10 Small-Town Ohio Restaurants That Are Serving Some Of The Best Amish Food In The Midwest

Ohio is home to one of the largest Amish communities in the country, and with that comes incredible food traditions passed down through generations.

From hearty breakfasts to comfort-filled dinners, these small-town restaurants offer a genuine taste of Amish culture that you simply can’t find anywhere else.

Whether you’re craving fresh-baked pies, broasted chicken, or homemade noodles, the spots on this list deliver authentic flavors in warm, welcoming settings.

Each restaurant has its own story, its own charm, and its own way of making you feel like part of the family.

If you’re planning a trip through Ohio’s beautiful countryside, make sure to add these dining destinations to your itinerary.

You’ll leave with a full belly, a happy heart, and maybe a pie or two for the road.

Ready to explore the best Amish food the Midwest has to offer?

1. Mrs. Yoder’s Kitchen

Tucked away in the rolling hills of Mt. Hope, Mrs. Yoder’s Kitchen has become a beloved destination for anyone seeking authentic Amish cooking.

The moment you step inside, you’re greeted by the comforting aroma of fresh-baked bread and simmering comfort food.

This restaurant is highly regarded for its homemade approach to everything on the menu, from the golden fried chicken to the tender roast beef that practically melts in your mouth.

One of the highlights here is the popular buffet, which allows guests to sample a wide variety of traditional dishes in one sitting.

The selection changes daily, but you can always count on finding hearty options that stick to your ribs.

And then there are the pies.

Mrs. Yoder’s is famous for its homemade pies, with flavors ranging from classic apple to rich chocolate cream.

Each slice is baked fresh and served with a smile.

The atmosphere is warm and unpretentious, making it a perfect spot for families, couples, or solo travelers looking to experience genuine Amish hospitality.

If you’re driving through Ohio and want a meal that feels like home, this is the place to stop.

You can find Mrs. Yoder’s Kitchen at 8101 State Route 241, Mt. Hope, OH 44660.

2. Boyd & Wurthmann Restaurant

Berlin’s Boyd & Wurthmann Restaurant has been a local favorite for generations, serving hearty comfort food with a side of nostalgia.

This historic diner opened its doors long ago and has been delighting guests ever since with its down-home cooking and friendly service.

The menu is packed with classic Amish-inspired dishes, including their famous roast beef dinners that come with all the fixings.

But what really sets this place apart is the pie selection.

On any given day, you’ll find over a dozen varieties of homemade pies lining the display case, each one more tempting than the last.

From coconut cream to cherry, every pie is made from scratch using traditional recipes.

The dining room has a cozy, old-fashioned charm that makes you feel like you’ve stepped back in time.

Locals and visitors alike gather here for breakfast, lunch, and dinner, sharing stories over steaming cups of coffee and plates piled high with comfort food.

The staff treats everyone like family, and the portions are generous enough to leave you satisfied without feeling stuffed.

It’s the kind of place where you can relax, enjoy good food, and soak in the small-town atmosphere.

You’ll find Boyd & Wurthmann Restaurant at 4819 E Main St, Berlin, OH 44610.

3. Der Dutchman

With two locations serving hungry guests, Der Dutchman has become a staple for anyone craving classic Amish-style cooking in Ohio.

The Walnut Creek location sits at 4967 Walnut St, Walnut Creek, OH 44687, while the Plain City spot can be found at 445 South Jefferson Avenue, Plain City, OH 43064.

Both locations offer the same welcoming atmosphere and delicious menu options that have made Der Dutchman a household name.

Guests can choose from traditional menu service or go all-in with the Barn Raising Buffet, an all-you-can-eat feast that showcases the best of Amish cooking.

The broasted chicken is a standout, with a crispy golden coating and juicy, tender meat inside.

Beyond the main dishes, the large bakery selection draws crowds on its own.

Fresh rolls, cookies, cakes, and pies are baked daily, filling the dining room with irresistible aromas.

The restaurants are spacious and designed to accommodate large groups, making them perfect for family gatherings or tour bus stops.

