I have tried a lot of ice cream in Indiana, and nothing has stopped me in my tracks quite like Sundae’s Homemade Ice Cream on the east side of Indianapolis. From the moment I walked in and caught a whiff of fresh waffle cones and rich cream, I knew this place was different.
The flavors here are not pulled from a corporate recipe book. They are crafted with care, made in-house, and backed by over 30 years of perfecting something truly special.
With a 4.8-star rating from over a thousand reviews, Sundae’s is not just a local favorite. It is the kind of hidden gem that makes you want to call every person you know and say, get in the car, we are going right now.
Homemade Ice Cream Flavors That Actually Taste Homemade
Most ice cream places will tell you their product is special, but you can taste the difference the second a scoop from Sundae’s Homemade Ice Cream hits your tongue. The texture is noticeably creamier and stretchier than anything you will find at a chain store.
Reviewers have pointed out that it melts faster in warm air, which is actually a good sign because it means the ice cream is not loaded with artificial stabilizers.
The vanilla base alone is enough to win you over. It carries a depth of flavor that generic vanilla simply cannot match.
You can tell real ingredients went into every batch, and that honesty in the product is what keeps people coming back.
Signature flavors like Graham Central Station, which features a graham cracker base with a chocolate crunch swirl, and Key Lime Pie with its bright citrus tang, show just how creative and precise the team is. Chocolate Amaretto Cheesecake is another standout that has earned serious praise from visitors who do not even live in Indiana.
One out-of-state reviewer admitted to getting seven scoops in a single 24-hour visit. That kind of devotion says everything.
Sundae’s is open every day until 10 PM, so you always have time for one more scoop.
Specialty Sundaes Big Enough To Share
Sundae’s Homemade Ice Cream takes its name seriously. The specialty sundaes here are not the sad little cups you get at fast food counters.
Customers have described them as large enough for two people to share comfortably, which makes them a fantastic choice for a date night or a family outing where everyone wants a taste of something indulgent.
The combination of fresh homemade ice cream with house-made toppings creates a dessert experience that feels genuinely celebratory. Whether you are piling on hot fudge, fresh fruit, or a drizzle of peanut butter, every element complements the rich, creamy base underneath.
Nothing here feels like an afterthought.
What makes these sundaes stand out beyond their size is the quality of every layer. Because the ice cream itself is made in-house, you are not starting with a mediocre foundation and hoping the toppings save it.
You are building something great on top of something already excellent. Families with kids especially love this spot because the staff is patient and genuinely happy to help little ones pick their perfect combination.
For nearby dessert-and-outing inspiration, Geist Reservoir Park at 11701 Olio Rd, Fishers, IN 46037 is just a short drive away and makes a perfect pre-sundae adventure before heading over to treat the whole crew.
Award-Winning Recognition That Speaks For Itself
Winning awards in the food world is not easy, especially when you are competing against national chains with massive marketing budgets and corporate backing. Sundae’s Homemade Ice Cream has done exactly that, earning recognition that places it above the big names that most people would assume would dominate the rankings.
That kind of achievement does not happen by accident.
Over 30 years of refining recipes, sourcing quality ingredients, and listening to customers has built a reputation that no amount of advertising can manufacture. The 4.8-star average across more than 1,100 Google reviews is a real-world endorsement that carries more weight than any trophy.
People keep coming back, and they keep bringing friends.
Local food lovers in Indianapolis know that the east side has always had its hidden culinary treasures, and Sundae’s fits right into that tradition. It is the kind of place that gets passed down through word of mouth, from parents to kids and neighbors to coworkers.
A local teacher even brought ten students from Walker Career Center for a shop tour, and the team welcomed them with open arms and free ice cream. That level of community investment is what separates a truly beloved local business from one that is simply passing through.
Sundae’s has earned every bit of praise it receives.
Generous Free Sampling Policy That Builds Confidence
Picking a flavor at Sundae’s Homemade Ice Cream can feel overwhelming in the best possible way. With dozens of options rotating through the display case, it is genuinely hard to commit to just one or two scoops without some guidance.
That is where the free sampling policy becomes a total game changer for first-time visitors and regulars alike.
The staff encourages you to try before you buy, which immediately takes the pressure off the decision. You can sample your way through several flavors until something truly speaks to you.
