When it comes to pies, Tennessee isn’t just about pecan or pumpkin. Enter the legendary buttermilk pie. With its smooth, creamy texture and subtle tang, this classic Southern dessert is stealing hearts (and tastebuds) all over the Volunteer State. As an aficionado of all things delicious, I embarked on a pie pilgrimage across Tennessee, and let me tell you, it was nothing short of a sweet revelation. Buckle up, pie lovers; here are 10 diners where buttermilk pie takes center stage.
1. Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop
Nestled in the heart of Tennessee, Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop is a haven for pie enthusiasts. Their buttermilk pie isn’t just a dessert; it’s a tradition. With locations scattered across Knoxville, Johnson City, and Chattanooga, it’s like a pie pilgrimage waiting to happen.
The ambience whispers Southern charm, with rustic decor and the sweet aroma of baking pies. The buttermilk pie is their pièce de résistance, with a custard-like texture that melts in your mouth, leaving a hint of tang that dances on your tastebuds.
Each slice feels like a warm hug from your favorite grandma. The secret? A family recipe passed down through generations. So, if you’re ever in Tennessee, missing out on a slice here would be a culinary crime. Trust me, it’s a slice above the rest!
2. City Cafe Diner
If you find yourself in Chattanooga at 3 AM craving something sweet, City Cafe Diner is the place to be. Known for its eternal hours and extensive menu, this diner is more than just your typical breakfast joint.
Their dessert case is a beacon of sugary delights, and while buttermilk pie isn’t a regular, it’s worth calling ahead to check. When it’s in, it’s a delight with a perfectly golden crust and a creamy filling that packs a flavorful punch.
The lively, bustling atmosphere adds a layer of excitement to every slice. The pie feels like a celebration, especially when paired with their vibrant diner vibes. It’s a must-visit for pie lovers and night owls alike!
3. Katie Pie and Sons Country Kitchen
When you step into Katie Pie and Sons Country Kitchen, it feels like stepping into a beloved family home. Located on Pulaski Highway, this place is renowned for its homemade treats. While the buttermilk pie isn’t an everyday item, it’s a local treasure when available.
Picture this: a cozy nook with the aroma of pies wafting through the air. The buttermilk pie here offers a comforting taste of nostalgia, rich with a creamy custard that feels like a warm Tennessee hug.
Local patrons swear by their pies, often describing them as the best in Middle Tennessee. Keep an eye on their specials, and you might just snag a slice of this elusive delight. It’s a slice of heaven you won’t forget!
4. The Butter Milk Ranch
Despite what the name might suggest, The Butter Milk Ranch isn’t your typical diner. This trendy bistro on 12th Ave S is known for its brunch and exquisite pastries. While buttermilk pie is not a staple, it’s worth the inquiry.
The aesthetic is as delightful as their desserts; think minimalist chic meets Southern comfort. If buttermilk pie graces their menu, expect it to be a work of art: beautifully crafted with a luxurious filling.
The vibe is upscale yet welcoming, making it a perfect stop for dessert connoisseurs. So, if you’re in the mood for a pie with a side of sophistication, this is your spot. Keep it on your foodie radar!
5. The Loveless Cafe
Hidden away on TN-100 lies The Loveless Cafe, a Nashville gem known for its iconic biscuits and Southern fare. Though their Chess Pie is famed, the occasional buttermilk pie is a sweet surprise.
Imagine a bustling eatery, walls lined with vintage memorabilia, and the inviting smell of baking. The buttermilk pie, when available, is a Southern dream, with a custard that’s silky and a crust that’s divine.
Call ahead to see if it’s on the menu. Each bite brings a sense of nostalgia, a reminder of simpler times, making it a must-try. It’s a classic you can’t miss on your pie journey!
6. Arnold’s Country Kitchen
A Nashville institution, Arnold’s Country Kitchen is known for its meat-and-three offerings. But their desserts, especially the buttermilk pie, are not to be overlooked.
The ambiance is down-home and full of Southern charm, with friendly faces and hearty laughs. If buttermilk pie is on the menu, it’s a creamy, rich delight that captures the essence of a Southern kitchen.
Every slice tells a story, a tale of tradition and taste. It’s a beloved spot for locals and tourists alike, and the pie? It’s always the perfect ending to a hearty meal. Check it out for a taste of Tennessee tradition!
7. Barksdale’s
Take a step back in time at Barksdale’s, an old-school diner on Cooper St in Memphis. Known for its traditional Southern fare, this diner is a hidden gem for buttermilk pie enthusiasts.
The decor is vintage, with a nostalgic feel that transports you to another era. The buttermilk pie, though not a regular menu item, is a memorable experience when available, with a texture that’s smooth and a flavor that’s exquisite.
Each bite is like a time capsule, capturing the essence of Southern hospitality. It’s a local favorite for a reason, and if you catch a slice, you’ll understand why. It’s a Memphis marvel worth seeking out!
8. Napa Café
Napa Café in Memphis might not scream ‘diner,’ but their buttermilk pie is a conversation starter. This chic spot on Sanderlin Ave is known for its unique culinary takes.
While the reviews on the pie are mixed, it’s a daring twist on tradition. The atmosphere is upscale, with a modern flair that adds an unexpected elegance to your pie experience.
If you’re seeking a different kind of buttermilk pie adventure, give them a call to ensure it’s on the menu. It’s a slice of modernity that challenges your taste buds. A must-try for those open to culinary innovation!
9. Puckett’s Grocery & Restaurant
For a blend of history and flavor, Puckett’s Grocery & Restaurant is a Middle Tennessee favorite. Known for its Southern comfort food, the buttermilk pie is a sweet star when it makes an appearance.
The setting is rustic, echoing the charm of an old-timey general store. If you’re lucky enough to find buttermilk pie on the menu, expect a treat that’s rich, creamy, and quintessentially Southern.
Puckett’s vibe is warm and welcoming, making every meal feel like a family gathering. Keep an ear to the ground for the pie’s appearance, because when it’s there, it’s a slice you won’t want to miss!
10. Bryant’s Breakfast
In the heart of Memphis, Bryant’s Breakfast is where mornings get a delicious start. Known for its hearty breakfasts, it’s their occasional buttermilk pie that steals the show.
The setting is unpretentious and welcoming, with a community vibe that’s hard to beat. When available, the buttermilk pie offers a taste that’s both comforting and indulgent.
Each slice feels like a morning hug, a perfect counterpart to their renowned breakfasts. It’s a must-visit for anyone looking to start their day with a slice of Southern sunshine!
Dear Reader: This page may contain affiliate links which may earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase. Our independent journalism is not influenced by any advertiser or commercial initiative unless it is clearly marked as sponsored content. As travel products change, please be sure to reconfirm all details and stay up to date with current events to ensure a safe and successful trip.
