10 Low-Key Virginia Spots Serving Pepperoni Pizza Locals Call The Best In The State

Think you’ve already tasted the best pepperoni pizza Virginia has to offer? You might want to take another bite.

Step away from the predictable chain spots lining every shopping center and follow the locals instead. The real pizza legends are hiding in plain sight inside humble storefronts, old converted gas stations, and family-run kitchens where recipes are guarded like heirlooms and every pie comes out blistered, bubbling, and unforgettable.

This is where the cheese pulls stretch dramatically with every slice, where pepperoni crisps into perfect little cups, and where the crust crackles just enough before giving way to that soft, chewy center.

Virginia’s pizza scene is far more serious than outsiders expect. From small-town favorites to city staples that spark heated debates, each region has its own champion that residents defend with fierce loyalty.

Some swear by paper-thin crust with a charred edge. Others demand thick, airy dough piled high with molten cheese and spicy rounds of pepperoni.

No matter which side you claim, one thing is certain: these ten spots have earned their reputations the old-fashioned way, one perfectly baked slice at a time.

Get ready for bold sauce, generous toppings, and the kind of neighborhood pride that turns a simple pepperoni pizza into a statewide obsession.

1. Andy’s Pizza

Old Town Alexandria holds plenty of historic charm, but locals know the real treasure is tucked on South Patrick Street. Andy’s Pizza has been slinging authentic New York-style pies that make transplants weep with nostalgia and converts out of skeptics.

The thin crust crackles under your teeth before giving way to a perfectly chewy interior. That’s the hallmark of a proper New York slice, and Andy’s nails it every single time.

Their Pepperoni Special showcases cupping pepperoni that forms tiny grease pools bursting with flavor.

Walk inside and you’ll find a no-frills setup where the focus stays squarely on what matters. The aroma hits you immediately, that intoxicating blend of baking dough, bubbling cheese, and sizzling meat.

Families squeeze into booths while solo diners belly up to the counter.

What sets this spot apart is consistency. You could visit monthly for a year and never get a subpar slice.

The team behind the counter moves with practiced efficiency, sliding pies in and out of the oven with perfect timing.

Awards and accolades line the walls, but the real testament comes from the steady stream of regulars. These folks could eat anywhere in the bustling Old Town food scene, yet they choose Andy’s time and again.

That kind of loyalty doesn’t happen by accident.

Located at 1504 Commonwealth Avenue in Alexandria, this pizzeria proves that sometimes the simplest approach yields the most satisfying results. No gimmicks, no fusion experiments, just honest pizza done exceptionally well.

2. Pizzoco Pizza Parlor

Winchester’s most unexpected pizza paradise lives inside what used to pump gasoline. Pizzoco Pizza Parlor transformed a former service station into a thriving neighborhood hangout where craft meets comfort in every bite.

The Hot Honey Pepperoni pizza has achieved near-mythical status among regulars. Sweet heat dances across your tongue as the honey’s gentle warmth plays against the pepperoni’s savory richness.

It’s a flavor combination that sounds risky but tastes absolutely brilliant.

Small-batch crafted meats make all the difference here. The owners obsess over sourcing quality ingredients, and it shows in every component.

The cheese stretches luxuriously, the sauce strikes that elusive sweet-tangy balance, and the crust provides structural integrity without turning into cardboard.

Exposed ductwork and industrial lighting nod to the building’s automotive past while creating an unexpectedly hip atmosphere. Families feel comfortable here, but so do couples on date night and groups of friends celebrating Friday.

Winchester might not be the first Virginia city that comes to mind for culinary adventures, but Pizzoco puts it firmly on the pizza map. The converted space gives diners something to talk about beyond just the food, though the pies certainly dominate the conversation.

You’ll find this gem at 2968 Valley Avenue in Winchester. The parking lot that once served cars now accommodates pizza pilgrims willing to drive across the state.

That former gas station serves up fuel of a different kind these days, the kind that powers happiness instead of engines.

