Fresh ownership has given a longtime Ohio country market a second chapter. Earlier this year, a local couple took over a former Amish-style grocery store, reopened it under a new name, and brought their own vision of old-fashioned shopping to the community.
Inside, the focus remains on everyday favorites: bulk spices, baking supplies, fresh bread, sliced meats, cheeses, and sandwiches prepared to order. Customers can pick up lunch while browsing pantry staples and small gifts, all under one roof.
I like how the owners have kept the familiar country-store feeling while giving the business a fresh identity. The combination of practical groceries and personal service makes it different from an ordinary supermarket run.
For longtime shoppers, the reopening means a familiar destination has survived a change in ownership. For newcomers, it offers a chance to discover a neighborhood business finding its feet again.
A Fresh Coat Of Life For An Old-Fashioned Favorite
New owners, a refreshed space, and the same old-fashioned country-store spirit. Ole Tyme Market in Marysville, Ohio, began its new chapter in early 2026 when Wendell and Abby Hostetler took over the former Amish Heritage Country Market.
The couple reopened the business with a focus on bulk foods, pantry staples, freshly sliced deli meats, cheeses, and made-to-order sandwiches. Their goal was to preserve the welcoming atmosphere of a traditional country store while building something of their own.
The recent remodel gives the store a cleaner, brighter feel. Shelves look tidy, aisles feel open, and the whole place reads as cheerful rather than dusty.
That matters more than you might think. A small market lives or dies on whether people want to linger, and a clean, welcoming room helps a lot.
The owners also seem to enjoy talking with customers. They reply to online feedback personally, often thanking shoppers by first name.
That kind of attention fits the old-fashioned spirit of the place. It feels less like a chain store and more like a neighbor who happens to sell groceries.
Fresh starts can be risky for beloved local shops. Regulars worry the charm will vanish, or the prices will jump overnight.
Here, the new chapter looks more like a polish than a total makeover. The bulk foods, deli counter, and quirky extras still anchor the experience.
So if you knew the old version, expect familiar comforts in a sharper package. If you are new, you are arriving at a pretty good moment.
Check The Boxes And Let The Deli Do The Rest
Paper and pencil still win at this deli counter. You grab an order sheet, fill in what you want, and hand it over.
It sounds almost too simple. Yet that little sheet keeps things clear, quick, and friendly for both sides of the counter.
Every sandwich is made to order with fresh bread, meats, and cheeses. You choose the combination, so picky eaters and bold eaters both get their way.
One popular pairing is turkey with hot pepper cheese on sourdough sandwich bread. It brings a little kick without overwhelming the turkey.
Portions lean generous on the meat and cheese. Lunch here is not the sad, thin sandwich you grab at a gas station.
The honey mustard deserves its own mention. It shows up as a favorite topping, and it may become your new default.
The market shares its sandwich offerings on Facebook, which has pulled in plenty of curious first-timers. A social media post can be a dangerous thing on an empty stomach.
Planning a stop? The market is open Tuesday through Friday from 9 a.m. to 5 p.m. and Saturday from 9 a.m. to 4 p.m.
It is closed on Mondays and Sundays.
That makes this an easy lunch-break mission rather than a late dinner plan. Fill out your sheet, wait a few minutes, and enjoy something built exactly your way.
Sweet Bologna Might Just Steal The Show
Sweet bologna. If those two words made you smile, you already understand part of the appeal here.
The deli case at Ole Tyme Market is a big reason people keep coming back. Fresh-sliced meats and cheeses fill the counter, ready for your fridge or tonight’s sandwiches.
Sweet bologna has a special following in Ohio and nearby Amish communities. It has a smoky, slightly sweet flavor that tastes nothing like the lunchbox stuff.
Beyond bologna, the case covers the classics you would expect. Think turkey, ham, and a range of cheeses that work for snacking or stacking.
Prices on deli meats are a strong point too. That makes it easier to buy a full week of lunches without wincing at the register.
Here is a tip worth remembering. Ask for slices cut the way you like, whether thin for sandwiches or thicker for snacking.
A good deli counter turns ordinary weeknight meals into something better. A grilled cheese with quality cheese is a whole different experience.
Kids can also get in on the fun. Letting them pick one new meat or cheese to try is a sneaky way to expand their taste buds.
