Super Bowl Weekend In New Jersey Isn’t Complete Without A Stop For These Chicken Wings

Need last-minute Super Bowl plans? I’ve got the ultimate wing play for you.

On my road trip through New Jersey, I stumbled into Blue 42 Restaurant and Bar on Market Street in Elmwood Park, and let me tell you, I wasn’t ready for what hit me.

This isn’t just another wing joint – it’s a full-blown Green Bay Packers shrine of a sports bar where chicken wings aren’t food, they’re an art form.

We’re talking over 180 flavors that go way beyond buffalo. Ever imagined wings coated in S’mores or Peanut Butter and Jelly?

How about Cool Ranch Dorito or Fruity Pebble wings that sound insane but taste like pure genius?

Blue 42 has them all, and each bite is a touchdown for your taste buds.

The vibe? Electric.

Every screen locked on the big game, every fan roaring like it’s fourth-and-goal, and plates of crispy-juicy wings flying out of the kitchen like passes from a star quarterback.

Locals swear by it, travelers make detours for it, and once you’ve had a basket here, you’ll wonder why you ever settled for boring buffalo.

So grab your crew, throw on your stretchiest pants, and get ready for a Super Bowl flavor blitz that’ll leave you cheering louder than the final score.

Spoiler alert: my top ten wing picks are wild, and yes, the dessert wings are as crazy-delicious as they sound.

Danny Boy Wings Bring the Sweet and Tangy Magic

Walking past tables at Blue 42 Restaurant and Bar, I noticed nearly every group had ordered these golden beauties, and after one bite, I completely understood the hype. Danny Boy wings taste like the perfect marriage of honey and mustard, creating this sweet and tangy flavor profile that hits all the right notes without overwhelming your palate.

The coating clings to each perfectly fried wing, giving you that ideal balance of crispy exterior and tender, juicy meat inside.

What makes these wings stand out is how approachable they are for everyone at your Super Bowl party, from kids to grandparents who might not be adventurous eaters. The honey mustard combination feels familiar yet elevated, like comfort food that got a serious upgrade.

I watched families splitting orders, mixing Danny Boy with spicier flavors, and these always seemed to disappear first from the basket.

Located at 158 Market St, Elmwood Park, NJ 07407, Blue 42 serves these wings fresh and hot throughout their extended hours, making them perfect for late-night cravings during overtime games. The sauce consistency is just right, not too thick or runny, coating each wing evenly without making them soggy.

After trying probably a dozen flavors during my visits, Danny Boy remains my go-to recommendation for first-timers.

Pro tip: order these during Wing Wednesday from 7 PM to midnight when wings drop to just eight dollars, and you can sample multiple flavors without breaking the bank. The sweetness level is moderate, so even if you’re not typically a honey mustard person, give these a shot because they might just convert you into a believer.

Buffalo Ranch Wings Deliver Classic Perfection

Sometimes you just want a wing that reminds you why buffalo sauce became legendary in the first place, and these beauties at Blue 42 absolutely nail that assignment. The buffalo ranch combination creates this beautiful harmony where the spicy kick from the buffalo gets mellowed out by the cool, creamy ranch, making each bite incredibly satisfying.

I ordered these during my first visit based on a family’s recommendation in a Google review, and they instantly became my comfort flavor.

The spice level sits right in that sweet spot where you feel the heat building but it never crosses into painful territory. Each wing arrives coated in this gorgeous orange sauce with visible specks of herbs from the ranch seasoning.

The meat pulls cleanly off the bone, and the skin has that addictive crackle that makes you reach for just one more piece even when you’re already full.

New Jersey knows good wings, and Blue 42 proves it with every order that comes out of their kitchen. The portion size is generous, with eight wings per order that you can split into different flavors if you’re feeling adventurous.

I’ve brought friends here who claimed to be wing connoisseurs, and even they admitted these buffalo ranch wings rival anything they’ve had in other states.

The beauty of this flavor is its versatility during Super Bowl weekend when you’re watching the game for hours and need something that won’t fatigue your taste buds. You can munch on these throughout all four quarters without getting tired of the flavor profile, which is exactly what you want when you’re settled in for the big game.

S’mores Wings Take Dessert to Wild New Heights

I’ll be completely honest: when I first saw S’mores wings on the menu, I thought someone in the kitchen had lost their mind. Chicken covered in marshmallow cream, drizzled with chocolate syrup, and sprinkled with crushed graham crackers sounds like a fever dream, not a legitimate menu item.

But then I watched them arrive at a nearby table, looking like an Instagram masterpiece, and curiosity got the better of me.

Taking that first bite required a leap of faith, and what happened next completely changed my perspective on what chicken wings could be. The savory, crispy chicken provides this incredible contrast to the sweet toppings, creating a flavor experience that somehow makes perfect sense.

The marshmallow cream is fluffy and not overly sweet, the chocolate adds richness without being cloying, and those graham cracker bits provide textural contrast that ties everything together.

Kids absolutely go wild for these, making them perfect for family Super Bowl gatherings where you want something fun and shareable. I’ve seen grown adults giggle with delight after trying them, and the presentation alone makes them conversation starters.

