I’ll be honest, I was not expecting much when I first pulled up to a small corner spot on Main Street in Greensburg, Indiana. But the moment I walked into Storie’s Restaurant, something shifted.
The smell of fresh-baked pie, the hum of friendly conversation, and the sight of those old-school booths just pulled me right in. Storie’s has been a beloved fixture in Decatur County for years, and locals will tell you it is the kind of place you never forget once you have tried it.
From legendary homemade pies to hearty comfort food that tastes like something your grandmother would make, this little restaurant punches way above its weight. If you have never made the trip to there, let me give you seven very good reasons why you absolutely should.
The Homemade Pies Are Genuinely Worth the Drive
Ask anyone who has ever visited Storie’s Restaurant and they will tell you the same thing before you even finish your sentence: go for the pie. These are not the plastic-wrapped slices you find at a gas station or a chain restaurant.
These are honest-to-goodness homemade pies baked fresh, and they sell out fast.
Reviewers have raved about the butterscotch pie, the peanut butter pie, the chocolate pie, and the strawberry pie. One customer even admitted to ordering the chocolate pie as an appetizer just to make sure there was still a slice left by the time the meal ended.
That is the kind of dedication a truly great pie inspires.
The crusts are golden and flaky, the fillings are rich without being overly sweet, and each bite carries that unmistakable quality of something made with care rather than convenience. If you are visiting on a Sunday, plan to arrive early because the pies move quickly.
Several reviewers noted that the pies sell out well before closing time. Bring cash if you can, since paying by card adds a small processing fee.
Take a whole pie home if you can manage it. One guest cut their pork tenderloin sandwich in half to save room and still took a pie home for the next morning.
That says everything.
Old-School Atmosphere That Feels Like Stepping Back in Time
Walking into Storie’s feels like the rest of the world just slowed down a little. The dining room has swivel stools at the counter, classic booths along the walls, and regular tables filling the middle.
One reviewer described it as feeling like an old-fashioned ice cream parlor, and that comparison is pretty spot-on.
There is something genuinely comforting about a place that has not tried to modernize itself into something unrecognizable. The atmosphere here is warm and unpretentious.
You are not going to find trendy industrial lighting or a chalkboard menu written in artisan fonts. What you will find is a clean, welcoming space that invites you to sit down, take a breath, and just enjoy a meal.
Families with kids feel at home here. Solo travelers stopping through Greensburg feel at home here.
Even first-timers from out of state consistently mention how the old-school vibe caught them off guard in the best way. One visitor from Illinois said it had exactly the small-town feel they had been searching for since relocating.
The seating variety also means you can grab a quick solo lunch at the counter or settle into a roomy booth for a longer family meal. Either way, the atmosphere does a lot of the work before the food even arrives.
The Pork Tenderloin Sandwich Is an Indiana Classic Done Right
Indiana has a deep and serious relationship with the breaded pork tenderloin sandwich, and Storie’s does not disappoint. Multiple reviewers called it a must-order, and one loyal customer described the tenderloin as genuinely big, the kind of big where you cut it in half and still have enough left over for breakfast the next day with a couple of eggs on the side.
What makes Storie’s version stand out is that the tenderloin is actually pounded out and fried properly. It is not steamrolled flat into a thin, flavorless disc like some places tend to do.
The result is a sandwich with real texture and real taste, which is exactly what a tenderloin should be. The breading is seasoned well and crisps up nicely without being greasy.
Pair it with fries or a side of cottage cheese and you have a full, satisfying meal that will not wreck your wallet. Storie’s keeps prices genuinely affordable, which is part of why locals keep coming back.
For anyone passing through Decatur County on a road trip or visiting the nearby Greensburg City Park at 1000 Park Ave, Greensburg, IN 47240, a stop for the tenderloin alone is worth the detour. It is the kind of sandwich that reminds you why Indiana diners have such a loyal following.
Comfort Food Classics That Hit Every Time
Beyond the pies and the tenderloin, Storie’s menu is a love letter to classic American comfort food. Chicken-fried steak, beef Manhattan, pot roast, dressing, green beans, biscuits and gravy, breakfast quesadillas, BLT sandwiches, and more fill out a menu that covers all the bases without trying to be something it is not.
The pot roast with dressing and green beans earned a strong shoutout from one regular visitor who said the homemade pies were the best part of dinner but the entree itself was solid and satisfying. The beef Manhattan, a Midwestern staple of roast beef over bread with mashed potatoes and gravy, is a hearty choice that several guests ordered and found filling.