Start with the sweet bologna, then branch out. Your shopping list may get longer each visit, and that is perfectly fine.
Fresh Bread And Sweet Treats Worth The Detour
Red Hen sourdough has earned a loyal fan club at this shop. The loaves come from a local baker, and they disappear into plenty of shopping bags.
Good sourdough makes everything better. Toast it, build a sandwich, or tear off a piece on the drive home.
Rhubarb bread is another standout on the bakery side. Rhubarb brings a tart, bright flavor that feels very country-kitchen.
Cheesecake also shows up as a favorite. It’s a handy dessert to grab when you are expected to bring something to dinner.
Ole Tyme Market carries a lot of local foods in general. That means your money supports nearby makers, not just distant factories.
Fresh baked goods can sell out, which is normal at smaller markets. Earlier visits give you the best shot at the full lineup.
Saturday hours run shorter, closing at 2 p.m. So weekend bread hunters should not plan a lazy afternoon arrival.
Pair a sourdough loaf with something from the deli case. Suddenly you have a picnic, a lunch spread, or an easy dinner with almost no effort.
Local bread rarely tastes like the bagged stuff in big stores. One bite, and you may start planning your week around a bread run.
Toys, Candles, And Surprises You Won’t See Elsewhere
Groceries and toys share the same roof here, which is a delightful twist. The store keeps a fun section of toys that you won’t easily find elsewhere in town.
That makes it a sneaky gift stop. Birthday party this weekend?
You might solve that problem while buying lunch meat.
Candles and home goods round out the mix. They add a cozy, browse-worthy feel that most grocery stores skip entirely.
Shopping with kids gets a little easier too. A quick peek at the toys can work as a reward for patient helpers.
Fair warning, though. Little ones may suddenly develop strong opinions about which toy needs to come home.
Candy fans should set expectations, since the store is not a full candy shop. The focus stays on food, bulk goods, and these fun extras.
Unique gifts carry more meaning than generic store-bought ones. A candle or toy from a local market feels thoughtful and personal.
The variety also reflects the store’s old-fashioned roots. Country markets have long mixed practical goods with small treats and household finds.
Leave a few extra minutes for browsing. You came for sandwiches, but you might leave with a holiday gift checked off your list.
Old-Fashioned Service Still Rules The Counter
Friendly faces might be the store’s best product. The staff and owners at Ole Tyme Market are known for warm, old-fashioned customer service.
That reputation shows up again and again. People mention cheerful workers, helpful answers, and a genuinely welcoming feel.
Cleanliness also stands out. The shop stays neat and tidy, which matters a lot when you’re buying fresh deli food.
Small details tell the story. The owners personally thank shoppers online, often by name, for taking time to share feedback.
Customer requests get real attention as well. When someone asks for a product, the team works to bring it in.
Big-box stores rarely offer that kind of back-and-forth. Here, you’re more than a receipt number.
Supporting local businesses keeps communities lively. Every sandwich and sack of spices helps a family-run shop grow in Marysville, Ohio.
So say hello at the counter. Ask what’s fresh, what’s new, or what the staff would put on their own sandwich.
You might pick up a great tip. At the very least, you’ll leave with better groceries and a friendlier start to your day.
Plan Your Stop On North Main Before Closing Time
Finding the place is the easy part. Ole Tyme Market sits at 728 N Main St, Marysville, OH 43040.
Main Street location means it’s handy for quick errands. You can swing by on a lunch break or between other stops around town.
Hours are worth checking before you go. Ole Tyme Market opens Tuesday through Friday from 9 a.m. to 5 p.m., with Saturday hours running from 9 a.m. to 4 p.m.
The store is closed on Mondays and Sundays. Saturday visitors have a little more time to browse than the shorter schedule might suggest, but checking for holiday changes is still a good idea.
Morning visits make good sense for bread and baked goods. Smaller markets restock in batches, and favorites can sell out.
Bringing a cooler is a smart move. Deli meats, cheese, and bulk chicken stay happier on a longer drive home.
Marysville sits northwest of Columbus, which makes this a doable trip for central Ohio shoppers. It pairs nicely with a day of local errands.
Keep a running list on your phone between visits. Spices, sourdough, cheese ends, and a gift or two can fill a basket fast.
A fresh start deserves fresh customers. Stop in, grab an order sheet, and see what this revived little market has in store.