The kitchen at Blue 42 clearly put thought into balancing the sweet elements so they complement rather than overpower the chicken.

Fair warning: you will need extra napkins, possibly an entire stack, because these get gloriously messy in the best possible way. The chocolate drizzle has a tendency to get everywhere, but that’s part of the fun.

Order these toward the end of your meal as a dessert wing experience, and don’t be surprised when everyone at your table wants to try at least one piece.

Peanut Butter and Jelly Wings Sound Crazy but Taste Incredible

Childhood nostalgia meets culinary creativity in what might be the most divisive yet beloved wing flavor at Blue 42 Restaurant and Bar. These wings arrive smothered in creamy peanut butter with a generous heap of jelly on top, looking like something that shouldn’t work but absolutely does.

The combination transports you back to elementary school lunch while simultaneously feeling like a gourmet experiment that paid off big time.

The peanut butter they use is smooth and rich, coating each wing thoroughly so you get that nutty flavor in every single bite. The jelly adds sweetness and a fruity brightness that cuts through the richness of the peanut butter beautifully.

What surprised me most was how well the savory chicken plays with these traditionally sandwich-based ingredients.

You can either dip your wings into the jelly or smear it directly onto the peanut butter coating, and both methods deliver slightly different taste experiences. I prefer the smearing technique because it creates this perfect ratio of peanut butter to jelly in each bite.

The wings themselves are cooked to that ideal crispy texture that Blue 42 has mastered across all their flavors.

Located in Elmwood Park, New Jersey, this sports bar has become famous partly because of wild flavors like this one that dare to be different. During Super Bowl weekend, these wings spark debates and laughter among friend groups trying to decide if they’re brave enough to order them.

Multiple reviewers have mentioned being skeptical at first but falling in love after the first bite, and I completely understand that journey.

Cool Ranch Dorito Wings Bring Snack Nostalgia to Life

Imagine your favorite childhood chip transformed into a wing coating, and you’ll start to understand the genius behind this flavor creation. Cool Ranch Dorito wings taste exactly like you’d hope, with that distinctive tangy, slightly cheesy, herby flavor profile that made the chips famous.

The kitchen somehow captures the essence of those blue bags we all crushed during after-school snack time and applies it to perfectly cooked chicken.

The coating has this incredible crunch that mimics the chip texture while still maintaining the integrity of a proper wing. Each bite delivers that familiar Cool Ranch taste with added depth from the chicken’s natural flavors.

I watched a group of friends order these during a football game, and their reactions ranged from shocked delight to pure nostalgia-fueled joy.

What makes these wings special is how they appeal to people who might not typically be adventurous eaters but still want something beyond plain buffalo. The flavor is recognizable and comforting while still being unique enough to feel like a special treat.

The seasoning blend clings to the crispy skin beautifully, ensuring every wing in your order tastes consistent.

Blue 42 Restaurant and Bar also offers Nacho Dorito wings if you want the regular chip flavor, but the Cool Ranch version feels more sophisticated somehow. These wings pair exceptionally well with cold drinks during Super Bowl weekend when you’re settling in for hours of game watching.

The portion size is perfect for sharing, though you might find yourself wanting to keep them all to yourself once you start eating.

Fruity Pebbles Wings Create Sweet Breakfast Magic

Breakfast cereal on chicken wings sounds like something a college student would invent at three in the morning, but Blue 42 elevated this concept into something genuinely special. The Fruity Pebbles coating creates this rainbow explosion of color and sweetness that makes you smile before you even take a bite.

The cereal maintains its crunch when applied to the hot wings, creating textural contrast that keeps things interesting.

The sweetness level is surprisingly balanced, letting the fruity notes shine without turning into a sugar bomb that overwhelms your palate. Each wing looks like a piece of edible art, covered in those familiar colorful pebbles that defined Saturday morning cartoons for generations.

Kids go absolutely wild for these, making them perfect for family gatherings during Super Bowl weekend.

What shocked me most was how the savory chicken flavor actually enhances the cereal’s sweetness rather than clashing with it. The combination creates this sweet and salty dynamic that food scientists have known works for years.

Multiple reviews mention these as standout favorites, with people specifically making the drive to Elmwood Park just to try them.

The presentation is Instagram-worthy, which explains why you see so many people photographing their orders before diving in. Blue 42 clearly understands that eating should be fun, and these wings embody that philosophy perfectly.

Order these when you want to impress guests or when you’re feeling playful and adventurous with your food choices.

They work surprisingly well as a dessert option after you’ve had your fill of traditional savory wings, cleansing your palate with their bright, fruity sweetness.

Lemon Pepper Wings Offer Classic Zesty Excellence

Sometimes simplicity wins, and these lemon pepper beauties prove that point with every perfectly seasoned bite. The dry rub style lets you appreciate the quality of the chicken itself while the lemon and pepper add just enough flavor to make things interesting.

I ordered these during my second visit after trying some of the wilder flavors, and they felt like coming home to a reliable friend.

The lemon flavor is bright and citrusy without being artificial or overwhelming, cutting through any richness from other foods you might be enjoying. Fresh cracked black pepper adds a gentle heat and aromatic quality that complements rather than competes with the lemon.

