served with a smile, this is the place to go.
2. Sangiovese Ristorante (Ironworks)
At 2727 E 86th St, Ste 110 in Indianapolis, Sangiovese Ristorante brings a touch of Tuscan elegance to the Ironworks neighborhood. Named after the famous Italian wine grape, this upscale eatery focuses on fresh, seasonal ingredients and house-made pasta that changes with the menu.
The chefs here are passionate about authenticity, and it shows in the attention to detail.
Their pappardelle with wild boar ragu is a standout, featuring wide ribbons of pasta tossed in a savory, slow-cooked sauce that melts in your mouth. The gnocchi is pillowy soft, and the ravioli fillings rotate based on what is fresh and available.
Each dish is plated beautifully, making every meal feel like a special occasion.
The dining room is sophisticated yet comfortable, with wood accents and soft lighting that create an intimate ambiance. The wine list is extensive, featuring both Italian imports and local selections that pair perfectly with the menu.
Service is attentive without being intrusive, and the staff is knowledgeable about both the food and wine.
After dinner, you can explore the nearby Fashion Mall at Keystone, located at 8702 Keystone Crossing, which offers upscale shopping and dining options. If you are in the mood for nature, the Monon Trail runs through the area, providing a scenic path for walking or biking.
Sangiovese is perfect for those nights when you want to dress up a little and enjoy a refined Italian dining experience. The combination of expertly crafted pasta, excellent wine, and elegant surroundings makes it a top choice for celebrations or romantic dinners.
3. Sangiovese Ristorante (Fishers District)
The Fishers location of Sangiovese Ristorante at 9708 District North Dr, Ste 920 offers the same commitment to quality pasta and Italian cuisine as its Ironworks sibling. Situated in the vibrant Fishers District, this spot has become a neighborhood favorite for both locals and visitors looking for an authentic Italian meal.
The open kitchen lets you watch the chefs at work, adding an interactive element to your dining experience.
House-made pasta is the star here, with options like rigatoni alla vodka that balances creamy tomato sauce with a hint of heat. The tagliatelle bolognese is another crowd-pleaser, featuring a rich meat sauce that clings perfectly to the flat noodles.
Vegetarian options are thoughtfully prepared, with seasonal vegetables and fresh herbs taking center stage.
The restaurant’s modern design features large windows that flood the space with natural light during the day, while evening dining feels cozy and romantic. The bar area is lively, offering craft cocktails and an impressive selection of Italian wines.
It is a great spot for happy hour or a pre-dinner drink.
The Fishers District itself is a walkable area with plenty to explore. Topgolf is located nearby at 11725 Fishers Crossing Dr, offering entertainment for groups and families.
You can also catch a show at the Nickel Plate District Amphitheater at 6 Municipal Dr, which hosts concerts and community events throughout the year.
Whether you are celebrating a milestone or just treating yourself to a great meal, Sangiovese in Fishers delivers on every level. The combination of fresh pasta, quality ingredients, and a welcoming atmosphere makes it a must-visit for Italian food lovers.
4. Mama Carolla’s Old Italian Kitchen
Mama Carolla’s Old Italian Kitchen at 1031 E 54th St in Indianapolis is the definition of comfort food done right. This cozy neighborhood spot has been a Broad Ripple staple for years, drawing crowds with its generous portions and homestyle Italian cooking.
The menu reads like a greatest hits album of Italian-American classics, and the pasta dishes are consistently excellent.
Their spaghetti and meatballs are legendary, with perfectly seasoned meatballs that are tender and juicy. The baked mostaccioli is a cheesy, bubbling masterpiece that arrives at your table piping hot.
Pasta portions are huge, so come hungry or plan to take home leftovers. The garlic bread is also a must-order, crispy on the outside and buttery on the inside.
The atmosphere is casual and family-friendly, with red vinyl booths and walls covered in Italian-themed artwork. It is the kind of place where kids are welcome and everyone feels at home.
Service is friendly and efficient, even during busy weekend dinner rushes.
Broad Ripple Village surrounds the restaurant, offering plenty of post-dinner activities. You can walk along the Monon Trail, which runs through the neighborhood, or explore the shops and cafes on Broad Ripple Avenue.
The Indianapolis Art Center at 820 E 67th St features rotating exhibitions and classes for all ages.
Mama Carolla’s is not trying to be fancy, and that is exactly why people love it. The focus is on hearty, satisfying Italian food that reminds you of Sunday dinners at grandma’s house.
When you want pasta that fills you up and makes you smile, this is your spot.