Despite the size, the service remains personal and attentive.

Whether you’re a first-time visitor or a regular, you’ll appreciate the consistency and quality that Der Dutchman brings to every plate.

It’s a place where tradition meets hospitality in the most delicious way possible.

4. Berlin Farmstead Restaurant

Right in the heart of Berlin’s shopping district, the Berlin Farmstead Restaurant offers a welcoming retreat for hungry shoppers and travelers alike.

Located at 4757 Township Rd 366, Millersburg, OH 44610, this family-friendly spot serves traditional Amish meals from morning until evening.

Breakfast here is a hearty affair, with options like fluffy pancakes, farm-fresh eggs, and savory sausage that set the tone for a great day.

Lunchtime brings classics like pot roast, mashed potatoes, and fresh vegetables, all prepared with care and served in generous portions.

Dinner continues the tradition with comforting dishes that remind you of Sunday suppers at grandma’s house.

One dessert that guests rave about is the bread pudding, a warm and sweet treat that’s perfect for ending your meal on a high note.

The atmosphere is relaxed and unpretentious, with simple decor that puts the focus squarely on the food.

Families with kids will appreciate the welcoming vibe and the menu options that appeal to all ages.

After your meal, you can stroll through the nearby shops and explore the local crafts and goods that make this area so special.

It’s a convenient stop that combines great food with a true taste of Amish culture.

5. Dutch Valley Restaurant & Bakery

Dutch Valley Restaurant & Bakery in Sugarcreek is more than just a place to eat; it’s a full experience of Amish heritage and hospitality.

Located at 1347 OH-39, Sugarcreek, OH 44681, this large restaurant features a buffet, an attached bakery, and a gift shop where you can take home a piece of your visit.

The buffet is the main attraction, offering a rotating selection of traditional Amish dishes that change throughout the week.

Many reviewers praise the broasted chicken, which arrives at the table with a perfectly crispy crust and tender, flavorful meat.

Fresh bread is another highlight, baked daily and served warm with butter that melts right into each slice.

The bakery section is a wonderland of sweet treats, from cookies and cinnamon rolls to towering cakes and fruit-filled pies.

Everything is made from scratch using recipes that have been passed down through generations.

The gift shop offers locally made crafts, jams, and souvenirs, making it easy to bring a little bit of Amish country back home with you.

The dining area is spacious and designed to handle large crowds, yet the service remains friendly and efficient.

Whether you’re stopping by for a quick lunch or settling in for a leisurely dinner, Dutch Valley delivers on flavor, variety, and authenticity.

6. Amish Door Restaurant & Village

At 1210 Winesburg St, Wilmot, OH 44689, the Amish Door Restaurant & Village invites guests to step into a world of authentic Amish culture.

This destination goes beyond just a meal, offering an attached inn and village shops where you can explore local crafts, furniture, and handmade goods.

The restaurant itself is known for its broasted chicken, a dish that has earned rave reviews from visitors near and far.

Each piece is seasoned to perfection and cooked until the skin is golden and crispy.

Beyond the chicken, the menu features a variety of traditional Amish dishes, including slow-cooked roasts, fresh vegetables, and homemade noodles.

The portions are generous, and the flavors are rich and satisfying.

After your meal, take some time to wander through the village shops, where artisans sell everything from quilts to wooden toys.

If you’re looking to extend your visit, the inn provides comfortable accommodations with a rustic charm that complements the overall experience.

The entire property is designed to immerse you in the local culture, giving you a deeper appreciation for the Amish way of life.

It’s a perfect stop for anyone traveling through Ohio who wants to slow down, savor great food, and connect with a unique heritage.

7. Hartville Kitchen Restaurant & Bakery

Slightly outside the main Holmes County area, Hartville Kitchen Restaurant & Bakery has been a trusted name in Amish-style cooking for decades.

You’ll find this long-standing restaurant at 1015 State St NE, Hartville, OH 44632, where it has been serving quality, homemade meals and baked goods for years.

The menu features all the classics you’d expect, from fried chicken and mashed potatoes to green beans and stuffing.

