Indiana boasts a thriving pizza culture that extends far beyond the big national chains.
Local pizzerias across the Hoosier State have earned devoted followings by serving up pies that reflect the unique character and tastes of their communities.
From college towns to bustling cities, these restaurants have become gathering places where families celebrate, friends reconnect, and newcomers quickly become regulars.
What makes these spots special is not just the quality of their food but the way they have woven themselves into the fabric of Indiana life.
Each restaurant on this list has stood the test of time, building reputations on consistency, creativity, and genuine hospitality.
Whether you crave thin and crispy crusts, deep-dish comfort, or inventive toppings that push the boundaries of traditional pizza, Indiana has something to satisfy every palate.
These ten local favorites represent the best of what the state has to offer, proving that great pizza is about more than just cheese and sauce.
1. Jockamo Upper Crust Pizza
Located in both Indianapolis and Greenwood, this pizzeria has captured the hearts of locals with its bold approach to pizza making.
The restaurant’s creative menu features inventive specialty pizzas that go beyond traditional toppings.
One standout option combines barbecue sauce, pulled pork, and coleslaw for a unique twist on classic flavors.
Quality ingredients form the foundation of every pie that comes out of the kitchen.
The atmosphere inside feels welcoming and casual, perfect for family dinners or catching up with friends.
Multiple locations make it convenient for residents throughout the Indianapolis metro area to enjoy their favorites.
The restaurant has built a loyal following by consistently delivering pizzas that surprise and delight.
Locals appreciate the willingness to experiment with flavors while maintaining excellent execution.
The vibe strikes a balance between laid-back and energetic, reflecting the community it serves.
Whether you stick with classic combinations or venture into more adventurous territory, the quality remains consistently high.
Address: 5646 E Washington St, Indianapolis, IN 46219 (and additional locations in Greenwood)
This spot has earned its place as a multi-generational favorite across central Indiana.
Families return again and again, knowing they will find both familiar comfort and exciting new options.
2. Mother Bear’s Pizza
Bloomington residents have embraced this pizzeria as an essential part of the local dining scene.
Indiana University students and alumni hold particularly fond memories of meals shared within its walls.
The restaurant specializes in deep-dish, pan-style pizzas that arrive at the table piping hot and generously portioned.
Artwork adorns the interior, creating a cozy and eclectic environment that feels distinctly Bloomington.
Conversations flow easily in the relaxed setting, where the focus remains on good food and good company.
Over the years, this establishment has become a rite of passage for college students and a nostalgic destination for graduates returning to visit.
The thick, satisfying crust provides the perfect base for a variety of toppings and flavor combinations.
Locals appreciate the consistency that has kept them coming back through different stages of their lives.
Whether celebrating a win, commiserating after a tough exam, or simply enjoying a night out, this spot fits the occasion.
The art-filled space reflects the creative spirit of the university community it serves.
Address: 1428 E 3rd St, Bloomington, IN 47401
Generations of Hoosiers have made memories here, cementing its status as a true Bloomington institution.
The restaurant continues to welcome new patrons while maintaining the charm that made it beloved in the first place.
3. Rock Bottom Restaurant & Brewery
Situated in downtown Indianapolis, this establishment combines two beloved traditions: craft brewing and quality pizza.
While primarily known for its house-brewed selections, the kitchen produces pizzas that stand on their own merit.
Made from scratch using quality ingredients, the pies complement the brewery’s offerings perfectly.
The casual atmosphere makes it an ideal spot for after-work gatherings or weekend outings with friends.
Locals value the reliability of finding both excellent pizza and a welcoming environment in the heart of the city.
The downtown location makes it convenient for residents and visitors alike to stop in.
Inside, the space balances industrial brewing aesthetics with comfortable dining areas.
Conversations buzz throughout the restaurant as patrons enjoy their meals in a lively yet relaxed setting.
The kitchen’s commitment to making everything from scratch shows in every bite.
Pairing a freshly made pizza with a house brew creates a dining experience that feels authentically Indianapolis.
Address: 10 W Washington St, Indianapolis, IN 46204
The combination of quality food and craft beverages has made this a go-to destination for locals seeking a dependable option.
Whether you come for the brewing or the pizza, you will leave satisfied and already planning your next visit.
4. Bazbeaux Pizza
For decades, this pizzeria has set the standard for gourmet pizza in Indianapolis and Carmel.
The thin, crispy crusts serve as the perfect canvas for unique and inventive topping combinations.
What started as a single location has grown into a beloved local institution without sacrificing quality.
Residents consistently praise the restaurant for its commitment to using premium ingredients.
The menu features creative options that you won’t find at typical pizza chains.
Each pie arrives at the table with a satisfying crunch and perfectly balanced flavors.
The atmosphere inside reflects the restaurant’s gourmet approach while remaining approachable and comfortable.
Families, couples, and groups of friends all find something to love about the dining experience.
Innovation drives the menu, with seasonal specials and rotating options keeping regular customers excited.
The restaurant has maintained its reputation through consistent execution and genuine attention to detail.
Address: 329 Massachusetts Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46204 (and additional Carmel location)
Locals view this spot as proof that pizza can be both elevated and accessible.
The combination of quality, creativity, and consistency has earned fierce loyalty throughout central Indiana.
5. The South Bend Chocolate Company
Known primarily for its confections, this South Bend establishment surprises visitors with its cafe offerings.
The pizza served here provides a casual and unexpected dining option in a space better known for sweets.
