10 Ohio Pizza Spots Often Compared To New York Favorites

Pizza lovers know that New York sets the gold standard for thin crust, foldable slices, and that perfect crispy-to-chewy bite.

But you don’t have to travel to the Big Apple to get your fix.

Ohio is home to some seriously impressive pizzerias that capture the authentic flavors and techniques of classic New York pies.

From wood-fired ovens to that famous cup-and-burn pepperoni, these spots have earned their reputation among locals and transplants alike.

Whether you’re craving a massive slice that folds just right or a whole pie with that signature thin crust, Ohio has you covered.

Owners who grew up in Brooklyn, chefs who studied the craft in Manhattan, and passionate pizza makers who perfected the art have brought East Coast excellence to the Midwest.

Get ready to explore the best of both worlds as we take you through ten outstanding Ohio locations where New York style pizza thrives.

1. Sexton’s Pizza

Central Ohio residents rave about this pizzeria that delivers an experience remarkably close to biting into a slice from Joe’s Pizza in Manhattan.

The thin, crispy crust achieves that ideal balance between crunch and chew that New Yorkers demand.

What really sets this spot apart is the famous cup-and-burn pepperoni that curls up and crisps at the edges when it hits the heat.

Locals who have lived in both cities swear this is the real deal.

The baking technique here mirrors traditional New York methods, creating a crust that holds up when you fold your slice in half.

No soggy bottoms or doughy centers, just authentic pizza perfection.

Regulars appreciate the straightforward approach to toppings and the quality of ingredients used in every pie.

The atmosphere feels unpretentious and welcoming, much like the neighborhood joints you’d find scattered across New York City.

Whether you’re grabbing a quick slice or ordering a whole pizza, the consistency remains impressive.

Transplants from the East Coast have made this their go-to spot when homesickness for proper pizza strikes.

The cheese melts beautifully, the sauce has just the right tang, and every bite transports you straight to the streets of NYC.

Ohio pizza lovers consider this a must-visit destination for anyone serious about authentic New York style pies.

2. Trophy Pizza in Evendale

Situated at 10325 Reading Rd in Evendale, this pizzeria has built a loyal following among those who crave genuine East Coast flavors.

The massive pies here stretch to impressive dimensions, giving you that generous New York experience.

Each slice folds effortlessly without breaking, a true test of proper pizza craftsmanship.

Customers frequently mention feeling like they’ve been transported to a corner spot in Jersey or Manhattan.

The crisp-to-chewy ratio hits that sweet spot that makes New York pizza so addictive.

You can taste the attention to detail in every component, from the perfectly seasoned sauce to the quality mozzarella that stretches with each bite.

The crust develops those characteristic air bubbles and charred spots that signal authentic preparation.

Families and pizza enthusiasts make regular pilgrimages here, often driving from surrounding areas just to grab a pie.

The staff understands what makes New York pizza special and executes it consistently.

Reviews from visitors who grew up eating pizza in Brooklyn or the Bronx confirm this place gets it right.

The texture, flavor profile, and overall experience align with what you’d expect from a top-tier East Coast establishment.

Ohio residents consider themselves lucky to have such an authentic option so close to home, making Trophy Pizza a standout in the region.

3. Aracri Pizzeria

Located at 51 E Gay St in the heart of downtown, this pizzeria has earned high praise from New York transplants who know their pizza.

The thin crust here passes the ultimate test by holding strong when you fold your slice.

No floppy, limp pizza here, just the structural integrity that defines proper New York style.

Visitors describe the experience as legitimately East Coast, capturing both the taste and the feel of grabbing a quick slice in Manhattan.

The downtown location adds to the authentic urban pizza experience.

Office workers and city dwellers stop by for lunch, creating a bustling atmosphere similar to busy New York pizzerias during the workday rush.

The sauce balances sweetness and acidity perfectly, complementing rather than overpowering the quality cheese.

Regulars appreciate the consistency in preparation and the commitment to maintaining traditional methods.

The crust develops a satisfying crunch on the bottom while maintaining enough flexibility to fold.

People who moved to Ohio from Brooklyn or Queens often cite this spot as their favorite local pizza destination.