Everything is prepared fresh daily, using recipes that have stood the test of time.

The bakery is a major draw, with shelves stocked full of cookies, cakes, breads, and pies that look almost too good to eat.

Almost.

Each item is made by hand, ensuring that every bite tastes just like it came from a home kitchen.

The dining room is spacious and comfortable, with a layout that accommodates both small parties and large groups.

Service is friendly and efficient, with staff members who take pride in making sure every guest leaves happy.

Whether you’re stopping by for breakfast, lunch, or dinner, you’ll find a menu full of options that cater to all tastes.

The combination of great food, welcoming service, and a warm atmosphere makes Hartville Kitchen a must-visit spot for anyone exploring the region.

8. East Main Kitchen

Baltic may be a small town, but East Main Kitchen proves that big flavor can come from unexpected places.

Located at 117 E Main St, Baltic, OH 43804, this quaint restaurant serves Amish cooking with a modern twist that appeals to both locals and tourists.

The menu features traditional favorites like turkey and mashed potatoes, prepared with the same care and attention you’d expect from a classic Amish kitchen.

But the kitchen also isn’t afraid to experiment, offering dishes like shrimp and grits that add a Southern flair to the lineup.

This blend of old and new makes East Main Kitchen a standout in a region known for its traditional dining options.

The portions are generous, and the ingredients are fresh, ensuring that every plate delivers on taste and quality.

The dining area is cozy and intimate, with a decor that reflects the charm of the surrounding town.

It’s the kind of place where you can enjoy a leisurely meal without feeling rushed, and where the staff takes the time to chat with guests and make recommendations.

If you’re looking for a dining experience that honors tradition while embracing creativity, East Main Kitchen is the spot.

It’s a hidden gem that deserves a spot on your Ohio food tour.

9. Des Dutch Essenhaus

Des Dutch Essenhaus in Shreve offers an authentic Amish dining experience that’s hard to find anywhere else.

Located at 10850 OH-3, Shreve, OH 44676, this family-run restaurant is noted for its authentic Amish staff and genuine home cooking.

One of the unique features here is the option for family-style service, where food is brought to your table in large bowls for everyone to share.

It’s a communal way of dining that reflects the Amish tradition of gathering together over meals.

The large salad bar is another highlight, stocked with fresh vegetables, toppings, and homemade dressings that let you build the perfect salad.

Main dishes include hearty options like roast beef, fried chicken, and mashed potatoes, all prepared using traditional methods.

The flavors are simple but satisfying, letting the quality of the ingredients shine through.

The dining room has a warm, welcoming atmosphere that makes you feel like you’re eating in someone’s home rather than a restaurant.

The staff is friendly and attentive, always ready to answer questions or make suggestions.

If you’re looking for a dining experience that goes beyond just food and offers a true taste of Amish culture, Des Dutch Essenhaus is the place to go.

It’s a restaurant that stays true to its roots while welcoming guests from all walks of life.

10. Wedgewing Family Restaurant

Off the beaten path in Perrysville, Wedgewing Family Restaurant offers a quiet escape and a taste of genuine Amish heritage cooking.

You’ll find this quaint spot at 167 E 3rd St, Perrysville, OH 44864, where the owners and cooks bring their former Amish background into every dish they prepare.

The menu is focused on fresh, homemade favorites, including tender chicken, real mashed potatoes, and Amish noodles that are made from scratch.

Each dish is prepared with care and served in portions that are both generous and satisfying.

The atmosphere is simple and unpretentious, with a decor that reflects the humble roots of the people who run it.

There’s no fuss here, just good food and friendly service in a setting that feels like a step back in time.

Because it’s located off the main tourist routes, Wedgewing tends to attract locals and those in the know, giving it a quiet, neighborhood feel.

It’s the kind of place where you can enjoy a peaceful meal without the crowds, and where the staff remembers your name if you visit more than once.

If you’re willing to venture a little off the main path, Wedgewing Family Restaurant rewards you with authentic flavors and a dining experience that’s as genuine as it gets.