3. Tony’s

Manassas has watched trends come and go since Tony’s opened its doors, but this stalwart refuses to chase fads. The philosophy here is refreshingly straightforward: make a damn good pepperoni pizza and keep making it the same way forever.

Northern Virginia locals speak about Tony’s with a reverence typically reserved for family heirlooms. Multiple generations have grown up on these slices, creating memories tied to that first stretchy cheese pull or the satisfaction of folding a slice lengthwise for easier eating.

Nothing about the interior screams Instagram-worthy, and that’s precisely the point. Laminate tables, simple booths, and fluorescent lighting create an environment where pretension dies at the door.

You come here for substance, not style.

The pepperoni pizza achieves what so many others attempt but fumble: balance. Not too greasy, not too dry.

Not overwhelmingly spiced, but far from bland. The crust provides enough structure to support the toppings without requiring a fork and knife.

Consistency matters more than innovation in the pizza world, and Tony’s understands this fundamental truth. Regulars order with confidence, knowing their pie will taste exactly like it did last week, last month, or even last year.

Located at 7971 Euclid Avenue in Manassas, Tony’s represents everything right about neighborhood pizza joints. No celebrity chef endorsements, no viral TikTok moments, just reliable deliciousness that keeps people coming back.

Sometimes the real deal doesn’t need bells and whistles, just quality ingredients handled with care and respect for tradition.

4. Teddy’s Pizza & Subs

Historic Middleburg exudes old-world charm with its brick sidewalks and colonial architecture, and Teddy’s fits right into that tradition of doing things properly. This small shop doesn’t rely on flashy marketing because the pizza speaks for itself, loudly and deliciously.

Self-proclaimed pizza snobs throughout Virginia point to Teddy’s when debates about the state’s best pepperoni pie heat up. That’s high praise considering how passionate people get about their pizza preferences.

The secret lies in obsessive attention to ingredient quality.

Fresh mozzarella stretches in those satisfying strings that make for perfect food photos, assuming you can resist devouring your slice long enough to snap a picture. The flavor balance hits that sweet spot where no single element dominates but everything works together harmoniously.

Middleburg’s equestrian culture brings a sophisticated crowd that appreciates quality without stuffiness. Teddy’s captures that vibe perfectly, offering elevated ingredients in a down-to-earth setting where everyone feels welcome.

The shop’s compact size means you might wait during peak hours, but regulars consider that a small price for excellence. Limited seating encourages a quick turnover, though many customers grab their pizza and head to nearby parks for an impromptu picnic.

You’ll discover Teddy’s at 2 East Washington Street in Middleburg, right in the heart of this charming town. The location makes it perfect for a post-shopping refuel or a destination lunch worth the drive.

Pizza snobs earned their reputation through discerning taste, so when they unanimously praise a spot, smart people listen and make the pilgrimage.

5. Pungo Pizza & Ice Cream

Virginia Beach’s Pungo neighborhood maintains a distinct identity separate from the tourist-packed oceanfront, and Pungo Pizza & Ice Cream serves as its delicious heart. This easygoing establishment combines two perfect comfort foods under one roof, though the pizza earns most of the glory.

Authentic taste means different things to different people, but locals agree that Pungo Pizza nails the fundamentals. The pepperoni pizza delivers exactly what you crave without unnecessary complications or trendy twists.

Sometimes straightforward beats clever.

Families dominate the dining room, and for good reason. The atmosphere welcomes kids without catering exclusively to them, striking that difficult balance where adults don’t feel like they’re eating in a playground.

High chairs and booster seats appear as needed, but so do couples enjoying date night.

The ice cream component provides the perfect dessert option, especially during Virginia’s sweltering summers. Finishing a hot pizza with a cold cone feels like a complete experience, a one-stop satisfaction station that keeps families from making multiple stops.

Residents recommend Pungo Pizza with the confidence that comes from repeated positive experiences. In a city dominated by seafood restaurants and tourist traps, finding a reliable neighborhood pizza spot feels like striking gold.

This place delivers that reliability consistently.

