Ohio knows comfort food, and Fairfield has a buffet that proves it with every slice. Cicis Pizza in Fairfield is the kind of place where you walk in hungry, promise yourself you’ll be reasonable, and then happily forget that plan. Locals whisper “dangerously good” with a grin, because the variety and speed make seconds feel inevitable. If you’re craving a fun, filling, and wallet-friendly feast, this is where the plates keep coming and the smiles follow.
1. Ohio’s Comfort-Food Crown
Ohio loves comfort food that feels like home, and Fairfield delivers it with a slice-first mindset at Cicis Pizza. The moment you step in, the scent of fresh dough and bubbling cheese sets the tone for a meal that’s about generosity and fun.
The all-you-can-eat spread is a celebration of classic favorites and quirky crowd-pleasers, all hot and ready to grab. Families, students, and teams flock here for the ease of letting everyone choose their own adventure without breaking the budget. What makes it “dangerously good” is the combination of flavor and pace. Fresh pies keep rolling out so fast you barely finish one slice before another steals your attention.
Every corner of the buffet invites sampling, from reliable pepperoni to bold specialty toppings. Add in pastas, salad, and sweets, and you have a lineup that rewards curiosity. It’s the kind of place where plates stack up and guilt takes the night off. Come hungry, leave happy, and maybe a little amazed.
2. Where To Find It: Easygoing And Family-Friendly
You’ll find Cicis Pizza in Fairfield, Ohio, at 6584 Forest Fair Blvd, conveniently near major roads and shopping. The location makes it an effortless stop during errands, after a movie, or before a game. Inside, the energy is casual and welcoming, with booths that fit families and big tables for groups.
Kids light up at the sight of the buffet, and adults appreciate how simple it is to please a crowd. Staff keep the line flowing and the trays replenished, so you never wait long for a fresh pie. The vibe is come-as-you-are, perfect for post-practice refuels and weeknight wins. Big windows and bright colors keep things lively, while the layout makes it easy to navigate with a plate in hand.
Whether you’re a local regular or passing through the Cincinnati area, it’s an anchor spot for quick comfort. Pull up, pop in, and let the buffet do the heavy lifting. It’s pizza night made easy.
3. The Buffet Breakdown: Endless Choices
The all-you-can-eat format at Cicis is the star: you pay once and explore freely. Pizzas arrive in a steady stream, from thin and crispy to deep, cheesy comfort. The salad bar offers crisp greens, toppings, and dressings to balance the indulgence.
Hot pasta trays keep it cozy with options like marinara or creamy Alfredo, and breadsticks add that perfect dip-and-crunch. Dessert is a head-turner with sweet pizzas and those famous cinnamon rolls. The rhythm is simple: grab a plate, take a slice, circle back for something new. Fresh pies appear so often that every lap reveals another must-try flavor. It’s designed for mixing and matching, building a little sampler of everything. You set the pace, and the buffet keeps up beautifully.
Best of all, it’s easy to share and compare favorites at the table, making it feel like a group tasting tour. One price, endless bites, and no tough decisions required.
4. Pizza For Every Mood: Classics To Bold
Cicis excels at serving a lineup that hits every craving. Classic pepperoni delivers that familiar, satisfying snap of spice and cheese. Cheese-lovers can go straight for a gooey, golden pie, while meat eaters snag a Meat Eater slice piled with hearty toppings.
For something playful, the mac and cheese pizza is creamy and nostalgic, while buffalo chicken brings a kick with tangy sauce. Veggie fans get garden-fresh balance with peppers, onions, olives, and mushrooms. The Alfredo and white-style pies offer a rich, garlicky alternative to red sauce. Thin crust lovers and pan enthusiasts both find their happy place as new trays roll out.
If you do not see your favorite, ask; staff often take requests and add it to the rotation when possible. Every pass by the buffet feels like a new chapter. Build a plate that matches your mood, then switch gears on the next round without missing a beat.
5. The Cinnamon Rolls Factor: Sweet Legends
Ask any regular and they will mention the cinnamon rolls. Warm, soft, and glazed, they arrive in trays that empty fast, with that bakery-sweet aroma that signals it is dessert time. The dessert pizzas also draw a crowd, from icing-drizzled cinnamon swirls to chocolatey options depending on the day.
There is something about ending a salty, savory lineup with a sugary finish that feels just right. Kids often make a beeline for them, but adults play along without hesitation. The trick is to snag them when they are fresh, then circle back if a new batch lands. Pair a sweet slice with a final piece of savory pizza for the full Cicis experience.
The balance of warm spice, soft dough, and glaze is a simple pleasure that lives up to the hype. Save room on your plate. Better yet, start dessert early and come back for more.