5. Nesso Italian Kitchen
Nesso Italian Kitchen at 339 S Delaware St in downtown Indianapolis brings a contemporary twist to traditional Italian cuisine. Located in the heart of the city, this modern trattoria focuses on fresh, locally sourced ingredients and pasta made from scratch daily.
The menu changes seasonally, ensuring that every visit offers something new and exciting.
Their squid ink pasta with seafood is a visual and culinary stunner, featuring jet-black noodles tossed with fresh shrimp, scallops, and mussels. The cacio e pepe is simple yet perfect, showcasing how just a few quality ingredients can create magic.
Vegetarian pasta options highlight seasonal produce, with dishes like butternut squash ravioli appearing in the fall.
The restaurant’s design is sleek and contemporary, with exposed brick, industrial lighting, and an open kitchen that adds energy to the space. The bar serves creative cocktails alongside an excellent wine list.
It is a popular spot for pre-theater dinners, given its proximity to the Indiana Repertory Theatre at 140 W Washington St.
Downtown Indianapolis offers plenty to do before or after your meal. Bankers Life Fieldhouse at 125 S Pennsylvania St hosts Pacers games and concerts.
Monument Circle, just blocks away, is the city’s iconic center and a great spot for photos. You can also visit the Soldiers and Sailors Monument, which offers observation deck views of the city.
Nesso strikes the perfect balance between innovation and tradition. The chefs respect Italian culinary heritage while not being afraid to experiment with new flavors and techniques.
For a modern take on pasta that still honors the classics, Nesso is an excellent choice.
6. Convivio Italian Cuisine
Convivio Italian Cuisine at 11529 Spring Mill Rd, Ste 300 in Carmel offers an upscale dining experience with a focus on Northern Italian specialties. The name means feast or banquet in Italian, and that philosophy is evident in every aspect of the restaurant.
From the moment you walk in, you know you are in for something special.
The pasta menu features both classic and creative options, all made in-house. Their lobster ravioli is decadent, filled with sweet lobster meat and topped with a light cream sauce.
The pappardelle with braised short rib is rich and hearty, perfect for cooler evenings. Each pasta dish is cooked to order, ensuring perfect texture every time.
The dining room exudes elegance, with white tablecloths, soft lighting, and attentive service that makes you feel pampered. The wine cellar is impressive, featuring hundreds of bottles from Italy and around the world.
The sommelier is happy to help you find the perfect pairing for your meal.
Carmel’s Arts and Design District is nearby, offering galleries, boutiques, and the Center for the Performing Arts at 1 Center Green. The Monon Trail also runs through Carmel, providing a scenic route for walking or biking.
If you are visiting during warmer months, the Carmel Farmers Market at Carter Green is worth checking out.
Convivio is ideal for special occasions when you want to impress someone or simply treat yourself to an exceptional meal. The combination of refined pasta dishes, extensive wine selection, and sophisticated atmosphere makes it one of the best Italian restaurants in the Indianapolis area.
7. Capri Italian Restaurant
Capri Italian Restaurant at 2602 Ruth Dr in Indianapolis has been a local favorite since 1974, serving classic Italian-American dishes in a warm, welcoming environment. This family-owned restaurant has maintained its commitment to quality and consistency for nearly five decades, earning a loyal following in the process.
The recipes here are traditional, focusing on flavors that have stood the test of time.
Their pasta dishes are generous and satisfying, with options like spaghetti carbonara that features crispy pancetta and a creamy egg-based sauce. The fettuccine alfredo is rich without being overwhelming, and the lasagna is layered with homemade meat sauce and plenty of cheese.
The chicken parmigiana over spaghetti is a customer favorite, combining two Italian classics into one hearty meal.
The atmosphere is relaxed and family-oriented, with comfortable seating and friendly service. The walls are decorated with Italian scenes and family photos, adding to the homey feel.
It is the kind of place where you can bring the whole family, including kids, and everyone will find something they love.
The restaurant is located near Castleton Square Mall at 6020 E 82nd St, making it convenient for a meal before or after shopping. Topgolf at 8890 E 96th St is also nearby, offering entertainment options for groups.
The surrounding area has plenty of chain restaurants and shops, but Capri stands out for its authentic approach and personal touch.
For those seeking a no-frills Italian meal that delivers on flavor and value, Capri is a solid choice. The focus here is on doing the basics exceptionally well, ensuring that every guest leaves satisfied and planning their next visit.
Dear Reader: This page may contain affiliate links which may earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase. Our independent journalism is not influenced by any advertiser or commercial initiative unless it is clearly marked as sponsored content. As travel products change, please be sure to reconfirm all details and stay up to date with current events to ensure a safe and successful trip.