Located at 1984 Princess Anne Road in Virginia Beach, Pungo Pizza serves the local community with genuine appreciation for their support. The family-friendly vibe extends beyond just tolerating children to actually creating an environment where everyone relaxes and enjoys themselves.

That’s increasingly rare and deeply valued by those who live nearby.

6. Benny Marzano’s

Blacksburg’s college town energy pulses through Benny Marzano’s, where the Virginia Slices have achieved legendary status among students and alumni alike. These aren’t your average slices, they’re fourteen-inch behemoths that challenge your jaw’s structural capacity and your stomach’s storage limits.

A local rite of passage involves attempting to finish an entire Virginia Slice in one sitting. Many try, fewer succeed, but everyone leaves impressed by the sheer audacity of the portion size.

The pepperoni slice remains the most popular choice, proving that sometimes bigger really is better.

College budgets appreciate the cheap prices that don’t sacrifice quality. Students scraping together change can still afford a satisfying meal, and that accessibility creates fierce loyalty that lasts well beyond graduation.

Alumni visiting Blacksburg inevitably make a pilgrimage here.

The atmosphere buzzes with youthful energy, especially during football season when Virginia Tech fans pack the place before and after games. Maroon and orange decorations remind everyone whose territory this is, and the staff embraces the school spirit wholeheartedly.

Enormous slices require structural engineering to eat properly. The fold technique becomes essential, and watching newcomers struggle with their first Virginia Slice provides endless entertainment for seasoned veterans.

Napkins disappear quickly, and dignity takes a temporary vacation.

You’ll find Benny Marzano’s serving Blacksburg’s hungry masses with portions that defy logic and prices that defy inflation. The massive slices represent more than just pizza, they’re edible memories that students carry with them long after leaving Virginia.

Sometimes the best local favorites are the ones that embrace excess unapologetically and deliciously.

7. 8 1/2

Richmond’s pizza scene exploded in recent years, but 8 1/2 quickly rose above the noise to claim its throne. Locals fiercely debate many things, but they’ve reached surprising consensus that this spot serves the best New York-style pizza in the city.

The pepperoni and hot honey combination sounds trendy, and it is, but the execution elevates it beyond gimmick status into genuine deliciousness. House-made ranch provides the cooling counterpoint that ties everything together.

Some purists scoff at ranch with pizza, but one taste converts the skeptics.

A dedicated following developed almost overnight, the kind of rapid loyalty that restaurants dream about but rarely achieve. Social media buzz certainly helped, but word-of-mouth from satisfied customers did the heavy lifting.

People genuinely want their friends to experience this pizza.

The open kitchen concept lets diners watch their pizzas come together, adding entertainment value to the meal. Seeing the dough tossed, the toppings arranged, and the pie sliding into the oven builds anticipation that makes that first bite even more satisfying.

Richmond’s food scene has matured considerably, shedding its reputation as a culinary backwater. 8 1/2 represents this new era, combining quality ingredients with creative touches while respecting traditional techniques. The city finally has pizza worth bragging about.

Located at 3101 West Cary Street in Richmond, 8 1/2 occupies a prime spot in the Carytown district. The address puts it in the middle of the city’s most walkable neighborhood, surrounded by shops and bars that make it easy to build an entire evening around your pizza pilgrimage.

That hot honey drizzle might just change your entire perspective on what pizza can be.

8. The Pizza Box

Coastal Virginia boasts plenty of dining options, but The Pizza Box has carved out a special place in local hearts through unwavering commitment to quality. This family-owned business treats every pizza like it’s going to their own dinner table, and that care shows in every bite.

High-quality ingredients cost more, but cutting corners would betray everything The Pizza Box stands for. The owners understand that building a reputation takes years while destroying one takes minutes.

Their pepperoni pizza showcases this philosophy with ingredients that taste noticeably fresher and more flavorful.

The sauce deserves special mention for achieving that elusive perfect seasoning. Too many pizzerias rely on canned sauce dumped straight from the tin, but The Pizza Box crafts theirs with attention to balance.