The attention to authentic technique shows in every pie that comes out of the oven.

Whether you’re a pizza purist or just someone who appreciates quality food, Aracri delivers an experience that stands up to East Coast standards and keeps customers coming back for more.

4. Mike’s Pizza

Canton residents treasure this gem located at 328 Walnut Ave NE for bringing authentic Big Apple flavor to their city.

The wood-burning oven makes all the difference, creating a thin crust that avoids the greasy bottom that plagues many Midwest pizzerias.

That subtle smoky flavor from the wood fire adds another layer of complexity to each bite.

Locals describe it as the most authentic slice of New York you’ll find in this part of Ohio.

The cooking method ensures even heat distribution, resulting in a crust with the perfect char and texture.

Pizza enthusiasts drive from surrounding towns specifically to experience what Mike’s has perfected.

The toppings stay put instead of sliding off, another hallmark of properly made New York style pizza.

Families appreciate the welcoming atmosphere and the quality that goes into every order.

The cheese melts into a beautiful golden layer with just the right amount of stretch.

Customers who have eaten pizza across New York boroughs confirm that Mike’s captures the essence of what makes that style so beloved.

The commitment to traditional wood-fired technique sets this pizzeria apart from competitors who rely on standard ovens.

Whether you’re a Canton local or passing through, stopping at Mike’s Pizza offers a genuine taste of New York craftsmanship right here in Ohio.

5. Brooklyn Pizza

Found at 240 N Liberty St, this pizzeria brings authentic Brooklyn vibes straight to Ohio.

The owner actually hails from New York, bringing firsthand knowledge of what makes pizza truly special.

That personal connection to Brooklyn shows in every aspect of the operation, from the recipes to the overall atmosphere.

Walking in feels like stepping into a neighborhood joint you might find on a tree-lined street in Brooklyn.

The decor, the energy, and most importantly the pizza all capture that distinctive East Coast character.

Transplants from New York report feeling instantly at home when they discover this spot.

The crust achieves that signature thin profile without sacrificing flavor or structural integrity.

Sauce and cheese come together in perfect harmony, creating the classic taste profile New Yorkers grow up loving.

Regulars develop relationships with the staff, much like the familiar faces at neighborhood pizzerias back East.

The menu stays focused on doing the classics exceptionally well rather than trying to reinvent the wheel.

People who know authentic New York pizza recognize immediately that this place gets all the details right.

From the way slices are cut to how they’re served, everything reflects true Brooklyn tradition and keeps customers returning week after week for their pizza fix.

6. Sarefino’s Pizzeria and Italian Deli

Nestled inside North Market at 59 Spruce St, this spot serves up massive slices that rival famous Bleecker Street destinations.

The portion sizes alone make you feel like you’re grabbing a quick bite in Greenwich Village.

Each slice maintains that essential portability factor, perfect for eating while exploring the market.

The texture hits all the right notes, with a crust that folds without breaking and holds toppings securely.

Market visitors often make Sarefino’s their first stop, drawn by the aroma of fresh pizza baking throughout the day.

The deli aspect adds authenticity, offering Italian specialties alongside the pizza selection.

Customers appreciate the convenience of grabbing a genuine New York style slice while shopping or exploring downtown.

The cheese pull when you take that first bite matches what you’d expect from a quality Manhattan pizzeria.

Sauce seasoning leans toward traditional Italian flavors without being too sweet or too acidic.

People who remember eating pizza on the streets of New York find familiar comfort in these generous slices.

The market setting creates a lively, energetic environment similar to the bustling food scenes in New York neighborhoods.

Whether you’re a local regular or a visitor to North Market, Sarefino’s delivers an authentic slice experience that stands up to East Coast comparisons and satisfies serious pizza cravings.

7. Paulie Gee’s

This location at 1195 N High St represents a direct connection to the beloved Brooklyn original.

The expansion brought renowned wood-fired artisanal techniques straight to the Short North neighborhood.

Fans of the original Brooklyn location celebrate having access to the same quality and creativity here in Ohio.

The wood-fired oven imparts distinctive flavor and texture that sets these pies apart from standard offerings.

Each pizza showcases careful attention to ingredient quality and preparation technique.