6. Why Locals Love It: Real Voices
Fairfield residents keep Cicis in their weekly rotation because it is easy, tasty, and unfussy. Parents talk about feeding the whole crew without negotiation or stress. Students appreciate the value after class or practice, where a quick bite can turn into an affordable feast.
You will hear regulars say things like “We finish soccer and head straight here,” or “The cinnamon rolls are my victory lap.” Another favorite line: “I planned on two slices, then tried six.” The staff’s pace and friendliness add to the loyalty, along with the willingness to bring out requested pies when possible. People love knowing they can mix salad, pasta, and pizza in one sitting. It is a place that rewards spontaneity and second helpings.
When locals say “dangerously good,” they mean it is tough to stop at one plate. The buffet turns dinner into a fun routine that feels satisfying every time.
7. Budget-Friendly Feasting: Big Value
Cicis is known for value, and the Fairfield location follows suit with an all-you-can-eat price that keeps families and students coming back. One reasonable cost opens the door to pizzas, salad, pasta, and dessert, making it easy to feed a group without doing mental math.
Daily offerings and deals vary by location, but you can expect wallet-friendly pricing at lunch and dinner, plus kid-friendly options. The pay-once approach encourages tasting widely without worrying about add-ons. It is perfect for busy weeknights, team celebrations, and after-school hunger. Fountain drinks are available, and you can opt for water if you are keeping costs low.
With so many choices included, everyone walks out full and happy. It is comfort food without sticker shock. Check posted pricing before you go, but expect a feast that respects your budget. Value is part of why locals call it “dangerously good.” Satisfaction per dollar is hard to beat here.
8. The “Dangerously Good” Reputation Explained
The phrase catches on because Cicis combines variety, speed, and craveable flavors. Fresh pies rotate so quickly that curiosity turns into a cycle of taste-and-repeat. Bold options like buffalo chicken sit alongside comfort classics, and the cinnamon rolls add a sweet finale that hooks newcomers.
The buffet format keeps momentum high, so nobody waits long for the next slice. Families like that every preference gets covered without complicated orders. Groups enjoy the freedom to try a bit of everything. The result is a meal that feels fun, unpretentious, and hard to quit. You come for a slice, leave after a sampling tour that stretched further than expected.
No wonder locals joke about self-control being optional. “Dangerously good” fits because the only risk is wanting just one more round.
9. Tips For First-Timers: How To Win The Buffet
Come during off-peak hours for the most relaxed experience, typically mid-afternoon or early dinner on weekdays. Start with a quick salad to pace yourself, then sample two or three pizza styles before committing to favorites.
If you do not see something you want, kindly ask the staff; they often can add it to the cycle. Keep an eye on the dessert station and grab cinnamon rolls when a fresh tray lands. Hydrate, take short breaks, and save room for a final lap. Share slices with your table to try more without overdoing it early. Kids love building their own plates, so let them explore.
If you plan for a group, call ahead to make seating easy. Most of all, lean into the fun and variety. The joy is in discovering that next great slice you did not expect to love.
10. Beyond The Buffet: Games And Good Times
Part of the charm at Cicis is the casual playtime energy. Many locations, including Fairfield, feature a game area that keeps kids entertained and groups smiling between slices. Think simple arcade fun that pairs perfectly with a laid-back meal.
It turns dinner into an easy outing where everyone gets to move around and enjoy themselves. The dining room layout supports large parties, birthday gatherings, and team celebrations. Parents appreciate the visibility, and kids love earning one more token before dessert. This playful vibe keeps the experience light and memorable.
It is not just about food; it is about feeling welcome and relaxed. With affordable plates and an upbeat atmosphere, the time flies as fast as the trays refresh. Eat, play, repeat, then finish strong with a warm cinnamon roll.
11. Nearby Attractions: Make A Day Of It
Fairfield sits within the Cincinnati metro area, so pairing Cicis with local fun is easy. Nearby, you can explore parks like Harbin Park for trails and wide-open greens. Shopping and entertainment options surround the area, making the buffet a convenient pit stop.
For indoor play, venues around the corridor offer movies and family activities to round out an afternoon. If you are visiting from out of town, the drive from Cincinnati is straightforward, with quick access back to highways. Plan a casual itinerary: a walk in the park, a round of games, and then a victory plate at Cicis.
The location’s convenience is part of its appeal. You can build a whole day without straying far. Finish with dessert pizza and call it a perfect Fairfield outing.
Dear Reader: This page may contain affiliate links which may earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase. Our independent journalism is not influenced by any advertiser or commercial initiative unless it is clearly marked as sponsored content. As travel products change, please be sure to reconfirm all details and stay up to date with current events to ensure a safe and successful trip.
