Ohio is home to some of the most nostalgic ice cream parlors, where flavors and memories blend together in perfect harmony.
From century-old establishments to modern classics, these ice cream parlors offer a sweet taste of childhood nostalgia. Join us as we explore eight must-visit spots that promise a delightful trip down memory lane.
1. Graeter’s Ice Cream
Graeter’s Ice Cream, with its roots dating back to 1870 in Cincinnati, is a timeless classic known for its French Pot method. The rich, creamy texture of Graeter’s ice cream has been a family favorite for generations. Their Black Raspberry Chocolate Chip is legendary, with massive chunks of chocolate that delight every bite.
The parlor’s old-world charm, complete with marble counters and vintage furnishings, evokes a sense of nostalgia. Graeter’s provides a cozy atmosphere where families can create lasting memories. Many locals recall childhood visits, making it a must-stop for those in search of tradition.
The secretive yet intriguing methods of their ice cream-making continue to draw crowds eager to taste history.
2. Mitchell’s Ice Cream
Mitchell’s Ice Cream in Cleveland, founded by brothers Pete and Mike Mitchell in 1999, offers a fresh and local approach to this beloved treat. Known for sourcing ingredients locally, their ice cream connects the community through flavor. The shop’s Toasted Pistachio and Wildberry Crumble are among the favorites.
Inside, the modern yet welcoming design invites patrons to relax and savor their selections. The open kitchen allows guests to witness the crafting process, adding an interactive element to their visit.
Mitchell’s commitment to sustainability and local partnerships ensures that each cone is not just a treat, but a celebration of Cleveland’s vibrant food scene.
3. Jeni’s Splendid Ice Creams
Jeni’s Splendid Ice Creams in Columbus is renowned for its innovative flavors and artisanal approach. Founded by Jeni Britton Bauer in 2002, the shop quickly became a favorite for those seeking something new. Their signature flavor, Brambleberry Crisp, combines sweet-tart jam and crunchy oat streusel.
The inviting, bright interior and commitment to quality ingredients set Jeni’s apart from conventional parlors. Each scoop tells a story, often sparking conversations among patrons enjoying their treats.
4. Aglamesis Bro’s
Aglamesis Bro’s in Cincinnati is a step back in time, offering an authentic ice cream parlor experience since 1908. Known for their handcrafted ice creams and chocolates, this parlor exudes a nostalgic charm. Their signature flavor, Opera Cream, is a must-try for new visitors.
The elegant interior, complete with original fixtures and a soda fountain, transports guests to a bygone era. The old-world ambiance and friendly service make it a popular destination for families and date nights alike.
Aglamesis Bro’s dedication to tradition ensures that every visit feels like a special occasion, bridging generations through its timeless offerings.
5. Johnson’s Real Ice Cream
Johnson’s Real Ice Cream in Bexley has been a community favorite since 1950. Known for its friendly service and homemade flavors, this family-owned shop offers a warm and welcoming atmosphere. Their signature Buckeye Fever flavor, rich with peanut butter and chocolate, is a local favorite.
The shop’s simple, classic decor and outdoor seating invite patrons to relax and enjoy their treats. Each visit to Johnson’s is a reminder of the simpler joys in life, where ice cream is a cherished family tradition.
6. Tom’s Ice Cream Bowl
Tom’s Ice Cream Bowl in Zanesville is a local legend, delighting visitors since 1948 with its generous servings and classic flavors. Known for its traditional sundaes and malts, Tom’s offers a genuine taste of nostalgia. The Peanut Butter Sundae is particularly popular among regulars.
The charming retro decor, complete with an old-fashioned soda fountain, adds to the experience, making each visit memorable. It’s a place where time seems to slow down, allowing guests to savor both their ice cream and the moment.
7. Handel’s Homemade Ice Cream
Since 1945, Handel’s Homemade Ice Cream in Youngstown has been serving classic flavors that resonate with simplicity and taste. Known for their generous portions and creamy texture, Handel’s offers a delightful array of flavors from Butter Pecan to Chocolate Raspberry Truffle.
The quaint, no-frills exterior is part of its charm, reminiscent of simpler times. It’s not uncommon to see families lined up, eager to enjoy their favorite scoops on a warm summer evening.
Handel’s commitment to tradition and quality makes it a beloved spot, where the ice cream is as much about the experience as it is about the flavor.
8. Toft Dairy Ice Cream Parlor
Established in 1900, Toft Dairy Ice Cream Parlor in Sandusky is Ohio’s oldest dairy and a beloved destination for ice cream fans. Known for its expansive flavor selection, including the famous Sea Salt Caramel, Toft’s is a treat for the taste buds.
The parlor’s vibrant atmosphere and friendly service create a delightful setting for families to gather and enjoy. The rich history and commitment to quality are evident in every scoop, making Toft a cherished part of the local community.
With over a century of experience, Toft Dairy continues to provide sweet memories for new generations of ice cream enthusiasts.
Dear Reader: This page may contain affiliate links which may earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase. Our independent journalism is not influenced by any advertiser or commercial initiative unless it is clearly marked as sponsored content. As travel products change, please be sure to reconfirm all details and stay up to date with current events to ensure a safe and successful trip.
