Pack your sweet tooth and hop on a delightful journey through Indiana, where hidden gems serve up desserts that will make your heart sing and your waistband groan. These cafés might be small, but their flavors are larger than life, and their charm is irresistible.
Let’s take a whimsical tour of ten spots where sugar reigns supreme.
1. MOTW Coffee and Pastries (Fishers)
Walking into MOTW Coffee and Pastries in Fishers feels like stepping into a warm hug. The ambiance wraps you in coziness, and the aroma of freshly baked pastries wafts through the air like an irresistible invitation.
Their lemon scones are legendary, a perfect balance of tartness and sweetness that dance on your taste buds. Pair one with a cup of their rich espresso, and you’ve got yourself a heavenly morning.
The staff here are as delightful as the treats they serve. With every visit, you’ll leave not just with a satisfied sweet tooth but also with a smile that stretches from ear to ear. It’s a place where every bite tells a story.
2. Pots & Pans Pie Co. (Indianapolis)
Pots & Pans Pie Co. in Indianapolis is where pie dreams come to life. This charming little spot is a shrine to all things pie, and stepping inside feels like a comforting trip down memory lane.
Their Hoosier Sugar Cream Pie is a local legend, a creamy delight that melts in your mouth and warms your soul. It’s a pie so good, it’ll have you speaking in pie puns before you’ve finished your slice.
With a nod to nostalgia in every bite, the atmosphere is cozy, the service is friendly, and the pies are, quite simply, divine. Prepare to fall in love, one slice at a time.
3. Café Babette (Indianapolis)
Café Babette in Indianapolis invites you to indulge in a world of elegance with a side of decadence. This café curates an experience that’s as artistic as it is delicious.
Their artisanal éclairs are a work of art, each one crafted with precision and filled with flavors that surprise and delight. Picture yourself savoring one with a perfectly brewed cappuccino.
The vibe here is sophisticated yet welcoming, making it the perfect spot for a luxurious afternoon treat. You’ll leave feeling like you’ve just been part of a Parisian dessert affair.
4. Leviathan Bakehouse (Indianapolis)
Leviathan Bakehouse in Indianapolis is where baking meets brilliance. This bustling bakery is known for its innovative approach to classic favorites, redefining what a bakery should be.
Their croissants are legendary, flaky, buttery, and often filled with delightful surprises like chocolate or almond cream. It’s like a treasure hunt for your taste buds.
The environment buzzes with creativity, as bakers whip up treats that are as visually stunning as they are scrumptious. You’ll find yourself wishing for bottomless pockets to carry home all the baked goodness.
5. Rene’s Bakery (Indianapolis)
Rene’s Bakery in Indianapolis is a sweet nook where passion meets pastry perfection. This quaint spot has been winning hearts with its heavenly confections for years.
Their cinnamon rolls deserve a fan club of their own. Soft, gooey, and topped with just the right amount of icing, they’re an embrace in pastry form.
Despite its modest size, the bakery overflows with warmth and joy, making each visit feel like a homecoming. There’s magic in every bite, and you’ll find yourself returning for more.
6. Amelia’s (Indianapolis)
Amelia’s in Indianapolis is a haven for bread and dessert lovers alike. This artisan bakery takes pride in crafting products that speak of tradition and taste.
Their chocolate babka is the stuff of legends, a sweet, swirly delight that satisfies every chocolate craving imaginable. Pair it with one of their freshly brewed coffees, and you’re in for a treat.
The atmosphere is unpretentious, filled with the comforting aroma of freshly baked bread. Each visit feels like a little escape to a world where desserts reign supreme.
7. Debbie’s Daughters Bakery & Cafe (Noblesville)
Debbie’s Daughters Bakery & Cafe in Noblesville is where family recipes meet community love. This heartfelt spot is a testament to the power of tradition and taste.
Their homemade pies are a true family affair, each slice a tribute to time-honored recipes that have been perfected over generations. You’ll find yourself savoring every bite.
The atmosphere is warm and inviting, with a friendly team that treats you like part of the family. It’s a place where memories are made, one delightful dessert at a time.
8. Creation Cafe – Coffee and Bakery (Danville)
Creation Cafe in Danville is a delightful escape into a world where coffee and desserts coalesce in perfect harmony. This café is a haven for those who appreciate the finer things in life.
Their caramel apple muffins are the star of the show, a sweet and tangy masterpiece that captures the essence of fall in every bite. Add a cup of their expertly brewed coffee, and you’ve got a match made in dessert heaven.
With a warm atmosphere and a penchant for creativity, this café is a must-visit for anyone looking to indulge their sweet cravings with a side of caffeine.
9. My Sugar Pie (Zionsville)
My Sugar Pie in Zionsville is a little slice of pie paradise. This charming spot specializes in crafting pies that are as beautiful as they are delicious.
Their key lime pie is a zesty delight, a perfect balance of sweet and tart that captures the spirit of summer in every bite. It’s a refreshing treat that never fails to impress.
With a focus on quality and a dash of whimsy, My Sugar Pie invites you to enjoy dessert in a way that’s truly special. Each pie is a testament to the art of baking and a joy to savor.
10. Le Croissant French Bakery (Greenwood)
Le Croissant French Bakery in Greenwood transports you straight to the heart of Paris without the airfare. This chic bakery is a celebration of all things French and flaky.
Their almond croissant is a buttery masterpiece, each bite a journey through layers of flaky perfection. It’s the kind of pastry that demands to be savored slowly.
The atmosphere exudes French charm, with pastries that look as exquisite as they taste. Le Croissant delivers a piece of France right to Indiana, inviting you to indulge in a culinary escape.
Dear Reader: This page may contain affiliate links which may earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase. Our independent journalism is not influenced by any advertiser or commercial initiative unless it is clearly marked as sponsored content. As travel products change, please be sure to reconfirm all details and stay up to date with current events to ensure a safe and successful trip.