The menu features both classic styles and creative combinations that honor Italian pizza traditions.

Diners appreciate the elevated approach while maintaining the soul of what makes New York pizza culture so special.

The atmosphere balances casual comfort with a touch of sophistication, reflecting the modern Brooklyn food scene.

Staff members demonstrate knowledge and passion for pizza craft, enhancing the overall experience.

The crust develops beautiful leopard spotting from the intense heat of the wood-fired oven.

Cheese and toppings receive the same meticulous attention as the dough and sauce.

Pizza lovers who track down the best pies across multiple cities include Paulie Gee’s on their must-visit lists.

Having this Brooklyn institution expand to Ohio gives residents access to exceptional pizza without boarding a plane to New York.

8. Courthouse Pizzeria

Positioned at 2 Public Square, this pizzeria receives consistent recommendations from New York pizza enthusiasts.

The crust, sauce, and cheese profile align perfectly with expectations for authentic East Coast style.

Customers who know their pizza inside and out confirm that Courthouse nails the fundamentals.

The location near the courthouse creates steady traffic from downtown workers and visitors alike.

Lunch rushes bring crowds seeking quality pizza that delivers on both taste and value.

The sauce strikes that ideal balance between tangy and savory without overwhelming the other components.

Cheese melts into a cohesive layer that stretches beautifully with each bite.

The crust maintains structural integrity whether you eat it folded or flat.

Regulars develop their favorite combinations while appreciating the consistent execution across all orders.

The straightforward approach focuses on doing classic New York style exceptionally well.

No gimmicks or unnecessary complications, just solid pizza craftsmanship.

People who grew up eating pizza in Manhattan or the Bronx recognize the authentic characteristics immediately.

The downtown setting adds convenience for those working or living in the area, making Courthouse Pizzeria a reliable destination for satisfying New York style cravings right here in Ohio’s urban core.

9. Home Slice Pizza

Toledo residents head to 28 S St Clair St when they want the closest thing to authentic New York pizza available in their area.

Local debates about pizza authenticity often circle back to this spot as the standard bearer.

The style captures essential New York characteristics that set it apart from typical Midwest offerings.

Slices arrive with that signature thin crust that folds naturally and holds toppings securely.

The cheese coverage and sauce distribution reflect attention to proper New York technique.

Customers who have traveled extensively and sampled pizza across multiple cities appreciate what Home Slice accomplishes.

The downtown location serves as a gathering spot for pizza lovers and casual diners alike.

Families, friends, and solo diners all find something to appreciate in the straightforward menu.

The crust develops a satisfying crunch on the exterior while maintaining a tender interior.

Sauce seasoning leans traditional, letting quality tomatoes shine through without heavy spice.

Portions satisfy without overwhelming, staying true to the New York philosophy of balanced eating.

Regular customers defend Home Slice in conversations about where to find real pizza in Toledo.

While purists may always find room for debate, most agree this pizzeria comes closer to New York standards than anywhere else in the region, making it a beloved local institution.

10. Pizzanos Express

Located at 804 Parsons Ave, this pizzeria has captured attention for delivering genuine New York style that rivals spots in Pennsylvania and New Jersey.

The cheese pull here has become legendary among regulars who appreciate quality ingredients.

That satisfying stretch when you lift a slice speaks to proper cheese selection and melting technique.

The buttery, thin crust provides the perfect foundation for classic toppings.

Customers describe the overall profile as matching what they remember from eating pizza in authentic East Coast establishments.

The neighborhood location creates a comfortable, unpretentious environment for enjoying quality pizza.

Families make this their regular spot, knowing they can count on consistent quality every visit.

The sauce brings bright tomato flavor without excessive sweetness or acidity.

Each component works in harmony rather than competing for attention.

Pizza enthusiasts who seek out the best examples of New York style across multiple states include Pizzanos Express in their top recommendations.

The commitment to authentic preparation methods shows in every pie that leaves the kitchen.

Whether you’re a longtime Ohio resident or new to the area, discovering this spot feels like finding a hidden gem.

The combination of quality ingredients, proper technique, and genuine care for the craft makes Pizzanos Express a standout destination for anyone serious about New York style pizza.