Locals have discovered that stopping by for a savory meal can be just as rewarding as visiting for chocolate.
The cafe atmosphere feels cozy and inviting, offering a break from more conventional dining spots.
This off-the-beaten-path location gives the experience a sense of discovery that regulars appreciate.
The building itself adds character to the dining experience with its charming details.
Visitors often arrive for the chocolate and stay for the pizza, pleasantly surprised by the quality.
The combination of offerings makes it a versatile destination for different occasions and cravings.
Families enjoy being able to satisfy both savory and sweet desires in a single stop.
The casual vibe encourages lingering over your meal in a relaxed, unhurried manner.
Address: 122 S Michigan St, South Bend, IN 46601
South Bend residents value having this unique option that defies easy categorization.
The unexpected pairing of chocolate shop and pizza cafe has created a beloved local gathering spot that keeps people coming back for both.
6. Arni’s Restaurant
Since opening its doors, this central Indiana institution has served generations of Hoosier families.
The restaurant’s square-cut pizzas have become a hallmark of the local pizza scene.
Families return repeatedly, knowing they will find the same reliable quality they remember from childhood.
The menu features unique items that have achieved legendary status among regular customers.
Inside, the atmosphere feels comfortable and unpretentious, designed for families to relax and enjoy their time together.
The restaurant has maintained its position as a go-to destination through decades of consistent service.
Parents who ate here as children now bring their own kids, continuing the tradition.
The square-cut style makes sharing easy, encouraging the communal dining experience the restaurant fosters.
Locals appreciate having a place where they can count on familiar flavors and friendly service.
The restaurant represents the kind of local institution that defines Indiana dining culture.
Address: 1825 S 18th St, Lafayette, IN 47905 (and additional Indianapolis area locations)
Through changing times and evolving tastes, this spot has remained true to what made it successful.
The combination of nostalgia, quality, and genuine hospitality keeps families coming back generation after generation throughout Indiana.
7. Greek’s Pizzeria
Started right here in Indiana, this pizzeria has expanded while maintaining its strong local roots.
The restaurant focuses on classic recipes executed with care and simple, quality ingredients.
Multiple locations throughout central Indiana make it accessible to communities across the region.
Despite growing beyond a single shop, each location retains a neighborhood feel that resonates with customers.
The restaurant’s involvement in local communities extends beyond just serving pizza.
Residents appreciate supporting a business that started locally and continues to invest in Indiana.
The straightforward approach to pizza making emphasizes getting the basics right every single time.
No fancy gimmicks or complicated concepts, just consistently tasty pizza that hits the spot.
Families trust the restaurant for reliable meals that please everyone from picky kids to discerning adults.
The casual atmosphere welcomes diners without any pretension or fuss.
Address: Multiple locations throughout central Indiana
The restaurant’s success demonstrates that doing simple things well can build lasting loyalty.
Hoosiers have embraced this homegrown chain as proof that local businesses can compete and thrive by staying true to their roots and communities.
8. Amore’ Pizzeria
Housed in a historic building, this Noblesville pizzeria brings authentic Italian flavors to the local community.
The setting adds character and charm that chain restaurants simply cannot replicate.
Residents seeking an alternative to corporate dining options have found exactly what they were looking for here.
The restaurant’s commitment to Italian-style pizza shows in every carefully crafted pie.
Inside, the atmosphere reflects both the building’s history and the restaurant’s dedication to quality.
Locals rate this spot highly for its ability to transport them to a traditional pizzeria experience.
The attention to authentic preparation methods sets it apart from more casual competitors.
Noblesville residents take pride in having such a highly regarded restaurant in their community.
The historic building provides a dining environment that feels special without being stuffy or overly formal.
Every visit offers not just a meal but an experience that honors pizza’s Italian heritage.
Address: 907 Conner St, Noblesville, IN 46060
The restaurant has become a point of local pride, representing the kind of independent business that gives a community character.
Diners leave satisfied knowing they have supported a local establishment while enjoying truly excellent pizza in a memorable setting.
9. Barnaby’s
With locations in South Bend and the Indianapolis area, this restaurant offers an experience unlike any other pizzeria.
The medieval and rustic atmosphere creates a dining environment that feels like stepping into another world.
Thick, rectangular-cut pizzas arrive at tables throughout the distinctively decorated dining rooms.
Northern Indiana families have made this a favorite destination for celebrations and special occasions.
The unique theming adds an element of fun that appeals to diners of all ages.
Beyond the atmosphere, the restaurant delivers consistently good pizza that keeps customers returning.
The rectangular cuts provide generous portions that satisfy hearty appetites.
Locals appreciate having an option that combines quality food with memorable ambiance.
The restaurant has maintained its distinctive character through the years without becoming gimmicky.
Children especially love the themed environment, making it popular for family gatherings and birthday celebrations.
Address: 1420 N Ironwood Dr, South Bend, IN 46615 (and additional Indianapolis area location)
The combination of unique atmosphere and reliable quality has earned devoted fans throughout the region.
Barnaby’s proves that pizza restaurants can offer more than just food, creating experiences that become cherished family memories across Indiana.
Dear Reader: This page may contain affiliate links which may earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase. Our independent journalism is not influenced by any advertiser or commercial initiative unless it is clearly marked as sponsored content. As travel products change, please be sure to reconfirm all details and stay up to date with current events to ensure a safe and successful trip.