The seasoning distribution is remarkably even, with no bald spots or overly seasoned areas that sometimes plague dry-rubbed wings.

These wings showcase Blue 42’s cooking technique beautifully because there’s nowhere to hide behind heavy sauces or toppings. The skin achieves that perfect crispy texture while the meat stays incredibly juicy and tender.

Multiple customer reviews specifically praise the lemon pepper as a standout traditional option among the more adventurous choices.

At 158 Market St, Elmwood Park, NJ 07407, you can order these any day of the week, though Wing Wednesday offers the best value. They pair exceptionally well with the other flavors if you’re doing a mixed order for your Super Bowl party.

The clean, fresh taste makes them ideal for people who want quality wings without a lot of fuss.

I’ve recommended these to friends who claim they don’t like adventurous food, and every single one has gone back for seconds.

Shut the Cluck Up Wings Combine Buffalo and Blue Cheese Bliss

Blue cheese lovers, this is your moment to shine because these wings were designed specifically with you in mind. Shut the Cluck Up takes classic buffalo sauce and elevates it with generous blue cheese crumbles and a creamy blue cheese drizzle that creates flavor heaven.

The combination is bold and unapologetic, perfect for people who order extra blue cheese dressing everywhere they go.

The buffalo sauce provides that familiar spicy tang while the blue cheese adds funky, sharp notes that create complexity in each bite. The crumbles offer textural interest and concentrated flavor pockets, while the drizzle ties everything together with creamy richness.

I watched a customer order these and literally close her eyes in appreciation after the first wing, which told me everything I needed to know.

The spice level is moderate, focusing more on flavor than pure heat, making these accessible to most people who enjoy buffalo wings. The blue cheese is high quality, not the cheap crumbly stuff that tastes like chalk, which makes a noticeable difference.

Every element works together harmoniously, creating a wing experience that feels both familiar and elevated.

These wings are substantial and filling, perfect for fueling you through a long Super Bowl game in New Jersey. The kitchen clearly doesn’t skimp on toppings, giving you plenty of blue cheese in every order.

If you’re the type of person who dips their buffalo wings in blue cheese dressing anyway, these wings essentially do that work for you.

The name is playful and memorable, fitting perfectly with Blue 42’s fun, casual atmosphere where sports fans gather to enjoy great food and good company.

FOMO Wings Deliver Chipotle Smokiness Worth the Hype

Fear of missing out is real, and these wings earned their name by being so good that you’ll regret not ordering them sooner. The FOMO wings feature a chipotle-based sauce that brings smoky, slightly spicy flavors with depth and complexity.

Unlike some chipotle dishes that lean too heavily on heat, these wings balance the smokiness with just enough kick to keep things interesting.

The sauce has this gorgeous reddish-brown color that looks as good as it tastes, coating each wing thoroughly without drowning it. The chipotle peppers provide an earthy, almost sweet heat that builds gradually rather than hitting you all at once.

I tried these during a lunch visit and immediately understood why one reviewer specifically mentioned them as awesome.

The wings arrive hot and fresh, with that signature Blue 42 crispy exterior that has become their trademark across all flavors. The meat is tender and pulls away from the bone easily, making these perfect for eating while watching the game.

The smoky notes pair beautifully with the natural chicken flavor, creating a harmonious taste experience that feels sophisticated yet approachable.

Located in Elmwood Park, New Jersey, Blue 42 Restaurant and Bar serves these wings throughout their extended hours, making them available for lunch, dinner, or late-night cravings. The chipotle flavor profile works well for people who want something beyond basic buffalo but aren’t ready to jump into the dessert wing category.

These have become increasingly popular according to recent reviews, with more people discovering them and spreading the word.

Blue 42 Burger Loaded with Mozzarella Sticks and Bacon

While wings rightfully steal the spotlight at Blue 42, this signature burger deserves serious recognition for its over-the-top deliciousness. Imagine a juicy burger patty topped with crispy mozzarella sticks, crumbled blue cheese, and bacon, all stacked between buns with the Blue 42 logo charred right on top.

This isn’t health food by any stretch, but during Super Bowl weekend, calories don’t count and indulgence is mandatory.

The burger itself is cooked perfectly, with a nice char on the outside while staying juicy inside, providing a solid foundation for all those toppings. The mozzarella sticks add gooey, stretchy cheese and a crispy element that creates textural variety in every bite.

Blue cheese crumbles bring that sharp, funky flavor that cuts through the richness, while bacon adds its smoky, salty magic that makes everything better.

This burger is messy in the best possible way, requiring multiple napkins and possibly a fork and knife if you want to maintain any dignity. The combination of flavors and textures keeps your taste buds engaged from first bite to last.

Several reviewers have specifically called out this burger as a must-try, praising how all the components work together.

The portion size is generous, easily shareable if you’re also ordering wings or other appetizers for your group. At 158 Market St, Elmwood Park, NJ 07407, Blue 42 serves this burger during all operating hours.

The decorative Blue 42 char mark on the bun shows attention to detail and pride in their signature creation, making it feel special rather than just another loaded burger.