For families with picky eaters or guests who are new to some of the more creative flavor combinations, this policy builds real confidence and makes the whole visit more enjoyable.
It also shows a level of trust and generosity that you do not always find in small businesses. The team at Sundae’s clearly believes in their product enough to let it do the talking.
One reviewer described the sampling experience as the reason they discovered their new all-time favorite flavor after years of ordering the same thing everywhere else. That moment of discovery is something you simply cannot put a price on.
If you are visiting the east side of Indianapolis and want to explore the neighborhood before stopping in, the Oaklandon area has charming residential streets and is close to the shop at 9922 E 79th St, Indianapolis, IN 46256.
Late-Night Hours Perfect for Evening Cravings
Most dessert shops close early, which means by the time dinner is done and the kids are wound down, your options for a sweet finish to the evening are pretty limited. Sundae’s Homemade Ice Cream solves that problem completely by staying open until 10 PM every single day of the week.
Whether it is a random Tuesday or a busy Saturday, you have the same window of opportunity to show up and treat yourself.
That late-night availability has become a genuine selling point for locals who love the idea of an evening ice cream run. One regular reviewer specifically called out the 10 PM closing time as what makes Sundae’s the perfect spot for a post-dinner outing with the family.
It fits naturally into the rhythm of a full day in Indianapolis without requiring any rushed planning.
The shop has a cozy, nostalgic feel that one reviewer compared to stepping back in time to a small-town soda shop. A couple of sturdy benches outside the storefront give you a place to sit and enjoy your scoops in the open air, which feels especially nice on warm Indiana evenings.
For a full night out on the east side, consider stopping at Britton Falls Park at 12690 Olio Rd, Fishers, IN 46037 for a walk before making your way to Sundae’s for a perfect finish to the evening.
Family-Friendly Atmosphere With Genuinely Kind Staff
Some places tolerate kids. Sundae’s Homemade Ice Cream actually welcomes them.
The staff here has a reputation for being patient, warm, and genuinely invested in making sure every guest leaves happy, regardless of age or how long the decision-making process takes. That kind of hospitality is rarer than it should be.
One of the most touching reviews shared a story about a young boy who dropped his lemon sorbet cone on the pavement right after getting to it. The shop had already run out of lemon sorbet, but the staff gave him a replacement scoop of his choice along with a brand new cone, no charge, no hesitation.
That single act of kindness turned a heartbreaking ice cream moment into a memory the whole family will carry for years.
The team is described across dozens of reviews as friendly, quick, and genuinely enthusiastic about what they serve. Young staff members bring real energy to the shop without sacrificing professionalism.
For families visiting the area, Shadyside Park at 2801 W 116th St, Carmel, IN 46032 offers a great outdoor stretch before or after your visit to Sundae’s. The combination of a fun outdoor space and a stop at a shop where your kids are treated like guests makes for a full and memorable day out in the greater Indianapolis area.
Affordable Prices That Make Every Visit Feel Like a Win
Great homemade ice cream does not have to cost a fortune, and Sundae’s Homemade Ice Cream, located at 9922 E 79th St, Indianapolis, IN 46256 proves that point every single day. The pricing has been praised consistently across reviews as fair and reasonable, especially considering the quality and generosity of the portions.
You walk out feeling like you got more than your money’s worth, which is not something you can say about most dessert experiences.
Scoops are described as generous, and the specialty sundaes are large enough that splitting one is genuinely a solid option. For families of five or groups of friends, the affordability makes it easy to let everyone order exactly what they want without watching the total climb into uncomfortable territory.
That freedom to just enjoy yourself without budget anxiety is a real gift.
The shop also sells coffee beans, which carry an amazing aroma according to longtime regulars, adding a small but delightful bonus to the experience. For visitors exploring the east side of Indianapolis, the nearby Irvington neighborhood at East Washington Street and Audubon Road, Indianapolis, IN 46219 is packed with local character and makes a wonderful detour before or after a stop at Sundae’s.
Between the fair prices, the generous portions, and the welcoming environment, every visit to 9922 E 79th St, Indianapolis, IN 46256 feels like a genuine treat without the guilt of overspending.
Dear Reader: This page may contain affiliate links which may earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase. Our independent journalism is not influenced by any advertiser or commercial initiative unless it is clearly marked as sponsored content. As travel products change, please be sure to reconfirm all details and stay up to date with current events to ensure a safe and successful trip.
