Indiana has plenty of great steakhouses, but when it comes to prime rib, one place stands head and shoulders above the rest. Hidden in a tiny town that most folks drive right past is a restaurant that’s become legendary for its melt-in-your-mouth beef. What makes this spot so special isn’t just the food – it’s the whole experience that turns first-time visitors into lifelong fans.
1. A Hidden Gem in Rural Indiana
In the quiet countryside of Madison County, Indiana, lies the small community of Perkinsville. Just outside of Country Club Heights, this unassuming spot is home to one of the state’s most beloved and surprising culinary destinations: Bonge’s Tavern.
Housed in a historic building that dates back to the mid-1800s, Bonge’s has been a local fixture for decades. Originally a general store, the building became a tavern in 1944 and has evolved over time into a restaurant known across the region for its outstanding food. Despite its rural location and modest exterior, Bonge’s draws crowds from across Indiana and beyond.
The restaurant’s charm lies not only in its history and cozy, rustic interior but also in its legendary menu. At the top of that menu is the smoked prime rib – a dish so good, it’s become the centerpiece of weekend dining at this unexpected hotspot in the Indiana countryside.
2. The Prime Rib: What Makes It Special
Bonge’s Tavern doesn’t serve prime rib every night – it’s a weekend-only special, available only on Fridays and Saturdays. That limited availability adds to the anticipation and demand. What makes their prime rib truly special is the preparation method: it’s applewood smoked, slowly cooked to achieve a deeply flavorful and tender cut of meat.
Diners can choose between a 10 oz, 16 oz, or even a massive 30 oz portion, depending on appetite and occasion. The meat is served with classic accompaniments, such as a rich horseradish cream and hearty sides like mashed potatoes or roasted vegetables. Each meal also includes either a fresh wedge salad or Bonge’s signature tomato soup.
The combination of slow smoking, precise seasoning, and careful attention to detail in plating has turned this dish into a destination meal. For many loyal patrons, a trip to Bonge’s on the weekend isn’t complete without ordering their famed prime rib.
3. The Dining Experience: More Than the Food
Eating at Bonge’s Tavern is about more than just great food – it’s an experience that starts long before you’re seated at a table. The restaurant doesn’t take reservations for small parties, and wait times on weekends can stretch well over an hour.
But instead of deterring visitors, this has become part of the restaurant’s unique charm. Guests often arrive early to tailgate in the gravel parking lot, setting up folding chairs, enjoying the outdoors, and chatting with fellow diners. This informal gathering ritual has become as iconic as the food itself. Once inside, the atmosphere is casual yet intimate, with the original character of the old building still intact.
Warm lighting, wooden beams, and a close-knit layout create a welcoming environment that feels more like a communal dining room than a typical restaurant. The shared anticipation and friendly vibe only enhance the meal once it’s finally served.
4. A Menu Full of Favorites
Though the prime rib is the standout star of Bonge’s Tavern’s weekend offerings, the rest of the menu is equally compelling and worth exploring. Dishes rotate seasonally and may include items like duck breast, fresh seafood, lamb chops, or the house-favorite Perkinsville Pork – a lightly breaded and pan-fried pork loin that’s simple but expertly made.
The restaurant takes pride in preparing everything from scratch, including dressings, soups, and desserts. One of the consistent favorites is the house-made tomato soup, which often serves as the starter to many meals. Starters like smoked salmon and crab cakes also have a loyal following. The kitchen staff takes a chef-driven approach to their menu, despite the laid-back atmosphere of the dining space.
This combination of elevated comfort food and casual surroundings is part of what keeps guests returning week after week, season after season. Bonge’s proves that high-quality cuisine doesn’t require big-city surroundings.
5. The Surprise of Perkinsville
What surprises most first-time visitors to Bonge’s Tavern isn’t just the quality of the food – it’s the fact that such a standout dining experience exists in a place as small and rural as Perkinsville. This is not a location you stumble upon by accident.
Perkinsville is a quiet area with little commercial activity, and Bonge’s remains the focal point of the community. Yet despite its out-of-the-way location, the restaurant draws crowds from Indianapolis, Fort Wayne, and even out of state. Part of its charm lies in the contrast: a gourmet-caliber meal served in a low-key, countryside setting. The building’s history adds to the allure, with its origins dating back to the mid-19th century and its long-standing role in the community.
Over the years, ownership has changed, but the dedication to quality and tradition has remained constant. For many, Bonge’s isn’t just a restaurant – it’s a tradition, a destination, and an experience worth the drive.
Dear Reader: This page may contain affiliate links which may earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase. Our independent journalism is not influenced by any advertiser or commercial initiative unless it is clearly marked as sponsored content. As travel products change, please be sure to reconfirm all details and stay up to date with current events to ensure a safe and successful trip.
