The French Lick Springs Hotel stands as one of Indiana’s most elegant landmarks, but behind its grand facade lies a reputation for something far more mysterious. Guests and staff have reported strange encounters for decades, from phantom footsteps to ghostly apparitions wandering the halls.
Whether you believe in spirits or not, there’s no denying the eerie atmosphere that makes this historic hotel feel truly haunted.
1. Thomas Taggart Still Watches Over His Hotel
Former owner Thomas Taggart was a powerful politician who made this hotel legendary during its golden age. His spirit apparently never left the building he loved so dearly. Staff members have spotted his dark shadow near the service elevator, while guests report strange encounters on the sixth floor.
He seems to be checking on his property even in death. The apparition appears most often late at night when the hallways grow quiet. Many believe Taggart’s devotion to his hotel keeps his soul bound to these elegant corridors forever.
2. Charlie the Bellhop Answers Calls From Beyond
A tragic accident claimed the life of a young bellhop named Charlie in the hotel’s elevator shaft many years ago. Visitors describe seeing a man in an old-fashioned uniform that suddenly vanishes into thin air. His voice has been heard offering to help with luggage, even when no living staff member is nearby.
The encounters feel friendly rather than frightening to most guests. Charlie apparently loved his job so much that death couldn’t stop him from serving visitors. His ghostly presence adds a touch of sadness to the hotel’s haunted reputation.
3. Red Stains Return to the Bride’s Bathtub
Legend tells of a heartbroken bride who ended her life in a guest room bathtub on her wedding night. Housekeepers have discovered mysterious red stains reappearing in that particular bathroom, no matter how thoroughly they clean. Even replacing the entire fixture hasn’t stopped the phenomenon from occurring.
The tragic story sends chills down the spines of anyone who hears it. Some guests refuse to stay in that room once they learn its dark history. The recurring stains suggest the bride’s sorrow has permanently marked this space with her final moments.
4. Floors Six and Seven Host Constant Activity
These upper levels have earned a reputation as the hotel’s most paranormally active areas. Unexplained footsteps echo through empty hallways at all hours of the day and night. Lights flicker on and off without any electrical explanation, while disembodied laughter rings out from vacant rooms.
A lady dressed entirely in white has been spotted gliding along these corridors. Guests staying on these floors often request room changes after experiencing too many strange occurrences. The concentrated supernatural energy makes these levels the ultimate destination for ghost hunters visiting the property.
5. A Gambler Searches Eternally for Lost Winnings
Winning big at the hotel’s illegal gambling tables proved fatal for one unlucky guest. Robbers murdered him in his room after he collected a massive prize, stealing everything he’d won. His restless spirit reportedly wanders near that same room, apparently still hunting for the money taken from him.
Witnesses describe a confused-looking man who disappears when approached. The tragedy of dying moments after achieving such fortune creates a powerful emotional imprint. His ghost serves as a chilling reminder of the hotel’s dangerous past during Prohibition.
6. Illegal Gambling Created a Dark Legacy
Under Thomas Taggart’s ownership, the hotel became infamous for underground gambling operations during Prohibition. High-stakes games attracted dangerous characters and shady deals that sometimes turned violent. This atmosphere of illegal activity and moral corruption left a heavy spiritual residue that many believe still permeates the building.
The energy from those intense, emotion-filled nights seems to linger in the walls. Guests report feeling watched or uneasy in certain areas where the gambling once occurred. The hotel’s glamorous exterior hides a past filled with secrets and darkness that fuel its haunted reputation today.
7. Pluto Water Connects to the Underworld
The hotel gained fame by bottling mineral spring water and marketing it as “Pluto Water” to customers nationwide. Pluto, the Roman god who ruled over the realm of the dead, gives this product an unintentionally spooky connection. The name choice seems oddly prophetic given the building’s current reputation for supernatural activity.
This mythological link to the underworld adds another layer to the haunting atmosphere. Whether coincidence or cosmic joke, the branding choice feels eerily appropriate now. Visitors can’t help but wonder if naming the water after death’s deity somehow invited restless spirits to take up residence.
8. Phantom Music Plays in Empty Ballrooms
Staff members working late shifts frequently hear orchestral music and dancing coming from the grand ballroom when it’s completely vacant. Mysterious phone calls originate from unoccupied guest rooms with no explanation for how the phones activated. Heavy objects seem to drop in rooms next door, but investigations reveal nothing out of place.
These disembodied sounds create an unsettling soundtrack throughout the building. The phantom noises suggest past celebrations and gatherings replaying themselves like recordings. Hearing laughter and conversation from empty spaces reminds everyone that the hotel’s history refuses to stay silent.
9. Cigar Smoke Appears Without a Source
The distinct smell of expensive cigar smoke drifts through hallways and rooms where smoking hasn’t been allowed for decades. This phantom aroma appears most frequently near areas where Thomas Taggart spent his time when alive. Guests and employees recognize the scent immediately, even though no visible smoke or burning tobacco can be found.
The olfactory phenomenon suggests Taggart still enjoys his favorite habit from beyond the grave. Unlike visual apparitions, smells feel more immediate and harder to dismiss as imagination. The recurring cigar smoke provides sensory evidence that something unexplainable continues happening within these walls.
10. Centuries of Tragedy Leave Spiritual Imprints
Like many grand hotels operating for over a century, French Lick Springs has witnessed numerous deaths, accidents, and suicides within its walls. Each tragic event potentially leaves behind emotional energy that accumulates over time. The sheer volume of sorrow and loss experienced here creates what paranormal researchers call residual haunting.
These spiritual imprints replay like recordings, showing glimpses of past events. The building has absorbed generations of human emotion, both joyful and devastating. This concentration of history and heartbreak makes the hotel feel alive with restless energy that visitors immediately sense upon entering.
Dear Reader: This page may contain affiliate links which may earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase. Our independent journalism is not influenced by any advertiser or commercial initiative unless it is clearly marked as sponsored content. As travel products change, please be sure to reconfirm all details and stay up to date with current events to ensure a safe and successful trip.