Sweetness, acidity, and herbs dance together without any single note overwhelming the others.

A perfectly cooked crust provides the foundation for everything else. Too doughy and it becomes filling without satisfaction.

Too crispy and it shatters into crumbs. The Pizza Box hits that Goldilocks zone where the crust supports the toppings while adding its own subtle flavor.

Many locals stake their reputation on calling this the best pizza in Coastal Virginia, a bold claim in a region with no shortage of options. That confidence comes from repeat experiences that consistently deliver satisfaction without disappointment or regret.

You’ll find The Pizza Box at 3204 Pacific Avenue in Virginia Beach, close enough to the ocean to feel the coastal vibe without the tourist chaos. The family ownership shines through in the personal touches and genuine hospitality that make customers feel valued rather than processed.

Quality ingredients handled with care by people who genuinely care about their craft, that’s a recipe worth celebrating.

9. Jackleg Pizza Company

Warrenton’s Jackleg Pizza Company refuses to pick sides in the crust debate, offering both sourdough and Detroit-style options that satisfy different cravings. This flexibility demonstrates confidence rather than indecision, the mark of pizzamakers who’ve mastered multiple techniques.

Detroit-style pizza remains relatively uncommon in Virginia, making Jackleg’s version a special treat for those who appreciate the thick, crispy-edged rectangular format. The Detroit Pepperoni earns consistent praise from regulars who describe it with words like amazing and incredible, high bars to clear in the competitive pizza world.

Thick, crispy edges provide textural contrast that thin-crust pizzas can’t match. The caramelized cheese that forms along the pan’s perimeter creates a crunchy, savory frame around the softer center.

It’s a completely different eating experience that converts people who thought they only liked thin crust.

Savory toppings get amplified by the Detroit-style preparation method, which allows the pepperoni to crisp up beautifully while releasing flavorful oils that soak into the cheese and dough. The result tastes richer and more intense than standard pizza without becoming heavy or greasy.

Local favorites earn that status through consistency and quality, not flashy marketing campaigns. Jackleg built its reputation slice by slice, customer by customer, good experience by good experience.

That grassroots loyalty proves more durable than any advertising blitz.

Located at 6 Diagonal Street in Warrenton, Jackleg Pizza Company brings artisan pizza craft to a town that might not expect it. The sourdough and Detroit-style options give customers legitimate choices rather than just different topping combinations on identical crusts.

Sometimes offering something genuinely different beats trying to perfect the same thing everyone else makes.

10. Brooklyn Pizza Authority

Midlothian’s Brooklyn Pizza Authority stands out not just for excellent pizza but for sparkling cleanliness that immediately impresses visitors. Owner-operated establishments often show this level of care because someone’s personal reputation rides on every detail, from the bathroom to the basil.

Neighborhood treasures become gathering places where faces turn familiar and orders get memorized. Brooklyn Pizza Authority achieved this status by treating customers like neighbors rather than transactions.

That personal touch transforms a business into a community institution.

Pepperoni slices deliver classic satisfaction, but the pepperoni-stuffed pinwheels showcase creative thinking without abandoning tradition. These spiral creations pack pepperoni and cheese into rolled dough that bakes into portable perfection.

They’re fun, tasty, and different enough to make you take notice.

Fresh flavor defines every bite at Brooklyn Pizza Authority, from the first taste to the last crumb. The homemade marinara provides the kind of bright, herb-forward taste that only comes from scratch cooking.

Jarred sauce simply can’t compete with the real thing made by people who care.

Highly recommended status comes from consistency across multiple visits and menu items. One great experience might be luck, but repeated excellence requires skill, dedication, and quality systems.

Brooklyn Pizza Authority clearly has all three working in harmony.

You’ll discover this gem at 13617 Midlothian Turnpike in Midlothian, where the owner’s pride shows in every corner. The sparkling clean environment and homemade marinara represent a philosophy that values quality over shortcuts.

When someone’s name is on the door, they tend to care more deeply about every single customer’s experience, and that care translates directly into better pizza.