Miami’s vibrant culinary scene offers seafood lovers a paradise of fresh catches and ocean views. From historic establishments to trendy waterfront spots, the city serves up delicious seafood in settings that are just as memorable as the food itself.
Whether you’re a local foodie or a camera-ready tourist, these seven seafood restaurants deliver both mouthwatering dishes and Instagram-worthy backdrops.
1. Rusty Pelican: Skyline Views Across Biscayne Bay
Perched on Key Biscayne with floor-to-ceiling windows, the Rusty Pelican offers perhaps the most dramatic dining backdrop in Miami. The panoramic view encompasses the entire downtown skyline reflected in Biscayne Bay’s sparkling waters.
While the setting steals attention, the kitchen ensures the seafood matches the scenery. Lobster risotto arrives with a generous tail perched atop creamy rice, while sushi rolls incorporate tropical Florida flavors like mango and avocado.
Sunset reservations are coveted for the spectacular color show that unfolds across sky and water. After dark, the twinkling city lights create an equally magical atmosphere. Professional photographers often set up tripods on the restaurant’s outdoor terrace to capture time-lapse videos of Miami’s changing light.
2. Joe’s Stone Crab: Classic Plates in a Timeless Setting
A Miami Beach institution since 1913, Joe’s Stone Crab practically invented Florida fine dining. The restaurant’s signature stone crabs arrive with a mustard sauce that’s become legendary among seafood enthusiasts.
Inside, white tablecloths and tuxedoed waiters create an atmosphere of old-school elegance that transports diners to a bygone era. The walls showcase black-and-white photographs documenting the restaurant’s storied history and famous patrons.
Beyond the celebrated claws, don’t miss their key lime pie, widely considered the city’s best. While Joe’s doesn’t take reservations, the wait becomes part of the experience as you mingle with locals and tourists alike in the bustling bar area.
3. Garcia’s Seafood Grille & Fish Market: Waterfront Views on the Miami River
Family-owned since 1966, Garcia’s offers an authentic Miami experience away from the glitzy beach scene. Boats pull directly up to the restaurant’s dock, delivering the day’s catch straight to your plate.
The outdoor terrace provides front-row seats to the working Miami River, where fishing vessels and luxury yachts create a constantly changing waterfront panorama. Order the grilled mahi-mahi or the mixed seafood paella, both prepared with simplicity that lets the freshness shine.
The no-frills atmosphere feels refreshingly honest in a city known for glamour. Sunset transforms the river into a golden pathway, creating perfect lighting conditions for photographers trying to capture Miami’s less touristy side.
4. Seaspice Brasserie & Lounge: Chic Dining Along the Water
Luxury yachts often dock alongside Seaspice, where Miami’s beautiful people come to see and be seen. The restaurant’s industrial-chic design incorporates wood, iron, and glass elements that frame stunning views of the Miami River.
Seafood towers arrive at tables like edible sculptures, piled high with oysters, lobster, and stone crabs on beds of ice. The wood-fired casseroles, cooked in cast-iron pots, make for particularly dramatic photos when they arrive steaming at the table.
Weekends transform Seaspice into a daytime party scene with DJs and champagne flowing freely. Arrive during golden hour when the setting sun bathes the outdoor lounge in warm light, creating a magical backdrop for both food photography and selfies.
5. Stiltsville Fish Bar: Laid-Back Vibes in Sunset Harbor
Named after the famous stilt houses in Biscayne Bay, this Sunset Harbor spot brings casual Florida Keys charm to Miami Beach. The bright turquoise exterior gives way to a nautical interior featuring reclaimed wood, rope accents, and vintage fishing photographs.
Chefs Janine Booth and Jeff McInnis showcase sustainable seafood in creative presentations that honor Old Florida traditions. The smoked fish dip arrives in a glass jar topped with colorful pickled vegetables, while the whole fried snapper becomes a showstopper when it lands on your table.
The breezy outdoor patio offers glimpses of the bay between buildings. For the best light, visit during lunch when the restaurant’s cheerful color palette really pops against the Miami sunshine.
6. Mignonette Downtown: Oyster Bar with Vintage Charm
Housed in a renovated 1930s gas station, Mignonette brings unexpected character to Miami’s restaurant scene. The oyster selection changes daily, displayed on an old-school letter board that hangs prominently on the wall.
Subway tiles and blue leather booths create a space that feels both retro and timeless. The open kitchen allows diners to watch as chefs shuck oysters and plate elegant seafood dishes that contrast beautifully against the restaurant’s minimalist white plates.
Photography enthusiasts appreciate the large windows that flood the space with natural light during daytime hours. The lobster roll, served with a mountain of crispy fries, consistently ranks among the most photographed items on the menu, its vibrant red meat popping against the buttery toasted bun.
7. A Fish Called Avalon: Art Deco Atmosphere on Ocean Drive
Situated in the iconic Avalon Hotel, this restaurant offers front-row seats to Ocean Drive’s famous Art Deco parade. The pastel-colored building with its neon signage creates a distinctly Miami Beach backdrop for your seafood feast.
Banana leaf ceiling fans spin lazily overhead as diners enjoy the signature bang bang shrimp or the paella studded with local seafood. The outdoor tables place you directly in the vibrant street scene, perfect for people-watching while sampling their award-winning key lime pie.
Visit during the blue hour just after sunset when the neon lights of Ocean Drive begin to glow against the darkening sky. The contrast between your elegantly plated seafood and the lively street scene creates photos that perfectly capture the essence of South Beach’s unique charm.
Dear Reader: This page may contain affiliate links which may earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase. Our independent journalism is not influenced by any advertiser or commercial initiative unless it is clearly marked as sponsored content. As travel products change, please be sure to reconfirm all details and stay up to date with current events to ensure a safe and successful trip.