Not every dish has landed perfectly for every customer, and a few reviews mention inconsistency on certain items, but the overall track record for comfort food done simply and affordably is strong.
Breakfast is also a highlight here. Bacon, eggs, hash browns, biscuits, and gravy make up a morning spread that one reviewer called the best coffee experience alongside the meal.
Storie’s opens at 8 AM most days, making it a solid early stop before exploring nearby Decatur County attractions like the Greensburg Courthouse Tree, one of Indiana’s most unusual and beloved local landmarks located right downtown on the Courthouse Square.
Friendly Small-Town Service That Makes You Feel Like a Regular
One of the things that keeps people coming back to Storie’s is the way the staff treats you. Reviewers consistently mention servers by name, which tells you something real about the experience.
Donna, Shannon, and Kelli have all earned specific callouts in reviews for being attentive, friendly, and genuinely pleasant to be around.
There is a warmth here that you simply cannot manufacture. When a server remembers your coffee order or checks in on your kids without being asked, that is the kind of small-town hospitality that makes a meal feel like more than just a transaction.
One family with four children mentioned how well their server handled the whole table, keeping drinks filled and everyone happy throughout the visit.
Not every visit has been perfect, and some reviews do note slower kitchen times during busy periods. But the front-of-house staff consistently comes through as a highlight even in the more critical reviews.
That says a lot about the character of the people running this restaurant. For visitors new to Greensburg, stopping at Storie’s is a genuine introduction to the kind of community warmth that small Indiana towns are known for.
It pairs naturally with a walk around the historic Greensburg Courthouse Square, just steps away from the restaurant at the intersection of Main and Broadway in downtown Greensburg.
Prices That Respect Your Budget Without Sacrificing Flavor
Eating out has gotten expensive almost everywhere, which makes Storie’s feel like a small miracle. The dollar sign rating on Google says it all: this is genuinely affordable food in a world where a basic cheeseburger at a chain restaurant can cost you close to fifteen dollars before tax.
Storie’s keeps things real and keeps things reasonable.
Reviewers regularly highlight the value here. One guest noted that prices were amazing and the food was good for the cost.
Another mentioned that a full breakfast with bacon, eggs, potatoes, biscuits, and gravy plus coffee felt like a great deal by any measure. For families, that kind of pricing matters a lot.
You can bring the kids, order real food, and walk out without feeling like you just made a financial decision you will regret.
One thing worth knowing is that paying with a card does add a small processing fee of around 3.99 percent to the total. Bringing cash avoids that entirely and is the preferred payment method for getting the listed menu prices.
It is a minor detail but worth planning for. Overall, the combination of low prices and generous portions on items like the pork tenderloin makes Storie’s one of the best value meals in Decatur County.
For a budget-friendly stop near the Greensburg Public Library at 1115 W Main St, Greensburg, IN 47240, this is an easy choice.
A Location That Puts You Right in the Heart of Greensburg
Storie’s Restaurant sits right on East Main Street in downtown Greensburg at 109 E Main St, Greensburg, IN 47240, which means visiting it naturally puts you in the middle of one of Indiana’s most charming small-town downtowns. The location is walkable, easy to find, and surrounded by things worth seeing before or after your meal.
The most famous of those things is the Greensburg Courthouse Tree, a living tree that has grown out of the top of the Decatur County Courthouse tower for well over a century. One reviewer mentioned parking in the back of Storie’s and being pleasantly surprised by the view of this beloved local landmark.
It is genuinely one of Indiana’s most unique sights and it is right there, just steps from your table.
After your meal, a short drive takes you to Greensburg City Park at 1000 Park Ave, Greensburg, IN 47240, a lovely spot for a walk or letting the kids burn off energy after a big plate of comfort food. The Historic Westridge Golf Course at 1800 W Westridge Blvd, Greensburg, IN 47240 is another option for those looking to extend the day.
Coming in from Indianapolis or Cincinnati, Greensburg sits conveniently right off Interstate 74, making Storie’s a natural and rewarding pit stop that turns a drive into a memory. Once you find it, you will plan your route around it next time.
Dear Reader: This page may contain affiliate links which may earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase. Our independent journalism is not influenced by any advertiser or commercial initiative unless it is clearly marked as sponsored content. As travel products change, please be sure to reconfirm all details and stay up to date with current events to ensure a safe and successful trip.
